Palmiro Togliatti

'Il Migliore': the strategist who led Western Europe's largest communist party for forty years

In the 'Yalta memorandum' written on his deathbed, he argued for polycentrism — autonomy from Moscow (1964)

Founder and secretary of the Italian Communist Party. He steered the Comintern Popular Front and, with the 1944 Salerno turn, brought the PCI into the anti-fascist coalition government. On his deathbed, his Yalta memorandum argued for polycentrism, anticipating Eurocommunism.

Activities and affiliations

Career Timeline

Related historical events

How did a Turin law student become a founder of the Italian Communist Party?

Palmiro Togliatti was born in Genoa on 26 March 1893, the third son of two schoolteachers. He was named Palmiro because he was born on Palm Sunday, and his parents were observant Catholics. His father's civil-service postings moved the family from town to town, and at the lyceum in Sassari, Sardinia, he was recognised as the school's best student. After his father died of cancer in 1911 the family fell into poverty, but a scholarship let him continue at the University of Turin. In the scholarship exam that year he met another young man from Sardinia, Antonio Gramsci.

Turin, where the Fiat works were being built, had the best organised labour movement in Italy. The young Togliatti came to socialism by way of Croce's idealism, the reviews of Prezzolini and Salvemini and the Marxism of Antonio Labriola, but the decisive influences were his friendship with Gramsci and the reality of Turin's working class. He joined the Italian Socialist Party (PSI) in 1914, yet, as part of a minority among socialists, he supported Italy's entry into the First World War on the side of the Entente. Exempted for severe short-sightedness, he volunteered with the Red Cross, was enlisted in 1916 and served in an Alpine regiment, missing an officer's commission because of pleurisy. He took his law degree in 1917.

After the war he founded the weekly L'Ordine Nuovo (The New Order) in May 1919 with Gramsci, Angelo Tasca and Umberto Terracini. In June Gramsci and Togliatti pushed out Tasca, who wanted a cultural review, and turned it into a revolutionary voice. Taking the Russian Revolution as their model, they saw the factory councils that had sprung up spontaneously in Turin's plants as the seeds of Italian soviets. By the end of the year the paper sold 6,000 copies, and in January 1921 it became a daily.

On 21 January 1921, at the Socialist Party congress in Livorno, the communist faction broke away to found the Communist Party of Italy (PCd'I), and Togliatti was among its founders. The party was led at first by Amadeo Bordiga. In 1922 Togliatti became editor of the party paper Il Comunista. When Mussolini took power after the March on Rome that year, Togliatti at first played down the danger, predicting that the fascist government, as a bourgeois dictatorship, would have no interest in abolishing the old democratic forms; he soon faced arrests and violence against communists. As the Comintern pressed its "Bolshevisation" campaign of 1924–1925, imposing Moscow's discipline on every party, he and Gramsci fought Bordiga's left, and in January 1926 he co-wrote with Gramsci the theses of the party's Lyon congress.

In October 1926 Gramsci addressed a letter to the Soviet party's Central Committee, worried about the factional struggle in the Soviet party, criticising Trotsky's opposition but warning against the methods of Stalin's majority. Togliatti, the party's representative in Moscow, opened it, read it and decided not to deliver it, a breach the two men never fully healed. When the fascist government banned all opposition parties that November and arrested Gramsci and other leaders, Togliatti escaped because he was in Moscow for a Comintern meeting.

What did the Comintern's "Ercoli" do in eighteen years of exile, and why is it contested?

After Gramsci's imprisonment Togliatti became party secretary in 1927 and led the banned party from exile. The centre moved to Paris; under the alias "Ercoli" he held clandestine meetings in Lyon, Cologne and elsewhere. Inside Italy communists kept an underground network going, distributing leaflets and papers and infiltrating fascist unions and youth groups; more than three quarters of the political prisoners of 1926–1943 were communists. In 1930 he gave up Italian citizenship to become a Soviet citizen, and from 1934 he was based in Moscow.

At the Comintern's Seventh Congress in 1935 he joined the secretariat with Dimitrov and became one of the leaders of the Popular Front line, which sought to unite social democrats and even the middle classes against fascism. When the Spanish Civil War broke out in 1936 he was sent to Spain as the Comintern's representative and, as "Alfredo", guided the Spanish Communist Party until 1939. There the Comintern fought Franco while also attacking other left-wing organisations on the Republican side that did not follow Stalin, whose activists were arrested and killed. Leaving Spain in 1939, he was briefly arrested in France, then returned to the Soviet Union, and during the war he called on Italians to resist over Radio Milano-Libertà.

This is the most contested part of his life. During the Great Purge many Italian communist exiles in Moscow, reported by their own party's leaders as "unreliable", were sent to the camps or shot, and Italian researchers hold the party leadership, Togliatti included, responsible for denouncing comrades who did not conform to Stalinism. In August 1936 the party journal carried an appeal "to the brothers in black shirts", offering fascist rank-and-file unity with the communists to realise the fascist programme of 1919. It was written by Ruggero Grieco, who ran the party while Togliatti was at the Comintern, and went out with Togliatti's and other leaders' names attached; Togliatti later called it "a piece of nonsense". A letter he wrote in 1943 about the fate of Italian soldiers taken prisoner in the Soviet Union caused an uproar when part of it was published, in a distorted form, in 1992.

At the same time, in Moscow he analysed Italian fascism and worked out a strategy of broad alliances reaching the middle classes, which after 1943 became his idea of a cross-class "new party". His defenders say that he survived and kept the party alive in a situation where the Italian underground and anti-fascist struggle were impossible without Soviet support; his critics say he took part in, or kept silent about, Stalin's crimes. Trotsky called him "the jurist of the Comintern". In May 1943 the party renamed itself the Italian Communist Party (PCI), and in March 1944 Togliatti returned to Italy after eighteen years abroad.

The Salerno turn (1944) — a communist party joins an anti-fascist cabinet

In March 1944 Italy was split in three. The south under Allied occupation. The north under the Nazi puppet Salò Republic. And the mountain zones of the north, where communist-led partisans were fighting a grinding guerrilla war.

Palmiro Togliatti, eighteen years in exile (most of them in Moscow), landed in Naples and stunned everyone with his strategic proposal: the PCI would join Marshal Badoglio's anti-fascist cabinet. The monarchy question would be postponed until after the war. The immediate task was to destroy fascism.

This was the Salerno turn (Svolta di Salerno).

Party hardliners were furious: it meant entering a government led by a marshal and a king who had served the fascist regime. But Togliatti's calculation was cold: (1) avoid an immediate civil war and concentrate all forces against fascism, (2) build the PCI's mass base inside the legal political space, (3) prevent the left from being excluded from the postwar settlement that the monarchy was preparing.

It worked. The PCI grew into Western Europe's largest communist party and Togliatti became one of the 'fathers' of the republican constitution. The clauses the communists won in the Constituent Assembly still form the frame of Italian democracy today.

The Salerno turn has been read both as the forerunner of 1970s Eurocommunism and as the moment the revolution was abandoned. Togliatti's own answer came in his final text, the Yalta memorandum: 'Every party must know how to act in an autonomous manner.'

From minister to opposition leader: what did Togliatti do in the postwar republic?

From the second Badoglio government of April 1944 Togliatti was part of the governments of national unity. Until June 1945 he was minister without portfolio and deputy prime minister under Badoglio and Bonomi, and from June 1945 to July 1946 he was Minister of Justice under Parri and De Gasperi. He promoted a mass "new party" open across class lines, and membership grew from a few thousand in 1943 to two million in 1946. He and the Christian Democrat De Gasperi, ideological adversaries, proved skilled mediators in a difficult period.

The amnesty of June 1946 that bears his name, issued while he was Minister of Justice, remains controversial. It was meant to close the account of the political crimes of the near civil war of 1943–1945 and reunite the country, and as a compromise between the Communists and Christian Democrats it pardoned both partisans and fascists. The gravest crimes and those of high officials were excluded, but in practice judges were far more lenient to fascists and collaborators than to partisans, who were treated like common criminals. Combined with later reductions of sentence and paroles, critics say, the amnesty turned into amnesia.

On 2 June 1946 a referendum made Italy a republic, and in the Constituent Assembly elected the same day the PCI won 19 percent and 104 seats. Togliatti was deeply involved in drafting the constitution, working with the Catholic jurist Giuseppe Dossetti among others. In March 1947, against much of his own party, he voted to write the Lateran Pacts of 1929 between Mussolini and the Holy See into the constitution (Article 7), avoiding a head-on clash with Catholic Italy. But in May 1947, with the United States involved, the Communist ministers were ejected from government, as in France, and the Cold War settled over Western Europe.

In the April 1948 election the Popular Democratic Front of the PCI and Nenni's Socialists won only 31 percent and was heavily defeated by the Christian Democrats. The campaign was marked by heavy American funding and propaganda, threats to cut off Marshall Plan aid, and the intervention of the Church, and Togliatti protested that the election had not been free. Three months later, on 14 July, as he left parliament he was shot three times and gravely wounded by Antonio Pallante, a student with neo-fascist sympathies. The CGIL union federation called a general strike and parts of the country came close to insurrection, but once he regained consciousness Togliatti appealed for calm from his hospital bed and defused the danger of an armed rising.

From then on the PCI was permanently in opposition nationally, but it ran many local governments and became Western Europe's largest non-ruling communist party. In 1950 a car accident fractured his skull and required brain surgery. In 1951 Stalin offered him the post of secretary-general of the Cominform; he declined and stayed in Italy. In 1953 he led the campaign against an electoral law giving a bonus of seats to the majority, which he called the "swindle law", and in that year's election the PCI won 22.6 percent, confirming itself as the leading opposition party.

How did Togliatti position himself towards Moscow after 1956?

When Khrushchev denounced Stalin's personality cult at the Soviet party's Twentieth Congress in February 1956 and spoke of peaceful coexistence and a possible "parliamentary transition to socialism", Togliatti took it as vindication of the "Italian road to socialism" he had followed since the Salerno turn. In a June 1956 interview with the review Nuovi Argomenti he suggested, cautiously, that Stalin's personal failings could not explain everything and that the roots had to be sought in the Soviet party of the 1920s, and he first used the word "polycentrism" for a communist movement without a single centre.

Faced with the Hungarian revolution that autumn, however, he sided with Moscow. He treated the Poznań rising in Poland in June and the Budapest rising in October as threats to the stability of socialism. Documents found after the Soviet archives opened show that he urged the Soviet leadership to intervene by force, describing events in Hungary as a "fascist-clerical reaction". Intellectuals who demanded solidarity with the Hungarian people, such as Antonio Giolitti, left the party, and many Italian intellectuals distanced themselves from the PCI. At the same time he sidelined the hard-line Stalinists in the party, and at the Eighth Congress in December 1956 made the Italian road to socialism the party's official programme. Hungary shook many Western communist parties, but his leadership survived intact.

In the 1960s he sought to broaden the PCI into a wider mass party. In a December 1961 article in Rinascita he set out "unity in diversity", and in a 1963 speech in Bergamo, "The Destiny of Man", he appealed for Catholics and communists to stand together against consumerism and the commodification of life. In the 1963 election the PCI passed 25 percent. Internationally, as the Sino-Soviet split deepened, he resisted the Soviet leaders' plan for an international conference to condemn China and tried to keep the communist movement from splitting in two.

In August 1964 he went to the Soviet Union to discuss this, and while on holiday at Yalta in Crimea with his partner Nilde Iotti he suffered a cerebral haemorrhage and died on 21 August, aged seventy-one. The memorandum he had just finished, the Yalta Memorandum, was published by the party after his death. In it he declared himself a "decisive champion" of the autonomy of each party, noted that the problem of how the cult of Stalin had become possible remained unresolved, and criticised the socialist countries for their slowness in overcoming "the regime of restrictions and suppression of democratic and personal freedom introduced by Stalin". It did not, however, question the idea of the dictatorship of the proletariat itself.

Some one million people attended his funeral in Rome, and the Soviet Union renamed the Volga city of Stavropol-on-Volga Tolyatti in his honour. Enrico Berlinguer, whom he regarded as his heir, later led the PCI into Eurocommunism. He is remembered both as a statesman who helped found the democratic republic and rooted a communist party in parliamentary democracy, and as a leader who stayed loyal to Moscow to the end, backed the crushing of Hungary and never fully faced the party's Stalin-era past.