Lenin’s oldest friend and most principled adversary
In 1918 Martov published an exposé revealing that Stalin had been expelled from the party in 1907. Stalin sued him for libel, and the revolutionary tribunal sentenced Martov to 'public censure.'
He built Iskra alongside Lenin, then split with him in 1903 over a single clause on party membership and led the Mensheviks. After October he stayed, fighting to keep a legal opposition alive, and in 1920 was permitted to leave. He died of tuberculosis in Berlin. It is told that the dying Lenin asked after him.
Also known as: Yuli Tsederbaum
Activities and affiliations
-
Political and party leadership
-
Russian Social Democratic Labour Party (RSDLP)
Political and party leadership
Career Timeline
- 1895Co-founds the Petersburg League of Struggle with Lenin
- 1900–1903On Iskra; leads the Mensheviks after the split
- 1914–1917Anti-war internationalist
- 1917–1920Leads the Menshevik Internationalists; tries legal opposition
- 1921–1923Founds the Socialist Courier in Berlin
Related historical events
- 1900.12.24–1905.05.10The Second Congress of the RSDLP and the Bolshevik–Menshevik SplitLeader of the minority (Mensheviks)Won the vote on Paragraph One 28 to 22 with his broader definition of a member. Refusing election to a three-man board as a "state of siege", he led the Bureau of the Minority in boycotting the new central bodies, and returned to Iskra when Plekhanov co-opted the old editors in November 1903.
- 1905–1907The Revolution of 1905Menshevik leaderHe returned to Russia in 1905, worked in the Soviet and the Menshevik press, and debated the Bolsheviks over the tactics and prospects of the revolution.
- 1907–1919The collapse of the Second InternationalMenshevik internationalistUrged and attended the Zimmerwald conference.
- 1914–1918First World WarAnti-war internationalistMartov attended the Zimmerwald anti-war conference and opposed continuing the war throughout 1917.
- 1917.02–07The February RevolutionMenshevik InternationalistLeading the Menshevik Internationalists, he consistently opposed entry into the coalition and the continuation of the war.
- 1917.10–1918.01The October RevolutionMenshevik-Internationalist leaderAt the Second Congress of Soviets he proposed an all-socialist coalition, and walked out when it was voted down.
- 1918–1922The Civil War and Foreign InterventionMenshevik who urged defence of the revolutionMartov called on workers to defend the revolution against the Whites and foreign intervention.
- 1919–1921The founding of the CominternLeader of the Vienna UnionWas a leading figure of the Vienna Union, the “Two-and-a-Half International”.
How did a Jewish boy born in Constantinople become the theorist of "agitation"?
Julius Martov was born Yuliy Osipovich Tsederbaum on 24 November 1873 in Constantinople, the Ottoman capital, into a prosperous Jewish family assimilated to Russian culture. His grandfather Alexander Tsederbaum was a leading figure of the Jewish Enlightenment (Haskalah) who founded the first Hebrew and Yiddish newspapers in Russia; his father was the Turkish correspondent of several St Petersburg papers and an agent of a Russian shipping company. As a small child he was dropped by a nanny and broke his leg, and because treatment came too late he limped for the rest of his life.
The family moved to Odessa in 1878, and there he lived through the pogrom of 1881. That experience and the official antisemitism of the tsarist state left him deeply alienated from the existing order. With his siblings he invented an imaginary realm called "Prilichensk", the Realm of Decency, governed by strict moral laws; his sister and fellow revolutionary Lydia Dan recalled that this early moral sense shaped his political life. After the family moved to St Petersburg he faced antisemitism at school, and in 1889 the laws restricting Jewish residence nearly drove the family out of the capital.
In his last years at the gymnasium he read the Communist Manifesto, which, he recalled, "dazzled me with its picture of a mighty revolutionary party which would proceed to destroy the old world." He entered St Petersburg University in 1891 but soon threw himself into radical student politics, and in 1892 he was arrested for distributing illegal literature. In prison he studied Marx and Georgy Plekhanov, and after watching peasants riot against doctors during the cholera epidemic that followed the famine of 1891, he gave up his hopes in a peasant revolution and became a Marxist.
In 1893 he chose Vilno (now Vilnius), a centre of the Jewish labour movement, as the place of his two-year administrative exile. At first he taught political economy to small circles of advanced workers, but together with Arkadi Kremer he concluded that "propaganda", teaching theory to a few, could never broaden the movement. It had to shift to "agitation": starting from the everyday grievances of workers, such as wages and hours, in order to move the masses. The pamphlet he edited, On Agitation (1894), became a handbook of Social Democratic work throughout Russia.
Martov argued that Jewish workers carried a double burden of economic exploitation and national oppression and therefore needed a separate Jewish workers' organization to lead the fight for Jewish emancipation; a working class that accepted its fate as an "inferior race" could never win the class struggle. These ideas laid the groundwork for the General Jewish Labour Bund, founded in 1897. Ironically, six years later he would be among the critics of Bundist separatism.
How did Lenin and Martov become a pair of comrades?
Back in St Petersburg in October 1895 after his exile, Martov founded the League of Struggle for the Emancipation of the Working Class together with Vladimir Lenin and other young intellectuals; the name itself is said to have been Martov's. The League applied the agitational method worked out in Vilno to the big factories of the capital, issuing leaflets on the grievances of particular factories and linking them to the political struggle against the autocracy. The great strike of the St Petersburg textile workers in 1896 showed that this work had taken root among the workers.
In January 1896 Martov and most of the League's leaders were arrested. After more than a year in prison he was exiled for three years to Turukhansk in Siberia, just below the Arctic Circle. The cold and isolation there probably gave him the tuberculosis of the throat that plagued him for the rest of his life. He survived through writing and correspondence, and through an intense intellectual friendship with Lenin, who was exiled further south. In exile he wrote a history of the Russian labour movement, The Red Flag in Russia, and in 1899 he backed the protest of seventeen exiles against the "Credo", an Economist document arguing that workers should confine themselves to the economic struggle and leave politics to the liberals.
In 1899 Lenin proposed that he, Martov and Alexander Potresov form a triumvirate to fight Economism and revive the party, and Martov agreed enthusiastically. When his exile ended in early 1900 he toured Russia recruiting agents for the planned newspaper, and in 1901 he joined Lenin and Potresov in Munich. Together with the veterans of Russian Marxism in Switzerland, Plekhanov, Pavel Axelrod and Vera Zasulich, they published the newspaper Iskra (The Spark). Martov became its leading journalist, writing a stream of articles against Economism, Socialist Revolutionary "adventurism" and Bundist "separatism".
The Munich period was the high point of the two men's friendship and collaboration. As early as 1897 Martov had sided with Lenin against "worker-philism", arguing that leadership of the movement by the intelligentsia was the quickest way to a direct struggle with the autocracy. But after the editorial board moved to London in 1902 the first crack appeared. In the "Bauman affair", over the unethical conduct of a party activist, Martov, Zasulich and Potresov demanded an investigation, while Lenin and Plekhanov dismissed it as a private matter outside the party's competence; Martov saw this as a breach of party ethics. That small gap between political comradeship and moral principle would widen at the 1903 congress into the rift that split the party.
Summer 1903: Parting with His Closest Comrade
Julius Martov was Lenin's closest early comrade. In 1895 the two founded the League of Struggle for the Emancipation of the Working Class in St Petersburg, were arrested in turn and served terms of Siberian exile, and from 1900 edited Iskra together in emigration. Their comrades thought of them as a pair.
At the Second Congress of the RSDLP, held in Brussels and London in the summer of 1903, they split over Paragraph 1 of the party rules. Martov wanted the party's doors opened wide, with regular cooperation under its guidance sufficing for membership; Lenin insisted that a member must belong personally to a party organization. Martov won that vote, but after the Bund and Economist delegates walked out, Lenin's faction won the elections to the central bodies and took the name of the majority, Bolsheviks, leaving Martov's followers the name of the minority, Mensheviks.
The difference over one clause grew into a difference over the whole conception of the party, and then into the two currents of Russian Social Democracy. The break was political, but the wound was personal: memoirs record that Lenin grieved over the rupture with Martov for years afterwards.
What kind of party did Martov try to make of the Mensheviks after the split?
After the 1903 split Martov and the Mensheviks fought Lenin bitterly for control of the party's institutions. Plekhanov soon broke with Lenin and brought the old editors back onto Iskra, and Martov became the paper's de facto editor, using it to denounce Lenin's "bureaucratic centralism" and the "state of siege" in the party. It was Martov who first used the word "Leninism" for Lenin's views. At the Menshevik conference in Geneva in April and May 1905 he insisted that all party bodies be elected.
In the 1905 revolution Martov, like most Mensheviks, held that Russia was ripe only for a "bourgeois revolution", one that would overthrow the autocracy and set up a capitalist democratic republic. Social Democrats should neither seize power nor join a government, but remain an "extreme revolutionary opposition" pushing the new bourgeois government to the left. A socialist party that took power in a backward country, he warned, would be forced to act against its own principles and would end either in a restoration of the old regime or in a "Jacobin" dictatorship that discredited socialism. This was directly opposed to Lenin's call for a "revolutionary-democratic dictatorship of the proletariat and the peasantry".
Returning to Russia in October 1905 after the October Manifesto, he worked in the St Petersburg Soviet and helped found Menshevik newspapers. He proposed building a nationwide network of organs of "revolutionary self-government" that would eventually assault the central government, but unlike some colleagues on the same paper he never accepted that Russia could skip the bourgeois stage. The defeat of the December rising in Moscow and the repression that followed seemed to him to confirm his caution. Arrested twice in 1906, he was sentenced to exile in Narym, commuted to expulsion abroad, and returned to emigration.
In exile during the years of reaction he fought on two fronts: against the "liquidators" on the right, who wanted to abandon illegal work altogether, and the "otzovists" or recallists on the left, who wanted to recall the Social Democratic deputies from the Duma. Martov argued for a flexible combination of legal and illegal work, using the Duma as a platform for revolutionary propaganda while keeping the underground organization alive. He also condemned the Bolsheviks' "expropriations", the armed robberies used to fund their activity, as crimes that corrupted the party. At the 1907 Stuttgart congress of the Second International he joined Lenin and Rosa Luxemburg in moving radical amendments to the resolution on war.
The two factions formally reunited at the Fifth Congress in London in 1907, but not for long. When Lenin held a separate conference in Prague in 1912 and set up a purely Bolshevik party, Martov and the Mensheviks answered by forming the "August Bloc" of non-Bolshevik Social Democrats in Vienna that August. Even so, he went on believing that unity with the Bolsheviks was both necessary and possible, a view that often set him against other Mensheviks.
October 1917: Remaining an Opposition Within the Revolution
When the war broke out, Martov stood with the internationalist left even within Menshevism: he rejected defencism, attended the Zimmerwald anti-war conference, and opposed the continuation of the war throughout 1917. On the night of the October insurrection (7 November New Style), at the Second All-Russian Congress of Soviets, he proposed a coalition government of all socialist parties to avert bloodshed. As the proposal died and he walked out, Trotsky's famous words followed him: from now on, your place is in the dustbin of history.
Yet Martov never crossed over to the counterrevolution. He remained in Russia as a legal opposition, criticizing repression and the Red Terror while calling on workers to defend the revolution against the Whites and foreign intervention; in 1919 he was even elected to the All-Russian Central Executive Committee. In 1920, gravely ill, he left the country legally and founded the Sotsialistichesky Vestnik in Berlin. He died of tuberculosis on 4 April 1923.
According to Krupskaya, Lenin, by then on his own sickbed, kept asking after Martov's condition with unconcealed affection: they say Martov is dying too. The two men who had fought each other for a lifetime died within a year of one another, and Martov is remembered as the critic who never betrayed the revolution.
How did Martov analyse Bolshevism from exile in Berlin?
On 14 June 1918 the Mensheviks were expelled from the All-Russian Central Executive Committee on charges of aiding the counter-revolution, and their newspapers were closed. That year Martov also revealed that Stalin had once been expelled from the party for involvement in the "expropriations" of 1906–1907; Stalin sued him for libel and he received a "public reprimand". At the end of 1918 he proposed a tactic of "agreement and struggle": accepting the Soviet system as "a fact of reality" while demanding its democratization. Defending the revolution against the Whites while opposing the Bolshevik regime politically won him few friends on either side.
In September 1920, with his tuberculosis advancing, he was allowed to leave Soviet Russia legally to attend the Halle congress of the Independent Social Democratic Party of Germany (USPD), which was about to split over joining the Communist International (Comintern). Martov urged it not to join, denouncing the Comintern as an instrument of the Russian state for imposing Bolshevik methods on the European socialist movement. Because his illness had left him barely able to speak, his address, "The Problems of the International and the Russian Revolution", was made public at his request. The USPD split all the same.
He settled in Berlin, which became the new centre of the Menshevik party in exile. In February 1921 he founded the Socialist Courier (Sotsialisticheskii Vestnik), which remained the main voice of Menshevism for the next four decades. He was also a leading figure in the Vienna International, often called the "Two-and-a-Half International", an alliance of centrist socialist parties seeking a middle path between the reformism of the Second International and the authoritarianism of the Comintern. In his last years he broke politically even with his oldest comrade, Pavel Axelrod. Martov held that, faced with counter-revolution, socialists had to support the Soviet regime as the "lesser evil"; Axelrod insisted that the Bolshevik dictatorship was a total negation of democratic socialism and could not be compromised with.
In his last writings, collected as World Bolshevism (1923), he offered a detailed critique of the Soviet state. The Bolshevik victory, he argued, was not a triumph of Marxist theory but a product of the war's disintegration of the working class. Bolshevism rested on the principle that "socialism is true and must therefore be imposed on the masses, who, deluded by the bourgeoisie, cannot understand their own interests"; he called it "anarcho-Jacobinism". He saw the New Economic Policy as a retreat from the attempt to impose socialism by force, but feared that this "Bonapartist perversion of the revolution", a Red dictatorship resting on a quasi-capitalist economy, would lead to a counter-revolutionary restoration from within the Bolshevik apparatus itself. The philosopher Leszek Kołakowski counts him, with Kautsky and Rosa Luxemburg, as the third major critic of Bolshevism in the years just after the revolution.
He died on 4 April 1923, aged forty-nine, in a sanatorium at Schömberg in the Black Forest, and after cremation was laid to rest in Berlin with Gorky present. His biographer Israel Getzler called him "the Hamlet of Democratic Socialism": a brilliant theorist and a man of great moral integrity who lacked will at decisive moments, and Trotsky likewise put his failure down to Hamlet-like indecision. Yet Getzler also stresses that Martov held consistently to his orthodox Marxist principles and to an ethic that refused to let the cause justify any means, even when that cost him politically.