Frankfurt School's spectral companion, Marxist critic who dissected capitalist culture through the lens of mechanical reproduction
In the "Theses on the Philosophy of History," Benjamin wrote: "There is no document of civilization which is not at the same time a document of barbarism."
Born to a prosperous assimilated Jewish family in Berlin, Walter Benjamin was a singular Marxist cultural critic who intersected deeply with the Frankfurt School yet belonged to no school. Weaving together Jewish mysticism and historical materialism, he analysed the decay of art's "aura" in "The Work of Art in the Age of Its Technological Reproducibility", and in his last text, "On the Concept of History" (1940), challenged the narrative of progress through the "angel of history". In Paris exile he excavated nineteenth-century capitalist culture in the unfinished Arcades Project, and in 1940 he took his own life at Portbou while fleeing.
Activities and affiliations
-
1934–1940
Frankfurt SchoolPaid associate, Institute for Social Research
Scholarship and theory
Career Timeline
- 1919PhD summa cum laude, University of Bern, on 'The Concept of Art Criticism in German Romanticism'
- 1925Withdrew his habilitation thesis "The Origin of German Tragic Drama" from the University of Frankfurt
- 1928Published "One-Way Street" and "The Origin of German Tragic Drama"
- 1933Fled Nazi Germany permanently, exiled to Paris
- 1935–1936Wrote 'The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction,' published in French
- 1940Wrote "On the Concept of History"; took his own life at Portbou on the Spanish border
The Trauerspiel book and the failed habilitation: why did the university turn Benjamin away?
Benjamin studied the German Baroque Trauerspiel (mourning play) of the seventeenth century in order to qualify as a university teacher. In 1923 he gathered some 600 quotations from Baroque dramas in the Berlin State Library, and in 1924 he wrote most of the manuscript while staying on the Italian island of Capri. There he read Lukács's "History and Class Consciousness" at Ernst Bloch's suggestion and met the Latvian Bolshevik theatre director Asja Lācis. In the middle of his Baroque studies he began to turn towards Marxism.
In 1925 he submitted the manuscript to the Philosophy Faculty of the University of Frankfurt as his habilitation thesis. Professor Schultz of German literature found it unsuitable for his department and passed it to aesthetics, where Hans Cornelius rejected it as incomprehensible. Max Horkheimer, who also sat on the panel, joined Cornelius and Schultz in asking Benjamin to withdraw. To spare himself the humiliation of a formal rejection, Benjamin withdrew his application in 1925, and with it his hope of a university career ended. The episode left behind the saying "One cannot habilitate intellect", and afterwards his father refused to go on supporting him financially.
With the university closed to him, Benjamin lived from 1925 to 1933 as an independent intellectual. He wrote reviews and criticism regularly for the Frankfurter Zeitung and Die literarische Welt, and from 1929 also wrote for radio. Over his life he produced some 50 essays, 400 newspaper pieces and 80 radio works. The thesis appeared as a book, The Origin of German Tragic Drama, from Rowohlt in 1928, together with One-Way Street.
Ironically, in 1932–3 that book became the text of a seminar given at the University of Frankfurt by the young lecturer Adorno. In his 1931 inaugural lecture "The Actuality of Philosophy", Adorno took over an idea from the book's prologue without naming the source. Benjamin pointed it out in a letter: "In my place I could not have failed to refer to the Baroque book here. Must I now add: in your place still less so." The book's content is treated under "The Origin of German Tragic Drama".
Ich an meiner Stelle hätte hier den Hinweis auf das Barockbuch nicht unterlassen können. Muss ich nun nicht hinzufügen: ich an Ihrer Stelle noch viel weniger.
Moscow visit and observations of the Revolution, 1926–1927
Benjamin arrived in Moscow on December 6, 1926, and stayed for about two months through the winter. His relationship with Asja Lacis, a Latvian Bolshevik theater worker whom he had met in Capri in 1924, was an important occasion for the visit; he also intended to observe Soviet society firsthand and consider whether to join the Communist Party. His Moscow diary records not only his private relationship with Lacis but also urban living conditions and debates in cultural institutions and literary circles. He visited the headquarters of the proletarian writers’ association and heard discussions about party intervention in literature and theater and the narrowing space for left cultural movements. The diary also notes reports that oppositionists were removed from important posts and that Jews were being removed from middle-level positions amid antisemitism in Ukraine. Benjamin recorded the case of Ernst Toller, whose lecture was canceled and who became unwelcome in Moscow, alongside his observations of the Revolution’s promises and constraints imposed by party and cultural institutions. The diary documents experiences and reports he encountered during the visit, not a final decision on party membership or a systematic judgment of the Soviet system as a whole.
Scholem, Brecht and Adorno: what did three friendships leave in Benjamin's thought?
Three friendships stand out in Benjamin's life: those with Gershom Scholem, Bertolt Brecht and Theodor W. Adorno.
Scholem was a mathematics and philosophy student six years his junior whom Benjamin met at a seminar in Berlin in the summer of 1915. A pacifist, socialist and committed Zionist, he became one of Benjamin's closest friends and most constant correspondents. During the First World War Benjamin told Scholem that, like him, he took the position of the radical opponent of the war Karl Liebknecht. Discussions with Scholem on Judaism and Jewish mysticism led to Benjamin's 1916 essay on language. With this friendship began plans to emigrate to Palestine that dragged on for nearly twenty years, but in 1930 Benjamin set aside his Hebrew plans for good. Scholem hoped Benjamin would renew metaphysics from the sources of Judaism, a hope that Benjamin, developing into an unorthodox Marxist, could not fulfil.
He first met Brecht in Berlin in late autumn 1924, at a meeting arranged by Asja Lācis, but it remained a formal encounter. A close friendship began in June 1929 and lasted until Benjamin's death. Until 1933 the two met often in Berlin, planned a journal together, Krise und Kritik ("Crisis and Criticism"), and in a reading group meant to "demolish Heidegger". From their first year of exile a collection of notes survives for a detective story they tried to write together. Benjamin wrote eleven finished essays and reviews on Brecht and epic theatre, and according to Adorno, Brecht spoke of Benjamin as his best critic. Their exchanges in exile in Denmark and over the artwork essay are treated in the section on the artwork essay and Brecht.
The relationship with Adorno was close but not free of rivalry, and Benjamin's material dependence on the Institute for Social Research in exile made it unequal. Their epistolary dispute is treated in the section "The epistolary dispute with Benjamin" on the "Theodor W. Adorno" card.
The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy sees the interpretation of "On the Concept of History" as also a legacy of these three friendships: Scholem promoted a theological reading, Brecht a materialist one, and Adorno tried to reconcile the two.
Exile in Paris and the Arcades Project: how did the exile in the national library live?
When the Nazis took power, Benjamin left Germany for good in September 1933 and went into exile in Paris. Living in a shabby room, he worked in the Bibliothèque nationale, where he befriended the young émigré photographer Gisèle Freund, who was writing a dissertation on the social history of photography. Hannah Arendt, also living in Paris, helped the almost penniless Benjamin as well.
Money was always short. His income came almost entirely from his former wife and his sister Dora Benjamin, and from the Institute for Social Research, now in New York. From the spring of 1934 the Institute paid him a monthly research stipend of 500 francs, from the end of 1937 transferred directly from New York as 80 US dollars. It was not enough to live on, and despite repeated gifts of money from Gretel Adorno he had to move to ever cheaper hotels. Until 1939 he travelled from his Paris base to the boarding house his former wife ran in Sanremo, Italy, and to Brecht's house at Svendborg in Denmark.
The work that absorbed him most in these years was the Arcades Project, begun in 1927. Taking the shopping arcades, exhibitions, fashion and Baudelaire of nineteenth-century Paris as its threads, it sought to draw the primal history of capitalist modernity, and it remained unfinished. The artwork essay and the Baudelaire studies also grew out of it. Its content is treated under "Arcades Project" and "Dialectical image".
In 1937 he met Georges Bataille, and until 1939 took part in the Collège de Sociologie founded by Bataille, Michel Leiris and Roger Caillois, though he was critical of its aim of fighting fascism with fascism's own means. A lecture on fashion he was to give there could not take place because of the outbreak of war.
The Nazi regime stripped German Jews of their citizenship, and when war broke out the stateless Benjamin was interned for three months with other German refugees in the camp at the Château de Vernuche in Varennes-Vauzelles, near Nevers. Released in November 1939, he returned to Paris and began his last text, "On the Concept of History".
The Work of Art Essay and the Friendship with Brecht
In exile Benjamin stayed several times at Brecht's house in Svendborg, Denmark. In 1934 he wrote "The Author as Producer", an essay largely devoted to the theory of Brecht's epic theatre, reportedly meaning to show it to Brecht when they stayed together at his house that summer. In 1939 he wrote again on epic theatre, defining it by the changed role of the spectator.
In Paris in 1935 he finished the first version of his best-known work, "The Work of Art in the Age of Its Technological Reproducibility". It first appeared in 1936 in Pierre Klossowski's French translation in the journal of the Institute for Social Research, but it was altered in translation and Max Horkheimer imposed drastic cuts. In July 1936, hoping for help from Brecht and Margarete Steffin, he tried to place it in the Moscow exile journal Das Wort, but in 1937 the managing editor Willi Bredel turned it down. The third version, which he revised between 1936 and 1939, is regarded as the last authorized one; it was first published only in 1955.
The heart of the essay lies in the word "aura". Even the most perfect reproduction cannot carry over the fact that the work exists here and now, once only. Benjamin wrote: "What withers in the age of the technological reproducibility of the work of art is its aura."
was im Zeitalter der technischen Reproduzierbarkeit des Kunstwerks verkümmert, das ist seine Aura.
He saw in this change the moment at which art grounded in ritual comes to be grounded in politics, and he closed the essay: "Such is the aestheticization of politics that fascism pursues. Communism answers it with the politicization of art."
So steht es um die Ästhetisierung der Politik, welche der Faschismus betreibt. Der Kommunismus antwortet ihm mit der Politisierung der Kunst.
In a long letter of 18 March 1936 Theodor Adorno objected that Benjamin underrated the technicality of autonomous art, and he criticized Brecht's influence in particular. The student movement of the late 1960s took "the politicization of art" from the essay as a slogan, and since the mid-1980s it has been counted among the founding documents of modern cultural and media theory. The details are covered in "Aura (Benjamin)".
Death at Portbou, 1940: why did Benjamin, having crossed the Pyrenees, not survive?
On 13 June 1940, a day before the German army entered Paris with orders to arrest him at his flat, Benjamin fled the city with his sister to Lourdes. He moved on to Marseille, and in August obtained a travel visa to the United States that Horkheimer had negotiated for him. His plan was to cross Francoist Spain to neutral Portugal and take a ship for America.
In September 1940 he crossed the border with the help of Lisa Fittko, who guided refugees over the Pyrenees by the route from Banyuls-sur-Mer in France past Cerbère to Portbou in Spain; the photographer Henny Gurland and her seventeen-year-old son went with him. On 25 September the party reached the border town of Portbou. But the Franco government had cancelled all transit visas and ordered the police to send such persons back to France. Told they would be returned to France the next day, and fearing he would be handed over to the Nazis, Benjamin took an overdose of morphine tablets that night in the Hotel de Francia.
The official Portbou register records 26 September as the date of death. The main text of the German Wikipedia and its article on Lisa Fittko give the night of 25 to 26 September, while another passage of the same German Wikipedia article gives the night of 26 to 27 September. The most important source, a farewell letter to Adorno, was read and destroyed by his companion Gurland, who later wrote it down again from memory, so both its exact wording and the exact time of death remain open to doubt. He was buried in a common grave in the municipal cemetery along with unidentified refugees and homeless people. Shaken by his death, the Spanish authorities allowed his companions to travel on, and they reached Lisbon safely on 30 September. His colleague Arthur Koestler, also fleeing Europe, attempted suicide with some of Benjamin's morphine but survived.
On hearing of Benjamin's death, Brecht said, as Hannah Arendt reported, that this was "the first real loss Hitler had inflicted on German literature", and he commemorated him in four epitaph poems. At Portbou stands the memorial Passagen, built in 1990–1994 by the Israeli artist Dani Karavan, and since 2007 the route Fittko used has been marked as a historical footpath named the "Chemin Walter Benjamin".