Architect of revolutionary legal consciousness, consumed by the Great Terror
In May 1918, when the courtroom stirred at a death sentence passed after the death penalty had been abolished, Krylenko said: "Executions have been abolished. But Shchastny is not being executed; he is being shot."
Born in the village of Bekhteyevo in Smolensk Governorate to a peasant family, he joined the Bolsheviks in 1904 while studying history and literature at St Petersburg University, where he was known as 'Comrade Abram'. After the February Revolution he chaired his regiment's and division's committees and then the 11th Army committee, and in November 1917 he became the first Soviet Supreme Commander-in-Chief, opening armistice talks with Germany. From 1918 he passed through the revolutionary tribunals, prosecution and justice commissariats, casting law as an instrument of class struggle and leading the 1922 SR, 1928 Shakhty, 1930 Industrial Party and 1931 Menshevik trials. Arrested on 31 January 1938 on charges of links to Bukharin's Right organisation and wrecking in the justice organs, he was sentenced to death after a twenty-minute trial, shot on 29 July 1938 and rehabilitated in 1955.
Activities and affiliations
Career Timeline
- 1904–1917Bolshevik underground: arrests, exile, and frontline service as an army officer in WWI
- 1917.11–1918.3First Soviet Supreme Commander-in-Chief; removes Dukhonin, opens ceasefire talks
- 1918–1922Chairman of the Revolutionary Tribunal of the All-Russian Central Executive Committee
- 1922–1929Deputy Commissar of Justice and Senior Assistant Prosecutor of the RSFSR
- 1929–1931Prosecutor of the RSFSR; state prosecutor in the Shakhty, Industrial Party, and Menshevik trials
- 1931–1936People's Commissar of Justice of the RSFSR
- 1936–1938.1People's Commissar of Justice of the USSR
- 1938.7.29Tried in twenty minutes, sentenced to death, shot the same day
Related historical events
- 1905–1907The Revolution of 1905Member of the Petersburg SovietDuring the 1905 Revolution, he belonged to the Petersburg Soviet and Bolshevik committee.
- 1914–1918First World WarJunior officer on the Southwestern FrontIn 1916 he served as a junior officer in a regimental communications unit on the Southwestern Front.
- 1917.10–1918.01The October RevolutionMRC memberA member of the MRC leadership during the insurrection, he was soon appointed commander-in-chief of the army.
- 1917.12–1918.11Brest-Litovsk and Germany’s eastern occupationCommander-in-Chief who backed armistice talks with GermanyHe backed armistice negotiations with Germany.
- 1918–1922The Civil War and Foreign InterventionFirst Supreme Commander-in-Chief and chairman of the Revolutionary Tribunal
- 1921–1928The New Economic Policy (NEP)People's Commissar of Justice
- 1937–1938The Great PurgeTargetAn architect of revolutionary law and Commissar of Justice, himself executed in 1938 after a twenty-minute trial.
Underground, Prisons, Exile, and the Front, 1904–1916
Studying history and literature at St Petersburg University in 1904, Krylenko joined the Bolsheviks and was known among students as "Comrade Abram". During the 1905 revolution he was a member of the short-lived St Petersburg Soviet and of the Bolshevik Petersburg committee. On 13 October 1905 he chaired a meeting at the Polytechnic Institute at which Khrustalev-Nosar proposed forming a soviet of workers' deputies. He left Russia in June 1906 and returned the same year; in 1907 the tsarist secret police arrested him, and after he was released for insufficient evidence he was exiled to Lublin without trial.
From 1906 he worked illegally as a propagandist for the Moscow committee, using the false names "Leno", "Gurnyak" and "Abramov". In 1909 he wrote a brochure, In Search of Orthodoxy, marking his theoretical break with Social Democracy; in 1937 the party leadership would judge it "syndicalist in tendency". Documents differ on when he broke with the party: the Russian account dates it to this 1909 brochure, while the English account records his departure from the RSDLP in 1911 and adds that he rejoined soon afterwards. Having passed his university final examinations in spring 1909 and received his degree, he taught literature and history at private Polish schools in Lublin and Sosnowiec.
From 1911 he worked on the Bolshevik newspaper Zvezda and then moved to Pravda. In spring 1911 Lenin summoned him to Krakow in Austrian Galicia, and from then on he was close to Lenin's family; he later became legal adviser to the Bolshevik deputies of the State Duma. From 1912 to 1913 he served a year of active duty as a first-class volunteer in the 69th Ryazan Infantry Regiment at Lublin, passing through the ranks of private and non-commissioned officer, and after transfer to the reserve he was commissioned as an army infantry second lieutenant in November 1913. The English account treats the same period as promotion to lieutenant before his discharge in 1913, so the two accounts differ over his rank.
Assigned by the party to the empire's Social Democratic Duma faction, he was arrested on 11 December 1913 and exiled from St Petersburg to Kharkiv for two years. There he graduated from the law faculty of Kharkiv University as an external student and took a law degree; this legal study during exile became the academic foundation for his later career in the revolutionary tribunals and the prosecution service.
In July 1914, on the eve of the First World War, he emigrated to Austria and then to Switzerland, attending the Berne party conference in March 1915. The English account records that in mid-1915 Lenin sent him to Russia to help rebuild the Bolshevik underground. In June 1915 he was sent illegally to Moscow together with his wife Elena Rozmirovich. In November 1915 he was arrested again on a charge of evading conscription as a reserve officer and held in Kharkiv until April 1916. He was released with an accompanying document demanding that those concerned "be prepared for his propaganda" and forced into the active army. In 1916 he served as a junior officer in the regimental signals unit of the 13th Finland Rifle Regiment, 11th Army, on the Southwestern Front, and from 12 (25) August to 15 (28) September 1916 he was treated at a field hospital in Moscow. After the February Revolution of 1917 his work in the regimental, divisional and army committees began on this ground of underground activity and frontline service.
November 1917, An Ensign Becomes Commander-in-Chief
On 22 November 1917 the Council of People's Commissars dismissed General Dukhonin, who had refused the order to open armistice negotiations, and appointed Ensign Nikolai Krylenko Supreme Commander-in-Chief in his place. The promotion of one of the tsarist army's most junior officers to command over millions of soldiers was a symbol of how thoroughly the revolution had overturned the military hierarchy. Krylenko, a Bolshevik orator educated at St Petersburg University, was known among frontline soldiers by his party name "Comrade Abram".
Krylenko traveled with a detachment of sailors by rail to the general headquarters at Mogilev and took over the Stavka without bloodshed on 3 December. That same day enraged soldiers and sailors lynched Dukhonin; Krylenko tried and failed to stop them, and publicly deplored the violence that had escaped his control. He then backed the armistice negotiations with Germany while shouldering the contradictory task of dissolving the old army and building a new one.
With the signing of the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk in March 1918 Krylenko resigned his command and moved from the army to the revolutionary courts. As the man who had enforced the Bolshevik promise of peace at the front, he embodied the fact that October rested not merely on the seizure of a palace but on the peace hunger of the soldier masses in the trenches.
Revolutionary Tribunals, Chess, and the Pamirs
From the Civil War years Krylenko was a builder of the Soviet legal system. As chief state prosecutor he led the major political trials of the era, including the SR trial of 1922, the Shakhty trial of 1928 and the Industrial Party trial of 1930, and he became People's Commissar of Justice of the RSFSR in 1931 and of the USSR in 1936. His jurisprudence treated law as an instrument of class struggle and rejected procedural formalism, yet he also worked at codification and legal education, the institutionalization of justice in the new state.
Krylenko was also the greatest patron of Soviet chess and mountaineering. As chairman of the All-Union chess section he organized the Moscow international tournament of 1925 under the slogan "chess to the masses" and founded the magazine 64. In summer he left for the Pamirs, leading expeditions including the joint Soviet-German Pamir expedition of 1928, and he laid the institutional foundations of Soviet alpinism.
At the January 1938 session of the Supreme Soviet his "hobbies" were attacked as proof of a commissar neglecting his duties. Vyshinsky's rival school of law took the place of his own; Krylenko was arrested on 31 January and shot on 29 July 1938 after a trial that lasted twenty minutes. He was rehabilitated in 1956. That the founder of the revolutionary tribunals vanished without even their minimal procedure shows how the Great Terror consumed the Soviet legal order itself.