Filipp Sergeyevich Oktyabrsky

Филипп Сергеевич Октябрьский
Soviet Union state institutions Marxism–Leninism Soviet Russia 1899.10.23.–1969.7.8. ○ Natural causes

Admiral who led the Black Sea Fleet in the defence of Odessa and Sevastopol, and remains at the centre of the evacuation controversy

On 22 June 1941, warned of approaching bombers, Oktyabrsky said "Act according to instructions" and refused to order fire. His chief of staff opened up on his own, but in that brief delay the Germans laid mines in the harbour.

Wartime commander of the Soviet Black Sea Fleet. In command from 1939, he also commanded the Sevastopol Defence Region in 1941–1942, led the defence of Odessa and Sevastopol together with the army, and took part in the Kerch–Feodosia landing. In July 1942, as Sevastopol fell, he flew out with the command after the Stavka gave permission; the evacuation, which left tens of thousands of defenders behind, is still disputed. Removed in 1943 after the failed South Ozereyka landing and sent to the Amur Flotilla, he returned to the Black Sea Fleet in March 1944, helped liberate the Crimea and was promoted to admiral in April. After the war he was First Deputy Commander-in-Chief of the Navy, and in 1958 he was made a Hero of the Soviet Union.

Also known as: Filipp Sergeyevich Ivanov

Activities and affiliations

Career Timeline

Related historical events

The Black Sea Fleet and the Sevastopol Defence Region (1941–1942)

Oktyabrsky had commanded the Black Sea Fleet since March 1939 and became a vice-admiral in May 1941. At dawn on 22 June 1941, when the fleet's duty officer reported a large number of enemy aircraft approaching Sevastopol, he would not give the order to fire and said only, "Act according to instructions." In the end the fleet's chief of staff Ivan Yeliseyev ordered fire on his own initiative, but in the delay the first pair of German bombers dropped six parachute magnetic mines. That evening the tug SP-12 struck one and 28 men died; a floating crane and a cargo lighter were then lost, and the destroyer Bystry was damaged beyond repair. Fearing the entry of large Italian surface ships or Turkey's entry into the war, the fleet command laid excessively dense defensive minefields off the ports, on which several Soviet destroyers and transports were sunk.

He was one of the leaders of the defence of Odessa, and after the Coastal Army, withdrawn from Odessa in October 1941, reached the Crimea, he also commanded the Sevastopol Defence Region. The land defence was in the hands of the Coastal Army's commander, Ivan Petrov. Using Soviet command of the sea, Oktyabrsky brought in 23,000 men from the Caucasus in November and the 11,000 of the 388th Rifle Division on 7–13 December, and the German 11th Army's two assaults were beaten off. When Petrov was removed by the superior command at the end of December, Oktyabrsky saved him with a telegram to Stalin. He also took part in preparing and carrying out the Kerch–Feodosia landing that began in December 1941.

On 18 June 1942 he reported to Stalin that the garrison's losses stood at 22,000–23,000. On 30 June he asked the People's Commissar of the Navy, Nikolai Kuznetsov, for permission to evacuate the command, and the Stavka granted it. The evacuation plan provided only for the senior and higher officers of the army and fleet and the city's party leaders; no evacuation of the rest of the troops was planned. On the night of 30 June to 1 July he flew out from the Chersonese airfield on a PS-84 transport kept ready in a separate revetment. About 20,000 people, mostly wounded, had been taken out during June; 70,000 to 100,000 were taken prisoner.

The decision is judged in opposite ways to this day. Critics ask whether more of the garrison could have been taken off and whether it was right to evacuate only the officers and leave the men behind, and there has even been talk of renaming Oktyabrsky Street in Sevastopol. At a military-scientific conference on the Crimea and Sevastopol in December 1961, by one account, he dwelt on sharing the glory with the late General Petrov and left a strongly negative impression on those present. Defenders point out that the command left with the Stavka's permission and that by late June sea and air belonged to the Germans, so that even the last ships were hammered from the air. Germany's Operation Sturgeon Catch was meant to end with the destruction of the Black Sea Fleet as it came to evacuate the garrison; Russian Wikipedia writes that this was the one aim the Germans did not achieve, because the fleet simply did not come. In 1958 he was made a Hero of the Soviet Union for his "skilful leadership of the fleet."

Dismissal and return, 1943–1944: the Amur Flotilla interlude

In July 1943 Oktyabrsky was removed from command of the Black Sea Fleet and posted to command the Amur Military Flotilla. The immediate trigger was the failure of the February 1943 landing at South Ozereyka. The posting effectively carried out what an earlier attempt had sought: in December 1942 the People's Commissar of the Navy, Nikolai Kuznetsov proposed removing him from the Black Sea Fleet and appointing him a member of the military council and deputy commander of the Transcaucasian Front, but the State Defence Committee rejected the proposal.

His successor was Vice-Admiral Lev Vladimirsky, whose tenure proved short. In October 1943 the destroyer leader Kharkov and two destroyers were sunk by air attack, and the landing at Eltigen in November and December of that year also failed. Vladimirsky was removed for both episodes, and in March 1944 Oktyabrsky returned to the Black Sea Fleet. Under his renewed command the fleet contributed substantially to the liberation of the Caucasus and Crimea, and on 10 April 1944 he was promoted to admiral.

The episode is best read not as the demotion and return of one commander but as the command's answer to a year of failed amphibious operations and fleet losses on the Black Sea coast, in which responsibility did not fall on Oktyabrsky alone: his successor was removed in the same manner, and he was recalled.