Ivan Yefimovich Petrov

Иван Ефимович Петров
Soviet Union state institutions Marxism–Leninism Soviet Union Russia 1896.9.30.–1958.4.7. ○ Natural causes

The army general who held Odessa and Sevastopol and came back to the front each time Stalin removed him

As Sevastopol fell, unable to save its garrison, Petrov raised his pistol to take his own life. His officers wrestled the weapon from his grip. Evacuated by submarine, he went back to the front.

A shoemaker's son who trained as a teacher, Ivan Petrov commanded the early defences of Odessa (1941) and Sevastopol (1941–1942). He made his career in the Civil War and in the campaigns against the Basmachi in Central Asia. As commander of the Coastal Army he led the defence of both cities; in 1942–1943 he commanded in the defence of the Caucasus, the liberation of the Taman Peninsula and the Kerch–Eltigen landings. In 1944–1945 he commanded the 2nd Belorussian and then the 4th Ukrainian Front, which crossed the Carpathians, but Stalin removed him several times and once demoted him. He ended the war as chief of staff of the 1st Ukrainian Front in the Berlin and Prague operations and was made a Hero of the Soviet Union.

Activities and affiliations

Career Timeline

Related historical events

Commander of the Coastal Army at Odessa and Sevastopol (1941–1942)

When the war with Germany began, Petrov commanded the 27th Mechanized Corps, then forming in Central Asia. The corps was sent towards Bryansk and disbanded in mid-July, and he took over the 1st Cavalry Division, forming in Odessa. On 20 August he became commander of the 25th Chapayev Rifle Division and defended Odessa, encircled by the Romanian army. Appointed commander of the Coastal Army on 5 October, he directed its evacuation by sea to the Crimea after the Stavka decided to give up the defence of Odessa.

In the Crimea the Coastal Army was pushed back by the German 11th Army and had to cross the mountains and go round by the coast road to reach Sevastopol. When the Sevastopol Defence Region was formed on 4 November, Petrov was at first its commander; soon Filipp Oktyabrsky, commander of the Black Sea Fleet, took over the whole region and Petrov became deputy commander for the land forces and commander of the Coastal Army. The land defence was his. The Coastal Army and the Black Sea Fleet beat off the two assaults of November and December 1941 by Erich von Manstein's German 11th Army.

At the end of December the commander of the superior Transcaucasian Front removed him without consulting Sevastopol's military council and put S. I. Chernyak in his place. Oktyabrsky and the fleet's military council member wired Stalin urgently that "General Petrov is a capable, devoted commander, in no way guilty of anything to be removed for", asking that he be promoted and kept in his post; the removal was cancelled. In January 1942, when the Coastal Army's chief of staff Nikolai Krylov was badly wounded by shellfire and marked for evacuation, Petrov insisted on keeping him in the city.

The third German assault began in June 1942. After the long blockade had all but cut off reinforcements and ammunition, the garrison held for four weeks and broke at the end of June. On 1 July, on the Stavka's order, Petrov left that evening with Krylov and the Coastal Army staff on the submarine Shch-209; command of the remaining garrison passed to the commander of the 109th Rifle Division, Pyotr Novikov. Russian Wikipedia writes that before leaving, tormented at being unable to save the city's defenders, Petrov tried to shoot himself and was stopped by his comrades. Tens of thousands of soldiers left behind were taken prisoner. The evacuation of the command alone is still disputed, and the dispute centres mainly on the defence region's commander Oktyabrsky, who had asked permission to leave.

From the Caucasus to Prague: dismissed and recalled (1942–1945)

Out of Sevastopol, Petrov took command of the 44th Army of the Transcaucasian Front in August 1942 and, from October, of the Black Sea Group of Forces holding the coast, fighting the defensive battle for Tuapse. On 4 January 1943, as the Germans began to withdraw from the North Caucasus, Stalin dictated a directive for the front to Sergei Shtemenko of the General Staff. In it, as Shtemenko records in his memoirs, Stalin said that "Petrov has been on the defensive all the time and has little experience of attacking" and told the front to make him switch to an offensive footing.

Chief of staff of the North Caucasus Front in March 1943 and its commander in May, he retook Novorossiysk and the Taman Peninsula (Taman was cleared on 9 October), and in November directed the Kerch–Eltigen landings across the Kerch Strait. The Eltigen bridgehead was lost, but the one north of Kerch held, and on 20 November the front became the Separate Coastal Army, still under him. Shtemenko, sent there with the Stavka representative Kliment Voroshilov, wrote that Petrov wanted the fleet to carry much of the supply and landing work, while the Black Sea Fleet's commander Lev Vladimirsky treated it as secondary, and they clashed often. When the attacks on the town of Kerch cost heavily for little gain, a Stavka directive of 27 January 1944 condemned the army's attachment to street fighting, and in February a new commander, Andrei Yeryomenko, arrived unannounced on a special train. Petrov was removed and in March demoted to colonel general. Shtemenko wrote that he had prepared the offensive and was not allowed to reap what he had sown.

In April he was given the newly formed 2nd Belorussian Front, only to be removed again in June, just before Operation Bagration. According to Shtemenko, Stalin said that the front's military council member Lev Mekhlis had written to him about Petrov's "softness" and claimed that Petrov was ill and spent too much time with doctors. Shtemenko wrote that "Stalin evidently had some prejudice against Petrov" and recorded that Petrov handed his plan over to his successor Georgy Zakharov without reservation.

On 5 August he came back as commander of the 4th Ukrainian Front, which crossed the Carpathians and freed Transcarpathia and eastern Slovakia; in October he was again made army general. Mekhlis was a member of the military council here too. Georgy Zhukov, visiting the front in September, reported to Stalin that "Petrov works well with Mekhlis and has no complaints about Mekhlis." The Moravská Ostrava offensive opened on 10 March 1945 in a snowstorm and stalled. On 17 March the Stavka rebuked Petrov for not reporting that the troops were unready; the same directive noted that Mekhlis had informed the Central Committee of the shortcomings only after the operation failed. On 25 March Stalin removed him "for an attempt to deceive the Stavka."

A few days later Stalin asked Ivan Konev whether he would take Petrov as chief of staff of the 1st Ukrainian Front, and Konev agreed. In his memoir Forty-Five Konev wrote that Petrov, having brought in his first daily report only at six in the morning, frankly admitted he was not used to operations on such a scale, and that though he had come down from front commander to chief of staff he showed no hint of resentment and set about learning the job. He served as chief of staff through the Berlin and Prague operations and was made a Hero of the Soviet Union on 29 May 1945.

Postwar service in the south and the Ashgabat tragedy

Petrov went south again at the end of the war. From 9 July 1945 he commanded the Turkestan Military District, returning to the region where he had begun his career fighting the Basmachi in the 1920s. In July 1952 he became first deputy chief inspector of the Soviet Army, in April 1953 head of the Main Directorate of Combat and Physical Training of the Ministry of Defence, in March 1955 first deputy commander-in-chief of the Ground Forces, and in January 1956 chief inspector of the Ministry of Defence. From June 1957 he served as chief scientific consultant to a deputy minister of defence. He was a deputy of the USSR Supreme Soviet in its 2nd to 4th convocations (1946-1954).

On the night of 6 October 1948 the Ashgabat earthquake struck. In the disaster his son, Soviet Army Lieutenant-Colonel Yuri Ivanovich Petrov, was shot dead by a looter. A commander who had watched his troops die many times over could not spare himself private loss after the war.

Petrov never completed his memoirs. He died on 7 April 1958 and was buried in Moscow's Novodevichy Cemetery, leaving a first military-historical study of the defence of Sevastopol and, at Konstantin Simonov's request, a short account of his part in the defence of Odessa that was published only after his death. Monuments to him stand in Trubchevsk and Sevastopol, and streets are named for him in Odessa, Sevastopol, Kerch, Tashkent and Trubchevsk.