白色恐怖 (臺灣白色恐怖時期) · 1949.05.19–1992.09.21

White Terror (Taiwan)

백색테러 (대만)

The political repression carried out in Taiwan by the Kuomintang-ruled government of the Republic of China from the declaration of martial law in May 1949 to the early 1990s, in which suspected Communists, supporters of Taiwan independence and liberal critics were arrested, imprisoned and executed. Its legal frame was the Temporary Provisions, martial law and the Statute for the Punishment of Rebellion; the Taiwan Garrison Command and other security agencies and military courts carried it out. Its end is dated to the close of the "mobilisation era" in 1991 or the amendment of Article 100 of the Criminal Code in 1992.

In depth

The White Terror in Taiwan was the political repression that the Kuomintang regime, driven onto the island by its defeat in the civil war, carried on for more than forty years on the ground of its military confrontation with the Communists. At first it was aimed at the underground of the Communist Party of China that really had entered the island, but the same laws and the same agencies were soon turned on everyone who criticised the regime. Civilians were tried by military courts, neighbours were encouraged to inform, and the victims included both native Taiwanese and people from the mainland.

The legal framework was built in 1949. Martial law was proclaimed on 19 May, and on 24 May the Legislative Yuan passed the Act for the Control and Punishment of Rebellion. Article 2, paragraph 1 of that act prescribed death as the only penalty for sedition, and people called it "Two-One". The Act for the Suppression of Communist Spies during the Period of Rebellion, of June 1950, allowed anyone denounced as a spy to be arrested and handed to the security organs without regular trial procedure, and gave the officers who handled a case 35 per cent of the property confiscated in it as a reward. Because of that reward the fabrication of cases never stopped.

In the first years the main target was the Chinese Communist Party's underground, built up by cadres sent from the mainland. When Cai Xiaoqian, secretary of the Taiwan Provincial Work Committee, was caught in 1950 and defected, arrests followed the network he revealed, and the deputy chief of the General Staff Wu Shi was shot. American support resumed with the Korean War and steadied the regime, but the searches went on. From the late 1950s the targets widened to critics inside the anti-Communist camp (the Lei Chen case of 1960), advocates of Taiwan independence (the Declaration of Taiwanese Self-Salvation of 1964) and writers punished for a phrase (Bo Yang in 1968). Political prisoners were held at the New Life Correction Center on Green Island and elsewhere.

The situation outside set the pace of the repression. From February 1950 members of the Taiwan Provincial Work Committee were shot almost every week at the Machangding execution ground in Taipei. When the Korean War broke out in June and the United States Seventh Fleet entered the Taiwan Strait, an attack from the mainland became less likely, and with McCarthyism rising in the United States the regime kept up its policy of severity. From 1953 Chiang Ching-kuo turned to a policy of conciliation that spared those who changed sides, but those who refused were still sentenced to death. Many of those executed in these years had been in the anti-Japanese movement under Japanese rule: Li Youbang, a lieutenant general of the Nationalist army who had led the Taiwan Volunteer Corps in the war against Japan on the mainland, and Chung Hao-tung, who had crossed to the mainland to join the war.

The president intervened in the trials himself. Political cases were dealt with under military law, and Chiang Kai-shek, as commander of the armed forces, had the power to review and confirm the verdicts. Of the 7,822 person-cases of political trials between 1950 and 1975, he intervened in 3,469, and six out of ten of the cases he reviewed ended in heavy sentences, from ten years' imprisonment up to death.

Counts of the victims differ. Statistics of the compensation foundation in 2009 give 8,296 people arrested and 1,061 executed; the estimate repeated by English Wikipedia is about 140,000 imprisoned and 3,000 to 4,000 executed. A Ministry of Justice report of 1988 counted 29,407 criminal cases against civilians judged by military bodies in 38 years of martial law. The lifting of martial law in 1987, the repeal of the Temporary Provisions and the Statute in 1991 and the amendment of Article 100 in 1992 removed the legal frame of the repression, and compensation and transitional justice followed.

Of the victims known to the compensation foundation, about 60 per cent were native Taiwanese and about 40 per cent mainlanders. Since mainlanders were 15 per cent of the population at the time, the proportion of victims was higher among them. Mainlander victims who had come to Taiwan alone often had no family to press for their rehabilitation. The last two political prisoners sentenced to life in the 1950s, Lin Shu-yang and Li Chin-mu, were released only in December 1984, after thirty-four years and six months.

The laws stayed after martial law was lifted. On 9 May 1991 agents of the Investigation Bureau entered a dormitory of National Tsing Hua University before dawn and took away a graduate student (the Independent Taiwan Association case), and more than a thousand students from several universities boycotted classes and occupied the concourse of Taipei station for six days. On 17 May the Legislative Yuan repealed the Act for the Control and Punishment of Rebellion. In June the last of the laws, the spy-suppression act, was repealed, and the Chinese Wikipedia also uses this date for the end of the White Terror.

The reckoning with the past came in two stages. The foundation created by the compensation statute of 1998 paid compensation in 10,067 cases over fifteen years, 809 of them death sentences. But the statute gave nothing to those whose sedition or treason was established even by present law and rules of evidence, that is, to real Communist Party members. Lin Shu-yang, himself a victim, charged that the Kuomintang reviewed only the procedure of enforcement, never questioned the anti-communist state policy itself, and was unwilling to apologise publicly as it had for the February 28 Incident. In 2017 the Act on Promoting Transitional Justice was passed and the Transitional Justice Commission was set up in May of the next year; beginning with 1,270 people in October 2018, the commission annulled the convictions batch by batch.

On the mainland the memory is different. The official Chinese newspaper Global Times has reported that around 1949 the party sent more than 1,500 agents into Taiwan and that more than 1,100 of them were executed, and in 2013 the People's Liberation Army built in Beijing a Square of the Nameless Heroes in their memory.

Related people

Related historical events

Sources

  1. zh.wikipedia.org
  2. Wikipedia (EN)
  3. Wikipedia (EN)
  4. Wikipedia (EN)
  5. Wikipedia (EN)
  6. zh.wikipedia.org
  7. zh.wikipedia.org