Aesthetic Theory (Adorno)
미학 이론 (아도르노)
A work of philosophy of art that Theodor W. Adorno wrote throughout the 1960s and left unfinished; it appeared posthumously in 1970, the year after his death. Starting from the "double character" of art as autonomous, detached from society, and at the same time a product of society, it argues that modern art bears witness to society's contradictions, and points to a better world, through its form rather than through any message. The "truth content" of artworks is the book's central concept.
In depth
How can a play with no plot and no message criticise society?
In Samuel Beckett's Waiting for Godot two men wait endlessly for someone who never comes. There is no exploitation of labour, no revolution, no good worker hero. Can such a work be said to criticise society? By the standard of socialist realism such theatre comes close to bourgeois decadence that turns its back on social reality. Theodor W. Adorno thought the opposite. In his view, under late capitalism the best art, and politically the most effective, works out its own internal contradictions so thoroughly that the hidden contradictions of society can no longer be ignored. He had intended to dedicate Aesthetic Theory to Beckett.
The book is Adorno's last major work, the systematic statement of this view. He died in 1969, and the unfinished manuscripts he had written between 1961 and 1969 were assembled by his widow Gretel Adorno and Rolf Tiedemann and published in 1970. Though nearly complete, the work remained a fragment. It is divided not into chapters or sections but only by large spaces between blocks of text, and has no basic concept from which it proceeds, no order or hierarchy of problems. Tiedemann himself wrote that the text confronts its readers with unforeseen difficulties.
How does art relate to society?
A theme Adorno keeps returning to is the "double character of art": autonomy and fait social, social fact.
Doppelcharakter der Kunst: der von Autonomie und fait social
As a social fact the artwork is a product of social intellectual labour and becomes a commodity; yet in its autonomy it at the same time sheds its commodity character. Hence Adorno called art "the social antithesis of society". Art arises within society but takes its stand against that very society.
Kunst ist die gesellschaftliche Antithesis zur Gesellschaft
What matters is how art connects with society. For Adorno art is social not by depicting social phenomena but through its forms and means of shaping. Because society and class struggles enter the structure of works, authentic artworks become "the unconscious historiography of their epoch".
die ihrer selbst unbewußte Geschichtsschreibung ihrer Epoche
Conversely, works act back on society not through manifest statements of position but through their "immanent movement against society". They embody both a denunciation of existing society and an anticipation of a liberated one. Adorno often quoted Stendhal's description of art as a "promise of happiness", but added that art is not only the stand-in for a better practice but equally a critique of practice as the rule of brutal self-preservation. This scheme pairs with the way Adorno and Max Horkheimer treated mass culture in their critique of the "culture industry": culture turned commodity faces autonomous art that refuses to be a commodity.
What is truth content?
The centre around which all the concentric circles of Aesthetic Theory turn is "truth content" (Wahrheitsgehalt). The artwork speaks the truth about society in a language other than the conceptual language of critical social theory, a non-discursive one. As Albrecht Wellmer summarises it, works are true insofar as they make reality appear as unreconciled, antagonistic and torn, yet because they synthesise what is split they also let it appear in the light of reconciliation. Adorno put it as a paradox: art must "bear witness to the irreconcilable and nevertheless tend to reconcile it".
Paradox hat sie das Unversöhnliche zu bezeugen und gleichwohl tendenziell zu versöhnen
Art bears witness to what cannot be reconciled while leaning towards reconciliation. That is its "semblance", and its unavoidable fault is that in an unreconciled reality it can achieve reconciliation only symbolically. The mark of modern art, for Adorno, was dissonance. Since Baudelaire and Wagner's Tristan dissonance has been an invariant of modernity, and in aesthetic intuition the ugly is its synonym. Dissonance in the work converges with social alienation in outer reality. His thought was that modern art, having abandoned classical harmony, is for that very reason close to the truth. This thought connects with his philosophy treated under "Negative Dialectics".
How did he view committed art and realism?
Adorno's position on art and politics grew out of his debates in the 1930s with György Lukács, Walter Benjamin and Bertolt Brecht. In 1936 he objected that Benjamin's "Work of Art in the Age of Its Technological Reproducibility" underestimated the technicity of autonomous art (see "Aura (Benjamin)"). Because of the structural shift in late capitalism, and because of his emphasis on art's autonomy, he doubted both the effectiveness and the legitimacy of tendentious, agitational art, art deliberately made to raise consciousness. Yet he did see politically engaged art as a partial corrective to the bankrupt aestheticism of much mainstream art.
His judgement of Lukács was sharper. Adorno read "Realism in the Balance", which Lukács wrote for Das Wort in 1938, as evidence that Lukács had abandoned the lucid objectivity of his Theory of the Novel and submitted to official communist doctrine (see "Expressionism debate"). In painting he regarded figurative art after Cubism and abstraction, like neoclassicism in music, as a regression to a technical level already surpassed. From the opposite side Mikhail Lifshitz, in The Crisis of Ugliness, criticised modern art's cult of the ugly. Faced with the same phenomenon, the two drew opposite conclusions: testimony to truth, and symptom of crisis.
What criticisms did it meet?
Aesthetic Theory is generally received as an "aesthetics of negativity". The criticisms took several lines. Hans Robert Jauss pointed out that critical works too are later absorbed into the classical canon as "cultural heritage", and that Adorno rejected too harshly the enjoyment of art, the admiring, laughing and weeping along; at bottom he faulted Adorno for confining himself to an aesthetics of the work and neglecting the aesthetics of reception. Rüdiger Bubner held that Adorno made art an assistant carrying out the intentions of critical theory, and Jürgen Habermas noted that the book sealed the handing over of cognitive competence to art.
Others objected that Adorno recognised only great and authentic works. Albrecht Wellmer found that his fixation on the German-Austrian musical tradition left him unable to deal with other lines of new music such as Debussy, Bartók and Stravinsky. Peter Bürger pointed out that, for reasons internal to his theory, namely his verdict against committed literature, Adorno excluded two of the most important writers of the twentieth century, Brecht and Sartre. Bürger's own alternative is treated under "Theory of the Avant-Garde".
How is an artwork made? Construction and mimesis
When a carpenter makes a chair he measures, cuts and joins the wood. Yet a well-made chair, though planned and calculated, can look as if it had grown by itself, the grain still alive. Adorno sees artworks the same way. The work is the result of a rational "construction" that fits individual "material" (sounds, words, colours, wood, metal) together into a unity. Construction means the layout, organisation and distribution of the material. Though shaped to a purpose, the finished work appears as if produced by nature, because the form-giving faculty itself belongs, in Kant's phrase, to "nature in the subject".
Construction can therefore succeed only if it clings "mimetically" to the sensuous impulses underlying it, those of the subject and of the material. Mimesis is usually rendered as "imitation", but as the philosopher Ruth Sonderegger stresses, what Adorno brings out in the word is less copying than "making oneself like" the object: not dominating the material but adapting oneself to where the material tends. When construction and mimesis interlock, the successful work appears as a harmonious unity. As with the double character discussed above, rationality and the nature it suppresses confront each other within a single work. This is the problem of Dialectic of Enlightenment carried into art.
How can something useless criticise society?
The artwork is autonomous in that it obeys only its own formal law. Adorno drew the conclusion that artworks are without function:
Soweit von Kunstwerken eine gesellschaftliche Funktion sich prädizieren lässt, ist es ihre Funktionslosigkeit
"Insofar as a social function can be predicated of artworks, it is their functionlessness." In a society where everything is measured by usefulness and exchange value, a work that refuses to be used for anything criticises that society merely by existing. By crystallising as something of its own instead of complying with existing social norms and qualifying as "socially useful", he wrote, art criticises society by its mere existence.
Here art's utopian character emerges:
In jedem genuinen Kunstwerk erscheint etwas, was es nicht gibt
"In every genuine artwork something appears that does not exist." The work is a "promise of happiness" pointing to what does not yet exist, a better world, but it can promise this only by negating given reality as a whole. Hence Adorno called art "the stand-in for a better practice" while opposing its use as a direct instrument of political action. That view leads to his critique of Sartre and Brecht in "Commitment (Adorno)".
Why is the artwork a riddle?
After reading a good poem we sometimes feel that we cannot say what it means and yet have clearly understood something. Adorno called this the "enigmatic character" (Rätselcharakter) of art. As the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy puts it, the modernist artwork is not an instance fulfilling a concept but a processual "force field" of tensions between conceptual polarities such as sensuousness and meaning, form and content, autonomy and heteronomy, mimesis and rational construction. That is why it does not resolve into a single answer.
The idea connects with the roots of Adorno's philosophy. In his 1931 inaugural lecture he likened philosophical interpretation to riddle-solving: philosophy must bring its elements into changing trial combinations until they fall into a figure that can be read as an answer, while the question itself disappears. The artwork's riddle demands such interpretation but is never fully solved in concepts. That unsolved remainder is where the "truth content" discussed above resides.
Why did he revive natural beauty and the sublime?
Adorno paid special attention to natural beauty, which philosophy had "repressed" since Schelling. Art, he said, imitates not nature but natural beauty. In Wellmer's reading this means not copying what is real but following what in the real already points beyond reality. Natural beauty is the cipher of a nature that does not yet exist, a reconciled nature, and the artwork becomes the image of a nature released from its muteness and able to speak, and of a reconciled humanity.
He also revived the sublime. For Kant the sublime was the feeling evoked by the overwhelming magnitude of external nature. Adorno inverted this into the experience of human beings' awareness of their own naturalness (see "Kantian aesthetics"). In modern art the sublime displaces the beautiful. The work gives up the gesture of mastery over its material and follows the material's own tendencies, and so turns towards the broken and fragmentary. Adorno commented that "there are no perfect works", because the works' constitutive irreconcilability cuts them off from reconciliation too.
Interpretations of this passage differ. Wolfgang Welsch saw the sublime as an "explosive charge" within an aesthetics centred on reconciliation. Wellmer held on the contrary that the sublime keeps its place within that scheme as the site of holding out against the overwhelming power of negativity in a world that, after Auschwitz, has fallen into complete negativity. What Adorno said about Auschwitz is treated under "To write poetry after Auschwitz is barbaric".
In what state was the manuscript left?
The present book was assembled from manuscripts Adorno wrote between 4 May 1961 and 16 July 1969, mainly between October 1966 and January 1968; revisions continued from September 1968 to July 1969, weeks before his death. In his editorial afterword Tiedemann said what was missing. Adorno meant to finish a last round of work by mid-1970, which would have brought many rearrangements and cuts, incorporated the fragments now printed separately as "Paralipomena", and replaced the early introduction with a new one.
So every summary of the book enters by a different door. Depending on whether one starts from reconciliation, natural beauty, the sublime, appearance, rational construction, enigmatic character, mimesis or the monad, a quite different map results. Rolf Wiggershaus called it "an ensemble of essayistic reflections". The form also explains why there are two English translations. Christian Lenhardt's of 1984 broke the long sections into smaller paragraphs; Robert Hullot-Kentor's of 1997 tried to reproduce the largely paragraph-less original and is now the standard version. Work on the manuscripts continues: in 2021 a two-volume text-critical edition appeared reproducing the last known revision of the third chapter of the so-called "chapter aesthetics".