Российская ассоциация пролетарских писателей (РАПП) · 1925.01–1932.04.23

Russian Association of Proletarian Writers

러시아 프롤레타리아 작가 협회

The Russian Association of Proletarian Writers (RAPP) was the leading organisation of proletarian writers in the Soviet Union from 1925 to 1932. It held that writers of the working class should lead literature, attacked the fellow travellers and other literary groups in its journal Na literaturnom postu, and in the cultural revolution of 1928–1932 all but dominated Soviet literary life. Until 1928 it was called the All-Russian Association of Proletarian Writers (VAPP). It was dissolved by the Central Committee resolution "On the Restructuring of Literary and Artistic Organizations" of 23 April 1932, and most of its members passed into the Union of Soviet Writers. The Russian abbreviation РАПП is pronounced as one word, "rapp".

In depth

Who was to lead the literature of a workers' state?

Picture the literary scene of the new country after the revolution. On one side were skilled writers who had been writing since before the revolution. They had accepted the revolution but were not Bolsheviks, and the party called them "fellow travellers". On the other side were young Communists who had only just taken up the pen in the factories and at the Civil War front. The party resolution of 1925 divided writers into three categories: peasant writers, fellow travellers and proletarian writers. Who, then, was to lead the literature of a workers' state, and whose side was the party to take in this quarrel? The Russian Association of Proletarian Writers was the organisation that answered most loudly: proletarian writers must lead, and it is we who speak for the party line in literature.

The association began at the First All-Union Conference of Proletarian Writers in January 1925. Its general secretary was Leopold Averbakh, and Dmitry Furmanov, Yury Libedinsky, Vladimir Kirshon, Alexander Fadeyev, Vladimir Stavsky and the critic Vladimir Yermilov are counted as its main activists and ideologists. It had more than four thousand members. Despite its name, most of its leaders were not of proletarian origin.

Where did the association come from?

The first attempt to unite proletarian writers came in 1920. In January of that year worker poets who had left Proletkult formed a group called Kuznitsa ("The Smithy"), and on its initiative the First All-Russian Congress of Proletarian Writers met on 18–21 October and founded the All-Russian Association of Proletarian Writers (VAPP). Kuznitsa's leading poets, Kirillov and Gerasimov, did not accept the New Economic Policy (NEP) and left the party, and the group's poets portrayed the NEP as the ruin of the revolution.

On 7 December 1922 young Bolshevik writers in Moscow founded the October (Oktyabr) group. Its leaders were the critics G. Lelevich, Semyon Rodov and I. Vardin; Alexander Bezymensky, Artyom Vesyoly and Yury Libedinsky among others belonged to it, and Furmanov and Averbakh joined a little later. Against Kuznitsa, October insisted on unconditional support for the current party line, the NEP included. From the critical journal Na postu ("On Guard") that the group published from 1923, its members were commonly called napostovtsy, the "On-Guardists".

In March 1923 October founded the Moscow Association of Proletarian Writers (MAPP), and in April 1924 MAPP took control of VAPP and remade it in its own spirit. The All-Union conference of January 1925, which drew these currents into one organisation, is the association's starting point. When the First All-Union Congress of Proletarian Writers in May 1928 created the All-Union Federation of Associations of Proletarian Writers (VOAPP) out of the republican associations, VAPP renamed itself the Russian Association of Proletarian Writers (RAPP) and took the leading position within the federation.

What did the party resolution of 1925 tell the association?

On 18 June 1925 the Politburo of the Central Committee of the Russian Communist Party (Bolsheviks) adopted the resolution "On the Policy of the Party in the Field of Literature". The draft was written by a Politburo commission of Iosif Vareikis, Nikolai Bukharin, Anatoly Lunacharsky, Fyodor Raskolnikov and Lelevich, and the resolution was published with changes in Pravda on 1 July.

The resolution supported proletarian writers but said that their leading position in literature had not yet been given to them: "There is as yet no hegemony of proletarian writers, and the party must help these writers to earn for themselves the historical right to this hegemony."

Гегемонии пролетарских писателей еще нет, и партия должна помочь этим писателям заработать себе историческое право на эту гегемонию.

It directed a "tactful and careful attitude" toward the fellow travellers and warned proletarian writers against komchvanstvo, Communist conceit: "Against capitulationism on the one hand, and against Communist conceit on the other: such must be the slogan of the party."

Против капитулянтства, с одной стороны, и против комчванства, с другой - таков должен быть лозунг партии.

The resolution stated flatly that no group would get a monopoly: "the party cannot grant a monopoly to any one of the groups, even the most proletarian in its ideological content: that would mean ruining proletarian literature above all."

партия не может предоставить монополии какой-либо из групп, даже самой пролетарской по своему идейному содержанию: это значило бы загубить пролетарскую литературу прежде всего.

The scholar S. I. Sheshukov holds that the resolution in effect supported the position of Alexander Voronsky. Maxim Gorky welcomed it as something that would push Russian artistic creation strongly forward. Averbakh said he supported it, yet called it "the realisation of the principles of Na postu", read it his own way and did not drop his hostility to the fellow travellers. The Soviet Literary Encyclopedia of 1935 summed up that the resolution condemned the "liquidationist" positions of Trotsky and Voronsky and at the same time struck at the sectarian attitude within the association that looked down on the fellow travellers.

What split the association from within?

The leadership split over how to read the resolution. After the extraordinary conference of proletarian writers on 26–27 February 1926 the "left", Lelevich, Rodov and Vardin, who refused to cooperate with the fellow travellers, were removed from the leadership. Power passed to Averbakh, Libedinsky, Kirshon, Yermilov and Luzgin, and Fadeyev later joined them. Furmanov tried to stop Averbakh from taking over the association but died on 15 March 1926.

The new leadership replaced Proletkult's slogan of "proletarian culture" with the slogan "learn from the classics". It dropped its earlier wariness of the pre-revolutionary literary heritage and took the psychological realism of classics such as Leo Tolstoy as its model.

What did Na literaturnom postu call for?

From April 1926 the association published the theoretical journal Na literaturnom postu ("On Literary Guard"). Averbakh was its executive editor from first to last, and Yermilov, Kirshon, Fadeyev (1927–1932) and others joined the editorial board in turn. The editorial of the first issue declared: "Against all-class and above-class theories, against the liberal-minded reconcilers of everyone, against those whom the Central Committee resolution called capitulators, we are still on guard."

Против всеклассовых и надклассовых теорий, против либеральничающих всепримирителей, против тех, кого резолюция ЦК назвала капитулянтами, — мы по-прежнему на посту.

The journal put forward slogans such as "for Plekhanovite orthodoxy", "for the living man" and "the Demyanisation of poetry", named after Demyan Bedny. The concept beneath them was the "dialectical-materialist creative method", founded on "tearing off the masks": the idea that a writer who masters the right world-view, dialectical materialism, will produce the right work.

"The living man" was the slogan of the First Congress of 1928. The congress explained that it meant fighting stock types, schematism and poster-like bareness, and portraying the complex human psyche with its conscious and unconscious, its traces of the past and shoots of the new. "Tearing off all and every mask" was taken from what Lenin wrote about Tolstoy and was used as a demand not to trust a character's outward behaviour but to dig out the contradictions within. At an association plenum in 1929 Fadeyev argued in his speech "Down with Schiller!" that the proletarian artist must show the new being born in the old and winning over it, and that this set him apart from the realism and romanticism of the past. The association also held up Fadeyev's creative method as the model of "the high road of proletarian literature".

Whom did the association fight?

What made the association's name in literary history above all was its attacks. It called the views of Trotsky and Voronsky "liquidationist" for denying that a proletarian culture and literature could be created, and it fought in turn the group Pereval, which followed Voronsky, the formalists, constructivism and the Left Front of the Arts. The scheme of dividing writers into "ally or enemy" also came out of its journal at this time. Pereval came under pressure from 1927 and lost members, and when the association sharply raised the pressure on other groups in 1930, more writers left it.

The writers it attacked included Communists and non-Communists alike. Its first targets were Yevgeny Zamyatin and Boris Pilnyak, and Mikhail Bulgakov, Maxim Gorky, Vladimir Mayakovsky and Alexei Tolstoy were also targeted. The literary theorist Pavel Medvedev, accused by Fadeyev of "Kantianism, formalism", had to change his research plans. The association also fought the school of the Marxist literary scholar Valerian Pereverzev.

How strong did the association become in the cultural revolution?

From around 1928, when the first five-year plan and the Soviet cultural revolution began, the association became the centre of literary life. By 1930 the other literary groups had in practice been broken, and the association's tone turned to command. Its resolution of 4 May 1931 called on all proletarian writers to portray the heroes of the five-year plan in art and to report on carrying this out within two weeks. In 1930 the association, together with the Central Council of Trade Unions, ran a campaign to call shock workers from production into literature, and even raised the slogan "the shock worker has become the central figure of the literary movement".

Writers still outside came in. In February 1930 Mayakovsky left REF (the Revolutionary Front of the Arts), the group he had founded, and joined the association, and Eduard Bagritsky and Vladimir Lugovskoy joined the same year. But on 9 March the association's leading critic Yermilov attacked Mayakovsky's play The Bathhouse in Pravda, and when Mayakovsky put up a huge poster mocking Yermilov, the association ordered him to take it down. In the note he left at his suicide in April, Mayakovsky regretted not having finished the argument with Yermilov.

Opposition also arose within. In 1930 Bezymensky, Vsevolod Vishnevsky, Rodov and others formed Litfront (the Literary Front) to criticise the leadership's cliquishness, but the group broke up in 1931. The struggle for power and the theoretical disagreements within the association grew, and the party leadership soon ceased to be satisfied with the situation.

Why was the association dissolved in 1932?

On 23 April 1932 the Politburo of the Central Committee of the All-Union Communist Party (Bolsheviks) adopted, on a draft put forward by Lazar Kaganovich, the resolution "On the Restructuring of Literary and Artistic Organizations". The surviving text marks the words Stalin himself wrote in and struck out. The resolution said that a few years earlier, when the ranks of proletarian writers were weak, the party had helped their organisations, but that now new writers had grown up in the factories and collective farms, so the frame of the existing proletarian organisations had become narrow and was holding back creative work. These organisations were in danger of turning "from a means of the greatest mobilisation of Soviet writers and artists around the tasks of socialist construction into a means of cultivating the closedness of a clique". The conclusion was short: "to liquidate the association of proletarian writers (VOAPP, RAPP)".

ликвидировать ассоциацию пролетарских писателей (ВОАПП, РАПП)

The resolution ordered that all writers who supported the platform of Soviet power be united in a single union of Soviet writers with a Communist fraction in it, and that the same restructuring be carried out in the other arts, such as music, painting and architecture. Association leaders including Averbakh, Alexander Afinogenov, Kirshon, Fadeyev and Mikhail Chumandrin joined the 50-member organising committee that prepared the new Writers' Union. Gorky was its honorary chairman, Ivan Gronsky its chairman and Valery Kirpotin its secretary. The committee's meeting at Gorky's home on 26 October 1932 was attended by Stalin and other Politburo members and discussed "socialist realism", the key concept of the union's statute. The First Congress of Soviet Writers met from 17 August to 1 September 1934.

There is also indirect testimony about what the dissolution meant for its leaders. In a 1993 memoir, "Why Did Stalin Kill Gorky?", the linguist Vyacheslav Ivanov, son of the writer Vsevolod Ivanov, retold what Fadeyev confided at the Ivanovs' dacha in Peredelkino a few weeks before his suicide in 1956. According to this memoir, after the resolution Fadeyev hurriedly wrote an article renouncing the association and apologising for his former views and actions. Genrikh Yagoda, Averbakh's brother-in-law, who had ties to the association, then summoned him to his office and berated him for betraying his comrades in RAPP. Fadeyev defended himself by pointing to the infallibility of any government decision but left afraid that he had made a powerful enemy, and he wrote a letter recounting the clash and delivered it to the Central Committee himself. After Yagoda's arrest in 1937 he was asked to reread the letter. In 1939, given a place of honour on the presidium at Stalin's birthday celebrations, he was approached by Molotov and Kaganovich, who told him that Stalin was forever grateful to him for taking his side in 1932, "when it was not known how the struggle would end". The story rests on Fadeyev's word as Ivanov passed it on, and the researcher Jamie Allan, who cites the memoir in a 2023 Glasgow doctoral thesis, qualifies it: "If Fadeev's account can be trusted". When Ivanov told the story again in a 2017 interview the details differed: Fadeyev sent a letter to Pravda, Yagoda berated him in the billiard room of his dacha, and the men who approached him at Stalin's jubilee were Molotov and Voroshilov.

What became of the leadership?

Most members passed into the Writers' Union, and leaders such as Fadeyev and Stavsky rose to high posts in it. Stavsky was general secretary of the Writers' Union from 1936 and was killed at the front in November 1943. Fadeyev led the Writers' Union in 1938–1944 and 1946–1954 and took his own life on 13 May 1956. Alexei Surkov, elected to the association's leadership in 1928, was first secretary of the Writers' Union in 1953–1959.

Other leaders were persecuted in the late 1930s on charges of Trotskyist activity. On 23 April 1937 the philosopher Pavel Yudin published "Why RAPP Had to Be Liquidated" in Pravda, attacking Averbakh and his followers Kirshon, Afinogenov and Bruno Jasieński. Averbakh was arrested on 4 April 1937 as a close relative of his brother-in-law Genrikh Yagoda and shot on 14 August. Kirshon was expelled from the party in May 1937, arrested on 29 August and shot on 28 July 1938. Libedinsky was expelled from the party for Trotskyism in June 1937 and readmitted in 1939.

How is the association judged?

The Literary Encyclopedia of 1935, three years after the dissolution, wrote that in its first period the association had played a positive role in the fight for proletarian literature and in gathering its forces, and had trained a number of proletarian writers. At the same time it counted cliquishness, sectarianism and the suppression of creative discussion by administrative shouting among its "gross literary-political errors", and concluded that under the conditions of victorious socialist construction its influence had become negative. This judgement follows the view of the party that had dissolved it.

A later Russian dictionary of literary terms points the other way. The association was the first to put forward the category of "creative method" in literary theory, but its dogmatic and politicised approach equated method with world-view and the artistic image with an illustration of an idea. The dictionary also points to the vulgar sociology of its guiding documents, its political labels and its cliquishness, and adds that the Writers' Union that replaced it, though formally a voluntary body, could in practice, like the association, govern not only writers' creative work but their political and material lives as well.

The association thus carried on in two directions. The habit of treating literature as a weapon of class struggle and vetting writers' world-views passed into the Writers' Union, while the category of "creative method" that the association first put forward led, from the autumn of 1932, into the discussion that defined the basic method of Soviet literature and became socialist realism. Criticism also came right after the dissolution: Yelena Usievich, later active in Literaturny Kritik, attacked the association's activity in her 1932 pamphlet For the Purity of Leninism in Literary Theory as having distorted the party line in literature.

Members

Related people

Sources

  1. web.archive.org
  2. Wikipedia (RU)
  3. Wikipedia (RU)
  4. Wikipedia (RU)
  5. Wikipedia (RU)
  6. Wikipedia (RU)
  7. feb-web.ru
  8. Wikipedia (RU)
  9. web.archive.org
  10. Wikipedia (RU)
  11. Wikipedia (RU)
  12. Wikipedia (EN)
  13. Wikipedia (RU)
  14. Wikipedia (RU)
  15. Wikipedia (EN)
  16. Wikipedia (RU)
  17. hist.msu.ru
  18. Wikipedia (RU)
  19. Wikipedia (RU)
  20. Wikipedia (RU)
  21. Wikipedia (RU)
  22. Wikipedia (RU)
  23. Wikipedia (RU)
  24. Wikipedia (RU)
  25. Wikipedia (RU)
  26. Wikipedia (EN)
  27. theses.gla.ac.uk
  28. godliteratury.ru
  29. booksite.ru Большая советская энциклопедия, «Леф»: LEF transformed in 1929 into РЕФ (Революционный фронт искусств)
  30. feb-web.ru Литературная энциклопедия, «Кузница»: Кириллов и Герасимов «не приняли» нэпа и вышли из партии