Commander of the Red Cossacks and the Soviet 'Red Lawrence' who led the covert 1929 intervention in Afghanistan
In 1929, Primakov crossed the Afghan border as 'Ragib-bey,' a Turkish officer, leading two thousand sabres in Afghan uniform. The West called him the Red Lawrence.
Vitaly Primakov was a Red Army commander who raised the Red Cossacks (Червонное казачество) in Ukraine and led them through fourteen rear raids and sixty victorious engagements in the Civil War, earning three Orders of the Red Banner. In 1929, disguised as the Turkish officer 'Ragib-bey' and dressed in Afghan uniform, he commanded the Soviet military intervention in Afghanistan, an exploit that earned him the Western sobriquet 'the Red Lawrence', and later served as military attaché in both Afghanistan and Japan. Arrested in August 1936, he was tried alongside Mikhail Tukhachevsky in the 'Trotskyist Anti-Soviet Military Organization' case, shot in June 1937, and posthumously rehabilitated in 1957. His third wife was Lilya Brik, Vladimir Mayakovsky's legendary muse.
Also known as: Vitaliy Markovich Primakov · Ragib-bey · Vitmar · Henry Allen
Activities and affiliations
-
1914–
Soviet Communist Party and Bolsheviks
Military command -
1918–1920
Soviet Union state institutionsMilitary and defenceMain
Military command
Career Timeline
- 1914Joined the Bolshevik faction of the RSDLP
- 1915Sentenced to lifelong exile in Siberia for anti-war propaganda
- 1917Freed by the February Revolution; Kiev Bolshevik committee; led assault on the Winter Palace
- 1918–1920Commanded Red Cossacks regiment → brigade → 8th Cavalry Division → 1st Cavalry Corps; three Orders of the Red Banner
- 1924–1925Head of the Higher Cavalry School in Leningrad
- 1925–1926Military advisor to the Chinese First National Army
- 1927–1930Military attaché in Afghanistan and Japan
- 1929Led the Red Army intervention in Afghanistan under the alias Ragib-bey
- 1933–1934Deputy commander, North Caucasus Military District
- 1935–1936Deputy commander, Leningrad Military District; member of the Military Council under the People's Commissar of Defence
- 1936Arrested (14 August)
- 1937Sentenced to death in the Trotskyist Anti-Soviet Military Organization trial; shot (12 June)
- 1957Posthumously rehabilitated (31 January)
Related historical events
- 1917–1921Ukraine’s revolution and warsCommander of the Red Cossack forcesHe raised the Red Cossacks in Ukraine and commanded them in the Civil War.
- 1917.02–07The February RevolutionExile freed by the revolutionThe February Revolution freed him from exile in Siberia.
- 1917.10–1918.01The October RevolutionCommanded the storming of the Winter Palace
- 1918–1922The Civil War and Foreign Interventioncommander of Red Cossacks
- 1937–1938The Great PurgeMilitary command targetFounder of the Red Cossacks and a senior cavalry commander, he was executed in the Tukhachevsky case in 1937.
1914–1917: From Schoolboy Bolshevik to the Storming of the Winter Palace
Vitaly Primakov was born in 1897 in Semyonovka in Chernigov Governorate, the son of the teacher Mark Primakov. He learned to ride and shoot early from his father, a Cossack, and grew up under the strong influence of his grandfather, a descendant of the Zaporozhian Cossacks. Orphaned young, he lived in the household of the Ukrainian writer Mykhailo Kotsiubynsky and later married the writer's daughter Oksana, who died in childbirth in January 1920. Oksana's brother Yuri Kotsiubynsky was a well-known Ukrainian Bolshevik.
At the gymnasium in Chernigov he joined a Bolshevik-led underground students' circle, and in 1914, at sixteen, he joined the Bolshevik faction of the Russian Social Democratic Labour Party, which had split in 1903 into Lenin's Bolsheviks and the Mensheviks. He led an underground workers' circle and agitated among soldiers. In February 1915 he was arrested for anti-war agitation in the Chernigov garrison, distributing leaflets and keeping weapons. Because it was done in wartime and among troops the sentence was severe: exile for life in Eastern Siberia.
Freed from exile by the February Revolution of 1917, he joined the Bolsheviks' Kiev committee and in August was called up into the army. As a delegate from Chernigov Governorate to the Second All-Russian Congress of Soviets he was elected to the All-Russian Central Executive Committee, and during the October Revolution he commanded one of the detachments that stormed the Winter Palace, the former imperial palace in Petrograd where the Provisional Government made its last stand. He then led Red Guard detachments near Gatchina against the troops of General Krasnov, who was trying to retake Petrograd. He was also elected to the Constituent Assembly on the Bolshevik list. Not yet twenty, he had his first experience of military command at the centre of the revolution.
1917–1920: Raising the Red Cossacks
The Cossacks descended from communities of mounted warriors on the southern frontier of the Russian Empire, and in Ukraine the Zaporozhian Cossacks were a symbol of national tradition. Primakov founded a Soviet Ukrainian cavalry force that took up that name, the Red Cossacks (Chervone kozatstvo). It was raised by the government of the Ukrainian People's Republic of Soviets, with its capital in Kharkov, as a counterweight to the so-called Free Cossacks of the Ukrainian People's Republic in Kiev.
Between the end of 1917 and the beginning of 1918 Primakov formed its first regiment in Kharkov from volunteer soldiers, students and workers and from Cossacks who had come over to the Bolsheviks. The regiment first fought the forces of the Central Rada, in the autumn of 1918 took part in building the Ukrainian Soviet Army, and grew into a brigade and then a cavalry division. Throughout the civil war it was filled only with volunteers.
In September 1919 his cavalry division held Chernigov against Denikin's Whites for a month. In November, during the Oryol-Kromy battle, it broke through the front into the White rear, covered 120 versts (about 128 kilometres) of snowbound road in 37 hours, took Lgov, Fatezh and Ponyri, and destroyed the Volunteer Army's rear bases and railway line. The breakthrough earned him his first Order of the Red Banner. His men often passed themselves off as Whites and killed civilians who sympathised with the Whites, which is why the Whites usually took no prisoners from Primakov's units. In October 1920 he became commander of the 1st Cavalry Corps of the Red Cossacks and took part in the assault on Perekop, the gateway to Crimea. Over the civil war he is credited with fourteen raids and sixty battles won.
Behind this fame lay rivalry. In the Soviet-Polish War of 1920 Primakov's men did not support Yakir and Budyonny in their attack on Lvov and headed instead for the Carpathians, Primakov dreaming of lighting "the fire of world revolution on the plains of Hungary." Budyonny also blamed him for the First Cavalry Army's setbacks near Brody. Researchers count the relationship between the First Cavalry Army veterans and "Primakov's men" among the most strained in the Red Army, and the feud would cast a shadow over his fate in the 1930s.
1925–1930: Adviser in China, Secret Expedition into Afghanistan
After the civil war Primakov completed the Red Army's higher command courses and in 1924 and 1925 headed the Higher Cavalry School in Leningrad, where future marshals Zhukov, Rokossovsky, Bagramyan and Yeryomenko were then studying. In 1925 and 1926 he served as military adviser to the First National Army in China, writing its regulations, founding an officers' school and fighting in many of its battles. His account of it, Notes of a Volunteer, was one of the first Soviet books about China. In the party disputes of 1925 to 1927 he supported Trotsky, and later announced publicly that he had broken with the opposition.
Appointed military attaché in Afghanistan in 1927, he led a secret expedition there in 1929. When the reforming king Amanullah Khan was overthrown by a rebellion, the Soviet Union decided to help restore him. It was the first time the USSR had backed with troops not a foreign communist party but a deposed monarch, which went against the principles of Marxism-Leninism, and so the operation was kept strictly secret. The roughly 2,000 men wore Afghan uniforms and the commanders used Asian names; Primakov passed himself off as a Turkish officer, Ragib Bey.
On 15 April 1929, after aircraft attacked an Afghan border post, the detachment crossed the Amu Darya, and on the 22nd it took Mazar-i-Sharif after a bombardment. Afghan losses there are put at about 3,000. The detachment was besieged by levies answering a call to "jihad" from the Islamic scholars, but held out thanks to air supply and reinforcements, and on 12 and 13 May entered Balkh and Tashkurgan. On the 18th Primakov was recalled to Moscow, and when Amanullah Khan abandoned the struggle on the 22nd and fled to India, Stalin withdrew the troops, since staying on would have looked like aggression against a sovereign country. Western writers called him "the Red Lawrence," after T. E. Lawrence, the British officer who took part in the Arab Revolt during the First World War.
On 7 August 1929 he received his third Order of the Red Banner. He described the expedition in Afghanistan on Fire, a book that Afghanistan specialists still rate highly. Posted to Japan as military attaché in 1930, he argued in Across Japan that Japanese military circles might lay claim to Soviet territory and that a conflict between Japan and the United States was inevitable. The same year he married Lilya Brik, Mayakovsky's longtime lover. In 1931 and 1932 he studied at the German General Staff academy.
1936–1937: The First Defendant Arrested in the Tukhachevsky Case
In the 1930s Primakov commanded the 13th Rifle Corps and served as deputy commander of the North Caucasus and then the Leningrad Military District; in 1935 he joined the Military Council under the People's Commissar of Defence and received the rank of corps commander (komkor). Tukhachevsky, who rated him "one of the most talented people," brought him in to help write the 1936 Field Regulations. His relations with the defence commissar, Voroshilov, were bad. Primakov felt unfairly passed over for promotion and criticised Voroshilov as an outdated commander, while Voroshilov despised him and even cited his private life against him. He had already been arrested once, in 1934, and released at Voroshilov's demand.
On 14 August 1936 he was arrested in Leningrad together with Vitovt Putna. At the trial of the "Trotskyist-Zinovievist centre" later that month, the first of the Moscow Trials, the 1936 to 1938 series of public trials at which old Bolshevik leaders were made to confess, the two men were named as members of a "military Trotskyist organisation" in the army. Primakov denied the charges for nine months. The interrogation was cautious at first and later used physical pressure. In May 1937 he finally made a statement admitting that an anti-Soviet military conspiracy existed in the Red Army and named Gamarnik, Dybenko, Sergey Kamenev, Shaposhnikov and others as conspirators. In his statement to Yezhov he wrote that Stalin had said "Primakov is a coward, holding out in a matter like this is cowardice."
On 11 June 1937 he stood before a special session of the USSR Supreme Court together with Tukhachevsky, Yakir, Uborevich and others. Under the decree of 1 December 1934 the hearing was closed, with no defence counsel and no right of appeal, and was over in a day; all the defendants were shot that night. While the other defendants spoke of their loyalty to the revolution and to Stalin and asked for leniency, Primakov, the first of them to be arrested, admitted his "guilt" without reservation in a speech of repentance that left the judges no doubt about the guilt of the whole "group."
On 31 January 1957 the Military Collegium of the USSR Supreme Court acquitted and rehabilitated all the defendants, on evidence that the confessions on which the verdict rested had been obtained by torture and beatings. The Tukhachevsky case became the starting point of the purge that swept through the whole Red Army. Primakov's case shows how the purge worked: the statement of one man who broke after long resistance became grounds for arresting many fellow commanders, and in the end he was a victim of it too.