camp · 1960s–present

Camp (aesthetics)

캠프 (미학)

A sensibility that loves the artificial, the exaggerated and the "too much," and looks at style before content: the taste that recognises works and people made in earnest that fail somehow and are enjoyable for it. Long a piece of gay subcultural slang, the word was first set down at length in 1964 by the American critic Susan Sontag in fifty-eight numbered notes. Queer theory and cultural studies later reread camp, and Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick proposed seeing it not as a technique for exposing a culture but as a "reparative" practice that draws from a culture the means to live.

In depth

Not a lamp but a "lamp": what is camp?

In 1964 Partisan Review (vol. 31, no. 4) printed Susan Sontag's "Notes on 'Camp'." It opens by observing that many things in the world have not been named, and many that have been named have never been described; one of them is the sensibility that goes by the cult name of "Camp." Sontag held that it could not be caught in a linear argument and set it down instead as fifty-eight numbered jottings. The piece is dedicated to Oscar Wilde, and Wilde's epigrams are scattered among the notes. It was collected in Against Interpretation (1966).

She begins by showing. Note 4 is a random list of items in "the canon of Camp": Tiffany lamps, Aubrey Beardsley's drawings, Swan Lake, Bellini's operas, the 1933 King Kong, the women's clothes of the twenties with their feather boas and fringed, beaded dresses. She calls Art Nouveau the most typical and fully developed Camp style and cites the Paris Métro entrances Hector Guimard designed in the late 1890s in the form of cast-iron orchid stalks. Making one thing into something else, the lamp shaped like a flowering plant, the living room that is really a grotto, "things-being-what-they-are-not," is what catches the camp eye. Her shortest definition:

Camp sees everything in quotation marks. It's not a lamp, but a "lamp"; not a woman, but a "woman."

She called this the farthest extension, in sensibility, of the metaphor of life as theatre: understanding Being as Playing a Role. Hence camp's attraction to the androgynous and, conversely, to sexual characteristics blown up beyond measure; she cited Greta Garbo's androgynous beauty alongside the flamboyant femaleness of Jayne Mansfield and the exaggerated he-manness of Steve Reeves.

How did Sontag define camp?

For Sontag camp is first a mode of aestheticism, one way of seeing the world as an aesthetic phenomenon, measured not by beauty but by style. To emphasise style is to slight content, so the camp sensibility is "disengaged, depoliticized, or at least apolitical." Nothing in nature can be camp, nothing rural either: camp is artificial and urban.

She distinguished naive from deliberate camp. The pure examples are unintentional and dead serious. The Art Nouveau craftsman who coils a snake round a lamp is not joking; he is saying in all earnestness, "Voilà! the Orient!" Busby Berkeley's numbers for the early-thirties Warner Brothers musicals do not mean to be funny. Work made in order to be campy is usually less satisfying. Her summary:

In naive, or pure, Camp, the essential element is seriousness, a seriousness that fails.

Not every failure qualifies: it takes the right mixture of the exaggerated, the fantastic, the passionate and the naive. What is merely mediocre in ambition is just bad, and what succeeds is not camp either. Eisenstein's films, she wrote, are not camp because for all their exaggeration they succeed dramatically without surplus; had Ivan the Terrible been a little more "off" it could have been great camp. The hallmark is the spirit of extravagance: camp is a woman walking around in a dress made of three million feathers.

Camp does not reverse good and bad; it offers art and life a different, supplementary set of standards. Sontag named three creative sensibilities. That of high culture, worshipping truth, beauty and seriousness, is moralistic; that of extreme states of feeling, represented by much contemporary "avant-garde" art, draws its power from a tension between moral and aesthetic passion; the third, camp, is wholly aesthetic, the sensibility of failed seriousness and of the theatricalisation of experience. The last note reads:

The ultimate Camp statement: it's good because it's awful....

But one cannot always say that, she added, only under the conditions the notes try to sketch. Camp only seems like malice or cynicism, she wrote; it is generous. Camp taste is enjoyment rather than judgement, identifies with what it enjoys, and is "a kind of love, love for human nature." That is why kitsch without that love, such as the novel Peyton Place, cannot be camp.

How is camp related to gay subculture?

At the outset Sontag calls camp a private code, a badge of identity among small urban cliques, which apart from a two-page sketch in Christopher Isherwood's novel The World in the Evening had never broken into print; to talk about it is to betray it. She confesses that she is strongly drawn to camp and almost as strongly repelled, and that describing a sensibility requires "a deep sympathy modified by revulsion." (Isherwood's novel came out in 1954; the 1964 magazine text dates it 1948.)

She placed the history of camp taste within the history of snob taste. With no authentic aristocrats left, its bearer is "an improvised self-elected class, mainly homosexuals, who constitute themselves as aristocrats of taste." Camp taste is not homosexual taste, she wrote, but there is a peculiar affinity and overlap: homosexuals are its vanguard and its most articulate audience. In her account homosexuals pinned their integration into society on promoting the aesthetic rather than the moral sense, and camp is "a solvent of morality" that neutralises moral indignation and sponsors playfulness. Yet if homosexuals had not more or less invented camp, she added, someone else would have.

Why was Sontag's account criticised and reread?

The essay brought the word to mainstream consciousness, but it was also faulted for turning a gay subcultural code into an apolitical taste described from outside. The art historian David Carrier held that her celebration of camp's ecstatic marginality downplays its implicit subversiveness. The scholar Moe Meyer defined camp as "queer parody," and the journalist Jack Babuscio called it a specific gay sensibility long misused to signify the trivial and superficial.

Queer theory in the 1990s mostly read camp as a technique for exposing and twisting the assumptions of a dominant culture; Judith Butler's theory of gender performativity, which offered drag as a practice that unsettles the idea of an original gender, is the leading example. Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick objected to this way of reading in "Paranoid Reading and Reparative Reading," first published in 1997 and reprinted in Touching Feeling in 2003:

The queer-identified practice of camp, for example, may be seriously misrecognized when it is viewed, as Butler and others view it, through paranoid lenses.

If camp is seen only as parody, denaturalisation and exposure, she argued, the love in camp is understood only as complicity with an oppressive status quo. She proposed seeing camp instead as the communal, historically dense exploration of a variety of reparative practices. Only then can one do justice to the defining elements of classic camp performance: the juicy displays of excess erudition, the passionate, often hilarious antiquarianism, the prodigal production of alternative historiographies, the "over"-attachment to fragmentary, marginal, waste or leftover products, the disorienting juxtapositions of present with past and popular with high culture. Her examples were Ronald Firbank, Djuna Barnes, Joseph Cornell, Kenneth Anger, Charles Ludlam, Jack Smith, John Waters and Holly Hughes; Sontag, in the same years, wrote in defence of Jack Smith's film Flaming Creatures. Reparative reading is treated under "Paranoid Reading and Reparative Reading."

How does camp treat mass culture and the commodity?

Sontag was explicit that camp belongs to the age of mass culture. The nineteenth-century dandy sought rare sensations undefiled by mass appreciation; the connoisseur of camp finds pleasure in the coarsest, commonest pleasures, in the arts of the masses. She called camp the answer to the problem of how to be a dandy in the age of mass culture: it makes no distinction between the unique and the mass-produced object and "transcends the nausea of the replica." The relation between boredom and camp, she added, cannot be overestimated, and camp taste is by its nature possible only in affluent societies.

The same Partisan Review had printed Clement Greenberg's "Avant-Garde and Kitsch" twenty-five years earlier, in 1939. Greenberg held that avant-garde and modernist art defended culture against kitsch, the ersatz culture of consumerism. Sontag's camp stands elsewhere: it does not despise kitsch and the products of mass culture but enjoys them again with love. She also set it apart from Pop Art, which she found related but flatter, drier, more detached and ultimately nihilistic. Later the Marxist critic Fredric Jameson read "the waning of depth" in Andy Warhol's pictures as a mark of late-capitalist culture (see "Postmodernism, or, the Cultural Logic of Late Capitalism").

The cultural critic Andrew Ross described camp as combining outmoded and contemporary forms of style, fashion and technology, reappropriating a "throwaway Pop aesthetic," and intermingling the categories of high and low culture. Camp has also gone on being turned into a commodity. In 2019 the Costume Institute of the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York built its exhibition Camp: Notes on Fashion around Sontag's essay, and camp was that year's Met Gala theme; the curator Andrew Bolton said camp comes to the fore in moments of social and political instability, as in the 1960s, the 1980s and now. As camp went mainstream, critics such as Jack Babuscio argued that it needs LGBTQ people's distance from the mainstream to keep its edge.

Where does the word come from?

Its origin is uncertain. One account derives it, through the British gay slang Polari, from the Italian campare ("to live, to get by"), another from the French se camper ("to pose in an exaggerated fashion"). Isherwood's 1954 novel distinguished Low Camp from High Camp; a character says you cannot camp about something you don't take seriously, you are not making fun of it but making fun out of it. Sontag placed the soundest starting point of camp in the modern sense in the late seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries, and in the nineteenth century saw wits such as Wilde and Firbank become its conscious ideologists.

In Korean the bare word kaempeu far more often means a prison camp, a military encampment or camping; this entry covers only camp as an aesthetic and cultural sensibility.

Related people

Sources

  1. bu.edu
  2. Wikipedia (EN)
  3. Wikipedia (EN)
  4. archive.org
  5. dukeupress.edu
  6. evekosofskysedgwick.net
  7. Wikipedia (EN)
  8. image.aladin.co.kr
  9. aladin.co.kr
  10. Wikipedia (EN)
  11. Wikipedia (EN)