Andrei Ivanovich Yeryomenko

Андрей Иванович Ерёменко
Soviet Union state institutions Marxism–Leninism Soviet Union Ukraine 1892.10.14.–1970.11.19. ○ Natural causes

The cavalryman who closed Stalingrad's southern pincer

In August 1941, taking command of the Bryansk Front, Yeryomenko promised Stalin personally: "I will smash that scoundrel Guderian." The promise failed; Guderian encircled Kiev instead.

Born to a poor Ukrainian peasant family, Yeryomenko rose from a conscript in the First World War to Marshal of the Soviet Union. He fought the Civil War in Budyonny's 1st Cavalry Army and survived the purges as a cavalry officer. At Stalingrad he commanded the Southeastern (later Stalingrad) Front, planning the city's defence with Khrushchev and closing the southern pincer of Operation Uranus to trap Paulus's 6th Army. He led no fewer than eight fronts during the war, ending it at the head of the 4th Ukrainian Front, liberating Slovakia and the eastern Czech lands. Made a Marshal in 1955, his battlefield record far outran his political weight. He was also a diarist: despite a ban on wartime journals, he kept one throughout.

Also known as: Andrey Yeremenko

Activities and affiliations

Career Timeline

Related historical events

The Forbidden Wartime Diary: A Commander Who Left a Record

Yeryomenko kept a diary throughout the war. Wartime note-keeping was forbidden, since records falling into enemy hands could have handed over military secrets. He kept the banned diary anyway.

How far these entries stand as a source is disputed. Critics argue the 2013 edition is a mechanical conglomeration of Yeryomenko's writings from different periods and of different character, and that what he could actually write at the front was extremely brief: two or three sentences recording his location, and occasionally whom he met. That the diary was not written from the outset as a war memoir, and that its text rates the author's own role highly, should likewise be weighed. The documents themselves are nonetheless treated as valuable: fragments appeared in the 1990s and the full text was published for the first time in 2013.

His writing beyond the diary was substantial. In spring 1943, while recovering at a sanatorium in Tskhaltubo, he wrote a first draft of his book on Stalingrad. In the 1950s and 1960s he published the memoirs In the Beginning of the War (1965), In the Western Direction (1959) and Years of Retribution (1969), and in them he criticised many commanders with whom he had served. His books stand among the early examples of the wave of Soviet marshal memoirs.

Another document belongs to this record. He offered Khrushchev his own candidacy to deliver the report denouncing Stalin's cult of personality at the 20th Party Congress, and on 24 February 1956, after studying the draft, he sent Khrushchev a letter setting out his views. It described how Stalin first berated him for proposing that the Stalingrad and Southeastern Fronts be merged, then merged them soon afterwards, and it criticised Stalin's unadopted plan for defeating Manstein.

The diary and the books show how he wanted to be remembered. They also show, in a case as contested as Stalingrad, how a participant's own record becomes a historical source, and how far it can be trusted.

What is documented: the wartime ban on note-keeping; the partial publication in the 1990s and full publication in 2013; and the contents of the letter of 24 February 1956. What remains interpretation: scholarly assessments of how the 2013 volume was assembled and how much he actually wrote during the war.

From Stalingrad to Crimea and the Baltic

On 5 August 1942 the Stavka split the Stalingrad Front, whose line had stretched to 800 km, and formed the Southeastern Front from its southern armies, the 64th, 57th and 51st among them, under Yeryomenko, with Khrushchev as member of the Military Council. According to Vasilevsky the split made air operations and the city's defence measures harder to manage, so on 13 August the Stavka placed the Stalingrad Front under Yeryomenko as well. On 28 September the Southeastern Front was renamed the Stalingrad Front and the old Stalingrad Front became the Don Front. Russian Wikipedia notes that during the defensive battle his command was repeatedly and sharply criticised by Stalin and Vasilevsky.

Accounts differ on who first proposed the counteroffensive. Vasilevsky writes in his memoirs that the decision was taken in mid-September after an exchange of views between Stalin, Zhukov and himself, and the chapter's subheading calls the counteroffensive plan "the result of collective work". Russian Wikipedia's article on the Battle of Stalingrad says that on 6 October Yeryomenko proposed to Stalin an encirclement by blows against both Romanian-held flanks meeting at Kalach-na-Donu, and that the Stavka judged it unworkable; its article on Operation Uranus dates the decision in principle to a meeting of Stalin with Zhukov and Vasilevsky on 13 September and credits the concept to Colonel M. M. Potapov of the General Staff's Main Operations Directorate.

The Stalingrad Front attacked from the south on 20 November and on the 23rd met the Southwestern Front near Kalach, closing the ring. In December, to stop Manstein's relief force, Malinovsky's 2nd Guards Army was transferred to his front at Vasilevsky's request. When the method of attack was discussed on the 23rd, Yeryomenko insisted on massing even the mechanised corps in the frontal attack from the north, and Vasilevsky gave way after Stalin advised him not to press his own view. In his 1961 book Stalingrad Yeryomenko wrote that a plan sent by Vasilevsky did not fit the situation and that he replaced it with his own. Vasilevsky replied that he had sent no such plan, accusing Yeryomenko of "attributing to me some mythical operational plan", and Malinovsky confirmed Vasilevsky's account.

Operation Ring, which finished off the encircled Germans in January 1943, was left to Rokossovsky's Don Front and the Stavka representative Nikolai Voronov. The Stalingrad Front, renamed the Southern Front on 1 January, advanced towards Rostov. According to Russian Wikipedia Yeryomenko took the decision very hard, having hoped to command the destruction of the 6th Army, and on 2 February he was relieved on grounds of health. Of the battle as a whole Vasilevsky wrote that Vatutin, Yeryomenko and Rokossovsky "coped splendidly with their complex tasks".

After commanding the Kalinin Front (the 1st Baltic from October) from April 1943, in February 1944 he took over the Separate Coastal Army on the Kerch bridgehead. In the Crimean offensive the army attacked on the night of 10 April, freed Kerch by the morning of the 11th and pushed on through Feodosia along the southern coast. When Vasilevsky proposed placing the army under the 4th Ukrainian Front, Stalin said he meant to send Yeryomenko to the 2nd Baltic Front, and the order came on 16 April.

In July 1944, as Operation Bagration spread north, the Stavka on 10 July also gave Vasilevsky the coordination of the 2nd Baltic Front. On the night of 14 July, when Stalin rebuked him for the front's slow advance, Vasilevsky passed the rebuke on to Yeryomenko and worked out remedies with him. The Rezekne-Dvinsk operation earned Yeryomenko the title Hero of the Soviet Union. In the autumn offensive on Riga his front fought hard with heavy losses, and it freed Riga only after Bagramyan's 1st Baltic Front reached the sea to the south and shut Army Group North in Courland.