Anton Pannekoek

Netherlands state institutions Left communism Western Marxism Netherlands Netherlands 1873.1.2.–1960.4.28. ○ Natural causes

The astrophysicist who mapped the Milky Way, and the council communist Lenin attacked in 'Left-Wing Communism'

In 1910 Pannekoek moved to Bremen and soon became one of the leading voices of the radical Bremen Left. He was also an astronomer, and later measured the distance to the star clusters that make up the Milky Way clouds in Cygnus and Aquila.

Dutch astronomer and founder of council communism. He won the RAS Gold Medal for his work on stellar atmospheres and galactic structure. In the Dutch and German left he built the theory of workers' council revolution, becoming the principal target of Lenin's 'Left-Wing Communism'.

Also known as: Antonie Pannekoek · K. Horner · J. Harper · P. Aartsz

Activities and affiliations

Career Timeline

The SPD left and the Bremen Left Radicals

After reading Edward Bellamy's Equality, Pannekoek became a socialist and studied the philosophies of Marx and Joseph Dietzgen; around 1900 he joined the Dutch SDAP and wrote for Dutch and German socialist journals, his articles appearing in Kautsky's Die Neue Zeit and Mehring's Leipziger Volkszeitung. His astronomy and his politics clashed when he was reprimanded for leading a strike support committee, and in 1906 he moved to Germany, joined the SPD and taught historical materialism at the party school in Berlin.

When the German authorities barred him from teaching in 1907 under threat of expulsion, he stayed in Berlin, working in the party archive and writing for party papers. He attended SPD congresses from 1907 to 1913, going to Magdeburg in 1910 as a member of the Bremen delegation. At the same time, as a member of the Dutch Social Democratic Party (SDP) from 1909, he wrote for De Tribune and edited SDP publications, forming a close friendship with Herman Gorter.

In 1910 he was called to Bremen as the SPD's education officer, writing for the Bremer Bürger-Zeitung and later Arbeiterpolitik, and in exchange with Johann Knief he became the intellectual head of the "Bremen Left Radicals". In the mass strike debate he defended revolutionary positions against reformism in the party, and his friendship with Kautsky broke in the course of this debate, which foreshadowed the split of social democracy. When war broke out in 1914 he was on holiday in the Netherlands and could not return to Germany.

Council Communism: The Theory of Workers' Self-Emancipation

Pannekoek saw workers' councils as the sole revolutionary organ capable of carrying out the transition from capitalism to communism. Starting from the soviets of the 1917 Russian Revolution, he argued that the working class must liberate itself through councils directly elected at the point of production. Not through parties or trade unions, which he regarded as obsolete forms tied to the old order. His core critique of Lenin and the Bolsheviks was that the party substituted itself for the soviets, crippling the revolution and becoming a new ruling class. In Workers' Councils (1946, as P. Aartsz), Pannekoek laid out the concrete forms of council organisation (workplace delegates, recallability, federative coordination) anticipating the autonomous mass movements of later decades such as the French general strike of 1968. His council thought opened a third Marxist path, distinct from both anarchism and social democracy: workers becoming the ruling class through their own democratic organs.

Left communism in 1920 and the Amsterdam Bureau

Back in the Netherlands during the war, Pannekoek wrote for Robert Grimm's Berner Tagwacht and Knief's Arbeiterpolitik, and from 1917 he championed council communism, rejecting parliamentarism, trade-union work and the dictatorship of a single party alike. In 1918 he joined the Communist Party of the Netherlands, and in the socialist debates after 1917 he became a determined opponent of the Bolsheviks' "democratic centralism".

In September 1919 the Comintern Executive set up the Amsterdam Bureau as its Western European outpost and sent Sebald Rutgers as its secretary. In February 1920 the Bureau printed "theses on parliamentarism" in No. 1 of its Bulletin, and in "Left-Wing" Communism: An Infantile Disorder Lenin attacked these theses as expressing the "Dutch-Left" tendency, lacking the class analysis that rejecting parliament would require. In the same book Lenin repeatedly mocked "K. Horner", Pannekoek's pen name, alongside Laufenberg and Wolffheim, as a representative of the German "Lefts" who refused work in reactionary trade unions and insisted on not recognising the Treaty of Versailles. Pannekoek did write as Karl Horner in the Kommunistische Arbeiterzeitung of Bremen and, after the KPD split at the Heidelberg congress, in the KAPD's Proletarier.

In his Open Letter to Comrade Lenin, Gorter replied that Lenin's criticism of the Amsterdam Bureau was wrong, and protested that the Comintern had dissolved the Amsterdam Bureau, "the only group of revolutionary Marxists and theorists in Western Europe that never wavered". In 1921 Pannekoek left the Communist Party of the Netherlands for its left split, the Communist Workers' Party of the Netherlands (KAPN), working closely with Gorter.

Lenin as Philosopher (1938): Was Lenin's Materialism Bourgeois Materialism?

In 1938 Pannekoek published Lenin as Philosopher in German under the pseudonym John Harper. Dutch Wikipedia presents the book as his answer to the sharp criticism Lenin had made of him in 1920 in "Left-Wing" Communism: An Infantile Disorder, and English Wikipedia says the book set out his view that the Bolsheviks, by putting the rule of their party in place of workers' councils, had become a new ruling class.

Pannekoek explained Lenin's philosophy from the social tasks the Russian Revolution faced. In Western Europe the bourgeoisie had used natural science as a weapon against religion and raised bourgeois materialism, while the working class grew strong not through natural science but through organisation and revolutionary insight, and its theory was Marxism. In Russia, where there was no bourgeoisie of any weight, the fight against tsarism and the church fell to the intelligentsia and the working class, and so the critique of religion stood at the centre of Lenin's theory. He concludes: "Hence in Lenin there appear the same trains of thought and basic views that then moved minds in the West as bourgeois materialism; he feels himself essentially akin to their spokesmen."

Deshalb treten bei Lenin die gleichen Gedankengänge und Grundanschauungen auf, die damals im Westen als bürgerlicher Materialismus die Geister bewegten; er fühlt sich ihren Wortführern wesensverwandt.

The diagnosis, then, is that Lenin's theory of reflection and concept of matter belong not to historical materialism, which explains society from class struggle, but to a bourgeois materialism leaning on natural science. The book was translated into English in 1948, and a German edition edited by Alfred Schmidt appeared in 1969. Lenin's side of the argument is treated in the entries "Materialism and Empirio-criticism" and "Reflection theory".