Chair of the Soviet delegation at Brest-Litovsk and Trotsky's longest-standing comrade
In his farewell letter he called his death "the protest of a fighter" and Trotsky's and Zinoviev's expulsion "the beginning of the Thermidorian period." He wrote the letter's body in the night of 15-16 November and dated it the 16th; sources give his death as 16 or 17 November.
Trotsky's longest-standing comrade and a Bolshevik diplomat. Born into a Jewish merchant family in Simferopol, he joined the RSDLP in 1903; arrested in Odessa in 1912, he served ten months and was exiled to Siberia, freed by the February Revolution of 1917. He helped prepare the October rising in the Petrograd Military Revolutionary Committee and, per Trotsky's testimony, chaired it. He led the Soviet delegation at Brest-Litovsk on the "neither war nor peace" line, built the Soviet embassy in Berlin as plenipotentiary to Germany and was expelled in November 1918 (sources record both a charge of preparing revolution and active preparation). Soviet representative to China in 1922-23, he issued the 1923 declaration with Sun Yat-sen, then sided with the Left Opposition; when treatment abroad was refused, he protested by suicide, and his family was repressed after his death.
Also known as: Ioffe · V. Krymsky · Viktor
Activities and affiliations
-
1903–1917
Social movements and organizing
-
1917–1919
Soviet Communist Party and Bolsheviks
Political and party leadership -
1917–1926
Soviet Union state institutionsForeign affairsMain
Diplomacy and international organization -
1917–1927
Soviet Communist Party and Bolsheviks
Diplomacy and international organization -
1923–1927
Social movements and organizing
-
1925–1927
Soviet Union state institutionsDeputy Chairman of the Chief Concessions Committee
Economy, finance and planning
Career Timeline
- 1903Joined the Russian Social Democratic Labour Party and worked as a Menshevik in Baku and Moscow.
- 1908–1912Published Pravda with Trotsky in Vienna and studied psychoanalysis with Alfred Adler.
- 1912Was arrested in Odessa and exiled to Siberia.
- 1917.04Freed by the February Revolution, came to Petrograd and joined the Mezhraiontsy.
- 1917.08Joined the Bolsheviks with the Mezhraiontsy at the Sixth Party Congress and became a candidate Central Committee member and secretary.
- 1917.10Led the October rising as chairman of the Petrograd Military Revolutionary Committee.
- 1917.11–1918.01Headed the Soviet delegation at the Brest-Litovsk peace talks.
- 1918.04As RSFSR plenipotentiary in Germany, opened the Berlin embassy and signed the Supplementary Treaty in August.
- 1918.11.06Was expelled from Germany with the whole embassy on charges of preparing a revolution.
- 1919–1920Served as People’s Commissar of State Control and member of the Defence Council of the Ukrainian Soviet Republic.
- 1920–1921Concluded peace treaties with Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania, and signed the Peace of Riga with Poland in 1921.
- 1922Was a member of the Soviet delegation to the Genoa Conference.
- 1922.07Became the Soviet government’s representative in Beijing.
- 1923Joined the Left Opposition.
- 1923.01.26Issued the Sun–Joffe Manifesto with Sun Yat-sen, opening the way to Kuomintang–Communist cooperation.
- 1924–1926Served as Soviet representative in Austria.
- 1925.06–1927Served as deputy chairman of the Main Concessions Committee under Trotsky.
- 1927.11Took his own life in Moscow after being refused treatment abroad.
The Central Committee Secretariat
- Secretary 1917.08–1918.03
1918.03 not re-elected
Related historical events
- 1915–1921May Fourth and the founding of the Chinese Communist PartySun–Joffe declaration (1923)Issued the joint declaration with Sun Yat-sen that opened Soviet aid to the Kuomintang; in 1922 he said the Karakhan declarations had no legal force.
- 1917.02–07The February RevolutionRevolutionary freed from exileHe was freed from exile in Siberia by the February Revolution of 1917.
- 1917.03–1921.03The Belarusian People’s Republic and Soviet BelarusMoscow's envoy; chief Soviet negotiator at RigaCame to Minsk in January 1919 to push through the Litbel merger and chose its ministers; led the Soviet delegation at the Riga peace talks of 1920–1921.
- 1917.10–1918.01The October RevolutionChairman of the Petrograd Military Revolutionary CommitteeAs chairman of the Petrograd MRC on 24–25 October, he directed the practical seizure of the capital's key installations during the insurrection.
- 1917.12–1918.11Brest-Litovsk and Germany’s eastern occupationInitial Soviet negotiatorHeaded the first Soviet delegation in December 1917 and put forward the six principles of peace without annexations; ambassador in Berlin after the treaty, he was expelled in November 1918.
- 1918–1922The Civil War and Foreign InterventionInitial Soviet negotiatorInvolved in this event as initial Soviet negotiator.
- 1918.10–1919.08The German Revolution of 1918–1919Soviet envoy who prepared revolution in GermanyAs Soviet envoy to Germany, he was expelled in November 1918 amid accounts of his active preparations for revolution.
- 1918.11–1920.10Baltic wars of independence and border settlementsSoviet negotiator at TartuLed the Soviet delegation at Tartu from December 1919, signing the treaty with Estonia on 2 February 1920, and went on to negotiate with Latvia, Lithuania and Poland.
- 1924–1927The first united front, the Northern Expedition and the catastrophe of 1927Soviet signatory of the Sun–Joffe statementAgreed the basic terms of the alliance with Sun in January 1923.
How did a rich Crimean merchant's son become a revolutionary and join Trotsky in Vienna?
Adolph Joffe was born on 10 (22 New Style) October 1883 in Simferopol in Crimea. His father, Abram Joffe, was a merchant of the first guild who owned nearly all the postal and transport services in Crimea and a house in Moscow, and was reportedly called Finance Minister Witte's "favourite Jew". The English-language account places the family in Crimea's Karaite community, a branch of Judaism that rejects the Talmud. When his daughter later asked how someone from such a family had become a revolutionary, he laughed: "Probably because I was a very fat boy. I was shy of it, so I didn't run about or go dancing. I sat and read books. And so I read my way into it."
He became a social democrat in 1900 while still at school and formally joined the Russian Social Democratic Labour Party in 1903, working with the Mensheviks. In 1903-1904 he studied medicine at Berlin University while carrying on revolutionary work in Russia and Germany. Sent to Baku in 1904, he had to flee to avoid arrest, and after another escape from Moscow he went abroad. He returned after Bloody Sunday in January 1905 and took part in the 1905 Revolution; at the 1906 Stockholm party congress he was made a member of the Central Committee's Foreign Bureau. Sentenced to Siberian exile in 1906, he escaped, lived in Germany until he was expelled, and also studied law at Zurich University.
In 1906 he moved to Vienna and grew close to Trotsky. From 1908 to 1912 the two published the workers' paper Pravda there, Joffe writing its international review and using his family fortune to keep it afloat. The paper belonged to neither Bolsheviks nor Mensheviks and argued for party unity; when the Bolsheviks launched their own paper of the same name in 1912, there was a dispute over the title. Joffe organised the 1912 Vienna conference of the "August Bloc", which brought together the social democratic factions other than the Bolsheviks. His party name was "V. Krymsky", "the Crimean".
In Vienna he completed his medical studies and qualified as a doctor. Interested in psychiatry, he became both a pupil and a patient of Alfred Adler, the founder of individual psychology. Trotsky wrote of him: "Despite his extremely imposing appearance, too imposing for his age, his extreme calm of tone, his patient gentleness in conversation and his exceptional courtesy, Joffe was in fact a neurotic from his youth."
In 1912 he was arrested on a visit to Odessa, held for ten months and sent to Siberia. In 1913 he was sentenced to perpetual exile in Siberia with the loss of all civil rights. He remained there until the February Revolution of 1917 freed him.
What part did he play in the October rising and the Brest-Litovsk talks?
Freed by the February Revolution, Joffe returned to Crimea, and the Crimean social democrats sent him to Petrograd as their representative. He soon moved to an internationalist position that made it impossible to stay with the Menshevik majority, which accepted the continuation of the war, and joined forces with Trotsky, just back from exile. The two entered the Mezhraiontsy (Inter-District group), a Petrograd social democratic organisation that was neither Bolshevik nor Menshevik, published the journal Vperyod! (Forward!), and pushed for unification with the Bolsheviks. When the Mezhraiontsy merged into the Bolshevik party at the Sixth Congress in July-August 1917, Joffe was elected a candidate member of the Central Committee and soon joined its standing bureau and secretariat.
In the autumn he led the Bolshevik group in the Petrograd city duma and took part in the Democratic Conference and the Pre-parliament, an advisory body the Provisional Government meant to keep until the Constituent Assembly. He had opposed participation together with Lenin and Trotsky, became a deputy when the party majority decided otherwise, and walked out with the Bolsheviks on 7 October. In the dispute over an armed rising he sided with Lenin and Trotsky and demanded the removal from the Central Committee of Zinoviev and Kamenev, who had publicly opposed the plan. According to Trotsky, on 24-25 October he chaired the Petrograd Military Revolutionary Committee and so was the actual leader of the rising. The committee, set up by the Petrograd Soviet, was the operational headquarters that took control of the garrison and toppled the Provisional Government. When some in the party argued right after the rising for sharing power with the other socialist parties, he again sided with Lenin and Trotsky.
At the end of November 1917 he became head of the Soviet delegation sent to Brest-Litovsk to negotiate an armistice and peace with Germany and its allies. He signed the ceasefire on 2 December and on 22 December put forward the Bolshevik terms: no forcible annexation of territory seized in the war, restoration of independence to nations that had lost it during the war, referendums to settle national questions, and no indemnities. The Austro-Hungarian foreign minister Czernin later recalled their first conversation. When he told Joffe that if he clung to his "utopian" ideas of the broadest self-determination he had better take the next train home, Joffe looked at him in astonishment with his gentle eyes and said in a friendly, almost pleading tone: "I very much hope that we will also be able to raise the revolution in your country."
After Trotsky took over the delegation, Joffe supported his line of "neither war nor peace". When the Central Committee decided in February 1918 to accept Germany's harsh terms and sign, he stayed on the delegation only under protest and in a consultative capacity; Sokolnikov signed. At the Seventh Congress in March 1918 he was again elected a candidate member of the Central Committee, and after the government moved to Moscow he stayed in Petrograd working in the Central Committee's Petrograd Bureau. From there he telegraphed Lenin proposing that Trotsky, who had resigned as foreign commissar, be made commissar for military affairs.
Why was the first Soviet envoy in Berlin expelled, and what peace treaties did he go on to sign?
In April 1918 Joffe was appointed plenipotentiary of the Russian republic in Germany and on 18 April opened the Soviet embassy in Berlin. The Brest treaty had ended the war, but Germany still occupied Ukraine and the Baltic lands, and the Soviet government had the double task of keeping relations with Germany while hoping for a German revolution. Joffe's embassy embodied that duality.
Outwardly he assured German politicians and businessmen that the Bolsheviks were ready to drop their utopian goals and pursue a pragmatic socialist policy, and won influential industrialists over with favourable trade offers. On 27 August 1918 he signed the Supplementary Treaty to the Brest peace, which among other things committed Russia to pay six billion marks in compensation for nationalised German property. At the same time the embassy worked with the German Spartacists, the revolutionary group of Luxemburg and Liebknecht, to print and distribute large quantities of communist propaganda; the Russian-language account says he took an active part in preparing revolution in Germany.
On 6 November 1918, just before Germany signed the armistice and revolution broke out, the German government expelled the entire embassy. The trigger was a diplomatic bag that burst in an "accident", spilling revolutionary leaflets; the accident had been staged by the German side. Just before leaving, Joffe handed Oskar Cohn of the Independent Social Democratic Party (USPD) a large sum of money and a bank account, and after returning to Russia he announced that the money had been meant for revolutionary activity and the purchase of arms. The revelation led the German foreign minister to resign rather than cooperate further with the USPD. The German charge of "preparing a revolution", in other words, was not a mere pretext.
Back home he served in 1919-1920 as People's Commissar of State Control and member of the Defence Council of the Ukrainian Soviet Republic. At the Eighth Congress in March 1919 he lost his place as a candidate member of the Central Committee and never again held a top party post. Instead he became the revolutionary government's leading negotiator. In 1920 he concluded peace treaties with Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania, by which Soviet Russia recognised their independence, and after an armistice with Poland in October 1920 he signed the Peace of Riga in March 1921, ending the Polish-Soviet War. That is why the Estonian embassy still visits his grave in Moscow's Novodevichy Cemetery every year on the anniversary of the Treaty of Tartu.
In 1921 he went to Central Asia as head of the Turkestan Commission, and in August met the Basmachi leader Kurshirmat in the Fergana Valley for peace talks; the Basmachi were the armed resistance to Soviet rule in Central Asia. In 1922 he was a member of the Soviet delegation to the Genoa Conference and described the experience in a short book. His daughter recalled that poor working relations with Foreign Commissar Chicherin made his work harder. He was then appointed ambassador extraordinary for China and Japan, the road that led to his declaration with Sun Yat-sen.
The Sun–Joffe Manifesto: Starting Point of Kuomintang–Soviet Cooperation
In 1922 Joffe was appointed extraordinary ambassador to China and Japan, and from 26 July 1922 he served as the Soviet government's representative in Beijing. On 23 September 1922, at the Changchun conference, he demanded the withdrawal of Japanese troops from North Sakhalin; on 26 September 1922 the Japanese delegation refused to withdraw and broke off the conference. On 26 January 1923 Joffe and Sun Yat-sen issued the Sun–Joffe Manifesto (孫文越飛宣言).
The manifesto asserted that the Soviet system was not suitable for China and announced Soviet willingness to co-operate with the Kuomintang in its struggle to unify China. It did not settle the Outer Mongolia or Chinese Eastern Railway questions, but it succeeded in establishing political relations with Sun and became the foundation of Kuomintang–Soviet co-operation. The Russian-side account treats the document as an important one defining policy toward Soviet Russia and credits it with helping to start co-operation between the Kuomintang and the Chinese Communist Party. In July 1923 Sun sent Chiang Kai-shek to Russia to study Soviet military and political conditions. The 1923 manifesto sits immediately before the 1924 First United Front.
In the Shanghai negotiations that led to the manifesto, it was agreed that Communist Party members would join the Kuomintang as individuals, constituting a "bloc within" the party. The individual-membership formula belongs to the negotiations leading up to the declaration, not to the period after it.
While based in China, Joffe travelled to Japan after the declaration to settle Soviet–Japanese relations, but the timing is disputed across sources: the English-language account dates the journey to January 1923, while other sources place the Japan trip after the declaration. Those negotiations ended when he became gravely ill and had to be sent back to Moscow. Sources also differ on the illness: one biography records that he contracted tropical malaria in Japan, after which his legs gave out and he suffered two heart attacks, whereas the Russian-language account attributes his grave 1923 illness to polyneuritis. Neither account is presented here as settled.
Why did the ailing diplomat take his own life, and what did his last letter say?
While negotiating in Japan in 1923 Joffe fell gravely ill and was brought back to Moscow; the Russian-language account names the illness as polyneuritis. After treatment in Austria and a partial recovery he joined the Soviet delegation to Britain in 1924 and served as Soviet representative in Vienna in 1924-1926.
He had been Trotsky's loyal comrade since 1912 and from 1923 belonged to the Left Opposition. After Lenin's death he proposed to Zinoviev that the chairmanship of the Council of People's Commissars either be made collective or given to Trotsky. When Trotsky became chairman of the Main Concessions Committee, the body that granted foreign capital the right to run mines and factories, in June 1925, Joffe became his deputy. From 1926 his illness and his disagreements with the party leadership forced him into semi-retirement; he tried to teach at the Soviet law faculty of Moscow University, but his health made even that difficult.
By autumn 1927 he was bedridden and in extreme pain. Doctors recommended treatment abroad, but the party leadership would not pay for it. On 12 November Trotsky was expelled from the party. Four days later, on the night of 16 November, Joffe shot himself (the Russian-language account gives the 17th). He left a ten-page letter addressed to Trotsky. It begins: "I have always held that a public figure should know how to leave life at the right moment, just as an actor leaves the stage, and that it is better to do so too early than too late." He urged Trotsky to be uncompromising: "You have always been right, and you have always given way." The secret police seized the letter, and the Stalinists later quoted parts of it to discredit both Joffe and Trotsky.
At the funeral his coffin was carried by diplomats including Chicherin, Litvinov and Karakhan. At the graveside Trotsky said: "Acts such as leaving life of one's own accord have an infectious power. But let no one dare imitate this old fighter in his death; imitate him in his life!" It was Trotsky's last public speech in the Soviet Union; early the next year he was deported to Alma-Ata.
After his death his family could not escape the shadow of the Terror. His second wife Maria was arrested as an oppositionist and spent some twenty years in the camps; she survived to write the memoir One Long Night. His daughter from his first marriage, Nadezhda, spent about twenty years in exile and camps from 1929 and also wrote a memoir. His son Vladimir was shot in Tomsk in 1937. Joffe is remembered as Trotsky's longest-standing comrade and as one who sensed early what lay in store for the Opposition.