Herbert Marcuse

Frankfurt School philosopher and the pre-eminent theorist of the 1960s New Left

'In its advanced positions, it is the Great Refusal — the protest against that which is' — One-Dimensional Man (1964)

Herbert Marcuse was a central philosopher of the Frankfurt School who fused Marxism with Freudian psychoanalysis to develop a critical theory of modern capitalist society. In Eros and Civilization (1955) he analyzed the repressive structures of capitalist society and explored the utopian potential of liberated Eros, while in One-Dimensional Man (1964) he diagnosed advanced industrial society as a 'one-dimensional' order where technological abundance erodes critical consciousness, introducing the concept of repressive desublimation. A German-Jewish émigré who fled Nazism for the United States, he served in the OSS during the war and later taught at Brandeis and UC San Diego, becoming the intellectual pillar of the 1960s student movements and the New Left. His radical thought, crystallized in the 'Great Refusal,' has had a lasting impact on critical theory and emancipatory politics.

Activities and affiliations

Career Timeline

Between Heidegger and Hegel: what was the young Marcuse looking for in philosophy?

After finishing his 1922 dissertation on the German artist-novel, Marcuse worked in bookselling and publishing in Berlin. What drew him back to philosophy was Martin Heidegger's Being and Time, newly published in 1927. In 1928 he returned to Freiburg to study under Heidegger and Edmund Husserl, worked as Heidegger's assistant and joined his inner circle of students. What he wanted was a "concrete philosophy": one that dealt with the actual lives of people living now.

That interest had a political background. The German revolution after the First World War had failed, and the mainstream Marxism of the day (the so-called "scientific socialism" of the Second International) leaned toward a mechanical reading in which capitalism would collapse on its own, like a law of nature. On that view the consciousness and decisions of the people who were to make the revolution had nothing to do. Marcuse tried to fill this gap with Heidegger. He read Heidegger's critique of "inauthentic" life, life swept along by how everyone else lives, alongside Marx's "alienation" and György Lukács's "reification". Reification is the process by which relations between people harden into what look like relations between things, so that they seem natural facts that cannot be changed. This attempt of 1928 to 1932 is now called "Heideggerian" or "phenomenological" Marxism, and Jürgen Habermas called him "the first Heideggerian Marxist".

When Karl Marx's Economic and Philosophical Manuscripts (early drafts written in 1844) were first published in 1932, Marcuse wrote one of the earliest commentaries on them that same year, "New Sources on the Foundation of Historical Materialism", in the social democratic journal Die Gesellschaft. He held that the manuscripts made it possible to reopen the original meaning of historical materialism and the relation between Marx and Hegel. The key he took from them was labour. People make themselves by working on nature and reshaping it to their needs. Under capitalism, however, the products of labour and labour itself confront the worker as an alien power. That is alienation. Marcuse read Marx as criticising capitalism not merely as an unfair system of distribution but as a crisis of the human essence, and from then on "alienated labour" was his starting point whenever he discussed Marx.

In the same years he wrote his Habilitation (the second thesis required in Germany to become a university professor), Hegel's Ontology and the Theory of Historicity. Heidegger never approved it, and according to Marcuse may not even have read it. The book was published anyway in 1932, and Theodor Adorno's review noted a decisive departure from Heidegger's public teaching. In 1932 the two men parted. One reason was Heidegger's turn toward National Socialism (he joined the Nazi Party in 1933); the other was philosophical. Marcuse later said that Heidegger's concreteness was "a phony, false concreteness". Heidegger's human existence was a neutral category, purged of the injuries left by class, work and society, with no trace of daily rebellion or the striving for liberation. As a Jew, Marcuse had no path to a professorship under the Nazis. With Husserl's recommendation he was hired by the Frankfurt Institute for Social Research, which was already preparing to move abroad, and in May 1933 he left Germany.

The break did not end the Heidegger question. In "The Struggle against Liberalism in the Totalitarian View of the State", published in the Institute's journal in 1934, he quoted and attacked Heidegger's rectoral address and his statement of November 1933 that "the Führer himself and alone is the present and future German reality and its law". In 1947 he wrote to Heidegger asking him to distance himself publicly from Nazism. Heidegger refused and set the extermination of the Jews beside the expulsion of Germans from the eastern territories; Marcuse replied in outrage, and the correspondence ended there. How much of Heidegger remained in his thought is still debated. Martin Jay holds that he dropped Heidegger's vocabulary on joining the Institute, while Adorno wrote to Max Horkheimer in 1935 that Marcuse was still a Heideggerian (though the two were rivals for Horkheimer's favour). Richard Wolin finds the Heideggerian dimension muted but traceable in the postwar writings and points to the likeness between the later critique of "one-dimensionality" and Heidegger's critique of "inauthenticity".

His second book on Hegel, Reason and Revolution (1941), dropped the style of Being and Time for a clear exposition aimed at American readers; in Jean Améry's phrase it is Hegel seen through Marx. Marcuse read Hegel's reason as "the power of the negative", a force that refuses to accept given reality as it is and overturns it. He argued that after Hegel the task of philosophy passed into social theory, and set Marx's dialectical theory of society against positivism, which treats society as a set of given facts. This "negative thinking" became the model for the critical thinking he later defended in One-Dimensional Man. The philosopher Michael Theunissen judged that Hegel had never been read so decisively toward the future, but objected that the destructive attitude to the given that Marcuse attributed to Hegel fits only Hegel's early writings.

Eros and Civilization: how much repression does civilization need?

Marcuse had read Sigmund Freud in the 1920s and 1930s, but his serious engagement began in the 1950s. A series of lectures at the Washington School of Psychiatry in 1950–51 became Eros and Civilization: A Philosophical Inquiry into Freud (1955). The book is a direct reply to Freud's Civilization and Its Discontents (1930). Freud was pessimistic: the more civilization advances, the more human desire has to be held down, and there is no way out. Marcuse set out to overturn that conclusion. Marx's name hardly appears in the book, yet it bends Freud's concepts toward a Marxian analysis of advanced industrial society, which is why it is often called a synthesis of Freud and Marx.

A few terms first. In psychoanalysis, "repression" is the mental process that pushes unacceptable desires out of consciousness and holds them down. People first follow the "pleasure principle", seeking immediate gratification, but the outside world does not bend to that demand, so a "reality principle" takes hold that postpones satisfaction and adjusts it to real conditions. Turning held-back sexual energy toward socially approved activities such as work or art is called "sublimation". For Freud, civilization is built on this repression and sublimation.

Marcuse asked whether all of that repression is really needed for human survival. He separated two kinds. "Basic repression" is the minimum control of the drives that human beings need to live together in civilization; since acting purely on the pleasure principle would infringe on others' freedom, it cannot be avoided. "Surplus repression" is what is added on top: the restrictions required by social domination. Surplus repression shapes the drives to fit the "performance principle", the historical form the reality principle takes today. The performance principle is the rule of an ever-expanding competitive society, in which people do not live their own lives but perform pre-established functions, working for a productive apparatus they do not control. Here Freud and Marx meet. That workers cannot realize their own needs and capacities in their work is what Marx called alienated labour; how these restrictions are taken inside and come to feel like one's own wishes is what Freud explains. In Marcuse's short phrase, a person "desires what he is supposed to desire".

This distinction yields his view of history. History so far has been not only a history of class struggles but also a struggle over the repression of human drives. In ages dominated by the struggle for existence and real scarcity, a repressive reality principle was to some degree unavoidable. But the productivity achieved under the performance principle has reached a level at which the drive energy spent in alienated labour could be greatly reduced. That repression does not shrink is due to relations of domination, and "scarcity" now works less as a real condition than as an ideology that keeps workers in place. The second half of the book looks for a way beyond this in fantasy, imagination and art. Repressed drives do not vanish; they survive in dreams, art and utopian images. Throwing off surplus repression would open a "new reality principle" that reconciles culture and the drives, in which work could become play and sexuality could become Eros, a force that enlivens the whole of life. He called this state, in which reason and desire go together instead of fighting, the "rationality of gratification". Unlike the dark view of history in Max Horkheimer and Theodor Adorno's Dialectic of Enlightenment, which saw enlightenment turning into domination, this is counted as Marcuse's most hopeful book.

The book soon drew controversy. In an epilogue, "Critique of Neo-Freudian Revisionism", Marcuse attacked his former Institute colleague Erich Fromm and others for dropping Freud's theory of the sexual drives and the death instinct and turning to a conformist "positive thinking". Fromm answered in the journal Dissent that Marcuse had made Freud, a man of the bourgeois era and an opponent of socialism, into a revolutionary thinker, and that by dealing with psychoanalysis without clinical experience he had decisively misread Freud. The dispute ended their friendship; the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy judges that the two largely spoke past each other. Michel Foucault criticised Marcuse for giving repression an exaggerated role, arguing that power does not only hold down but also produces desire and knowledge; feminist theorists such as Jessica Benjamin and Nancy Chodorow argued that relying on drive theory alone misses how people develop through relations with others. Leszek Kołakowski saw the book as essentially anti-Marxist for replacing the theory of class struggle with an inverted reading of Freud. Bernard Görlich, by contrast, credited Marcuse with founding a "political psychology" by going into the centre of Freud's thought rather than merely dressing his subject in Freudian terms. The book became one of the most widely read texts of the 1960s student movements.

Soviet Marxism: how did Marcuse read the official Soviet ideology?

Soviet Marxism: A Critical Analysis (1958) measures the official ideology of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union against Marxist theory itself. Marcuse analysed the categories used by Soviet ideologists one by one and asked whether Marxism had been transformed beyond recognition under Stalinism. His answer runs as follows. The Soviet Union reshaped Marx's theory to justify state power. Putting "dialectical materialism", understood as the general laws by which nature and society develop, in front made the view of society rigid and mechanical, while "historical materialism", the study of how societies actually change, was pushed into the background. As a result Marx's aim of transforming society was weakened, and Marxism became an official ideology that upheld the existing state and guided people's thinking.

A point often singled out as original is the reversal of base and superstructure. Marx held that economic relations (the base) shape politics, law and ideas (the superstructure); according to Marcuse, in Soviet society this scheme was literally turned upside down, and ideology itself served as the basis of the system. Yet his conclusion was not a one-sided condemnation. Because Soviet society kept the Marxist ideal of a classless, equal society as its official theory, he thought that as productivity grew the better possibilities hidden in that theory could really unfold. He even raised the possibility that Communist parties outside the Soviet bloc, or the Soviet party itself, might develop into social democratic parties. In One-Dimensional Man (1964) he then treated Western capitalism and Soviet society together, regarding the bureaucratic trends in self-described Marxist countries as just as opposed to freedom as those in the West.

The book grew out of his government service. After a stint at the Office of War Information in 1942, from 1943 Marcuse analysed Nazi Germany in the Research and Analysis Branch of the Office of Strategic Services, and after 1945 he worked until 1951 in the State Department's intelligence research office and the Committee on World Communism. His report from these years, "The Potentials of World Communism", held that, contrary to Marx's expectations, communism had taken root only in less industrialized countries and that national Communist parties had been wholly subordinated to Soviet domestic and foreign interests, while explaining the strength of the Italian and French parties by national conditions such as their role in the Resistance. A 1951 paper he was responsible for first set out the theme of communism turned into bureaucratic rule. The historian Tim B. Müller sums up that the analyses of Marcuse and his colleagues consistently argued for a policy of détente. After leaving government he continued his research at Columbia University's Russian Institute in 1952–53 and Harvard's Russian Research Center in 1954–55, and the book appeared in 1958 in Columbia University Press's series of Studies of the Russian Institute. Douglas Kellner notes that it rested partly on his OSS and State Department work and the classified report he wrote there.

Opinion was divided from the start. The historian Sidney Monas called it a dense, eloquent and convincing book that brought the insights of Hegel, Marx and Freud to bear on Soviet ideology, noting that its analysis differed from Isaac Deutscher's and that its conclusions were far bleaker than those of Eros and Civilization. John Francis Cronin compared it to the work of Milovan Djilas. The political scientist Edward Taborsky, on the other hand, held that Marcuse was biased by a belief in the "over-riding rationality" of the Soviet system: wrong to see faith in the rationality of Soviet indoctrination as decisive for the regime's popular strength, wrong to expect Communist parties to turn social democratic, wrong to find few Soviet moral ideas not shared by Western ethics, and wrong in implying that Soviet totalitarianism was caused by the existence of a competitive Western society. Müller called the book "a manifesto of the politics of détente", and the Croatian political scientist Žarko Puhovski regards it as probably the first theoretical description of "real socialism". Marcuse stayed interested to the end in the possibility of changing Soviet-type socialism from within. Shortly before his death he defended the East German dissident Rudolf Bahro and called Bahro's The Alternative: A Critique of Really Existing Socialism the most important contribution to Marxist theory and practice to appear in recent decades.

Engagement with the New Left and student movements

In the 1960s Marcuse’s writing became directly entangled with New Left and student-movement debates. One-Dimensional Man (1964) and “Repressive Tolerance” (1965) criticized the integration of advanced industrial society and liberal notions of tolerance; he also spoke at student protests, engaging with the movement’s concerns. Written while he taught at Brandeis, One-Dimensional Man circulated widely among student activists, and his teaching and writing influenced students including Angela Davis. Yet student movements were active before his works appeared, and Marcuse himself lightly rejected the media’s label of him as the New Left’s “father.” His role is better understood as a theorist and public speaker who connected existing resistance with new forms of political criticism, rather than as the movement’s founder. He continued engaging with the New Left through speaking appearances in the United States and Western Europe in the late 1960s and 1970s.

One-Dimensional Man and "Repressive Tolerance": how does an affluent society swallow criticism?

Written during his years at Brandeis, One-Dimensional Man: Studies in the Ideology of Advanced Industrial Society (1964) opens with the sentence that "a comfortable, smooth, reasonable, democratic unfreedom prevails in advanced industrial civilization". He meant not a dictatorship that holds people down by force but an unfreedom people accept willingly. He returned to the "negative thinking" he had defended in Reason and Revolution. Critical thinking is "two-dimensional": it sees the gap between what is and what could be, and the contradictions and domination in society. "One-dimensional" thinking erases that gap and accepts reality as the only possibility. In a society ruled by such thinking the very capacity to criticise and oppose withers away.

How does this happen? Marcuse held that the mass media, advertising, industrial management and the prevailing modes of thought create "false needs" that tie people into the system of production and consumption. In his well-known line, people recognize themselves in their commodities and find their soul in their automobile, hi-fi set and kitchen equipment. Domination no longer works through authority figures such as fathers or teachers but takes the form of institutions and "administration". Under the pressure of consumerism the working class has been integrated into the system, and its parties and trade unions have become bureaucratized. Marcuse therefore questioned the classical Marxist expectation of a revolutionary proletariat and of inevitable capitalist crisis. The analysis was aimed not only at the West but also at Soviet society: in both systems new forms of social repression were growing.

A widely known concept from the book is "repressive desublimation". If sublimation is the redirection of held-back desire into work or art, desublimation is the release of desire directly, without that detour. It looks like liberation, but Marcuse argued that postwar mass culture, with its flood of sexual stimulation, actually reinforces political repression: easy gratification scatters the energy to change the world, and people remain repressed and uncritical. Where then is the force for change? He pointed to those not yet integrated into one-dimensional society: the substratum of the outcasts and outsiders, the exploited and persecuted of other races and colours, the unemployed and the unemployable, together with radical intellectuals. Their opposition, he wrote, is revolutionary even if their consciousness is not. This is the "Great Refusal", the protest against that which is. Yet the book is not optimistic. It says that critical theory cannot prophesy, and closes with Walter Benjamin's words that "it is only for the sake of those without hope that hope is given to us".

The next year, "Repressive Tolerance", his contribution to A Critique of Pure Tolerance (1965) with Robert Paul Wolff and Barrington Moore Jr., applied this logic to tolerance, a core liberal value. Tolerance had once been a critical concept used by persecuted minorities against domination. But in an unequal reality, he argued, a "pure" tolerance that treats all opinions alike in practice helps those who already hold power and becomes a tool for legitimating established policies. He therefore proposed a "liberating tolerance": intolerance toward movements of the Right and toleration of movements of the Left, extending to the withdrawal of toleration of speech and assembly from groups that promote aggressive policies, armament, chauvinism, discrimination on grounds of race and religion, or that oppose the extension of public services and social security. He also called this "discriminating tolerance".

Both texts became classics of the 1960s New Left, and drew correspondingly sharp debate. Douglas Kellner ranks One-Dimensional Man as a paramount work of the 1960s and one of the most subversive books of the twentieth century, and Ronald Aronson wrote in 2014 that it was more relevant than ever. Criticism came from the left too. The council communist Paul Mattick argued that Marcuse overstated integration and underestimated capitalism's continuing tendency toward crisis, and Marcuse conceded in a private letter that this was "the only central criticism". The Marxist humanist Raya Dunayevskaya also criticised the book from a Marxist standpoint, and Marshall Berman found in it a contempt for the masses. Alasdair MacIntyre held that almost all of Marcuse's key positions were false, and that a theory giving revolutionary minorities the right to suppress opinions would block rational progress and make the radicals who held it allies of the very forces they attacked. The sociologist Nathan Glazer also reviewed it unfavourably. On the other hand the essay influenced later movements, such as the activists who campaigned for homosexuality to be removed from the classification of mental disorders, and in the twenty-first century it has been read again in debates over campus protests and Black Lives Matter. Marcuse himself repeatedly answered press charges that he advocated violence by saying that only the "violence of defense", not the "violence of aggression", could be justified.