filosofia della praxis · 1897.05.14

Philosophy of praxis

실천의 철학

A current that understands Marxism as a philosophy centred on human practice, the social activity that changes the world, and the name for it. The Italian Antonio Labriola first used it, and it became widely known when Antonio Gramsci used it in the Prison Notebooks to refer to Marxism. Because it sought the objectivity of knowledge in people's historical practice and cultural unification, it stood in tension with the epistemology of dialectical materialism, which starts from the reflection of a world outside consciousness. The Yugoslav Praxis school, Kosík and others continued the current.

In depth

Where is "the East"?

Point to a spot on a map and ask whether it is east or west. The answer depends on where you look from. From Seoul, Tokyo is east; from Hawaii it is west. Are "East" and "West" then names made up at will? No. Trade routes are drawn, wars fought and school subjects divided according to them. A distinction made by people works objectively in reality.

In prison Antonio Gramsci used exactly this example to answer an old question of epistemology: what is objectivity? The name he gave Marxism was "philosophy of praxis" (filosofia della praxis). The philosophy of praxis does not deny that the world exists outside our heads. It holds, however, that how we know that world and what we call objective cannot be explained apart from the historical activity in which people have changed the world together.

Where did the name come from?

The starting point is the Theses on Feuerbach that Marx wrote in a notebook in 1845. The second thesis says: "The question whether objective truth can be attributed to human thinking is not a question of theory but a practical question."

Die Frage, ob dem menschlichen Denken gegenständliche Wahrheit zukomme, ist keine Frage der Theorie, sondern eine praktische Frage.

And the eleventh thesis ends: "The philosophers have only interpreted the world in various ways; the point is to change it."

The one who read these theses as the philosophical core of Marx's thought and gave it the name "philosophy of praxis" was the Italian Antonio Labriola. In letters to the Frenchman Georges Sorel in 1897 (collected in a book the following year) he called historical materialism the philosophy of praxis. German Wikipedia sums up that Labriola was the first to identify a philosophy of praxis as the immanent core of Marx's work and to treat it as a task to be developed further. Italian Wikipedia likewise writes that Gramsci took up in the Prison Notebooks Labriola's description of Marxism as the "philosophy of praxis".

Gramsci had reasons for using the term in prison. It is well known that he used it instead of "Marxism" to escape the notice of the fascist prison censor. Italian Wikipedia stresses, however, that he called Marxism by this name not only to evade censorship. The name carried his philosophical position.

What did Gramsci argue?

First, all people are philosophers. Gramsci said the prejudice that philosophy is a matter for specialists must be broken, and that one must start from "the principle that all men are 'philosophers', that is, that between professional or 'technical' philosophers and other men there is no 'qualitative' difference but only a 'quantitative' one."

Posto il principio che tutti gli uomini sono «filosofi», che cioè tra i filosofi professionali o «tecnici» e gli altri uomini non c’è differenza «qualitativa» ma solo «quantitativa»

The philosophy of ordinary people is contained in language, common sense and popular religion. This philosophy, though, is often contradictory. Gramsci saw two conceptions of the world coexisting in people: one affirmed in words, the other shown in actual conduct. The discrepancy does not always come from bad faith; it arises because subaltern groups follow in words a conception borrowed from ruling groups. The task of the philosophy of praxis is to criticise this scattered common sense and raise it into a coherent conception of the world, which connects with the cultural leadership described in the entry "Hegemony (Gramsci)".

Second, objectivity is "humanly objective". Gramsci wrote: "Objective always means 'humanly objective', which can correspond exactly to 'historically subjective'."

Oggettivo significa sempre «umanamente oggettivo», ciò che può corrispondere esattamente a «storicamente soggettivo»

Humans know objectively insofar as knowledge is real for the whole human race historically unified in a single cultural system. But society is divided into classes and this unification has not yet happened. So Gramsci says that there is a "struggle for objectivity", a struggle to free oneself from partial and fallacious ideologies, and that this is the same as the struggle for the cultural unification of humankind. The example of east and west given above comes in this very passage: he wrote that East and West are historical and cultural constructions and yet "objectively real".

Third, the philosophy of praxis is absolute historicism. Gramsci called it absolute "historicism", the absolute secularisation and earthliness of thought, an absolute humanism of history. He held that it was the translation of Hegelianism into the language of historicism. In the same notebook he criticised the philosophy of the Italian philosopher Benedetto Croce as, conversely, a retranslation of the philosophy of praxis into speculative language.

How did it clash with reflection theory?

Criticising a widely read introduction to Marxism (the book he called the "popular manual" in his notes), Gramsci wrote that the whole polemic over "the reality of the external world" seemed to him badly posed and largely idle. In the idea that sets up the objectivity of the external world first, apart from human history, he saw Catholicism and Aristotelianism standing together. Dialectical materialism as formulated in the Soviet Union, by contrast, took as basic the account that matter precedes consciousness, that knowledge reflects reality outside consciousness, and that practice is the criterion of whether the reflection is correct (see "Reflection theory" and "Criterion of practice"). Both accounts value practice, but they part over whether practice is the place where knowledge is tested or the place where objectivity itself is made.

In the 1960s criticism came from another side. Louis Althusser criticised historicism and humanism as ideological deviations within Marxism, and Gramsci's absolute historicism was among his targets. For Althusser, Marxism was not a philosophy of practice in general but a science. The opposition continues in the entry "Theoretical practice (Althusser)".

How did the philosophy of praxis continue?

German Wikipedia sums up that Gramsci, Herbert Marcuse, Ernst Bloch, Henri Lefebvre and others formed a European current that developed the concept of practice as the philosophical core of Marx's thought. Lukács's History and Class Consciousness and Korsch's Marxism and Philosophy, both of 1923, stand at the head of this current. When Marx's Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts were first published in 1932, the young Marcuse welcomed them, and after the war the manuscripts became a new foundation for the philosophy of praxis.

The current was not tolerated within the Soviet sphere of influence. Bloch had to leave East Germany in 1961, and the Czech Karel Kosík was driven from the university after the Prague Spring was crushed in 1969. In non-aligned Yugoslavia, by contrast, the Praxis school enjoyed international influence for nearly ten years around the journal Praxis and the Korčula Summer School. Today "philosophy of praxis" is used both in the narrow sense of Gramsci's term and in the broad sense of the whole of Marxist philosophy that takes practice as its central category.

Related people

Sources

  1. archive.org
  2. it.wikipedia.org
  3. it.wikipedia.org
  4. Marxists Internet Archive
  5. de.wikipedia.org
  6. Wikipedia (EN)
  7. archive.org
  8. Wikipedia (EN)