The Spirit of Utopia
유토피아의 정신
Ernst Bloch's first major work, written in Swiss exile during the First World War and published in 1918; a heavily revised edition followed in 1923. Weaving together an old jug, music, revolution and the apocalypse in one book, it made the unfinished state of the world and of human beings, and the hope that rises from that unfinishedness, into a subject of philosophy. It is the starting point of the utopian philosophy that continues in The Principle of Hope, and its long philosophy of music makes it a source of Bloch's aesthetics.
In depth
Why write about "utopia" in the middle of a war?
Clearing out old belongings, we sometimes find ourselves held by something for no clear reason: an old teapot, a grandmother's jug. It is not that the thing is useful now. It seems to hold something not yet fulfilled, something we have long wished for and do not yet have. Ernst Bloch's first book, The Spirit of Utopia, starts from exactly this sense and moves to a philosophy in which the whole world is still unfinished.
The book was written in the middle of the First World War. While most German intellectuals were enthusiastic about the war, Bloch opposed it firmly from the start and went to Switzerland, where he wrote the book. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy notes that in this he differed radically from most German intellectuals of the time. He broke off his friendship with his teacher Georg Simmel when Simmel enthusiastically backed the German war effort. The historian Arnold Schölzel reports that Bloch wrote Simmel a letter of rupture, remarking that Simmel had never sought a definitive answer to anything and had now found the metaphysical absolute in the German trenches.
According to Schölzel the book was written between 1915 and 1917. In spring 1917 Bloch moved with his wife to Locarno-Monti in Switzerland and finished the manuscript there. It was published in 1918 by Duncker & Humblot in Munich. The encyclopedia attributes the book's general spiritualist mood largely to his first wife, Else von Stritzki, a devout Christian.
What does the book say?
The book has no orderly system. In Schölzel's words it is a "Storm and Stress" book, aimed at Prussia and Austria and polemically at the imperialism of the Entente as well. Bloch saw the war on two levels. One was an entrepreneurs' war set off by competing profit interests; the deeper one was a will to destruction that had become manifest on a new scale. He traced its roots to the Prussian military apparatus and, further back, to the machine culture of the industrial age, which mass-produced will-less people. Against it he searched for traces of a "metaphysics of inwardness" that escapes such grasp, and found them in Expressionist art, in music, in ciphers and symbols.
The starting point of Bloch's philosophy is the experience that a person does not fully know himself. We live this moment but cannot grasp what it is. The encyclopedia notes that Bloch called this the "darkness of the lived moment", and called the situation in which the ultimate metaphysical question cannot even be posed without presupposing an answer "the shape of the inconstruable question". This darkness and feeling of lack is the source of longing for the future.
The early Bloch tried to grasp this dimension of the future mainly from the side of the subject. In The Spirit of Utopia he called it the "soul". That soul is not alone. The book ends by invoking a utopian community; for Bloch the "inconstruable question" was in the end a question about "us". He regarded the state as a hierarchical and violent institution and called for a new form of community, a "fraternal inwardness". Schölzel points out that already in 1917 Bloch did not want utopia reduced to ecstasy and dream, but still lacked a concept of the world as it is and as it ought to be. A socialist economic order could only be a preliminary stage that relieves the misery of human existence; what was needed was a new church that takes on suffering, care and death. That was the book's conclusion.
How do an old jug and ornament become philosophy?
Near its opening the book contains a long contemplation of an old jug. In his aesthetic essays Bloch dwelt on concrete, rich thingness of this kind, which invited comparison with Heidegger; the encyclopedia notes that he was sometimes called a left-wing Heidegger. But what Bloch saw in things was not the origin of Being but a hint of what has not yet come.
In this book he praised applied art and crafts. In his analysis of ornament he set Egyptian art, a dead and merely external form, against Gothic art, in which the human dimension becomes prominent. Things and ornaments hold a tension between the expression of the people who made them and objective form, and that tension is open towards the future. The idea returns when he defends Expressionism in the 1930s: Bloch valued the Expressionist painters' love of carved peasant furniture and glass painting (see "Expressionism debate").
Why is music at the centre of the book?
Bloch studied philosophy at university with physics and music as minor subjects. The Spirit of Utopia contains, as a relatively autonomous part, a "Philosophy of Music", which the encyclopedia describes as Bloch's most extensive work on music. For Bloch music was the art that most directly sounds the "utopian sound" of existence. It is ineffable, essentially incomplete and an inexhaustible source of novelty; in it the future in the past can be heard.
Bloch held that music begins as "singing-to-oneself", a starting point akin to the darkness of the lived moment, and that musical forms unfold out of this darkness a dialectic between human expression and objective form. What music achieves in this book is "self-encounter", which Bloch also described by reference to Expressionist art. In The Principle of Hope this encounter later widens into humanity as a whole encountering itself.
This theory of music also bears the shadow of a joint project with his friend György Lukács. According to the editors' presentation in Aesthetics and Politics, the two lived in Heidelberg from 1912 to 1914 in an intense philosophical partnership. Paradoxically it was Bloch who led Lukács to the serious study of Hegel, and Lukács who directed Bloch towards Christian mysticism, Kierkegaard and Dostoevsky. Even after the war first divided them, Lukács proposed that they write an aesthetics together, with Bloch contributing the part on music. The Spirit of Utopia contains ardent tributes to this friend.
How does it relate to Marxism?
The book is far from a Marxist textbook. The encyclopedia holds that Bloch's commitment to Marxism is visible even in this first book but was never orthodox. The Aesthetics and Politics editors call the book a wild synthesis of religio-apocalyptic and proto-socialist ideas. The encyclopedia notes that the early Bloch spoke a prophetic, performative language and drew heavily on mystical, especially gnostic, traditions while trying to synthesize them with Marxist materialism.
Theodor W. Adorno made a sharp observation on this subject-centred anticipation. According to the encyclopedia, Adorno remarked that Bloch's key argument resembled an ontological proof: the very presence and persistence of utopian anticipation is taken as evidence that the world is pregnant with unrealized possibilities.
Around the time Bloch brought out the 1923 edition, Lukács published History and Class Consciousness. In his review Bloch proposed that Marxist dialectics move from the concept of totality to that of "spheres". This idea of seeing society not as one seamless whole but as a tangle of different times later grew into the theory of "non-simultaneity (Bloch)".
The revised edition and after
In 1923 Bloch published the final version of the book with Paul Cassirer in Berlin. German Wikipedia describes the revision as made "in the sense of a Marxist philosophy". The book entered volume 3 of the collected works in a further revised edition of 1964. An English translation appeared only in 2000.
The book left marks on its contemporaries too. There is scholarship reading Walter Benjamin's "Theological-Political Fragment" as a response to The Spirit of Utopia, so closely did the two exchange ideas on messianism and history. The Aesthetics and Politics editors note that they were friends and that Bloch once sent Benjamin as a personal emissary to Lukács, then living underground in Vienna.
Schölzel sums up the difference between the first book and The Principle of Hope: the first sought to give expression to the utopian, while the later book aimed at an encyclopedia of utopia that starts from "little daydreams" and works systematically through anticipatory consciousness. The cry of the Expressionist years turned into the long research of exile. The theory of art in that research is treated under "Vor-Schein".