French Communist Party (PCF) Marxism–Leninism France France 1900.4.28.–1964.7.11. ○ Illness

A miner's son who built the Popular Front and led the French Communist Party for 34 years

'The French people will never make war against the Soviet Union' — address to the PCF Central Committee, February 1949, as France prepared to join NATO (reported by The New York Times, 23 Feb. 1949)

A coal miner's son who led the French Communist Party for 34 years (1930–1964). He designed the 1936 Popular Front and pioneered the 'French road to socialism' after the war, becoming a forerunner of Eurocommunism.

Activities and affiliations

Career Timeline

Related historical events

How did a mining boy become leader of the French Communist Party at thirty?

Maurice Thorez was born on 28 April 1900 at Noyelles-Godault in the Pas-de-Calais coalfield of northern France. He never knew his biological father and was raised by the miner Louis Thorez, who recognised him as his son when he was two and a half; his maternal grandfather was a socialist miner. After gaining his primary certificate in 1912 he went to work at the pit, where by his own account he started at twelve as a stone sorter, picking rock out of the coal. During the First World War he fled the German advance with his grandfather, worked as a farmhand and a bargeman and read Hugo, Jules Verne and Jules Vallès, then returned home after the war to work underground.

In 1919 he joined the CGT trade-union confederation and the Socialist Party (SFIO) and, inspired by the Russian Revolution, the campaign to join the Third International. When the Socialist majority joined the Comintern at the Congress of Tours in December 1920 and founded the Communist Party, he was doing his military service. On his return the mine refused to rehire him, and he devoted himself to the party, becoming a full-time organiser in the Pas-de-Calais in 1923. The party leader Boris Souvarine singled him out as the "model pupil" to be trained in Moscow. In 1924 he followed Souvarine in backing publication of Trotsky's The New Course, but after Souvarine's expulsion he rallied to the Comintern majority.

A member of the Political Bureau from 1925, he led the campaign against the Moroccan war, was driven underground by the police and spent eleven months in prison in 1929–1930. The Comintern was then imposing the "class against class" line, which attacked social democracy as "social fascism"; Thorez resisted at first but ended up as its champion. The isolated party shrank from 55,000 members in 1927 to 25,000 in 1931. Arbitration in Moscow made him the party's effective leader in 1930, and in 1931 he formally took the post of general secretary. The Comintern's representative in Paris, the Slovak Eugen Fried, was his patron and real supervisor. Blame for the party's poor showing was laid on the "youth group" of Barbé and Célor. In the 1932 election, in which the party fell to 6.8 percent, he narrowly won Ivry-sur-Seine.

Biographers explain his rise by two things: personal qualities such as clear speech, a common touch and a sense of the political situation, and an unfailing discipline towards the Comintern's decisions. The historian Claude Pennetier noted his ability to back positions he had first opposed when circumstances changed, and Pierre Souyri judged that the Comintern needed not strong, independent-minded figures but able and ambitious leaders who were also docile, and that Thorez was exactly that.

Why did he leave the army and spend the Second World War in Moscow?

The announcement of the Nazi-Soviet pact on 23 August 1939 threw the French Communist Party into confusion. On 1 September the Communist deputies, chaired by Thorez, voted war credits in response to Germany's attack on Poland, and on 3 September he answered the mobilisation order and joined his engineer regiment at Arras. But from mid-September the Comintern ordered the party to denounce the war as imperialist, and on 26 September the French government dissolved the party. The Comintern's general secretary, Dimitrov, cabled Thorez to desert. "What do Benoît and Jacques think?" he is said to have asked, meaning Frachon and Duclos, before submitting as he had all his career. He left his unit on the night of 3–4 October and travelled through Belgium, Stockholm and Riga to reach Moscow on 8 November.

A French military court sentenced him to six years for desertion in wartime, in January 1940 he lost his seat in the Chamber and in February his French nationality, and in April he received a further five-year sentence in absentia for defying the decree dissolving the party. He lived hidden near Moscow under the name "Ivanov" and in the autumn of 1941, as the Germans approached, was evacuated to Ufa in the Urals. Biographers describe this time of idleness in hiding, watching Soviet poverty, as the darkest of his life. In France Jacques Duclos ran the underground party. After Germany invaded the Soviet Union in June 1941 the party openly declared armed struggle against the occupation and organised the Francs-Tireurs et Partisans, becoming one of the main forces of the Resistance. Articles in the clandestine L'Humanité were signed "Maurice Thorez, somewhere in France"; the party admitted only years after the war that he had been in Moscow throughout.

After the liberation of Paris in August 1944 and the formation of a provisional government with two Communist ministers, the party campaigned for Thorez's return. On 6 November de Gaulle granted him an individual pardon. Historians link this to an understanding between Stalin and de Gaulle: the Communists would accept the dissolution of their armed Patriotic Militias and not rise against de Gaulle, and Thorez would come home. Before he left, Stalin instructed him to take the legal road rather than seize power, to "hide the weapons" and rally the people around the party.

His desertion remained a weapon for his opponents all his life. In 1945, 63 percent of French people polled opposed his return, but the party, which called itself "the party of the 75,000 shot", hailed him as "the first of the francs-tireurs and partisans", and the 1949 edition of Son of the People rewrote events to say that the party had sent him underground to lead the militants in France.

What was the 'French road to socialism', and how far was it independent of the Soviet line?

Returning in November 1944, Thorez turned his back on the temptation of revolutionary insurrection. The party accepted the dissolution of the Patriotic Militias, and in July 1945 at Waziers in the northern coalfield he urged miners to produce more, declaring that "to produce is today the highest form of class duty, the duty of the French." The party won 26 percent in the Constituent Assembly elections of October 1945, and Thorez joined de Gaulle's government as minister of state for the civil service, where he drew up the general civil service statute, and from 1946 he served as deputy prime minister. Electricity, gas and the coal mines were nationalised in these years. When de Gaulle visited Moscow in the autumn of 1944, Stalin told him that Thorez was "a good Frenchman" and advised against putting him in prison; de Gaulle replied that the French government treated Frenchmen according to the services it expected of them.

Thorez's most original political contribution was the concept of a "French road to socialism." Just after the November 1946 elections, in which the Communists won 28 percent and became the largest party, he declared in an interview with The Times published on 18 November that the French Communist Party could reach socialism by a path different from that of the Russian Bolsheviks: peacefully, through parliamentary democracy and a broad alliance of the working and middle classes. This was a pioneering formulation of the "national road" that Western European communist parties sought after the dissolution of the Comintern (1943), and it gave the postwar PCF a strategic basis for converting its armed Resistance networks into regular politics and building a mass party commanding over a quarter of the vote. In December 1946 Thorez stood as a candidate for prime minister and won 261 of 579 votes, short of a majority; it was nonetheless the closest a Western communist leader came to the head of government through legal procedure.

In 1947, as the Cold War began and conflicts over the wage freeze and the Indochina war sharpened, the Communist ministers were forced out of the government in May; the US ambassador had warned the prime minister that aid would suffer if Communists stayed in government. At the founding conference of the Cominform in September the French and Italian parties were criticised for deviation, and Thorez fell into line with the new Soviet course. Even so, at the 14th Party Congress (1956) he reaffirmed that "the Popular Front is an application of the principles of Marx and Lenin," and this line, later seen as a forerunner of Eurocommunism, defined the PCF's independent identity.

His simultaneous support for the Soviet intervention in Hungary (1956) and resistance to de-Stalinisation show, however, that his national path was never fully autonomous from the Soviet line.

Why did Thorez resist de-Stalinisation in his last years, and what did he leave behind?

The year 1950 marked Stalin's seventieth birthday and Thorez's fiftieth, and the cult of both men peaked. An exhibition of birthday gifts was held at Ivry town hall, and the 1949 edition of Son of the People alone ran to 500,000 copies. In the Lysenko affair he endorsed the Soviet doctrine of two sciences, "bourgeois" and "proletarian". But on 10 October 1950 a stroke left him partly paralysed; in November he went to the Soviet Union for treatment and did not return until 1953, after Stalin's death. In his absence Duclos ran the party and in 1952 removed the Resistance heroes André Marty and Charles Tillon from the leadership, and in 1955 the rising Auguste Lecœur was expelled as well.

Khrushchev's secret speech against Stalin at the Soviet party's Twentieth Congress in February 1956 put Thorez in a difficult position. He was the only foreign leader besides Mao to name Stalin in his speech to the congress, and although he received a copy of the report he hid its existence from party members, who learned of it from the "bourgeois" press. At the 14th Party Congress in July he stressed that Stalin had shown "exceptional merits" and earned great authority. When Togliatti in Italy accepted de-Stalinisation, the leaders of Western Europe's two great communist parties fell out. That autumn he supported the Soviet suppression of the Hungarian uprising, and when anti-communist crowds attacked party offices the party closed ranks around him. In 1959 he sidelined Laurent Casanova and others close to the Italian line, and in the international dispute he took the Soviet side against China and Albania.

From the 1930s he opposed legal abortion. In 1956, when his wife Jeannette Vermeersch called birth control a "weapon of the bourgeoisie", he backed her, declaring that "women's liberation comes through social reforms, through social revolution, not through abortion clinics". The position went against the views of many party members, especially in the medical professions.

In May 1964 the ailing Thorez had Waldeck Rochet, who was closer to Khrushchev's line, named general secretary and became party president himself. On 11 July he died of a cerebral haemorrhage aboard the Soviet liner Litva on its way to the Black Sea. The party said a million people attended his funeral in Paris; observers put it at 600,000 to 650,000. De Gaulle's condolences said that "at a decisive time" Thorez had "contributed to maintaining national unity". The historian Claude Pennetier ranks him with Togliatti as one of the great figures of Western European communism. His biographer Philippe Robrieux concluded that the sincere militant had become, after his illness, the most complete type of Stalinist general secretary, and that the French party owed him both its hours of glory and its delay in de-Stalinisation.