Leninist Dialectics and the Metaphysics of Positivism
레닌의 변증법과 실증주의의 형이상학
The last book of the Soviet philosopher Evald Ilyenkov, published by Politizdat in 1980, the year after his death. Its subtitle is "Reflections on V. I. Lenin's book Materialism and Empirio-Criticism". Against the reading of Lenin's 1909 book as a mere primer of materialism, it argues that the book already treats dialectics as logic and theory of knowledge. It is especially known for reading Bogdanov's novel Red Star as the social outcome of Machist philosophy.
In depth
Why reopen a dispute of 1908 in the 1970s?
People who reread old books are usually in a dispute now. That was why Ilyenkov reread Lenin's Materialism and Empirio-Criticism. Is this a book that at length defends what everyone knows, that "there is a world outside my head"? If so, it cannot be explained why Lenin fought so fiercely.
The attack at that time came from Marxists outside the Soviet Union. In his small book Lenin, the Frenchman Roger Garaudy rated the work as "preparatory-class materialism", and Gajo Petrović of the Yugoslav journal Praxis claimed that Lenin became interested in dialectics only after studying Hegel, in the period of the "Philosophical Notebooks". As Ilyenkov saw it, the same misunderstanding existed inside the Soviet Union, in the claim that Lenin's definition of matter holds only in the dispute with subjective idealism, is too narrow beyond it, and has to be widened by an "ontological aspect".
Ilyenkov's answer is the theme that carries the whole book. Lenin's book and the "Philosophical Notebooks" are not broken apart. As early as 1908 Lenin understood dialectics as logic and theory of knowledge and fought to defend it. The book's structure is as follows: an introduction; chapter 1, "Marxism against Machism as a philosophy of dead reaction"; chapter 2, "The positive programme of Russian positivism"; chapter 3, "Dialectics, the logic of revolution. Philosophy and natural science"; and a conclusion. Lev Naumenko's foreword states that this was his last book.
Why is "there is a world outside" not enough?
Chapter 1 begins with an easy question. Does it really have to be proved that the sun, rivers and cities are there without me? Any sane person thinks so. Bogdanov cannot have been ignorant of it, nor can the physicist Ernst Mach, whose name is left on the unit of the speed of sound. Had Lenin defended only that, the dispute would have been a waste of time.
So the issue must lie elsewhere. For Ilyenkov the issue was Marx's philosophy itself. Karl Kautsky thought little of philosophical disputes and printed the empirio-critics as they stood, while Georgi Plekhanov saw Bogdanov's incapacity well but did not get to the roots. He traces why Lenin, after discussing the matter with Plekhanov and corresponding with Bogdanov, hurried to an open fight following their last meeting on Capri in April 1908. This part can be read together with the entry "Materialism and Empirio-Criticism".
Why does the novel Red Star appear here?
The most unexpected part of the book is chapter 2, where a philosophy book analyses a novel at length. Bogdanov's 1908 novel Red Star is the story of a Russian revolutionary who visits a socialist society on Mars. Ilyenkov did not see it as mere literature. He read it as not only lifting passages from "Empiriomonism" but as a pictorial equivalent of that theory of knowledge.
The key to his reading is "equilibrium". According to Ilyenkov, in Machism the aim of knowledge is to remove contradiction, and its ideal is a state in which no opposed forces remain. This equilibrium rises to a basic category explaining the cosmos, the psyche and history. He pricks it with the example of the scales. A balance is only a momentary result of opposed forces acting on the two arms. And what happens when this category is carried over to society? The Martian socialism of the novel is a society without contradiction, and the hero Lenni is diagnosed as biopsychically incompatible with it and accepts treatment. Against Bogdanov's intent, Ilyenkov reads this as the process by which the socialist ideal turns into a pale icon, alien to the living person. He called this walking the path of Marx and Engels backwards, the path "from science to utopia".
на путь от науки к утопии
This reading is polemical. Ilyenkov summed up that Bogdanov's economic scheme is Marx's while the rest, morality, art and the political-legal superstructure, follows Mach. This entry explains his reading and does not speak for Bogdanov's position. Bogdanov's side of the argument can be found in the entries "Empiriomonism" and "Tektology".
Why is dialectics "the logic of revolution"?
Chapter 3 separates Lenin from Plekhanov. As Ilyenkov saw it, the Machists had a monopoly on the name of natural science. Lenin had already remarked that one could not pick up the literature of or about Machism without meeting references to the new physics. Where Plekhanov stopped at showing that Machism and Marxism are different things, Lenin dug out the connection with the new physics and struck at Machism's root.
The physicists' statement of the time that matter had disappeared is a good example. On Ilyenkov's account, if a physicist accepts a positivist definition of matter, the statement is formally correct. He holds that it is in reality a false expression of an advance in knowledge. Science advances through contradictions in which older knowledge is negated. The logic of Machism tries to erase contradiction by making it a question of words, while dialectics shows it to be a real problem and gives natural science a way out of its crisis. Hence he held that if Lenin's idea of the coincidence of dialectics, logic and theory of knowledge is pressed thoroughly, there is no need to add an "ontological aspect". Ilyenkov ends the book thus: "The logic of revolutionary thought, the logic of revolution, is one and the same there and here. And this logic is called materialist dialectics."
Логика революционного мышления, логика революции и там и тут одна и та же. И называется эта логика материалистической диалектикой.
He turned the same criticism on neo-positivism. Since the neo-positivists fish for unclear expressions in Einstein, Bohr and Heisenberg, Lenin's dispute was not over.
How should this book be read?
The book came out from the party's publishing house in an edition of 100,000, a large run for a work of philosophy. Its tone too is much more militant than Ilyenkov's other books. It calls Garaudy and Petrović revisionists and declares that without militant materialism there can be no Marxist-Leninist world view. Naumenko's foreword states that it is his last book and says that his passion was materialist dialectics as the logic of revolutionary thought. The English edition appeared in 1982 from New Park Publications in Britain.
In content the book continues Ilyenkov's other work. In The Dialectics of the Abstract and the Concrete in Marx's Capital he treated contradiction as the form of scientific development, and in "Dialectical logic" he argued for the coincidence of dialectics, logic and theory of knowledge. Here the theme returns to the dispute over Machism before the Russian Revolution. But his position was not the only road for Marxist theory of knowledge. Like Garaudy and Petrović, whom he opposed, others split Lenin's philosophy before and after the "Philosophical Notebooks". His friend Mikhail Lifshitz, as the "Ilyenkov-Lifshitz debate on the ideal" shows, was in the same year questioning his concept of activity from a different direction.