Postmodernism · 1960s–1990s

Postmodernism

포스트모더니즘

The collective name for the currents that appeared in architecture, art, literature and philosophy from the 1960s to the 1990s, doubting modernism's austerity and its faith in progress, mixing styles and quoting them playfully. In architecture it revived historical ornament and popular taste against the unornamented International Style; in art it took in the imagery of advertising and commodities and blurred the line between high art and mass culture; in philosophy Jean-François Lyotard defined it in 1979 as "incredulity towards metanarratives". The same word moves between a cultural style (postmodernism), a diagnosis of an epoch (postmodernity) and a philosophical current (poststructuralism), and Marxists divided over whether it was the culture produced by a new phase of capitalism, the resignation of a defeated left, or an overblown fashion.

In depth

What does postmodernism refer to?

On 16 March 1972, television showed an eleven-storey apartment block in St. Louis, Missouri, collapsing under dynamite. It belonged to Pruitt–Igoe, a public housing project first occupied in 1954. Designed by the architect Minoru Yamasaki in the modernist style, the complex consisted of thirty-three eleven-storey high rises and, when it opened, was one of the largest public housing developments in the United States. Poor maintenance and crime soon ran it down, and by 1970 more than two-thirds of it stood empty. After the first building was blown up, others followed on 21 April, 9 June and 15 July. In The Language of Post-Modern Architecture (1977) the architecture critic Charles Jencks wrote:

Modern architecture died in St. Louis, Missouri, on 15 July 1972 at 3:32 p.m. (or thereabouts) when the infamous Pruitt–Igoe scheme, or rather several of its slab blocks, were given the final coup de grâce by dynamite.

That sentence is the most famous scene through which the public came to know the word postmodernism. It announced the collapse of modernism's promise that rationally designed buildings would improve people's lives. Later research revised the story, however. In her 1991 article "The Pruitt–Igoe Myth" the architecture scholar Katharine Bristol argued that underfunded public housing, poverty and racial discrimination, and the fact that St. Louis lost some thirty per cent of its population, mattered more than the design flaws. Whether what collapsed was a principle of architecture or an American urban policy is still argued over.

Postmodernism is therefore less a single theory than a bundle of attitudes that appeared almost simultaneously in many fields after the 1960s. Architecture revived ornament, art painted soup cans and photographs of film stars, novels showed readers that they were novels, and philosophy distrusted the one great story that explains everything. The literary scholar Hans Bertens sums up the common denominator of these postmodernisms as "a crisis in representation", a loss of faith in our ability to represent the real.

Reading the word, one always has to keep a few others apart. "Modernity" names the condition of society and experience created by industrialisation, urbanisation and secularisation; modernisation is the socio-economic process that brings that condition about; and "Modernism (arts)" is the artistic and cultural response to it. Postmodernism divides the same way into three. In the narrow sense postmodernism is a cultural and artistic style of the period after the 1960s; postmodernity is the epoch or social condition in which that culture appeared; and "Post-structuralism" is a philosophical current that arose in France in the 1960s. Literary studies have also proposed distinguishing postmodernity as a historical period from the mid-1960s, theoretical postmodernism as the theories of Barthes, Derrida, Foucault and others, and cultural postmodernism as film, literature and visual art with postmodern features. The three are entangled but not the same. Derrida and Foucault are often named as representatives of postmodernism, yet they hardly ever defined the postmodern themselves or took part in the debate about it.

The word also has a long history. "Postmodern" was first used in 1870 by the English painter John Watkins Chapman for painting that went beyond French Impressionism, and in 1939 the historian Arnold Toynbee wrote that the First World War had inaugurated a "Post-Modern Age". The Marxist historian Perry Anderson, in The Origins of Postmodernity (1998), pointed out that the word was first used in the Spanish-speaking world of the 1930s, crediting the Spanish literary scholar Federico de Onís with "postmodernismo". The present meaning began with the Black Mountain poets Charles Olson and Robert Creeley in the 1950s and spread to literary criticism in the 1970s, architectural theory in the 1980s and, after Lyotard, philosophy.

What changed in architecture?

Postmodernism took its most visible form in architecture. The cities of America and Europe after the Second World War were covered with the glass, steel and concrete boxes of the International Style. The German-born architect Ludwig Mies van der Rohe's dictum "less is more" summed up its spirit: the belief that a building stripped of ornament down to structure and function is honest and universal.

The American architect Robert Venturi was the first to rebel against that belief on a large scale. In 1966 the Museum of Modern Art in New York published his Complexity and Contradiction in Architecture, which defended ambiguous and contradictory forms against pure and unified ones. His twist on Mies's phrase was "less is a bore". The house he built for his mother in Philadelphia in 1962–64, the Vanna Venturi House, is a small five-room house that looks monumental thanks to a gable and a non-structural appliqué arch on its front.

In 1972 Venturi published Learning from Las Vegas with his wife and partner Denise Scott Brown and Steven Izenour, the result of a 1968 study of the Las Vegas strip with Yale students. The book called a building whose form is itself the symbol a "duck" and an ordinary shed given meaning by signs and decoration a "decorated shed", and argued that modernist buildings, having given up ornament, had become mute and vacuous. Its call to learn from the casino signs and parking lots that elite architects despised split the profession.

Jencks gave the current its name. The Language of Post-Modern Architecture (1977) ran to seven editions, and he defined postmodern architecture as "double coding": the combination of modern techniques with something else, usually traditional building, so that architecture speaks at once to the public and to a concerned minority, usually other architects. Charles Moore's Piazza d'Italia in New Orleans (1978) and Michael Graves's Portland Building (1982) became its landmarks. When the Venice Biennale first opened to architecture in 1980, historicist designs filled the show, and Jürgen Habermas answered that very exhibition with a speech in defence of modernity (see the section on Marxist assessments below).

What did it do in art and literature?

The first emblem of postmodernism in art was Andy Warhol's Campbell's Soup Cans. The thirty-two paintings of 1961–62 each reproduced one flavour of Campbell's soup can on a canvas of the same size, and were first shown in July 1962 at the Ferus Gallery in Los Angeles. A former commercial artist, Warhol painted not the things but their commercial packaging, and repeated the same image mechanically through silkscreen. The pictures blurred the line between art and commercial imagery and fuelled a debate about originality and reproduction in a consumer society. In 1961 the sculptor Claes Oldenburg opened The Store in a dime-store district of New York's Lower East Side and sold plaster hamburgers and soda cans. Pop art chose the surfaces of mass culture over the seriousness and purity of medium of modernist painting, then represented by Abstract Expressionism.

In the 1970s and 1980s came appropriation art, which takes over other people's works as they are. At her 1981 show at Metro Pictures in New York Sherrie Levine exhibited well-known photographs by Walker Evans, rephotographed from an exhibition catalogue and presented unaltered as her own work (After Walker Evans), a direct challenge to the pillars of modern art: original and copy, author and originality.

In literature the American critic Ihab Hassan made "postmodernism" a byword of literary studies with The Dismemberment of Orpheus: Toward a Postmodern Literature (1971). John Barth, who declared the novel "exhausted" as a genre, Donald Barthelme and Thomas Pynchon are counted as its representative writers. In V. (1963), The Crying of Lot 49 (1966) and Gravity's Rainbow (1973) Pynchon portrayed a world in which conspiracies and signs interlock without end and never add up to a single truth. The signature technique of the postmodern novel is metafiction, fiction that reveals that it is a made-up story. Italo Calvino's If on a winter's night a traveler (1979) is about a reader trying to read a novel of the same name, and the first chapter of Kurt Vonnegut's Slaughterhouse-Five (1969) is about the writing of the novel. The literary scholar Brian McHale argued in 1987 that where modernist fiction asked how we can know this world, postmodernist fiction asks what kind of world this is and what happens when there are several. In film, Ridley Scott's Blade Runner (1982), which mixes film noir and science fiction, 1940s clothes and punk hairstyles in a single frame, has been studied as a prime example.

How did it become a philosophical theory?

Postmodernism entered philosophy with Lyotard's The Postmodern Condition (1979). In this report, commissioned by the Conseil des universités du Québec, Lyotard gave his definition:

"Simplifying to the extreme, I define postmodern as incredulity towards metanarratives."
En simplifiant à l'extrême, on tient pour « postmoderne » l'incrédulité à l'égard des métarécits.

Metanarratives, also called grand narratives, are the great stories that gave all knowledge and history a single meaning and direction, such as the Enlightenment story of the emancipation of the rational subject or Hegel's history of universal spirit. Lyotard counted Marxism among them. The book is treated in "The Postmodern Condition".

Around the same time Jean Baudrillard argued that images and signs do not reflect reality but precede it and produce it. He called the state in which signs no longer have any original to point to the "hyperreal". That idea is treated in "Simulacrum (Baudrillard)". Derrida's deconstruction, Foucault's analysis of power and Baudrillard's hyperreality are often named as three sources of postmodern philosophy, yet the French poststructuralists themselves did not define the postmodern or intervene in the debate. Most of them began with Marxist sympathies, became disillusioned and came to oppose the French Communist Party and its application of theory, the turmoil after May 1968 being the decisive point of rupture.

Lyotard himself, interestingly, was critical of postmodernism in architecture and art. In his 1982 essay "Answering the Question: What Is Postmodernism?" he called eclecticism of Jencks's kind "the degree zero of contemporary general culture": the taste that mixes everything, listening to reggae, watching a western and eating at McDonald's for lunch, is the one best adapted to the power of capital. For him the postmodern was not what comes after the modern but the modern "in the nascent state", the moment at which the rules accepted by the previous generation are put in doubt. Using the same word, Jencks meant a historicist style that communicates with the public, Lyotard an experiment that bears witness to the unpresentable. That the word never had a single meaning is worth remembering whenever one reads this debate.

How did Marxists assess it?

The most persistent and systematic assessments of postmodernism came from Marxism and critical theory, and their answers were not one.

The first political use of the word came from the American New Left of the 1960s. The critic Irving Howe denounced postmodern literature for being content merely to reflect, rather than to try to refashion, the "increasingly shapeless" character of contemporary society. Postmodern was then close to a term of abuse for a younger generation's drift away from the ideals of socialism.

In September 1980 Jürgen Habermas, receiving the Theodor W. Adorno Prize of the city of Frankfurt, gave the speech "Modernity: An Unfinished Project". Prompted by that year's architecture exhibition at the Venice Biennale, he described the exhibitors as "an avant-garde of reversed fronts" who had sacrificed the tradition of modernity to a new historicism. He then distinguished three conservatisms that would abandon modernity: the "young conservatives", who take up the experience of aesthetic modernity but step outside the modern world (in France a line running from Georges Bataille through Michel Foucault to Jacques Derrida); the "old conservatives", who refuse to be touched by cultural modernism at all; and the "neoconservatives", who welcome economic modernisation and blame cultural modernism alone. His conclusion was that the project of modernity has not yet been fulfilled and that its deficits are to be remedied not by abandoning the Enlightenment but by radicalising it. In The Philosophical Discourse of Modernity (1985) he widened this into a critique of the whole post-Nietzschean critique of reason.

Lyotard replied in 1982 with the essay just mentioned. He asked what kind of unity Habermas had in mind in reconnecting a splintered culture with life, and wrote that the nineteenth and twentieth centuries had paid in as much terror as we can take for the nostalgia of the whole and the one. His conclusion was to wage war on totality, bear witness to the unpresentable and activate the differences. Lyotard criticised Habermas's "Theory of Communicative Action" as a "theory of unification" and put forward a pluralism in which untranslatable discourses must live side by side. Foucault, on the other hand, said he was "completely in agreement" with the problem Habermas had raised, that abandoning the work of Kant or Weber risks a fall into irrationality.

The American Marxist critic Fredric Jameson published "Postmodernism, or, the Cultural Logic of Late Capitalism" in New Left Review in 1984 and expanded it into a book of the same title in 1991. Drawing on the Belgian Marxist economist Ernest Mandel's theory of "Late capitalism", he saw postmodernism as the "cultural dominant" of the age of multinational capitalism. It is not something to be simply embraced or condemned, he argued, but something to be analysed in order to understand the social world that produced it. The features he named include the erasure of the line between high and mass culture, a "depthlessness" that makes it hard to find meaning beneath surfaces, the "waning of affect", and the shift from parody, which mixes styles to make a point, to pastiche, which mixes them without regard to their original contexts. The geographer David Harvey, in The Condition of Postmodernity (1989), connected postmodernity with the shift from Fordism to "flexible accumulation" and with the experience he called "time-space compression". Both analyses are treated in their own entries.

Alex Callinicos, a theorist of the British Socialist Workers Party, took another road in Against Postmodernism: A Marxist Critique (1989). He divided the postmodernist claims into three: the critique of the Enlightenment by Foucault, Derrida and others; the claim that High Modern art had reached an impasse and been replaced by new forms; and the claim that "post-industrial" society had arrived beyond the industrial capitalism Marx analysed. Callinicos rejected all three. There was no radical break between modern and postmodern art, and recent socio-economic changes did not depart from the classical patterns of capital accumulation. He also took issue with Habermas and Jameson. In his view postmodernism reflected the generation whose revolutionary hopes of 1968 had been disappointed, many of whom had been incorporated into the professional and managerial "new middle class"; it was best read as a symptom of political frustration and social mobility rather than as an intellectual phenomenon in its own right.

The British literary theorist Terry Eagleton reached a similar diagnosis. In a 1995 article in Monthly Review he wrote that left intellectuals had adopted postmodernism out of a sense of having been badly defeated, a belief that the left as a political tendency had little future. The next year The Illusions of Postmodernism opened:

Imagine a radical movement which had suffered an emphatic defeat.

After such a defeat, Eagleton argued, radicalism would shift from transforming the system to subverting it, and a new left ideology would arise that does not give up the dream of liberation yet scorns anyone naive enough to believe it could be realised, the attitude he called "libertarian pessimism". In After Theory (2003) he wrote that insisting on the relativity of truth leaves us powerless to criticise oppression.

Perry Anderson set the whole debate out as history in The Origins of Postmodernity (1998). Begun as a preface to Jameson's essay collection The Cultural Turn, the book traced the word's birthplace to the Spanish-speaking world, examined Hassan, Lyotard and Habermas in turn, and placed Jameson at the centre of the debate.

In sum, Habermas wanted to defend the project of modernity; Jameson and Harvey analysed postmodernism as the culture produced by a new stage of capitalism; Callinicos denied that any such new stage existed; and Eagleton read postmodernism as the state of mind of a defeated left. On the other side, Lyotard held that the age of grand narratives was over, and Baudrillard that Marxism's production-centred thinking could not explain a society of signs.

Is postmodernism over?

From the late 1990s more and more people in academia and popular culture said that postmodernism had "gone out of fashion". In 2007 McHale titled an essay "What Was Postmodernism?", beginning to speak of it in the past tense. The American "science wars" of the 1990s and the Sokal hoax of 1996 fixed a popular impression that equated postmodernism with relativism as a term of abuse.

Attempts to name what came next followed. The term "post-postmodernism" was first coined in 2003, and names such as Gilles Lipovetsky's hypermodernity, Nicolas Bourriaud's altermodern and Alan Kirby's digimodernism were proposed. In 2010 Timotheus Vermeulen and Robin van den Akker's "Notes on Metamodernism" described a new sensibility oscillating between modern idealism and postmodern scepticism, sincerity and irony. None of these labels has gained wide acceptance.

In 2022 the British critic Steven Connor argued that postmodernism had not so much died as disappeared into the general culture by assimilation: the clashing and mixing of styles had become so routine at every level of culture that little can now be called a postmodern style. The Marxist question also remains open: whether the "cultural logic of late capitalism" Jameson described has grown stronger in the age of neoliberalism and digital information technology, or given way to another logic.

Related people

Sources

  1. Wikipedia (EN)
  2. Wikipedia (EN)
  3. Wikipedia (EN)
  4. Wikipedia (EN)
  5. Wikipedia (EN)
  6. blographialiteraria.blogspot.com
  7. Wikipedia (EN)
  8. Wikipedia (EN)
  9. Wikipedia (EN)
  10. philosophyandartcollaboratory.org
  11. Wikipedia (EN)
  12. Wikipedia (EN)
  13. Wikipedia (EN)
  14. jffp.pitt.edu
  15. fr.wikipedia.org
  16. philosophyandartcollaboratory.org
  17. de.wikipedia.org
  18. de.wikipedia.org
  19. de.wikipedia.org
  20. Wikipedia (EN)
  21. Wikipedia (EN)
  22. Wikipedia (EN)
  23. Wikipedia (EN)
  24. cca.qc.ca
  25. goodreads.com
  26. connexions.org
  27. perlego.com
  28. Wikipedia (EN)
  29. Wikipedia (EN)
  30. Wikipedia (EN)
  31. aladin.co.kr
  32. aladin.co.kr