Co-founder of Western Marxism, the German philosopher who challenged Marxist orthodoxy with Marxism and Philosophy
“If we get a few more of these Professors spinning out their theories, we shall be lost.” — Zinoviev at the 5th Comintern Congress, 1924, attacking Korsch and Lukács
German Marxist philosopher and revolutionary who, alongside Lukács, laid the foundations of Western Marxism. In Marxism and Philosophy (1923) he applied the materialist conception of history to Marxism itself, arguing for the revolutionary recovery of the Hegelian dialectic, a move that drew fierce denunciation from the Comintern. Served as Justice Minister in the 1923 Thuringian workers' government and as a KPD Reichstag deputy before his expulsion as a left-oppositionist. Fled the Nazis for American exile, where his scholarship left a deep imprint on Brecht, Benjamin, and the Frankfurt School.
Activities and affiliations
-
1917–1920
Independent Social Democratic Party of Germany (USPD)
Scholarship and theory -
1920–1926
Communist Party of Germany (KPD)
Political and party leadership
Career Timeline
- 1906–1910Studies law and philosophy at Munich, Geneva, Berlin; doctorate in law, University of Jena
- 1912–1914Legal research in London; joins the Fabian Society
- 1914–1918German Army service — refuses to carry weapons; awarded the Iron Cross twice for bravery
- 1917Joins USPD; elected delegate to soldiers' soviet
- 1920Joins KPD with the USPD left wing; lecturer at University of Jena
- 1923.03Publishes Marxism and Philosophy; becomes target of fierce Comintern criticism
- 1923.10–11Justice Minister, Thuringian workers' government — collapses after 27 days under Reichswehr intervention
- 1924–1928KPD Reichstag deputy; delegate to 5th Comintern Congress
- 1926.04Expelled from KPD; forms the Resolute Lefts (Entschiedene Linke) opposition faction
- 1933Flees Germany the night of the Reichstag fire; passes through Denmark and England
- 1936–1961US exile — Tulane University, Institute for Social Research; teaches Marxism to Brecht
- 1938Publishes Karl Marx; deeply influences Benjamin's Arcades Project
- 1950Ten Theses on Marxism Today — declares break with orthodox Marxism
Related historical events
Marxism and Philosophy and the Recovery of the Hegelian Dialectic
Published in 1923, Marxism and Philosophy is Korsch's masterwork and, alongside Lukács's History and Class Consciousness, the founding text of Western Marxism. Korsch applies the materialist conception of history to Marxism itself, analyzing how Marxist theory came to forget its own relationship to its historical conditions. He argues that the "orthodox" Marxists of the Second International (Kautsky, Mehring, and others) treated Marxism as a "pure science," effectively discarding the dialectical principle that Marx and Engels had rescued from Hegelian idealist philosophy. These orthodox Marxists insisted Marxism had nothing to do with philosophy, and on this point they found unwitting agreement with bourgeois philosophy professors. Against this, Korsch contends that Marxist theory is the "real expression" of the proletarian class struggle and that the dialectical unity of theory and practice is the lifeblood of revolutionary Marxism. The "principle of historical specification" (the methodological insistence that all social categories must be grasped in the specific form they take in a given historical epoch) became the hallmark of Korsch's thought, elaborated more systematically in his Karl Marx (1938). The 1923 book was a radical attempt to reintegrate the history of Marxism into the history of philosophy, and it provoked Zinoviev's public denunciation at the Fifth Comintern Congress in 1924. In the 1930 second edition, Korsch added a fundamental critique of Leninism, sealing his break with Communist orthodoxy. The work deeply influenced the Frankfurt School, Brecht, and Benjamin, and was rediscovered by the New Left in the 1960s.
The 1930 Anti-Critique: Against Lenin's Theory of Reflection
In 1930 Korsch added a long essay to the second edition of Marxism and Philosophy, "The Present State of the Problem of 'Marxism and Philosophy': Also an Anti-Critique". It answered the condemnations the book had received from both the Social Democrats and the Communists in 1924, and German Wikipedia notes that this edition contains a fundamental critique of Leninism.
In the theory of knowledge his target was the theory of reflection set out in Lenin's Materialism and Empirio-criticism. In Korsch's view Lenin understood the passage from Hegel to Marx merely as swapping an idealist world view for a materialist one, and so fell back on the absolute oppositions of "thought" and "being", "spirit" and "matter" that Hegel had already overcome, the dispute of the Enlightenment in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries. He wrote: "Lenin and his followers transfer the dialectic one-sidedly to the object, nature and history, and define knowledge as the mere passive reflection and copying of this objective being in the subjective consciousness."
Indem Lenin und die Seinen die Dialektik einseitig in das Objekt, die Natur und die Geschichte verlegen, und die Erkenntnis als eine bloße, passive Widerspiegelung und Abbildung dieses objektiven Seins in dem subjektiven Bewußtsein bezeichnen
The result, Korsch diagnosed, was that the dialectical relation between being and consciousness collapses, and the relation of theory and practice reverts to an abstract opposition between a pure theory that discovers truths and a pure practice that applies them to reality. He also remarked that narrowing the broad question of the relation between historical being as a whole and the forms of consciousness to the narrow "gnoseological" question of the relation between subject and object of knowledge paid an involuntary tribute to the Kantianism Lenin so fiercely attacked. The case for reflection is treated in the entry "Reflection theory". Pannekoek took aim at the same target in Lenin as Philosopher in 1938.