Russian avant-garde
러시아 아방가르드
The collective name for the radical artistic experiments in painting, literature, architecture, theatre and film in Russia and the Soviet Union from the 1910s to the early 1930s. Its leading currents were Futurism, which broke up language in poetry, Malevich's Suprematism, which carried painting to pure geometric form, and Constructivism, which sought to move art into the building of industry and everyday life. Many of its artists embraced the October Revolution as an opportunity for a new art, but it came to an end with the 1932 resolution "On the Restructuring of Literary and Artistic Organizations" and the official adoption of socialist realism, leaving a deep mark on twentieth-century abstract art and design.
In depth
Why did a single black square become an event?
A single black square on a white ground. People seeing this painting in a museum for the first time often say, "I could paint that." But in December 1915, in an exhibition hall in Petrograd, Kazimir Malevich hung the painting high in the corner of the room, in the "red corner" where Russian homes hung icons. Abandoning the centuries-old habit of painting a likeness of something, he put a form that represents nothing in the place of the icon. The Russian avant-garde was a movement that tried in this way to change the very question "what is art?"
В красном углу помещения, где у славян всегда висят иконы, Малевич водрузил «Чёрный квадрат»
"Avant-garde" is originally a French word for the vanguard of an army. The name "Russian avant-garde" is said to have been first used by the artist and critic Alexander Benois in the spring of 1910, when he divided the painters of an exhibition into groups. Because the same people moved between several currents within a short span and moved together while arguing with one another, this entry surveys the whole at a glance; the detailed story of each current is in the entries "Russian Futurism", "Suprematism" and "Constructivism (art)".
What did Futurism break?
On 18 December 1912 the Moscow poets' group Hylaea published the miscellany A Slap in the Face of Public Taste. Its manifesto, signed by David Burliuk, Velimir Khlebnikov, Aleksei Kruchenykh, Vladimir Mayakovsky and others, cried: "Throw Pushkin, Dostoevsky, Tolstoy, et cetera, et cetera overboard from the Steamship of Modernity." They called themselves Cubo-Futurists in the sense of carrying the method of Cubist painting into poetry, and Khlebnikov and Kruchenykh made zaum ("transrational") poetry built from sound rather than meaning.
Бросить Пушкина, Достоевского, Толстого и проч. и проч. с Парохода Современности.
How did Suprematism and Constructivism differ?
At "The Last Futurist Exhibition of Paintings 0,10", held from 19 December 1915 to 17 January 1916, Malevich showed geometric abstract paintings including Black Square and called the approach "Suprematism" (from the Latin supremus, "highest"). He meant to paint the "pure sensation" of colour and form themselves. Malevich, who came to the art school in Vitebsk in 1919, formed UNOVIS (Affirmers of the New Art) in 1920 with El Lissitzky and other students.
Vladimir Tatlin's path was different. He designed an enormous spiral building of glass and steel, the Monument to the Third International, whose model was first shown during the Eighth Congress of Soviets in 1920. In debates at the Institute of Artistic Culture (INKhUK) in Moscow from 1920, Alexander Rodchenko, Varvara Stepanova, the theorist Aleksei Gan and others, having ousted Wassily Kandinsky, who had drawn up the first programme, as "too subjective", formed the First Working Group of Constructivists. In his 1922 book Constructivism Gan declared that the group of constructivists "sets itself the task of the communist expression of material values." The idea was to design objects, buildings and printed matter instead of painting pictures. This dictionary's entry "Production Art" covers the practice that followed.
группа конструктивистов ставит своей задачей коммунистическое выражение материальных ценностей
Where Suprematism, in pursuit of the purity of sensation, took painting into a "world without objects", Constructivism took art into the labour of making real things. The two criticised each other, but they shared a starting point in abandoning the old representation.
What was the revolution for the avant-garde?
Many avant-garde artists took the October Revolution to be the same thing as the revolution in their art. They worked in the fine arts department of the People's Commissariat of Education, made street festivals and propaganda posters, and taught at the Higher Art and Technical Studios (VKhUTEMAS) founded in Moscow in 1920. Leon Trotsky is counted as Constructivism's main early political patron.
Not everyone in the party leadership welcomed this art, however. According to Clara Zetkin's memoir, Lenin said he could not praise new movements such as Expressionism, Futurism and Cubism as the highest expressions of artistic genius: "I do not understand them" (see this dictionary's entry "Narodnost"). The voices demanding an art the working masses could understand and the avant-garde project of changing the masses' very perception were in tension from the start.
Ich kann die Werke des Expressionismus, Futurismus, Kubismus und anderer Ismen nicht als höchste Offenbarungen des künstlerischen Genies preisen. Ich verstehe sie nicht.
Why did it end, and what remained?
With the expulsion of Trotsky and the Left Opposition in the late 1920s, Constructivism began to be regarded with suspicion, and the party gradually leaned toward realist art. The Central Committee resolution "On the Restructuring of Literary and Artistic Organizations" of 23 April 1932 dissolved the independent art groups, and in 1934 socialist realism became the official method. Malevich was arrested by the OGPU in the autumn of 1930 and released that December. From the mid-1930s the avant-garde fell under the stigma of "formalism" (see this dictionary's entry "Anti-Formalism Campaign").
Assessments long divided in two. In the West the Russian avant-garde was often read as an instance of the free spirit of the revolution crushed by the Stalinist system. Soviet Marxist aestheticians such as Mikhail Lifshitz, by contrast, criticised the avant-garde as abandoning the human content of classical art and as connected with currents that worshipped force and destruction (see this dictionary's entry "The Crisis of Ugliness"). Either way, there is little dispute that the Russian avant-garde left a broad influence on twentieth-century abstract art, design, typography, architecture and film.
In the late 1980s an interpretation appeared that overturned this framework itself. In The Total Art of Stalinism (1988) the émigré Soviet philosopher Boris Groys argued that the avant-garde had demanded that art stop depicting the world and start transforming it, that this demand already contained a demand for power, and that the Stalinist regime, making the party leadership into an artist and organising the whole of society as a single work, fulfilled that dream in a form the avant-garde itself had not wanted. He held that it was not Stalin but the Russian Association of Proletarian Writers (RAPP) and the Association of Artists of Revolutionary Russia (AKhRR) that actually finished off the avant-garde, and read socialist realism not as a victory of mass taste but as a project of educated elites who had absorbed the experience of the avant-garde. This "continuity thesis" collided both with the narrative of the avant-garde as a mere victim and with Trotsky's reading, which saw in Stalin-era art the decline of the revolution, and it was also criticised for generalisations that escape empirical validation. The argument and its reception are treated in "The Total Art of Stalinism".
The architectural historian Vladimir Paperny read the same period by another route. In Culture Two, finished in manuscript in 1979 and published in the United States in 1985, he modelled the culture of the 1920s as a horizontal, mobile "Culture One" spreading outward from the centre and the culture of the 1930s to 1950s as a vertical, hierarchical "Culture Two" gathering at the centre and hardening, and held that the two alternate in Russian history. Its emblematic case is the Palace of the Soviets, planned as the tallest building in the world on the site where the Cathedral of Christ the Saviour was blown up in 1931. Paperny too rejected the explanation that "they spoiled it from above" and pointed out the avant-garde's love of power. But he read the 1920s and the 1930s not as the continuation of one project but as the alternation of two cultures running in opposite directions, and Groys criticised him precisely for putting down the specific character of Stalinist culture to a recurring lapse in Russian history. The model is treated in "Culture Two".
Where to read on in this dictionary
The various currents and institutions of the Russian avant-garde are treated in more depth in entries of their own in this dictionary.
- Currents: "Russian Futurism", in which poets broke up language; "Suprematism", of Malevich and UNOVIS; "Constructivism (art)", of Tatlin and Rodchenko; and "Production Art", which proposed to stop painting and make things.
- Institutions: "INKhUK", the institute where Kandinsky's programme and the Constructivists clashed, and "VKhUTEMAS", the school that taught every student a basic course in space, volume, colour and graphics.
- Stage and page: "Biomechanics (Meyerhold)", Meyerhold's training of the actor's body; "Literature of fact", in which the Left Front of the Arts (LEF) put the document in place of the novel; "Montage Theory", of Eisenstein and Vertov; and "Russian formalism", which analysed poetic form.
- State and street: "Lenin's plan of monumental propaganda", which set out to make the streets a place of mass education, and "Proletkult", which sought to build a separate workers' culture.
Read together, these entries show that the revolutionary avant-garde was a movement that went beyond innovation in a single picture to try to reorganise schools and institutes, theatres and newspapers, streets and factories. In the words of the Encyclopedia of the Russian Avant-garde, the revolution gave a "second wind" to the Futurist myth of the art of the future.
Related people
Sources
- Wikipedia (RU)
- Wikipedia (EN)
- Wikipedia (RU)
- Wikipedia (RU)
- Wikipedia (EN)
- Wikipedia (RU)
- Wikipedia (RU)
- Wikipedia (RU)
- Wikipedia (RU)
- Wikipedia (RU)
- Wikipedia (RU)
- Wikipedia (RU)
- projekt-gutenberg.org
- hist.msu.ru
- rusavangard.ru
- rusavangard.ru
- monoskop.org
- newleftreview.org
- Wikipedia (RU)
- books.yandex.ru
- Wikipedia (RU)