«Вперёд» · 1909–1913

Vpered group

전진파

The group around Bogdanov that parted from Lenin's line inside the Bolshevik faction in 1909, named after its journal Vpered (Forward). It defended otzovism, the demand to recall the party's Duma deputies, and ultimatumism; ran party schools on Capri and in Bologna to train worker cadres; and called for building an independent proletarian culture. The break with Lenin was entangled with the controversy over Bogdanov's empiriomonist philosophy. The group dissolved around 1913, and most of its members returned to the Bolsheviks in 1917.

In depth

Who split, and why?

After the defeat of the 1905 revolution the Bolsheviks divided over tactics. On participation in the Duma of Stolypin's regime, Lenin held that even the legal platforms of a reactionary period had to be used. The left around Bogdanov answered that Duma participation was corroding the revolutionary party, and demanded the recall of the deputies (otzovism) or an ultimatum to them (ultimatumism). In June 1909 the enlarged editorial board of Proletary expelled Bogdanov from the faction, and with Lunacharsky, Gorky and others he formed the Vpered group at the end of that year. Bogdanov was then a Bolshevik theorist and financial steward second only to Lenin, so this was a split in the leadership itself.

Did the philosophical difference begin then?

No. The usual account has them falling into Machism during the years of reaction, but Mikhail Lifshitz pointed out in his 1967 essay "Lunacharsky" that this scheme does not fit the facts. Lunacharsky himself dated his later ideas to a lecture of 1898, "Idealism and Marxism", and Lenin opposed Bogdanov's philosophy from his book of 1899. Even so, the two made a tacit bloc in 1904 that set philosophy aside as neutral ground, and at the Third Party Congress in 1905 it was Lunacharsky who gave the report on armed insurrection. The years of reaction only brought an old difference to a head.

What brought it to a head was the danger of philosophy becoming the faction's public face. Plekhanov had called Lenin's circle "Nietzscheans and Machists" as early as 1905, and in 1908 Bogdanov published "Ernst Mach and the Revolution" in Die Neue Zeit. That summer Lenin wrote to Vorovsky that a split was being prepared on an empiriomonist and boycottist basis, and that he would leave the faction if that line won. On this view the break with Vpered was also a fight to keep philosophy from becoming the faction's programme. Lifshitz judges that the group ended close to anarcho-syndicalism. That judgement is a reading from Lenin's side; as noted below, later research reads the group differently.

What did it stand for?

Vpered was more than a tactical grouping. First there was the philosophical quarrel: Bogdanov had developed empiriomonism, an epistemology drawing on Mach, and Lenin attacked it in Materialism and Empirio-criticism as an abandonment of materialism. Second there was a cultural programme: the group argued that before taking political power the proletariat had to build its own science and art, an independent culture, and taught worker activists accordingly at the party schools on Capri (1909) and in Bologna (1910–11). The idea flowed after the revolution into the Proletkult movement, and Bogdanov's organisational theory was systematised as tektology.

What became of it?

The group did not last. Worn down by running the schools and by émigré politics, Bogdanov himself withdrew from front-line politics around 1911, and the group had effectively dissolved by 1913. When revolution came in 1917 most of its members, Lunacharsky among them, returned to the Bolsheviks and took charge of culture and education in the Soviet government. Official Soviet historiography filed Vpered away as the left deviation of otzovism, but later research has read it differently: as a strand of early Bolshevism that stressed inner-party democracy and workers' self-education, and as a rare attempt to make culture an independent task of the revolution rather than its dependent variable.

Related people

Related historical events

Sources

  1. Zenovia A. Sochor, Revolution and Culture: The Bogdanov-Lenin Controversy (Cornell University Press, 1988)
  2. Robert C. Williams, The Other Bolsheviks: Lenin and His Critics 1904–1914 (Indiana University Press, 1986)
  3. Marxists Internet Archive Marxists Internet Archive glossary: Vpered
  4. gutov.ru