The Aesthetic Dimension
미적 차원 (마르쿠제)
Herbert Marcuse's last major work, published in German in 1977 as Die Permanenz der Kunst. Wider eine bestimmte marxistische Ästhetik ("The Permanence of Art: Against a Certain Marxist Aesthetics") and widely known from the English edition of the following year, The Aesthetic Dimension: Toward a Critique of Marxist Aesthetics. It criticises orthodox Marxism for narrowing art to an expression of class consciousness, and argues that authentic art carries a promise of liberation not through political tendency but through the autonomous form by which it keeps its distance from reality.
In depth
Is a love poem a luxury for a revolutionary?
Imagine that during a strike someone in the factory reads a book of love poems on a break. A co-worker says: "Is this the time for that? We should be singing fighting songs." Are poems and paintings that do not deal directly with the workers' situation really useless to a liberation movement? In his last book Herbert Marcuse answered no. He held that the truth, experience and necessity that art expresses as art, though not in the domain of radical praxis, are nevertheless essential components of revolution.
Marcuse's literary, philosophical and political life began and ended with works on aesthetics. He wrote a doctoral dissertation, The German Artist-Novel, in 1922, and published this book a year before his death. The German edition appeared in 1977 from Hanser in Munich as Die Permanenz der Kunst. Wider eine bestimmte marxistische Ästhetik, and the English edition in 1978 as The Aesthetic Dimension.
What did it criticise?
The book is a polemic against the orthodox Marxist interpretation of the function of art. The orthodox Marxists Marcuse targeted claimed that only proletarian art could be revolutionary. As the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy summarises it, Marcuse held that in orthodox Marxist aesthetics the consciousness and unconscious of individuals tend to be dissolved into class consciousness. A major prerequisite of revolution is thereby minimised: the fact that the need for radical change must be rooted in the subjectivity of individuals themselves, in their intelligence and passions, their drives and goals.
The experience of the Frankfurt School lies behind this critique. They saw no evidence that the proletariat would rise up against its oppressors. Marcuse had long criticised so-called scientific Marxism for teaching the inevitable collapse of capitalism while playing down the subjective factor of working-class consciousness; he saw the same problem repeated in aesthetics. Instead, the book sought to establish the revolutionary potential of all art by establishing the autonomy of authentic art. This sets it clearly apart from the theory of realism György Lukács advanced in the "Expressionism debate" and from the Soviet doctrine of "socialist realism".
Why is the autonomy of art liberating?
Marcuse's view goes back to his 1937 essay "On the Affirmative Character of Culture". There he wrote that art in bourgeois society has two faces. Art is "affirmative" because it compensates for the unhappiness of what exists: in an autonomous sphere split off from society people may share in happiness only through the medium of beauty, a false reconciliation with the misery of social conditions. Yet art cannot be reduced to its affirmative character. Because it anticipates a happy state, because in Stendhal's words it holds a "promise of happiness", it remains critical and subversive in its content. For Marcuse, therefore, art was truth and ideology at once.
The Aesthetic Dimension takes this up again. Art can promise transcendence because it is conceptually independent of society, and the successful artist attains truth through the symbolic representation that comes from detachment. Such art evokes a longing for the utopian and the promise of ultimate happiness that beauty represents, and that longing wakes people from complacency. Marcuse took his standard from literature but held that it applies to music and the visual arts as well.
The enthusiasm of 1968 and its revision
Marcuse's path to this book was not straight. When he wrote An Essay on Liberation in 1969, amid the worldwide student revolt and the Paris May of 1968, he saw in action-oriented forms of art the "sublation of art as art" and harbingers of approaching social upheaval. In Counterrevolution and Revolt (1973) he revised his enthusiasm for activist and surrealist aspirations to abolish the tension between art and life. Jürgen Habermas remarked that here "we meet a Marcuse who is alarmed by the consequences of de-differentiating art and life".
lernen wir einen Marcuse kennen, der vor den Folgen einer Entdifferenzierung von Kunst und Leben erschrickt
The scholar Gerhard Schweppenhäuser called this a "revision of the revision", a return to the thinking of 1937. The Aesthetic Dimension is its outcome. Peter Bürger's "Theory of the Avant-Garde" treats the same problem from another direction.
What does it share with Benjamin and Adorno, and where does it differ?
The book responds to earlier writings on art within critical theory, notably those of Walter Benjamin and Theodor W. Adorno. Marcuse rejected the call in Benjamin's "Work of Art in the Age of Its Technological Reproducibility" for the politicisation of modern, reproducible art (see "Aura (Benjamin)"). With Adorno he agreed that art's emancipatory possibility must be realised through detachment and symbolism, but he was more inclusive than Adorno, who regarded the works of high culture as the sole source of emancipation (see "Aesthetic Theory (Adorno)").
The decisive difference concerned the future of art. Adorno, in the Hegelian-Marxist tradition, could imagine an end of art in the realised utopia of a liberated society. For Marcuse the arts remain even in a classless society: since such a society can only reduce the "realm of necessity" to a minimum, art remains "forms of expression of a beauty and truth that reality does not know in this way".
Ausdruckformen einer Schönheit und Wahrheit, die die Wirklichkeit so nicht kennt
This idea, that art never loses its reason for existing, is the "permanence of art" of the German title.