Lenin's periphery-builder who brought Soviet power to Belarus and Armenia
When news of the October Revolution reached Minsk, Myasnikov immediately formed and led a Military Revolutionary Committee, and Soviet power was established there without bloodshed.
An Armenian Bolshevik born to a merchant family in Nakhichevan-on-Don. He joined the RSDLP in 1906 and was administratively exiled to Baku for illegal literature, where Shaumyan influenced him. In 1917 he led the Western Front Bolsheviks in Minsk and played the leading role in establishing Soviet power there. He chaired the Byelorussian SSR Central Executive Committee in February 1919, then from May 1921 headed the Armenian SSR Council of People's Commissars, building Soviet Armenia's state institutions and economy. From 1922 he chaired the Transcaucasian SFSR Union Council and served as first secretary of the Transcaucasian Kraikom. He wrote on Marxist-Leninist theory and Armenian literature. On 22 March 1925 his aircraft caught fire and crashed near Tbilisi, killing him alongside Atarbekov and Mogilevsky; the cause of the fire was never established.
Also known as: Martuni · Aleksandr Myasnikyan
Activities and affiliations
-
1906–1925
Soviet Communist Party and Bolsheviks
Political and party leadership -
1917–1918
Soviet Union state institutionsHeads of governmentMain
Government and administration
Career Timeline
- 1906Joined the RSDLP; exiled to Baku for illegal literature — met Shaumyan
- 1911–1914Graduated Moscow University law faculty (1911); army service, then assistant barrister writing for Bolshevik press
- 1914–1917Served on the Western Front in WWI, revolutionary propaganda among soldiers
- 1917.09–1918.05Chairman of North-Western Regional Party Committee, Minsk VRK chairman, Western Front Commander
- 1919–1920Military organiser then secretary of Moscow Party Committee; head of Political Directorate, Western Front
- 1919.01–02First Chairman of the Central Executive Committee and Military Commissar of the Byelorussian SSR
- 1921–1922Chairman of the Council of People's Commissars and Military Commissar of the Armenian SSR; deputy chairman of ZSFSR
- 1922–1925Chairman of the Transcaucasian Union Council, first secretary of the Transcaucasian Kraikom — USSR CEC Presidium, Revolutionary Military Council, candidate CC member
- 1925.03.22Died in a plane fire near Tbilisi alongside Atarbekov and Mogilevsky
Related historical events
- 1914–1918First World WarWestern Front soldier and propagandistHe served on the Western Front in the First World War and spread revolutionary propaganda among soldiers.
- 1917.03–1921.03The Belarusian People’s Republic and Soviet BelarusWestern Front commander, Byelorussian party leaderLed the establishment of Soviet power in Minsk in 1917 and opposed Belarusian autonomy; chaired the Central Executive Committee of the Byelorussian Soviet republic in February 1919.
- 1917.10–1918.01The October RevolutionChairman of Minsk Military Revolutionary Committee
- 1917.11–1921.10Revolution and war in the CaucasusChairman of Armenia's Council of People's CommissarsWas appointed head of the Soviet Armenian government after the February Uprising was suppressed.
- 1918–1922The Civil War and Foreign InterventionCommander-in-Chief of the Western Front and leader of Sovietization in Belarus and Armenia
- 1919–1921The Soviet-Polish WarHead of the Western Front Political DirectorateDuring the Polish war, he headed the Western Front Political Directorate.
- 1922.12Formation of the USSRChairman of the Transcaucasian Union Council, first secretary of the KraikomAs chairman of the Transcaucasian Union Council and first secretary of the Transcaucasian Kraikom in 1922, he was the institutional link binding the republics into the USSR. He served on the commission preparing the formation of the USSR alongside Stalin, Ordzhonikidze, and Molotov, and became a member of the USSR CEC Presidium after the union was formed.
How did an Armenian merchant's son from Nakhichevan-on-Don become a Bolshevik lawyer?
Alexander Myasnikov (in Armenian form Miasnikian; party name Martuni) was born on 28 January (9 February, New Style) 1886 in Nakhichevan-on-Don, on the lower Don, the son of a small Armenian trader. Nakhichevan-on-Don had been founded in the late eighteenth century by Armenians resettled from the Crimea and is now a district of Rostov-on-Don. He attended a parish school and the Armenian seminary of Nakhichevan-on-Don, graduating in 1903, and then completed the Lazarev Institute of Oriental Languages, an Armenian educational institution in Moscow, in 1906.
His revolutionary activity began around 1901 in underground circles in Nakhichevan while he was still a student. At first he moved among Armenian revolutionary-nationalist groups, but the first Russian Revolution of 1905 drew him to the Social Democrats, and in 1906 he joined the Russian Social Democratic Labour Party. The same year he was arrested for possessing illegal literature. The Russian Wikipedia says he was sent into administrative exile in Baku, where he met Stepan Shaumyan, who influenced him greatly; the English Wikipedia says he was first sent back to Rostov-on-Don and was active in the Bolshevik underground in Baku in 1907–1908. Either way, the oil city of Baku and Shaumyan were an important stage in his political development.
Back from Baku, he resumed his studies in the law faculty of Moscow University. From 1910 he wrote for Marxist newspapers and journals and organised a revolutionary student circle. In 1911–1912 he did military service in the Imperial Russian Army, receiving the rank of reserve ensign, and he received his law diploma on 19 November 1912 (the English Wikipedia dates his graduation to 1911). Until 1914 he worked in Moscow as an assistant to a barrister while continuing to work with the Bolshevik press.
He took up literary criticism early. From 1906 he wrote theatre reviews, and in articles such as "Philanthropy and its Lackeys" (1912) he attacked apolitical literature and "art for art's sake". On Armenian literature he wrote an essay on Mikael Nalbandian and pamphlets on the poets Hovhannes Hovhannisyan and Hovhannes Tumanyan. On the other hand, one person who knew him testified that after the 1905 revolution and his arrest he drifted away from revolutionary activity for several years and rejoined the Bolshevik movement only after the revolution of 1917. This testimony conflicts with the official Soviet biographies, which stress his underground career. His writings were later collected in an Armenian edition (Yerevan, 1965) and a Russian one (Moscow, 1985).
How did Myasnikov, an officer on the Western Front, bring Minsk under Soviet power in 1917?
When the First World War broke out in 1914, Myasnikov was called up again. He commanded the training detachment of the 121st Reserve Regiment in Dorogobuzh, and from May 1915 served on the staffs of the 3rd Army Corps and the 10th Army on the Western Front. He was a diligent enough officer to receive the Orders of St Stanislaus and St Anna, but according to the English Wikipedia he belonged to an underground party cell in the army and spread revolutionary ideas among the soldiers.
After the February Revolution of 1917 he went straight to Minsk, headquarters of the Western Front, where he worked among the soldiers and joined the Bolshevik Minsk committee. In April he was elected to the presidium of the Western Front's soldiers' committee and, together with Mikhail Frunze, later one of the Red Army's great commanders, led its Bolshevik faction. He helped found and edit the Bolshevik newspaper Zvezda and was a delegate to the Sixth Party Congress in Petrograd in July and August. In September he was elected chairman of the Northwestern Regional Committee, the forerunner of the Bolshevik organisation in Belorussia.
As soon as news of the October Revolution reached Minsk he created and led the Minsk Military Revolutionary Committee, and Soviet power in Minsk was established without bloodshed. In November a congress of soldiers' deputies elected him commander-in-chief of the Western Front, and he became chairman of the executive committee of the Western Region. For about two weeks from 12 December 1917 he acted as Supreme Commander-in-Chief of the Russian army while Nikolai Krylenko was away. A reserve ensign of the old army had, thanks to the revolution, come to command an entire front. The English Wikipedia says that when Krylenko became Supreme Commander he appointed Myasnikov his deputy. Krylenko himself had held no higher rank than ensign, so in the weeks after the revolution the top of the Russian army was held not by professional soldiers but by Bolshevik activists in uniform.
But in February 1918, when the German army advanced after the Brest-Litovsk peace talks broke down, he failed to organise the defence of Minsk, and the city fell to the Germans without resistance. Attempts to organise partisan warfare also failed, although he managed to evacuate most of the artillery and ammunition before the city fell. In June 1918 he became commander of the Volga Front against the Czechoslovak Legion, and then took up party work in Smolensk. He appears from this period in Roll-Call Vote, the first film of the 1967 Soviet series Sketches for a Portrait of Lenin, about the party vote over the Brest-Litovsk peace, where he was played by Yevgeny Dubasov. Zvezda, which he helped found, still appears today under the inherited name as the Belarusian-language newspaper Zviazda.
Why did Myasnikov, an opponent of autonomy, become the first leader of the Belorussian republic?
When Germany surrendered in November 1918 and its army withdrew, the Bolsheviks moved back into the former Western Region. Myasnikov was an active opponent of the idea of Belorussian autonomy; he believed Belorussia should form a single state with the Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic. Moscow, however, mindful of the national question, decided to create a formally independent Belorussian Soviet republic, and chose him to lead it.
On 31 December 1918 he became chairman of the Central Bureau of the Communist Party (Bolsheviks) of Belorussia, which is why he is often called the first leader of the Belorussian Communist Party. The Socialist Soviet Republic of Byelorussia was proclaimed on 1 January 1919, and from 4 to 27 February he was chairman of its Central Executive Committee, as well as deputy chairman of its Council of People's Commissars and People's Commissar for Military Affairs. But the republic lasted less than two months: at the end of February, to create a single buffer republic against the Polish advance, Belorussia and Lithuania were merged into the Lithuanian–Belorussian Soviet Socialist Republic, and he became a member of the Bolshevik Central Committee of that short-lived state. At the same time he sided with the "Military Opposition", which opposed building a regular army and employing former tsarist officers.
In the spring of 1919 he was recalled to Moscow and made military head of the Bolshevik Moscow committee. On 25 September 1919 a bomb exploded in the committee's meeting hall in Leontievsky Lane in Moscow. It was the work of the so-called All-Russian Insurgent Committee of Revolutionary Partisans, calling itself the "Anarchists of the Underground"; the committee secretary Vladimir Zagorsky and several others were killed. Myasnikov was contused by the blast, and on 27 September he succeeded Zagorsky as secretary of the Moscow committee. It was the moment when Denikin's Whites were pushing north from the south as far as Orel and threatening Moscow, and the Moscow party organisation had to lead the mobilisation to defend the capital; his appointment, as the committee's military head, fitted those circumstances.
During the Soviet–Polish War of 1920 he went west again as head of the political directorate of the Western Front. The Red Army advanced to the gates of Warsaw before being heavily defeated in August and driven back. In Belorussia his name was long remembered: in 1932 a rolling-stock repair works in Minsk was named after him and a monument to him was raised on its grounds, and a square and a street in central Minsk and, in 1959, a street in Vitebsk also took his name. In Belarus he is remembered as one of the leaders who established Soviet power.
Why did Lenin entrust Armenia to Myasnikov after the February Uprising, and what did he do there?
In Armenia, Sovietised at the end of 1920, the harsh requisitions and repression of the Revolutionary Committee provoked resistance. In February 1921 forces led by the Armenian Revolutionary Federation (Dashnaks) rose and briefly overthrew Soviet power in Yerevan. After this "February Uprising" was put down, Lenin decided in March 1921 to send Myasnikov to head the government of the Armenian Soviet Socialist Republic. The New Economic Policy was just beginning, and his task was to pursue a more moderate policy better attuned to Armenian national sensibilities.
On his way to Armenia he delivered to the Caucasian Bolshevik leadership in Tiflis Lenin's letter "To the Comrade Communists of Azerbaijan, Georgia, Armenia, Dagestan and the Mountain Republic", which urged them to act with caution and slow down the transition to socialism. Arriving in Yerevan in May 1921, he became Chairman of the Council of People's Commissars and People's Commissar for Military Affairs of Armenia, while also serving as deputy chairman of the Council of People's Commissars of the Transcaucasian federation and as a member of the Kavbiuro.
The Armenia he took over had been devastated by war, massacre and famine. He took the lead in building the republic's state institutions and economy, and launched work to help refugees from Western Armenia driven out of the Ottoman Empire, to eradicate illiteracy and to develop local manufacturing and infrastructure. He also invited major figures of the Armenian intelligentsia to help rebuild the republic, among them the painter Martiros Saryan, the architect Alexander Tamanian, who later drew up Yerevan's city plan, and the linguist Hrachia Acharian. He kept close ties with the writers Yeghishe Charents and Shushanik Kurghinian.
Early in his tenure he faced two urgent problems: the anti-Bolshevik rebellion in Syunik (Zangezur) in the south, and the status of Karabakh (Artsakh), disputed between Armenia and Azerbaijan. He negotiated with the Zangezur rebels, offering a number of concessions in return for their accepting Soviet power, but on 3 June 1921 the Kavbiuro resolved to suppress the rebellion; the rebels were defeated and fled across the Araks into Iran on 15 July. The Karabakh question is treated separately. In January 1922 he handed over the leadership of the Armenian government to Sargis Lukashin. The Norwegian explorer and refugee commissioner Fridtjof Nansen praised the "wise moderation" of his rule in Armenia. In 1976 Armenfilm released Delivery (Yerkunk), directed by Frunze Dovlatyan, about his role in consolidating Soviet power in Armenia, with Khoren Abrahamyan in the title role.
Why did the Kavbiuro reverse its Karabakh decision within a day in 1921, and what did Myasnikov do?
When Myasnikov arrived in Yerevan in May 1921 as Chairman of the Armenian Council of People's Commissars, one of the most acute issues before him was the status of Nagorno-Karabakh. This mountainous region with an Armenian majority had already been the object of bloody conflict between independent Armenia and Azerbaijan in 1918–1920, and after both were Sovietised it remained a dispute between Soviet Armenia and Soviet Azerbaijan. On 3 June 1921 a Kavbiuro meeting, at which Myasnikov was present, adopted a point stating that Karabakh should be declared part of Armenia. On 12 June Myasnikov signed a decree of the Armenian government stating that the Revolutionary Committees of Armenia and Azerbaijan had agreed that Nagorno-Karabakh was an "inalienable part of Armenia". The Azerbaijani side, however, insisted on postponing a final decision.
At an enlarged Kavbiuro meeting on 4 July, Myasnikov and a majority of members voted to hold a referendum in Armenian-majority Karabakh and to make it part of Armenia. The next day, 5 July, with the Azerbaijani side led by Narimanov arguing that "Karabakh's economic orientation is towards Baku", the Kavbiuro reversed the previous day's decision and resolved to leave Karabakh as an autonomous region within the Azerbaijan Soviet Socialist Republic. Stalin, as People's Commissar of Nationalities, attended the meeting; how decisively he intervened in the reversal is disputed among historians. The Armenian Central Committee protested, without success.
Six months later, in January 1922, Myasnikov revealed what lay behind the decision at the First Congress of the Armenian Communist Party: Azerbaijan had threatened to halt kerosene supplies to Armenia if Yerevan did not relinquish its claims to Karabakh. For Armenia, which had no oil and was exhausted by war and blockade, this was pressure hard to refuse. While he openly questioned the decision, he did not go beyond accepting the party's ruling.
The Kavbiuro decision of 5 July 1921 became the institutional starting point for Nagorno-Karabakh remaining an autonomous region within Azerbaijan for some seventy years, and is often cited as the origin of the Karabakh conflict that erupted at the end of the Soviet era. Armenians see it as an unjust reversal, while Azerbaijanis see it as confirming that Karabakh had always belonged to Azerbaijan. The Armenians of Karabakh later named a town and district Martuni after his party name, and in 2014 raised a monument to him in Stepanakert.
How did Myasnikov, a leader of the Transcaucasian federation, die, and why did his death leave suspicions?
When Armenia, Georgia and Azerbaijan were joined in the Transcaucasian Socialist Federative Soviet Republic in March 1922, Myasnikov took leading posts in the federation in Tiflis. From 1922 he was chairman of the federation's Union Council and first secretary of the Transcaucasian regional committee of the Russian Communist Party, and at the same time a member of the Revolutionary Military Council of the USSR and of the Presidium of the USSR Central Executive Committee. In 1923–1925 he was a candidate member of the party Central Committee. In these years he kept writing on Marxist-Leninist theory, the history of the revolutionary movement and Armenian literature, and in 1925 he published Armenian Political Parties Abroad in Tiflis.
On 22 March 1925 he left Tiflis in a Junkers F 13 aircraft, bound for a communist conference in Abkhazia, together with Solomon Mogilevsky, head of the Transcaucasian Cheka, and Georgy Atarbekov. Shortly after take-off the aircraft caught fire, and eyewitnesses reported people jumping from the burning plane. All three, together with the pilot and the flight engineer, were killed. They were buried in a common grave in the Garden of the Communards in Tiflis.
The cause of the fire was never established. Investigative commissions were headed first by Lavrentiy Beria and then, for the second and third, by Karl Pauker, but nothing was found to be mechanically wrong with the aircraft. Leon Trotsky, who came from Sukhumi, where he was convalescing, spoke at the funeral and suspected the cause of the crash. Some suspected that Beria himself had arranged it, but no evidence has emerged to support this. Whether it was an accident or an assassination remains an open question.
His memory rose and fell with the times. The poet Charents described him as a commanding presence: "not his imposing face alone, but his entire being seemed to be made of bronze." In a speech in Yerevan in March 1954 Anastas Mikoyan called for reviving his memory along with that of Charents, Raphael Patkanian and Raffi, opening the Thaw in Armenia. The National Library of Armenia bore his name from 1925 to 1990, and his party name Martuni was given to a town in Armenia's Gegharkunik province and to a town in Karabakh. An avenue and a square in Yerevan, a district of Rostov Oblast (Myasnikovsky) and the Kacha Higher Military Aviation School of Pilots also bore his name, as did a street in Volgograd and, for a time, the settlement of Aliabad in Azerbaijan's Nakhchivan (formerly Myasnikovabad). A monument to him was unveiled on that Yerevan square in 1980; another, erected in Stepanakert in 2014, was destroyed by the Azerbaijani government in 2024.