He opposed October, vouched for Stalin, and was shot by him
In May 1924 Lenin's testament was read to a plenum of the Central Committee. Kamenev read the document; Zinoviev then spoke for Stalin and moved to re-elect him General Secretary by show of hands, which carried with only Trotsky's small group against. The testament was not reported to the congress.
One of Lenin's long-standing companions in exile and the first chairman of the Comintern's executive committee, he was an early face of international communism. Born Ovsei-Gershon Radomyshelsky to a Jewish dairy-farming family in Yelizavetgrad, today Kropyvnytskyi in Ukraine, he opposed the October 1917 rising publicly alongside Kamenev, yet as chairman of the Petrograd Soviet he controlled the party's northern base and became a full Politburo member in March 1921. After Lenin's death he formed a triumvirate with Stalin and Kamenev to isolate Trotsky, but was defeated at the XIV Party Congress in December 1925 and lost the Leningrad Soviet and Comintern posts in 1926. He then joined Trotsky in the United Opposition; in August 1936 the first Moscow trial sentenced him to death and he was shot, and he was rehabilitated in 1988.
Also known as: Yevsei Radomyslsky
Activities and affiliations
-
1901–1903
Russian Social Democratic Labour Party (RSDLP)
Diplomacy and international organization -
1903–1934
Soviet Communist Party and Bolsheviks
Political and party leadership - 1919
Career Timeline
- 1907–1917Lenin’s closest companion of the exile years
- 1917.10With Kamenev, opposes the rising; the leak scandal
- 1919–1926First chairman of the Comintern
- 1923–1925The triumvirate against Trotsky
- 1926–1927The United Opposition; expulsions and recantations
- 1936The first Moscow trial; shot
The Soviet Politburo
- October 1917 Politburo
- Candidate 1919.03–1921.03
- Full member 1921.03–1926.07
1926.07 removed · Executed in 1936
The Central Committee Orgburo
- Member 1923.09–1924.06
1924.06 not re-elected
Related historical events
- 1907–1919The collapse of the Second InternationalZimmerwald Left bureauLed the Zimmerwald Left with Lenin.
- 1912–1913The Balkan WarsInterpreter of the Basel ManifestoStressed that the Basel Manifesto explicitly rejected "defensive war" and "defending the fatherland", calling it "better than Stuttgart".
- 1914–1918First World WarZimmerwald Left spokesmanAt the anti-war Zimmerwald Conference in early September 1915, he spoke for the revolutionary socialist left.
- 1917.02–07The February RevolutionLenin's companionHe returned on the sealed train and, after the July Days, went into hiding with Lenin at Razliv.
- 1917.10–1918.01The October RevolutionDissenting leaderWith Kamenev he publicly opposed the insurrection plan, but remained in the party leadership after the revolution.
- 1917.12–1918.11Brest-Litovsk and Germany’s eastern occupationSupporter of the peaceOn 8 March 1918, he sided with Lenin in the debate over the Brest-Litovsk peace.
- 1918–1922The Civil War and Foreign InterventionChairman of the Comintern and member of the Politburo
- 1918–1923The aftermath of the First World War: peace treaties and the revolutionary waveChairman of the CominternInstructed the KPD in August 1923 to prepare for a revolutionary crisis.
- 1919–1921The founding of the CominternFirst president of the Executive CommitteeDrafted the Twenty-one Conditions and gave the keynote at Baku.
- 1921–1928The New Economic Policy (NEP)New Opposition leaderA member of the ruling triumvirate, from 1925 he led the New Opposition warning of the kulak danger.
- 1923–1927The Succession Struggle and the Left OppositionTriumvirate member; opened the Nov-Dec 1923 party debate in Pravda before turning against TrotskyTriumvirate member who opened the Pravda debate on Nov 7, 1923, but shifted to attacking 'Trotskyism' by Dec 15. Later formed the New Opposition; expelled 1927.
- 1924–1927The first united front, the Northern Expedition and the catastrophe of 1927Leader of the United OppositionWith Trotsky demanded that the Communists leave the Kuomintang and form soviets.
- 1937–1938The Great PurgeTargetAn Old Bolshevik leader sentenced to death at the first Moscow Trial in 1936.
The Exile Years, 1907–1917: Lenin's permanent closest collaborator
At the Fifth Party Congress in London in 1907 Zinoviev was elected a candidate (voting) member of the RSDLP Central Committee with 143 votes and was named to the parallel factional leadership, the 'Bolshevik Center'. Arrested in March 1908 and then released, he was called to Geneva by Lenin in August 1908 and moved to Paris with Kamenev. From then until the Revolution of 1917 he remained 'Lenin's constant aide-de-camp and confidante'.
His party identity in these years was built on emigre editorial and organisational work. In Paris he worked as editor of the Bolshevik factional organ Proletarii, and it was then that the pseudonym 'Zinoviev', wordplay on his wife Zlata Lilina's party name 'Zina', became his main signature. In Switzerland in 1915 he co-wrote with Lenin the pamphlet 'Socialism and War: The Attitude of the RSDLP Towards the War', in which Lenin wrote chapter 1 and parts of 3–4 while Zinoviev wrote all of chapter 2 and parts of 3–4. He also worked on Sotsial-Demokrat, the organ printed in Geneva from November 1914.
Internationalist work belonged to this phase as well. At the anti-war Zimmerwald Conference in early September 1915 Zinoviev was the chief spokesman for the revolutionary socialist 'Zimmerwald Left' and summarised the conference for the Bolshevik press. Afterwards the Zimmerwald Left continued as a loose entity with Lenin, Zinoviev and Karl Radek as a three-person directing body in Bern.
The return of 1917 and the July Days form a phase of their own. Zinoviev travelled with Lenin, Krupskaya and Lilina on the 'sealed train' and arrived in Petrograd on 16 April (n.s.) 1917 as Lenin's 'trusted right-hand man'. During the July Days of 1917, with Lenin briefly away, he played an oversized role steering the party's response, and it was he who delivered the impromptu speech that dispersed the crowd outside the Tauride Palace.
That phase has to be told together with the October dispute. At the closed meeting of the Bolshevik Central Committee on 10 (23) October 1917 Zinoviev and Kamenev voted against Lenin's resolution on armed insurrection as premature, and their open airing of the opposition effectively exposed the Bolsheviks' and Left SRs' intentions to the government. Lenin called their conduct traitorous, but the leadership limited itself to barring them from speaking in the name of the Central Committee rather than expelling them. On 18 (31) October Kamenev published a statement in Gorky's non-party Novaya Zhizn signing for himself and for Zinoviev; Zinoviev declared he had not authorised this, and Lenin demanded the expulsion of both as 'strikebreakers', while the Central Committee on 20 October (2 November) declined to act against them for airing confidential party matters in a non-party publication.
Siding with Lenin on the Brest-Litovsk peace on 8 March 1918 restored him to Lenin's favour and to the Central Committee; on 25 March 1919 he joined the new Politburo as a non-voting member, and from March 1919 he was named chairman of the Comintern's Executive Committee. A post-October thread runs on from the same phase: ten days after the Bolsheviks took power Zinoviev, along with Rykov, Milyutin and Nogin, resigned his Central Committee place over the decision to exclude the Left SRs from the government, and after Lenin's ultimatum only Zinoviev renounced the decision and resumed his seat, effectively ending his revolt. Lenin later recalled this 'October episode' in his testament.
Comintern chairman and the Halle congress of 1920
Zinoviev became chairman of the Executive Committee of the Communist International when it was founded in March 1919, and on 25 March a candidate member of the newly created Politburo. In September 1920 he presided over the Congress of the Peoples of the East in Baku, and the next month he went to the Halle congress of the Independent Social Democratic Party of Germany (USPD), which was to decide whether to join the Comintern on the twenty-one conditions laid down by its Second Congress.
Before that he had written the Executive's reply to the USPD's letter of December 1919. Based on a far sharper draft by Lenin, it reached the USPD leadership through Mikhail Borodin only on 9 April 1920. It denounced the USPD's approach as an attempt to "drag the movement back into the swamp of the yellow Second International" and demanded a "purge" of the leadership and the union of the party's "best elements" with the Communist Party of Germany.
At the congress, which opened in Halle's Volkspark on 12 October 1920, both sides brought prominent guest speakers. For the supporters of affiliation Zinoviev gave a four-hour speech in German; for the opponents Jean Longuet of the French Socialists and the Menshevik Julius Martov spoke. Martov, his health failing, had been allowed to leave Soviet Russia legally in September to attend, and urged the USPD not to join the Comintern, which he denounced as a tool of the Russian state designed to impose Bolshevik methods on the European socialist movement. His speech appeared that year as a pamphlet, "The Problem of the International and the Russian Revolution".
Only the affiliation resolution of Walter Stoecker and Ernst Däumig was put to the vote, and it passed by 236 to 156 with two abstentions. When Arthur Crispien declared that the majority had in effect left the USPD for the Communist Party, the minority walked out. The party split: about 400,000 members of the left merged with the KPD on 4 December to form the United Communist Party of Germany (VKPD), while some 340,000 under Georg Ledebour and Crispien carried on as the USPD.
The United Opposition, 1925–1927 — from Stalin's ally to Trotsky's comrade
After Lenin's death in 1924, Zinoviev formed the 'triumvirate' with Kamenev and Stalin to isolate Trotsky. Zinoviev played a leading role in the 1924 'Literary Discussion,' attacking Trotsky's 'Lessons of October.' He stood with those demanding Trotsky's expulsion from the party.
But victory was short-lived. Once Trotsky was neutralised, Stalin pivoted, allying with Bukharin and Rykov. At the XIV Party Congress in December 1925, Zinoviev, backed by the Leningrad delegation, raised the banner of the 'New Opposition,' demanding inner-party democracy. He was crushed. The following February, in a desperate bid to save his political life, he reached out to his lifelong enemy. Zinoviev and Trotsky exchanged friendly letters, and by summer the 'United Opposition' was formed.
Zinoviev was swiftly removed as chairman of the Leningrad Soviet and head of the Comintern, then expelled from the Politburo in July 1926. In October 1927 he was ejected from the Central Committee; on November 14 he was expelled from the party; on November 28 he was banished from the Society of Old Bolsheviks. Alongside Trotsky, he was now being crushed by the very machine he had helped build.
In early 1928 Zinoviev was exiled to Kaluga. By year's end he capitulated (a public letter to Stalin confessing his 'anti-party errors') and was readmitted to the party. The defeat of the United Opposition was the final gateway to Stalin's one-man dictatorship. Zinoviev's betrayal and humiliation were merely the prologue to the fate awaiting him eight years later.
The First Moscow Show Trial — the Comintern chairman in the dock
In August 1936, sixteen defendants stood in Moscow's Trade Union House. The biggest name was Grigory Zinoviev (Lenin's closest comrade, first chairman of the Comintern, once the face of the Soviet system) now charged as the ringleader of a 'Trotskyite-Zinovievite terrorist centre.'
Prosecutor Vyshinsky pinned the Kirov assassination on Zinoviev's alleged orders. Zinoviev already knew that personal loyalty alone would not save him. Neither letters to Stalin with Kamenev, nor confessions, nor swearing fealty to the party made any difference. What he symbolised was the problem: the Old Bolshevik, Lenin's era, every hesitation of October 1917.
By day two, every defendant had confessed 'guilt' and accepted the demand for the death penalty. In his final statement, Zinoviev declared: 'I curse my fascist, anti-Soviet activity… For the crime of betraying the socialist motherland, I deserve to be shot.'
Within days, all sixteen were executed. The chairman of the Comintern no longer existed.