The last Tsar, who believed autocracy was a duty from God
On the night of 2 March 1917, after signing the act of abdication, Nicholas II wrote in his diary: "At one in the morning I left Pskov with a heavy feeling of what I had lived through. All around there is treason, cowardice, and deceit!"
After the shootings of 1905, and even after taking personal command in 1915 and with it the blame for defeat, he held autocracy to be a trust from God that could not be yielded by an inch. In February 1917, when no army would fire for him, three hundred years of Romanov rule ended in a week; in July 1918 he was shot with his family in a cellar in Yekaterinburg.
Activities and affiliations
-
1894–1917
Russian Empire state institutionsEmperorMain
Monarchs and royalty
Career Timeline
- 1894Accedes to the throne
- 1904–1905Defeat by Japan; the 1905 revolution
- 1906Fundamental Laws: a hedged Duma order
- 1915Takes supreme command, defeat now attaches to the throne
- 1917.03Abdicates
- 1918.07Shot with his family at Yekaterinburg
Related historical events
- 1905–1907The Revolution of 1905TsarHe met the revolution with gunfire and martial law, and in the reaction took back one by one the concessions of the October Manifesto he had signed under the pressure of the general strike.
- 1912–1913The Balkan WarsRussian Emperor, arbiter of the allianceNamed arbiter in the Serbo-Bulgarian treaty of 1912, he offered on 8 June 1913 to arbitrate between the two kings, an offer Bulgaria's conditional reply effectively rejected.
- 1914–1918First World WarSupreme commander of the Russian armyIn 1915 he took supreme command and went to the front.
- 1917.02–07The February RevolutionThe abdicated tsarHaving lost both the army and the capital, he abdicated on 15 March, ending three hundred years of Romanov rule.
- 1918–1922The Civil War and Foreign InterventionDeposed by revolution and executed during the Civil WarExecuted with his family at Yekaterinburg on 17 July 1918 as the Czech Legion approached the Urals; whether the centre ordered the killing remains disputed.
How was the heir Nicholas raised, and what did he make plain as soon as he took the throne?
Nicholas II was born in May 1868, the eldest son of Emperor Alexander III and Maria Feodorovna. He was educated at court for thirteen years: eight years of an expanded gymnasium course in political history, Russian literature and English, German and French (his English was as good as a native's), then five years combining the state and economics courses of a university law faculty with the course of the General Staff Academy. His teachers were eminent scholars and officials, among them Konstantin Pobedonostsev, Over-Procurator of the Holy Synod, a conservative thinker who held autocracy and Orthodoxy to be Russia's foundations and called parliamentarism "the great lie of our time". The professors, however, could only lecture; they had no right to question the heir on what he had understood.
He served as a junior officer in Guards regiments and became a colonel in 1892. His father had him attend the State Council and the Committee of Ministers, and on Sergei Witte's suggestion made him chairman of the committee building the Trans-Siberian Railway. In 1890-1891 he made a long voyage by warship to Greece, Egypt, India, China and Japan, returning overland across Siberia. At Otsu in Japan a police guard, Tsuda Sanzō, struck him on the head with a sword and wounded him.
When Alexander III died suddenly at forty-nine in October 1894, the twenty-six-year-old Nicholas took the throne, and a few weeks later married Alexandra Feodorovna, born a princess of Hesse. On 17 January 1895 he made his first public speech, to deputations of the nobility, the zemstvos (local self-government bodies) and the towns who had come to congratulate him: "I am aware that of late, in some zemstvo assemblies, the voices of people carried away by senseless dreams of the participation of zemstvo representatives in the affairs of internal government have been heard. Let everyone know that I shall preserve the principles of autocracy as firmly and unswervingly as my unforgettable late father." It was rumoured that the written text had said "unrealisable" rather than "senseless", but either way the speech dashed educated society's hope of constitutional reform from above. Even the monarchist historian Sergei Oldenburg wrote that it became a starting point for a new rise of revolutionary agitation.
The coronation took place in Moscow in May 1896. A few days later a festival with gifts and food for the public was held on Khodynka Field, a military training ground full of ditches and trenches; rumours that there would not be enough for everyone set off a crush in which, by the official count, 1,379 people died. That night the emperor attended the French ambassador's ball as planned. He is said to have wanted to stay away and pray, but his uncles urged him to go for the sake of the French alliance; to the bereaved and the public he looked indifferent. Because of Khodynka and later Bloody Sunday, the radical opposition called him "Nicholas the Bloody".
How did the drive into the Far East and the war with Japan lead to the Revolution of 1905?
Nicholas II took a keen interest in the Far East from the start of his reign. In 1896 Russia concluded a military alliance with China against Japan and won the concession to build the Chinese Eastern Railway (КВЖД) across Manchuria to Vladivostok, and in 1898 it leased Port Arthur (Lüshun) and Dalny (Dalian) on the Liaodong Peninsula for twenty-five years. In 1900 it sent troops to help crush the Boxer Rising and kept a large army in Manchuria. Meanwhile, in 1898, he proposed an international conference to halt the arms race, which led to the Hague Peace Conference of 1899 and the Permanent Court of Arbitration. Talking peace while expanding into Manchuria was a contradiction that ran through his foreign policy.
As Russia pushed into Manchuria and Korea, a clash with Japan, which coveted the same region, became unavoidable. On the night of 26 January 1904 (Old Style) the Japanese fleet attacked the Russian squadron at Port Arthur without a declaration of war, opening the Russo-Japanese War. Russian armies lost in turn on the Yalu, at Liaoyang, on the Shaho and at Mukden; Port Arthur fell in December 1904, and in May 1905 at Tsushima the fleet sent all the way from the Baltic was almost wiped out. Through the mediation of US President Theodore Roosevelt the Treaty of Portsmouth was signed in August 1905: Russia recognised Korea as Japan's sphere and ceded southern Sakhalin and the Liaodong lease. Russia's first defeat in half a century badly damaged the emperor's authority.
During the war social anger was near boiling point. In December 1904 he issued a decree promising wider local self-government and lighter censorship, yet told Witte, "I will never, under any circumstances, agree to a representative form of government, for I consider it harmful to the people God has entrusted to me." On Sunday 9 January 1905 (Old Style) tens of thousands of workers led by the priest Georgy Gapon marched to the Winter Palace carrying icons and portraits of the tsar, to present a "Petition on the Workers' Needs" that joined economic demands with a political one, the convening of a constituent assembly. Troops fired volleys into the columns across the city. The official figure was 130 killed and 299 wounded; the Soviet historian Vladimir Nevsky estimated up to 200 killed and 800 wounded. The emperor had already left for Tsarskoye Selo, and whether he personally ordered the shooting cannot be established, since ministers' oral reports to him were not minuted. That night he wrote in his diary: "A painful day! ... The troops had to fire in several places in the city. Lord, how painful and sad!" Bloody Sunday began the Revolution of 1905.
Strikes, peasant risings, the mutiny on the battleship Potemkin and terrorist attacks followed. In August 1905 he promised a merely consultative Duma, but in October a general strike of over two million people brought the country to a halt. After long hesitation he signed, on 17 October, the October Manifesto drafted under Witte, which granted freedom of person, conscience, speech, assembly and association and promised that no law would take effect without the Duma's consent. To liberals it marked the end of unlimited autocracy. The emperor, however, saw it as a grudging concession, and at the same time quietly supported the far-right monarchist Union of the Russian People. The Moscow armed uprising in December was crushed by the army.
How did Rasputin get into the imperial family's circle, and why was his presence so damaging to the dynasty?
Grigory Rasputin, a peasant from Siberia, first met Nicholas II in November 1905. The emperor noted in his diary that he had met "a man of God, Grigory, from Tobolsk province". The Orthodox world had many "elders" and wandering holy men who held spiritual authority through pilgrimage and prayer without being ordained, and some of high society was drawn to them. Rasputin was introduced to St Petersburg society as such a figure.
What won him the imperial family's trust was that he eased the suffering of the heir Alexei, who had haemophilia, when medicine could do nothing. Because the heir's illness touched the succession it was kept a state secret, so the public had no way of knowing why this dubious peasant came and went at the palace. Rumour filled the gap. From about 1910 criticism of his debauchery and political meddling grew in the press, in the Duma and among senior clergy, but Empress Alexandra Feodorovna firmly believed he was keeping her son alive, and the emperor did not send him away.
After Nicholas II became commander-in-chief in 1915 and left for the front, the empress stood in for him in the capital, and Rasputin's influence swelled until it reached cabinet appointments. Alexandra wrote to her husband recommending or opposing candidates for ministries, and it was an open secret that Rasputin's views lay behind some of these letters. In 1916 alone four prime ministers and four interior ministers came and went. This "ministerial leapfrog" eroded the monarchy's authority, and rumours about Rasputin's private life became material for revolutionary propaganda. Suspicion even spread that the German-born empress and "dark forces" were selling the country to Germany, though no evidence for this has emerged. Historians still differ on how much Rasputin really shaped appointments, but few dispute that his presence alone destroyed confidence in the regime.
On the night of 17 December 1916 (Old Style), monarchists including Prince Felix Yusupov, the right-wing Duma deputy Vladimir Purishkevich and the emperor's cousin Grand Duke Dmitri Pavlovich lured Rasputin to the Yusupov palace, killed him and threw his body into the Neva. They believed that removing him would save the monarchy. Instead, the fact that members of the imperial circle had killed the empress's confidant exposed the rifts within the dynasty, and the emperor merely punished the plotters. By then the dynasty's credibility was beyond repair, and the February Revolution broke out barely two months later.
How did he live with the Duma after the October Manifesto, and what did Stolypin's reforms leave behind?
The Fundamental Laws revised in April 1906 gave the Duma a say in legislation, but kept the emperor an "autocrat" and left him the power to appoint and dismiss ministers and to legislate by emergency decree under Article 87. The First Duma, opened in April 1906, clashed with the government at once. Left-wing deputies demanded abolition of the State Council, the upper chamber, and the handing of state and monastery lands to the peasants, and 104 Trudovik deputies tabled a bill to confiscate landlords' estates and nationalise the land. After two months, in July, the emperor dissolved it, accusing the deputies of straying "into a sphere not theirs" instead of making laws.
With the dissolution he made Pyotr Stolypin prime minister. Stolypin crushed revolutionaries with field courts-martial and hangings (the noose was dubbed "Stolypin's necktie"), and at the same time pushed a land reform to detach peasants from the village commune (obshchina) and make them independent farmers owning their own land. The Peasant Land Bank lent them money to buy landlords' land, and scattered strips were consolidated into single holdings. By 1913 Russia led the world in rye, barley and oats, yet its grain yields per hectare were a third of Britain's or Germany's. How much the reform changed the countryside is still debated.
The Second Duma, elected with the Social Democrats and Socialist Revolutionaries taking part, was even further left. On 3 June 1907 the emperor dissolved it too and changed the electoral law unilaterally, in a way the Fundamental Laws forbade. The new law hugely increased the weight of landowners and the wealthy and produced a Duma with a moderate-right majority. This was the "Third of June system", which the opposition called a coup. According to General Mosolov of his entourage, the emperor saw Duma members not as the people's representatives but as "just intelligentsia", while he gladly spent long hours with peasant delegations. Abroad, the Anglo-Russian Convention of 1907 completed the Triple Entente with Britain and France.
Relations between Stolypin and the emperor cooled. In September 1911, in a Kiev theatre, Stolypin was shot dead by Dmitry Bogrov, who was also an informer of the Okhrana, the tsarist secret police. At the Romanov tercentenary celebrations of 1913 the emperor appeared before large crowds for the first time since Bloody Sunday. On the eve of war in 1914 Russia was Europe's most populous country, with railways and coal and oil output growing fast. But its industry leaned heavily on foreign capital and state loans, and the mistrust between Duma and emperor remained unresolved. At home, a 1910 law subjected legislation on the Grand Duchy of Finland to the imperial legislative process, sharply curtailing Finnish autonomy.
How did the First World War end in his abdication?
When Austria-Hungary declared war on Serbia in July 1914, Nicholas II telegraphed Wilhelm II proposing to refer the dispute to the Hague tribunal, but got no reply; after Russia's general mobilisation Germany declared war on 19 July (Old Style). At first a wave of patriotic feeling swept the country. Russian armies beat the Austrians in Galicia, but in East Prussia Samsonov's Second Army was encircled and routed. When Germany turned its main effort east in 1915, the Russians gave up Galicia and Poland in the "Great Retreat", short even of shells and rifles.
In August 1915 the emperor dismissed the commander-in-chief, Grand Duke Nikolai Nikolaevich, made himself commander-in-chief, and went to the Stavka, the general headquarters at Mogilev. He believed a sovereign's duty was to share the army's ordeal, but most of his ministers opposed the move: blame for defeat would now fall on the emperor himself, and government in the capital would be left to the empress and her circle. Ministers did indeed come and go thereafter; the Duma's moderate majority formed the Progressive Bloc and demanded a "ministry of confidence", but the emperor would not yield. It was in this setting that Milyukov, in November 1916, assailed the government in the Duma with the question "Stupidity or treason?"
On 23 February 1917 (Old Style) women workers in Petrograd began demonstrating for bread, and within days strikes and marches had spread across the city. On 26 February troops fired on the crowds, but on the 27th soldiers of the capital's garrison went over to the demonstrators one unit after another, and the rising became a revolution. The same day Duma deputies set up the Provisional Committee of the Duma and the socialists the Petrograd Soviet. From Mogilev the emperor ordered General Ivanov to restore order, but his chief of staff, General Alekseyev, judging that repression would spread chaos through the army and ruin the war effort, halted the movement of troops.
The emperor's train, trying to return to the capital, found its way blocked and reached Pskov, headquarters of the Northern Front, on 1 March. There the front commander, Ruzsky, pressed him to accept a government responsible to the Duma, and that night he agreed. But Duma chairman Rodzianko replied that it was too late and demanded abdication in favour of the heir, and when Alekseyev polled the front commanders, all of them advised abdication. On 2 March Nicholas II signed his abdication. He first meant to pass the throne to his son Alexei, but, unwilling to be separated from the sick boy, he named his brother, Grand Duke Mikhail Alexandrovich, instead. The next day Mikhail declared that he would not accept the throne unless a constituent assembly offered it, and so the Romanov dynasty ended after more than three hundred years. That day Nicholas wrote in his diary, "All around is treason, cowardice and deceit." He felt that his generals had abandoned him. His critics answer that it was he who had refused any real concession until there were no troops left to fire.
How were the abdicated emperor and his family executed, and how has their death been judged?
After the abdication Nicholas and his family were held under house arrest at the Alexander Palace in Tsarskoye Selo from March to August 1917. In late March Foreign Minister Milyukov tried to send them to King George V in Britain, and the British at first agreed, but in April the king, worried about opinion at home, withdrew. When Petrograd grew unsettled again after the July Days, Kerensky's government moved the family to Tobolsk in Siberia, where they lived in some comfort in the former governor's mansion and were even allowed to walk to church on Sundays.
After the October Revolution the Bolshevik government meant to put the former emperor on trial in Moscow, and in April 1918 the All-Russian Central Executive Committee approved his transfer. But the family was taken not to Moscow but to Yekaterinburg, held by the Ural Regional Soviet, and confined in the house of the merchant Ipatiev. In summer 1918, as civil war spread and the Czechoslovak Legion and the Whites closed in on Yekaterinburg, things changed. In June Grand Duke Mikhail was murdered by local Bolsheviks in Perm.
On the night of 16-17 July 1918 the commandant, Yakov Yurovsky, sent the family down to a half-basement room and then brought in a firing squad. Nicholas, Alexandra, their five children, their doctor Botkin and three servants were killed there with guns and bayonets, and the bodies were mutilated and buried in the forest. The Ural Regional Soviet announced that, citing a White plot to seize him and his "bloody violence", it had decided to shoot the former tsar. Whether Moscow approved in advance is still debated: a coded telegram went from Yekaterinburg to Moscow that evening and Lenin and Sverdlov are said to have conferred and replied, but no copy of a reply has ever been found. Moscow at first announced only the former emperor's execution and claimed his family had been moved to safety.
In the Soviet period he was portrayed as an incompetent and cruel autocrat; the 1939 Great Soviet Encyclopedia called him a "dull-witted autocrat", and later textbooks avoided treating him as a person at all. After the Soviet collapse the remains were exhumed near Yekaterinburg in 1991 and buried in July 1998 in the Peter and Paul Cathedral in St Petersburg. In 2000 the Russian Orthodox Church canonised him and his family, not as martyrs for the faith but as "passion-bearers"; even within the church some objected that he had been a weak ruler who brought on the revolution. In October 2008 the Presidium of the Russian Supreme Court rehabilitated them as victims of political repression. "Nicholas the Bloody" who sent in the troops, or a victim killed without trial together with his children: judgements of his life still hang between these two facts.