Deutsche Zeitschrift für Philosophie (DZfPh) · 1953–present

Deutsche Zeitschrift für Philosophie

《독일 철학 잡지》

The leading philosophy journal of East Germany, founded in East Berlin in 1953. Ernst Bloch, Wolfgang Harich and others edited it, aiming at intellectuals across the German-speaking world, but after the Hegel debate and Harich's arrest in 1956 it became an organ under party control. It has continued since unification, appearing every two months with De Gruyter.

In depth

Why does one journal get an entry?

Scholarly journals are usually read only by specialists. But if, in some country, an issue of a philosophy journal is printed, withdrawn and reprinted with its contents page and pagination altered so that it seems never to have existed, the journal becomes a record of something. The Deutsche Zeitschrift für Philosophie is such a case. In East Germany, the question of how far philosophy could speak for itself before political power was played out in the pages of this journal.

Abbreviated DZfPh, it appeared in 1953, after Kurt Hager announced a specialist philosophy journal at the Jena logic conference of 1951. In East German times it was published by the Akademie-Verlag in East Berlin.

What kind of journal was it meant to be?

The editors were four: Ernst Bloch, Wolfgang Harich, Arthur Baumgarten and the logician Karl Schröter. Harich recalled the plan in the 1990s: the four editors, the editorial secretary Hertwig and, from afar, Lukács agreed on making a journal that would impress philosophically interested intellectuals "in the whole German-speaking area" through the highest possible standard and so help open them to Marxist thought.

die philosophisch interessierte Intelligentsja im ganzen deutschen Sprachraum durch möglichst hohes Niveau zu beeindrucken

Sources differ on the first editor-in-chief. The German Wikipedia article names Schröter, while the Hegel-Institut study covering the years up to 1956 and the journalist Fricke call Harich the editor-in-chief. When the editorial board arrived in 1955, the editor-in-chief it joined was Harich. Whether Schröter was first named while Harich ran the journal in practice could not be settled from the sources behind this entry.

Its pages in the first years carried Georg Lukács, Auguste Cornu, Werner Krauss, Harich and Schröter. The Hegel-Institut study judges this a visibly different kind of discourse from the party journal Einheit of the same years: socialist in intention, yet in no way a propagandist for party resolutions.

What was at stake in the Hegel debate?

The question was not only how to rate a philosopher of long ago. During the war, in 1944, Stalin had fixed by a secret decision of the Soviet Central Committee the verdict that Hegel had fostered German nationalism and become a forerunner of fascism. Was Marxism Hegel's heir, or his opposite? On the answer depended whether dialectics was a way of thinking for oneself or a judgement the party handed down case by case.

In 1954 the journal ran, across two issues, an article by Rugard Otto Gropp of Leipzig. His claim was plain: "The class struggle between bourgeoisie and proletariat is also waged in the field of philosophy as a struggle between materialism and idealism."

Der Klassenkampf zwischen Bourgeoisie und Proletariat wird auf dem Gebiet der Philosophie ebenfalls geführt als ein Kampf zwischen Materialismus und Idealismus.

For Gropp, materialist dialectics lay in the facts of the class struggle, and the theorist merely made it conscious. He named Cornu, Lukács, Bloch and Fritz Behrens as conciliators.

Against a contrary recommendation from Hager, the editors put Gropp's article up for discussion in issue 3 of 1954. It became the only explicit Hegel debate in the journal. Cornu, Behrens, Schubardt, Albrecht and Mönke rejected Gropp, and in issue 2 of 1956 the young Helmut Seidel and Klaus Gäbler turned Lenin's Hegel studies against him as a weapon. Only Schleifstein and Höppner took his side. Bloch counted six against two in his open letter of 1957.

What happened to the journal in 1956?

The party's response came first through organization. In April 1955, by party order, an editorial board was created, placing Matthäus Klein, Alfred Kosing, Hermann Ley and Georg Mende beside editor-in-chief Harich. The journal announced this as "the principle of collectivity in the management of the journal".

In November 1956, part of the print run of that year's issue 5, with Harich's Hegel article, went out. That same month Harich was arrested. What followed the philosopher Iring Fetscher counted a unique curiosity in the history of scholarly journals. In April 1957 the reorganized editors issued a double number 5/6 without a word about issue 5, bound in an annual contents list that left issue 5 out, and made its pagination run straight on from issue 4. Among the pieces that vanished were Harich's discussion article and Bloch's essay on separating Hegel's method from his system. For readers inside East Germany, the issue had disappeared.

The board of editors was dissolved without explanation, and the editorial secretary Hertwig went to prison with Harich. The leading article of the first issue of 1957 mocked Harich's "quackeries, addicted to mediation". Articles on Hegel fell sharply in number after that.

What was it afterwards?

From then on a new generation of authors took over, but dispute went on inside the journal. It was here that Georg Klaus and others introduced cybernetics; by Jérôme Segal's count, almost 90 titles on cybernetics appeared in it between 1960 and 1971. Yet Klaus Fuchs-Kittowski's review criticizing Klaus's book as dogmatic was not published. From 1980 to 1986, 24 articles on the problem of contradiction show what occupied philosophers then.

Judgement depends on the period in view. The first years have been called a "spring" of East German philosophy, as by Claus Burrichter. Of the rest one can say that party control and specialist discussion existed side by side. Hans-Christoph Rauh has written on these years, but his text could not be consulted for this entry.

After unification most institutions of East German philosophy were wound up, and the Central Institute for Philosophy in Berlin was dissolved entirely. The journal survived. It now appears every two months with De Gruyter as an international German-language journal with English summaries, intended to serve discussion between different philosophical schools.

Related people

Sources

  1. de.wikipedia.org
  2. hegel-institut.de
  3. bpb.de
  4. bpb.de
  5. cosmonautmag.com
  6. deutschlandfunk.de
  7. de.wikipedia.org