1945.03.26–1972.05.15

Okinawa: US Rule and the Reversion Movement

Why was Okinawa cut off from Japan and ruled by the US military for 27 years, how did its people defend their land and rights and win reversion, and why did the bases remain afterwards?

Occupied by the US military after the Battle of Okinawa in 1945, Okinawa was separated from mainland Japan by Article 3 of the 1952 peace treaty and ruled by the US Civil Administration. The military seized land with "bayonets and bulldozers" to expand its bases, and Okinawans resisted through the island-wide struggle of 1956, the founding of the reversion council in 1960 and the movements of the People's Party, teachers and base workers. The 1969 Sato-Nixon agreement and the 1971 Reversion Agreement returned Okinawa to Japan on 15 May 1972, but the bases stayed.

Why did Okinawa take a different road from mainland Japan?

Okinawa is the main island of the Ryukyu chain, which stretches south of the Japanese archipelago between Kyushu and Taiwan. The Battle of Okinawa began when US forces landed on the Kerama Islands on 26 March 1945. They landed on Okinawa Island on 1 April, and the Japanese 32nd Army fought a war of attrition meant to buy time for the decisive battle on the home islands. It was a large ground battle on Japanese soil that swept up the civilian population. Organised fighting ended when the commander Mitsuru Ushijima killed himself on 23 June, and the surrender was signed on 7 September. 1

According to the Okinawa prefectural relief section in 1976, of the 188,136 Japanese dead and missing, 122,228 were from Okinawa, 94,000 of them civilians. With a pre-war population of about 490,000, roughly one Okinawan in four died. Students were sent to the front as the Iron and Blood Student Corps, and civilians died in "mass suicides." Koreans were brought into the battle too. One view holds that more than 10,000 Korean labourers, who built airfields and positions, and "comfort women" are missing from the statistics, and Korean labourers under suspicion were sometimes massacred by Japanese soldiers and by residents. The Ryukyu Shimpo puts the Koreans mobilised at more than ten thousand, yet the Cornerstone of Peace erected in 1995 carries the names of only 381 people from the Republic of Korea and 82 from the Democratic People's Republic of Korea as of 2026. 1 2 3 4 5

Even while the fighting raged, the US military began turning Okinawa into an island of bases. On landing in the Kerama Islands it issued Nimitz Proclamation No. 1, suspending all administrative authority of the Japanese government in the Nansei Islands. Survivors were confined in camps while the military took over large tracts of land and built bases. Okinawa's bases came about in three ways: Japanese airfields seized and enlarged, like Kadena; land taken while residents were in the camps, like Futenma airfield; and land seized by force after the war. 6 7 8

How did the United States govern Okinawa?

Mainland Japan, after the Allied occupation, regained sovereignty when the San Francisco Peace Treaty took effect on 28 April 1952. Article 3 of the treaty, however, gave the United States all powers of administration, legislation and jurisdiction over the Nansei Islands south of 29 degrees north, including Okinawa. Sovereignty was said to remain with Japan, but Okinawa was left in an ambiguous status, belonging neither to Japan nor to the United States. Residents needed a passport to travel to the mainland, and Okinawan ships, having no flag of their own, flew the international signal flag D. In 1962 an Okinawan tuna boat was fired on in Indonesian waters on the grounds that its nationality was unknown, and there were casualties. 9 10 11

The governing body was the United States Civil Administration of the Ryukyu Islands (USCAR), which replaced the US military government in December 1950. From 1957 its head was a High Commissioner, the commander of US forces on Okinawa, who could legislate by proclamation and ordinance, veto the residents' laws, dismiss officials and move cases to USCAR's own courts. Beneath it the Government of the Ryukyu Islands was set up in April 1952 as the residents' own administration, with a Chief Executive, an elected Legislature and courts; but the Chief Executive was at first appointed by USCAR, which could overrule any of its decisions. Residents were covered by neither the Japanese nor the US constitution. 12 13 14 15

These powers were used most openly under High Commissioner Paul Caraway from 1961 to 1964. He vetoed bill after bill passed by the Legislature, intervened in elections to disqualify People's Party candidates and screened the political views of military employees. At a club meeting in Naha in March 1963 he declared that "self-government by the Okinawan people is no more than a myth." Okinawans called this the "Caraway whirlwind." His heavy-handedness split even the pro-American conservative camp and strengthened the reversion side instead. 16 17 18

How did residents defend their land against "bayonets and bulldozers"?

Once the peace treaty took effect the US military needed a legal basis for using the land. In November 1952 USCAR tried to sign twenty-year leases, but the annual rent was about two cents per tsubo, so that the rent for some nine tsubo equalled the price of a bottle of Coca-Cola, and hardly any owners signed. In April 1953 Ordinance No. 109, the land acquisition ordinance, allowed land to be taken without the owner's consent. At its first targets, Mekaru, Aja and Ameku in Mawashi village, bulldozers escorted by armed troops levelled the land early on 11 April. On Ie Island in March 1955 houses were burned to clear a target for practising nuclear bomb delivery, and at Isahama in Ginowan on 19 July gravel was dumped into the paddies in front of soldiers with fixed bayonets. These seizures are known as "bayonets and bulldozers." 19 7 20

Shoko Ahagon, an Ie Island farmer who had lost his land, walked Okinawa Island with his fellow villagers from July 1955 to February 1956 in a non-violent "beggars' march" to make the seizures known. USCAR proposed a "lump-sum payment" that would settle the rent at once and secure the land in effect for ever, and in January 1954 President Eisenhower declared that the Okinawa bases would be kept indefinitely. In April 1954 the Ryukyu Legislature resolved on the "Four Principles for Protecting the Land": no lump-sum payment, fair compensation, damages, and no new seizures. 21 19 22

When it became known in June 1956 that the Price Report of a US House investigating team endorsed the lump-sum payment, Okinawan opinion boiled over. Residents' rallies were held in 56 of the 64 municipalities, and on 28 July some 150,000 people gathered on the grounds of Naha High School. This movement, which crossed the line between conservatives and progressives, is called the "island-wide struggle" (shimagurumi tōsō). The US military answered by declaring central civilian districts off-limits to its personnel, squeezing the base economy. In 1958 it dropped the lump-sum plan and raised rents sharply, but new seizures were tacitly allowed and damages were left unsettled. The struggle revived the reversion movement, which US repression had silenced. 22 20 10

Why were Kamejiro Senaga and the Okinawa People's Party targeted?

Under US rule the Communist Party was illegal in Okinawa, so in July 1947 Kamejiro Senaga and others founded the Okinawa People's Party in its place. Before the war Senaga had been expelled from school for socialist activity and jailed under the Peace Preservation Law for leading the Tanna Tunnel labour dispute in 1932. The party at first regarded the US forces as liberators and even passed a resolution of thanks, but in 1951 it adopted reversion to Japan as its policy. Senaga topped the poll in the first Legislature election of 1952 and refused to take the oath at the founding ceremony of the Ryukyu government. 23 24

In October 1954 USCAR arrested Senaga on a charge of sheltering party members under deportation orders. He was tried without a lawyer on the testimony of a single witness and sentenced to two years; in this "People's Party incident" two leaders, Senaga among them, and 28 members were arrested. Released in 1956, Senaga won the Naha mayoral election in December. USCAR had the Bank of the Ryukyus cut off the city's subsidies and loans and freeze its deposits, but citizens flocked to pay their taxes voluntarily, and the collection rate rose from 77 per cent to as much as 97 per cent. In 1957 High Commissioner Moore rewrote the ordinance to remove Senaga on the grounds of his 1954 imprisonment and stripped him of the right to stand for office. English-language accounts describe this as the military authorities arbitrarily changing the election rules. 24 23 25

Senaga regained his eligibility when the so-called "Senaga ordinance" was abolished in 1967, and in 1970, in the national participation election in which Okinawans chose members of the Japanese Diet for the first time, he was elected to the House of Representatives for the People's Party. The party merged into the Japanese Communist Party in 1973, after reversion, and Senaga became the JCP's vice-chairman. He is still highly regarded in Okinawa because of his battle with USCAR over the Naha city government. 24 23

Who led the movement for reversion to the homeland, and what did it demand?

Right after the war Okinawans debated whether to return to Japan, become independent or accept UN trusteeship. As long-term US rule and its military-first policy became clear, most opinion turned to reversion. In January 1953 the Okinawa Teachers' Association, headed by Chobyo Yara, the youth federation and others, 23 organisations in all, formed a council to work for reversion, but under USCAR pressure it faded away. Because the United States at first regarded keeping administrative control as inseparable from keeping the bases working, it treated the reversion movement as a challenge to its rule and repressed it. 10 11

When the island-wide struggle revived the movement, the Okinawa Prefecture Council for Reversion to the Homeland (Fukkikyo) was founded on 28 April 1960. Built around the teachers' association, it brought together 46 organisations, every party except the Okinawa Liberal Democratic Party, trade unions, parent-teacher associations and the bereaved families' federation; its first chairman was Chobyo Yara, and in 1962 Shin'ei Kyan took the chair. Making 28 April, the day the peace treaty took effect, "Okinawa Day," it held marches every year and a rally at sea off Cape Hedo at the northern tip of the island. Fukkikyo went beyond demanding reversion to lead anti-war and anti-base struggles and campaigns for self-government, livelihoods and human rights. From this time arguments for reversion also stressed closing the gap with the mainland in wages, taxation and social security. 26 10 27

Okinawan politics divided over the path to reversion. The ruling Okinawa Liberal Democratic Party, committed to cooperation with the United States, sought gradual integration by winning greater self-government, an end to travel restrictions and more aid from Tokyo one step at a time. The opposition and Fukkikyo condemned this as accepting the status quo and demanded the right to fly the Japanese flag, an end to travel restrictions, an elected Chief Executive and representation in the Diet. In March 1962 President Kennedy announced a "new Okinawa policy" recognising Okinawa as part of Japan and providing for consultation on Japanese aid, and after the island-wide struggle USCAR too took steps to narrow the gap with the mainland. In August 1964 the Legislature resolved to ask for freedom to fly the Japanese flag and for Japanese nationality to be stated explicitly. 10 11

The political axis of the reversion movement was the progressive parties. Alongside the People's Party, the Okinawa Social Mass Party (Shadaito) was founded on 31 October 1950 by Tatsuo Taira, governor of the Okinawa Islands, and others. It proclaimed that "politics is for the people and belongs to the people," called itself "a national party grounded in humanism" and pledged "a new Ryukyu built by the gathered strength of the masses"; at first it included conservative politicians too, but it grew steadily more progressive. When President Johnson approved direct election of the Chief Executive in January 1968, the Shadaito, the Okinawa Socialist Party and the People's Party joined the teachers' association, the prefectural labour council and others in the "Association for a Bright Okinawa," the progressive joint struggle council, and chose the teachers' association president Chobyo Yara as their common candidate. After reversion the People's Party merged into the Communist Party, but the Shadaito did not join a national party and remained an Okinawan regional party. 28

How did military crimes, accidents and the Vietnam War deepen Okinawan anger?

Crimes by US servicemen and civilian employees were investigated by the military and tried by closed courts-martial. The Ryukyu police had no power to investigate, and offenders were often acquitted or lightly punished, or transferred home so that even the outcome was unknown. In September 1955 a five-year-old girl was raped and murdered at Kadena by a US Army sergeant. A court-martial sentenced him to death, but in 1960 President Eisenhower commuted the sentence to 45 years, and he was paroled in 1971. On 30 June 1959 a US Air Force F-100 fighter crashed into Miyamori Elementary School in Ishikawa, killing 17 people, 11 of them children, and injuring 210. 15 29 30 6

In the 1960s the Vietnam War made Okinawa the front-line base of the US forces. Crimes involving US personnel exceeded 1,000 a year from 1965 to 1967, as the build-up in Vietnam peaked. Base workers organised as well. A USCAR ordinance made strikes by base workers illegal, and wage discrimination was rife; Kosuke Uehara founded a federation of military workers' unions in 1961 and in 1963 built it into the All-Okinawa Military Workers' Union (Zengunro). When a B-52 strategic bomber crashed and exploded on take-off from Kadena early on 19 November 1968, the Socialist Masses Party, the People's Party and the Socialist Party joined Fukkikyo, the unions and the teachers' association in a "prefectural joint struggle council to protect life" and prepared a general strike for 4 February 1969 to demand the removal of the B-52s. 15 31 32

The strike never took place. Chief Executive Chobyo Yara, who had won the first direct election in 1968, met Prime Minister Sato six days before the strike to ask for the removal of the B-52s but received no commitment on timing. Saying he had gained an impression from government leaders that the B-52s would be moved abroad, Yara asked for the strike to be avoided, and in January the council called it off. The Ryukyu Shimpo reports that Yara acted out of fear that reversion would be delayed; English-language accounts describe him persuading the radicals in return for concessions from the mainland government. Rank-and-file unionists denounced the "spineless" leadership, and Fukkikyo afterwards widened its aims to "removal of the military bases" and "abrogation of the US-Japan Security Treaty." 32 33

Early on 20 December 1970, in the base town of Koza, a drunk American serviceman hit a local man with his car. It came just after a court-martial on 7 December had acquitted the serviceman who ran down and killed a housewife in Itoman three months earlier, and while demands to remove the poison gas found stockpiled at the Chibana depot were at their height. When military police fired warning shots, a crowd of some 5,000 burned more than seventy American vehicles and some entered Kadena Air Base. In this spontaneous "Koza riot," which no party directed, 88 people were injured, 40 of them US servicemen, but no one was killed and no homes or shops were looted. It shocked both governments on the eve of reversion. 15 34 35

How was reversion decided, and what did Okinawa gain and lose?

In August 1965 Eisaku Sato became the first post-war prime minister to visit Okinawa, declaring that "Japan's post-war era will not end until Okinawa returns to the homeland." As the Vietnam War inflamed the anti-war and reversion movements, the US government, fearing that if things were left as they were it would soon be unable to keep the bases working, began considering reversion by 1966. In the first direct election for Chief Executive in November 1968, Chobyo Yara, who stood for "immediate, unconditional and total reversion," defeated the gradualist Junji Nishime. Diplomatic papers released in 2010 show that the Japanese and US governments worked behind the scenes for Nishime. 36 37 10 38

The Sato-Nixon joint communique of 21 November 1969 agreed on reversion in 1972, "without nuclear weapons and on a par with the mainland." Because it left the bases in place, Yara and Fukkikyo protested strongly. Behind the talks Sato's secret envoy Kei Wakaizumi dealt with Henry Kissinger, who in September 1969 demanded the right to bring nuclear weapons back into Okinawa and move them through it in an emergency. In a 1994 book Wakaizumi revealed that Sato and Nixon had signed a secret agreed minute granting it. Because reversion was tied to talks on Japanese textile export restraints, critics said Japan had "sold thread to buy rope," a pun on Oki-nawa. Sato received the Nobel Peace Prize in 1974. 15 39 36 11 37

The Okinawa Reversion Agreement was signed in Tokyo and Washington on 17 June 1971. It applied the US-Japan Security Treaty to Okinawa, kept most existing bases in US service, had Japan pay $320 million and in principle waived residents' claims against the United States. A secret arrangement under which Japan quietly paid the $4 million the United States owed for restoring land came to light through Foreign Ministry cables obtained by the Mainichi reporter Takichi Nishiyama, but it was the reporter and the ministry clerk who were punished. Ahead of Diet approval in November, the Ryukyu government compiled a "Petition on Reversion Measures" stating that the bases had been "built and formed in violation of the principles of democracy, suppressing or ignoring the will of the people" and asking for "an island of peace without bases." Fukkikyo staged general strikes in May and November demanding that the agreement be scrapped and renegotiated. 40 41 42 6 32

Okinawa returned to Japan on 15 May 1972. Ceremonies were held simultaneously at the Nippon Budokan in Tokyo and the Naha Civic Hall, and Chobyo Yara became governor of Okinawa Prefecture that day; USCAR had closed the day before. On the day of reversion the US-Japan Joint Committee drew up the "May 15 memo" fixing the conditions of use of the bases to be kept. Neighbouring states were watching too: Japan's ambassador in Seoul reported President Park Chung-hee as saying it was "absolutely necessary that the Okinawa bases remain as they are, nuclear weapons included, ready for free sortie." 11 12

Verdicts on reversion differ. Nakamoto, who sat on Fukkikyo's executive, told the Ryukyu Shimpo of his mixed feelings, "some joy at escaping rule by another people, but the bases remain," and confessed that over the years he had come to wonder whether "Japan is not our homeland but another country." In NHK polls, on the other hand, approval of reversion stood at about 51 per cent just after 1972 but has stayed above 75 per cent since the late 1980s, and in a 2017 joint survey by the Okinawa Times and the Asahi Shimbun 82 per cent said reversion had been a good thing. On the fiftieth anniversary the prefecture stated that the goal shared at reversion, "to make Okinawa an island of peace," had still not been achieved. 32 11 10 6

How did the base question continue after reversion?

Reversion brought the Japanese constitution and with it the Status of Forces Agreement, but the bases did not shrink. As US bases on the mainland were cut back sharply, Okinawa's share of the area of exclusive-use US facilities in Japan rose from 58.8 per cent at reversion to 70.3 per cent today, concentrated in a prefecture with about 0.6 per cent of the country's land. "Anti-war landowners" such as Shoko Ahagon, who refused to lease their land to the Japanese government, went to court against its forced use. 6 43 21

On 4 September 1995 three US servicemen raped a twelve-year-old girl. The Status of Forces Agreement kept the suspects out of Japanese custody until indictment, and some 85,000 people, Governor Masahide Ota among them, gathered at a protest rally in Ginowan on 21 October. Ota, who had been drafted into the Iron and Blood Student Corps in the Battle of Okinawa, had that year erected the Cornerstone of Peace, which carries the names of the war dead regardless of nationality. In April 1996 the two governments agreed to return Futenma air station on condition of relocation, but as the site settled on Henoko in Nago, the Futenma relocation issue has continued to this day. Takeshi Onaga was elected governor in 2014 on a platform against relocation within the prefecture, and in the 2019 prefectural referendum more than seventy per cent voted against the Henoko landfill. The national government has nevertheless won in the courts and continues construction. 44 45 46 47

Pushed by the anger of 1995, the two governments set up the Special Action Committee on Okinawa (SACO) that November, and its final report of December 1996 proposed a sea-based heliport off the east coast of the main island to replace Futenma. That same year Japan and the US also agreed to study defence cooperation in a Far East emergency. In 2009 Yukio Hatoyama of the Democratic Party promised to move the base "at least out of the prefecture" and took power, but could not keep the promise. On 27 December 2013 Governor Hirokazu Nakaima approved the landfill at Henoko; Governor Onaga revoked the approval and was drawn into lawsuits with the state. In 2018, the year he died in office, the vice-governor acting with his authority withdrew the approval, but the land minister overturned the withdrawal. In the prefectural referendum of 24 February 2019, 71.74 per cent of valid votes opposed the landfill, but the result had no legal force, and on 25 March soil began to be poured into a new section. 46

Consequences

Okinawa returned to Japan and came under the Japanese constitution on 15 May 1972. But the Reversion Agreement kept most US bases, and secret arrangements on bringing back nuclear weapons and on costs came with it. Okinawa's share of exclusive-use US facilities in Japan rose from 58.8 per cent at reversion to 70.3 per cent, and since 1995 the anti-base movement has continued over the relocation of Futenma air station.

Timeline & Map

Naha Ie Island Kadena Air Base Koza (Okinawa City) Futenma air station 16 Washington 18 Tokyo 10 Ishikawa 14 Kadena Air Base 17 Koza 7 Isahama 20 Ginowan 21 Futenma air station 5 Mawashi 3 Naha 4 Naha 6 Naha 8 Naha 9 Naha 11 Naha 12 Naha 15 Naha 19 Naha 1 Kerama Islands 13 Naha Airport 2 Mabuni
  1. 11945.03.26United StatesJapan
    US landing on the Kerama Islands; Nimitz Proclamation

    US forces landed on the Kerama Islands, opening the Battle of Okinawa, and issued Nimitz Proclamation No. 1 suspending the Japanese government's authority in the Nansei Islands.

  2. 21945.06.23Japan
    End of organised fighting on Okinawa

    Mitsuru Ushijima, commander of the Japanese 32nd Army, killed himself and organised fighting on Okinawa Island ended.

  3. 31950.12.15United States
    USCAR established

    The US military replaced its military government with the United States Civil Administration of the Ryukyu Islands.

  4. 41952.04.01Japan
    Government of the Ryukyu Islands founded

    The Government of the Ryukyu Islands, the residents' administration, began work under a USCAR ordinance.

  5. 1952.04.28JapanUnited States
    Peace treaty takes effect; Okinawa separated

    The San Francisco Peace Treaty took effect; mainland Japan regained sovereignty while Okinawa stayed under US administration under Article 3.

  6. 51953.04.11Japan
    First seizure under the land ordinance

    Bulldozers escorted by armed troops seized land at Mekaru, Aja and Ameku in Mawashi village.

  7. 61954.04.30Japan
    Legislature adopts the Four Principles

    The Ryukyu Legislature resolved on the four principles: no lump-sum payment, fair compensation, damages, no new seizures.

  8. 71955.07.19Japan
    Seizure at Isahama

    Under guard of soldiers with bayonets, gravel was dumped into the paddies of Isahama in Ginowan and residents were driven out.

  9. 81956.07.28Japan
    Rally to carry the Four Principles through

    Some 150,000 people gathered at Naha High School against the Price Report.

  10. 91956.12.25Japan
    Kamejiro Senaga elected mayor of Naha

    Kamejiro Senaga of the Okinawa People's Party won the Naha mayoral election.

  11. 101959.06.30Japan
    Jet crash on Miyamori Elementary School

    A US Air Force F-100 crashed into Miyamori Elementary School in Ishikawa, killing 17 people including 11 children.

  12. 111960.04.28Japan
    Fukkikyo founded

    Forty-six organisations led by the teachers' association founded the reversion council, with Chobyo Yara as its first chairman.

  13. 121963.03.05United States
    Caraway calls self-government "a myth"

    High Commissioner Paul Caraway told a club meeting in Naha that Okinawan self-government was no more than a myth.

  14. 131965.08.19Japan
    Prime Minister Sato visits Okinawa

    Eisaku Sato declared at Naha airport that Japan's post-war era would not end until Okinawa returned.

  15. 1968.11Japan
    Yara wins the first direct election for Chief Executive

    Chobyo Yara, standing for immediate reversion, defeated Junji Nishime in the first direct election for Chief Executive.

  16. 141968.11.19Japan
    B-52 crash at Kadena

    A B-52 strategic bomber crashed and exploded on take-off from Kadena Air Base.

  17. 151969.01Japan
    February 4 general strike called off

    At Chief Executive Yara's request the joint struggle council decided to call off the B-52 general strike.

  18. 161969.11.21JapanUnited States
    Sato-Nixon joint communique

    Prime Minister Sato and President Nixon agreed on the reversion of Okinawa in 1972.

  19. 171970.12.20Japan
    Koza riot

    After an accident caused by a US serviceman, some 5,000 people in Koza burned more than seventy US vehicles.

  20. 181971.06.17JapanUnited States
    Okinawa Reversion Agreement signed

    The Okinawa Reversion Agreement was signed simultaneously in Tokyo and Washington.

  21. 191972.05.15Japan
    Reversion of Okinawa

    Administrative rights over Okinawa returned to Japan, and Chobyo Yara became governor of Okinawa Prefecture.

  22. 201995.10.21Japan
    Prefectural rally over the 1995 rape

    Some 85,000 people gathered in Ginowan to protest the rape of a schoolgirl by US servicemen.

  23. 211996.04.12JapanUnited States
    Agreement to return Futenma

    Prime Minister Hashimoto and Ambassador Mondale agreed to return Futenma air station on condition of its relocation.

Related people 18

Related terms

Sources: reference 1reference 2reference 3reference 4reference 5reference 6reference 7reference 8reference 9reference 10reference 11reference 12reference 13reference 14reference 15reference 16reference 17reference 18reference 19reference 20reference 21reference 22reference 23reference 24reference 25reference 26reference 27reference 28reference 29reference 30reference 31reference 32reference 33reference 34reference 35reference 36reference 37reference 38reference 39reference 40reference 41reference 42reference 43reference 44reference 45reference 46reference 47