The founding of the Comintern
How did the Communist International, founded for world revolution, split European socialism in two and become an organisation centred on Moscow?
In March 1919 the Bolsheviks, believing world revolution imminent, founded the Communist International (Comintern) in Moscow. Its Second Congress in 1920 adopted the Twenty-one Conditions and the national and colonial theses, and the socialist parties of Germany, France and Italy split over joining, giving birth to communist parties. After the failed March Action of 1921 the Comintern turned to “To the masses!” and the united front.
The call for a new International
Lenin saw the socialist parties’ votes for war credits in August 1914 as a “sheer betrayal of socialism” and from that autumn declared the Second International dead and called for a Third. During the war anti-war socialists regrouped at Zimmerwald in 1915 and Kienthal in 1916. At Zimmerwald a pacifist majority seeking an immediate peace without annexations or indemnities parted from Lenin’s left minority, which wanted to turn the imperialist war into a revolutionary civil war. Lenin’s position gained ground at Kienthal, and this Zimmerwald Left laid the ideological foundations of the new International. 1
The Bolsheviks came from a tradition unlike that of the Western mass parties. Western socialist parties spoke of revolution in their programmes while in practice pursuing gradual reform through parliaments and trade unions; Russian revolutionaries had worked underground in small, disciplined groups of professional revolutionaries. For Lenin the October Revolution of 1917 was the first act of a world revolution, and for European workers to follow they needed a new organisation purged of reformist “traitors”. 1
When the monarchies fell in Germany and Austria in autumn 1918 and councils took power, the Bolsheviks believed world revolution imminent. On 21 January 1919 about a dozen communists in Moscow decided to hold a congress, and Trotsky wrote the invitation. Sent by wireless on 24 January, it diagnosed the Second International as split into three groups — the avowed social-patriots, a wavering “centre” whose chief theoretician was Kautsky, and the revolutionary left — and named thirty-nine parties and groups that should attend, among them the left of the American Socialist Party (the tendency of Debs), the socialist groups of Tokyo and Yokohama (Sen Katayama) and the Socialist Youth International (Münzenberg). 1 2 28
The haste had a reason in Bern. There, from 3 to 9 February 1919, reformist socialists met to revive the Second International. The Swede Hjalmar Branting moved a resolution supporting bourgeois democracy and arguing that the dictatorship of the proletariat could not lead to socialism, while Kautsky and Bernstein urged the conference to condemn the Bolshevik seizure of power. Friedrich Adler and Jean Longuet countered that information was lacking and proposed sending a commission to Russia before taking a stand; it never went. Opponents called the Bern body the “Yellow International”. 27 1
The founding congress of March 1919
The congress was first set for 15 February and then, because of transport difficulties, postponed to 2 March. Under the Allied blockade hardly any organisation received the call in time: of some two dozen messengers sent out, only three or four arrived in time, and Fritz Platten of Switzerland and Karl Steinhardt of Austria were arrested in transit and briefly jailed. Only two parties managed to send credentialed delegates to Moscow for the opening. 2
The congress opened on 2 March in a small hall of the Courts of Justice in the Kremlin, a long, narrow room barely large enough for a hundred people, with the delegates on flimsy chairs at small tables. Over six days fifty-one delegates registered for thirty-five organisations in twenty-two countries, but only nine had broken through the blockade from abroad; the rest already lived in Soviet Russia. Boris Reinstein, seated for the American Socialist Labor Party, had never been authorised by it, and the party later repudiated him; the only Briton was Joseph Fineberg, who had come to Russia on his own in 1918. 2 29
Votes were weighted by a party’s importance. The Russian Communist Party (Lenin, Trotsky, Zinoviev, Stalin, Bukharin, Chicherin), the German Communist Party and the American Socialist Labor Party had five each; the communists of Austria, Hungary, Sweden, Norway, Switzerland, the Balkan federation, Poland, Finland and Ukraine three each. Delegates from outside Europe were surprisingly numerous: the “United Group of the Eastern Peoples of Russia”, Armenia, Turkestan, Turkey, Persia, China and Korea made up a quarter of all delegates. Of the forty-three whose ages are known, twenty-four were in their thirties — younger than at earlier socialist gatherings. 2 29
Given who was present, the delegates first decided to sit as a preparatory conference rather than a founding congress. Hugo Eberlein, the German Communist Party’s delegate, came mandated to oppose immediate founding, reflecting Luxemburg’s fear that a premature International would be dominated by the Bolsheviks. But on 4 March the Austrian, Swedish, Balkan and Hungarian delegates moved to found the International. Their motion argued that with the old opportunist International being recreated at Bern a sharp line had to be drawn between revolutionary elements and “social-traitors”, and that if the Moscow meeting did not found the International it would be concluded that the communist parties were not in accord. The congress voted overwhelmingly, with Eberlein abstaining, to found the Third International. Platten sat on the presidium. 2 30 1 3 4
The congress’s principal document was Trotsky’s “Manifesto to the Proletariat of the Entire World”, which put forward soviets as the instrument of working-class unity, dismissed “bourgeois democracy” and reaffirmed the dictatorship of the proletariat. The platform adopted with it called the present the period of the decomposition and collapse of the entire world capitalist system and named the socialisation of large-scale industry and the banks as the task of the day; a resolution by Kollontai on the role of working women was also adopted. Formal statutes were left to the following year, and an Executive Committee was elected with Grigory Zinoviev as president. Places were provided for foreign parties, but the prestige of the Russian Revolution and the weakness of the foreign parties left the Bolsheviks in charge. 1 5 6
Soon after the founding, Béla Kun’s Soviet Republic was proclaimed in Hungary on 21 March and a Bavarian Soviet Republic in April, but neither survived the summer. When Kautsky argued in The Dictatorship of the Proletariat that a revolution in backward Russia could only end in a terroristic dictatorship, Lenin replied in The Proletarian Revolution and the Renegade Kautsky that “proletarian democracy is a million times more democratic than any bourgeois democracy”. Luxemburg, too, had warned from a revolutionary standpoint that the Bolsheviks’ centralist model would lead to a bureaucratic dictatorship over the proletariat rather than of it. 7 1
The Second Congress and the Twenty-one Conditions
In “Left-Wing” Communism: An Infantile Disorder (April 1920) Lenin wrote that certain “fundamental features” of the Russian Revolution had international significance, and criticised Western left communists who refused to work in parliaments and reformist unions. On 14 June the Executive called a Second Congress in Moscow a month later. Under the blockade the only legal route ran through the Estonian port of Revel (Tallinn); delegates used false passports or stowed away on ships, and three French delegates drowned when the small fishing boat on which they tried to run the blockade from Murmansk went down in a storm. 8 9 31
The congress opened in Petrograd on 19 July with Lenin’s keynote address. Delegates marched with thousands of workers, and in front of the former stock exchange a cast of three thousand performed the open-air pageant “Spectacle of the Two Worlds”. The working sessions met in the Moscow Kremlin from 23 July to 7 August. The official record lists 218 delegates, 54 of them from socialist, social-democratic and other non-communist parties. Unlike in 1919, mass parties sent delegations — the German Independent Social Democrats (USPD), the French Socialist Party (SFIO) and the Czechoslovak Social Democrats — while the Ukrainian Communist Party, formed in January 1920, was refused admission. The congress met as the Red Army advanced on Warsaw. 31 1 10
The official languages were English, French, German and Russian; voting delegates held red cards and consultative delegates blue ones. A delegation’s votes reflected its party’s importance to the international movement rather than its membership. The British historian E. H. Carr called the congress “the crowning moment in the history of the Comintern”, when the Russian revolution seemed about to become a European one, and observed that the Russian delegation, which “invariably spoke with a united voice” against divided foreign delegations, placed Russian leadership on an impregnable basis. 31
The congress adopted the “Twenty-one Conditions” for admission, which grew out of a 19-point draft Lenin wrote in July and were expanded to twenty-one in the debate. Parties had to remove reformists and centrists from every responsible post, combine legal and illegal work, break completely with figures such as Kautsky and MacDonald, form communist cells in the unions, adopt democratic centralism with iron discipline, support every Soviet republic unconditionally and call themselves “Communist Party”. Point sixteen made the decisions of congresses and the Executive binding on all parties. The congress also ratified statutes that made the world congress the supreme body. 11 12 13 1
In the debate Zinoviev insisted that the Comintern was no “public house” to drop into. He told how the Italian Modigliani had urged Longuet to join because “it does not place us under any obligation — all that has to be done is to send the Executive a postcard once a fortnight”, and reported that the commission had replaced “Turati, Modigliani and others” with a reformist named from each country: “Turati, Modigliani, Kautsky, Hilferding, Longuet, MacDonald, Hillquit”. The USPD delegates Crispien and Dittmann defended their party, and Serrati of the Italian Socialist Party opposed expelling its reformists. The theses on the conditions were adopted on 6 August with three votes against and one abstention, Serrati voting against. 32 33 13
The trade-union question was fiercely argued too. Delegates of the British shop stewards’ movement and syndicalists from Germany and the United States wanted to destroy the reformist unions and found revolutionary ones, but Lenin answered that the 25 million workers in the unions of the Amsterdam International had already made their organisational choice and communists must work inside them. Willie Gallacher and Sylvia Pankhurst opposed the advice that British communists affiliate to the Labour Party. The majority followed Lenin. 31 33
The colonial theses and the Baku Congress of the Peoples of the East
The Second Congress was the first to take up seriously the liberation movements of the colonies of Asia, Africa and the Americas. In his report of 25 July Lenin said that of the world’s 1,750 million people about 1,250 million — some seventy per cent — belonged to oppressed nations, colonies, semi-colonies such as Persia, Turkey and China, or countries made dependent by the peace treaties. The theses started from a world divided into a few oppressor nations and many oppressed ones, and from a post-war state system shaped by the struggle of the imperialist powers against Soviet Russia. 34 31
The sharpest issue was whether to support the “bourgeois-democratic movement” in backward countries. In his supplementary theses the Indian M. N. Roy argued that two movements were growing apart in the colonies — a bourgeois nationalist movement seeking political liberation while preserving the capitalist order, and the struggle of propertyless peasants against every kind of exploitation — and that the Comintern must fight the first one’s control over the second. After debate the commission replaced “bourgeois-democratic” with “national-revolutionary” almost throughout the theses: communists would support colonial liberation movements only when they were genuinely revolutionary and did not obstruct the revolutionary organisation of the peasantry. 34 14 15
The Dutch communist Maring (Henk Sneevliet) served as the commission’s secretary, and Avetis Sultan-Zade of Persia and Pak Chin-sun of Korea took part in the debate. The congress adopted the theses unanimously with three abstentions, though the Bolsheviks did not apply these principles to the non-Russian territories then under their own control. 31 42
Straight after the congress the Comintern convened the Congress of the Peoples of the East in Baku. The call told its readers that as they had once crossed deserts to reach the holy places, they should now cross mountains and rivers to meet and discuss how to free themselves from the chains of servitude. The British government tried to block the route to oil-rich Baku, and two delegates were killed when British warplanes attacked a ship coming from Iran. When the congress opened on 1 September, 1,891 delegates were present. Some 1,273 registered as communists, but most were anti-colonial fighters and sympathisers rather than seasoned Marxists. By nationality the largest groups were 235 Turks, 192 Persians, 157 Armenians, 104 Russians and 100 Georgians; 55 delegates were women. 16 35
In his opening speech Zinoviev called the gathering the “second half” of the Second Congress and summoned the peoples of the East to “a real holy war” against the British and French capitalists; the delegates rose, brandishing their weapons, and shouted “We swear it.” But when a statement by Enver Pasha, one of those chiefly responsible for the Armenian genocide of 1915, was read, the hall was in uproar, and tension between Muslims and non-Muslims, Armenians and Turks ran through the congress. It adopted a Manifesto of the Peoples of the East and set up a Council of Propaganda and Action, but its effect was more symbolic than practical. 36 16
Halle, Tours, Livorno: the split of European socialism
The Twenty-one Conditions were meant to split the rank and file of Europe’s socialist parties from their “opportunist” leaders. The congress required parties wishing to join to hold an extraordinary congress within four months to discuss them. At Halle in October 1920 the German Independent Social Democrats (USPD) voted 236 to 156 to join the Comintern and broke in two; the left merged with the KPD into a united Communist party that December, while the right returned to the SPD in 1922. 17 11 42
At the congress of the French Socialist Party (SFIO) in Tours on 25–30 December 1920 three currents faced each other. The majority under Fernand Loriot, Boris Souvarine, Ludovic-Oscar Frossard and Marcel Cachin wanted to accept the conditions and join; a second current proposed joining on conditions and finally allied with the third; the third, led by Léon Blum and most of the elected deputies, rejected the conditions outright. The majority voted 3,208 to 1,022 to join, founding the French Section of the Communist International, which became the French Communist Party in 1921, and took with it L’Humanité, the paper Jaurès had founded in 1904. Blum stayed in the SFIO with the minority, declaring that “someone has to stay and keep the old house”. The next year the CGT union confederation split too, giving rise to the communist CGTU. The young Nguyen Ai Quoc (Ho Chi Minh) spoke at the congress against the exploitation of the French colonies and for joining. 18 19
The Italian Socialist Party’s Livorno congress of 15–21 January 1921 refused to expel the reformists as the Twenty-one Conditions required; its leader Giacinto Menotti Serrati chose party unity. The left under Amadeo Bordiga and Antonio Gramsci of Turin’s L’Ordine Nuovo walked out on 21 January to found the Communist Party of Italy. Paul Levi, chairman of the German United Communist Party, attended Livorno for his party and on his return defended Serrati’s side. When on 24 February the party’s Central Committee condemned Serrati and welcomed the new Italian party, Levi, Clara Zetkin, Ernst Däumig and two others resigned from it. 20 21 38
Not every party split. In autumn 1920 the Spanish Socialist Workers’ Party (PSOE) sent Fernando de los Ríos and Daniel Anguiano to Moscow; when de los Ríos asked about personal freedom and the length of the dictatorship of the proletariat, Lenin is said to have answered, “Freedom, what for?” De los Ríos insisted that the party must be free to pick among the conditions and remain wholly independent of Moscow, and in April 1921 an extraordinary congress rejected the Twenty-one Conditions. The Comintern’s supporters left to form the Spanish Communist Workers’ Party, which later merged with the Spanish Communist Party. 11
The Two-and-a-Half International: the Vienna Union
Parties that would neither accept the Twenty-one Conditions nor return to the reformist International of Bern founded the International Working Union of Socialist Parties in Vienna on 27 February 1921. Ten parties joined, among them the rump USPD, the SFIO, the British Independent Labour Party and the Swiss and Austrian Social Democrats; the Spanish Socialists followed in April, and the Maximalists of the Italian Socialist Party also joined. Its secretary was the Austrian Friedrich Adler, and Otto Bauer and Julius Martov were leading figures. Communists derided it as the “Two-and-a-Half International”, caught between the Second and the Third. 37 40
The Vienna Union criticised both Internationals as dogmatic, urged more attention to each country’s particular situation, and worked for their unification. A conference of the three Internationals met in Berlin on 2–5 April 1922, but the communists under Radek denounced the “social patriots”, who in turn condemned the persecution of the Socialist Revolutionaries and Mensheviks in Russia and the Soviet invasion of the social-democratic republic of Georgia. A Committee of Nine, three from each International, met only once, in May, and achieved nothing, and the Comintern soon withdrew. In May 1923 in Hamburg the Vienna Union merged with the Bern International to form the Labour and Socialist International. 37 1
The March Action and “To the masses!”
The Halle–Merseburg district of Prussian Saxony, an area of lignite mines and chemical works, was where the Communists had become the largest party with almost thirty per cent of the vote in the Prussian elections of February 1921. On 19 March the provincial president Otto Hörsing sent police into Mansfeld and Eisleben to restore order. The leadership of the United Communist Party hoped the workers would rise spontaneously against the state’s intervention and called for action in its paper Die Rote Fahne, but the workers were at first cautious, and despite the call for a general strike on 21 March most outside Mansfeld kept working. 22
With the arrival of Max Hoelz of the Communist Workers’ Party (KAPD) the strike escalated into armed insurrection: he armed strikers and unemployed miners and led arson, looting, bank robberies and bombings. On 24 March President Ebert declared a state of emergency for Hamburg and the province of Saxony under Article 48 of the Weimar Constitution; the same day the Communists proclaimed a national general strike, which found only scattered support. At the Leuna works, where half the workforce belonged to the KAPD-aligned union, workers even fielded a home-made armoured car, and government troops retook the plant only with artillery. On 1 April the last band under Hoelz was broken up and the party withdrew its strike call; the “March Action” ended in defeat, with over a hundred dead and more than three thousand arrested. 22
In a letter to Zetkin and Levi of 16 April Lenin wrote that he readily believed the Executive’s representative had defended “silly tactics, which were too much to the left — to take immediate action ‘to help the Russians’”; the representative was Béla Kun, a member of the Executive’s presidium. Levi, who had resigned the chairmanship in February, attacked the party’s tactics in early April in his pamphlet Our Path: Against Putschism. The Central Committee expelled him for breach of discipline on 15 April, and the Executive endorsed the expulsion on 29 April. 38 23
The Third Congress met in Moscow from 22 June to 12 July 1921, after the New Economic Policy had begun and the German revolution had failed. Its resolution on Germany called the March Action “the heroic struggle of hundreds of thousands of proletarians”, forced on the party by the government’s attack, and “a step forward”, yet named as the gravest error the failure to stress the defensive character of the struggle and the presentation of the offensive as the party’s main method. Lenin told the congress that anyone who, like Levi, came out against a struggle of hundreds of thousands should be expelled, but admitted that the “theory of the offensive” as applied to the March Action was incorrect. Against Terracini of Italy and others who wanted the word “majority” deleted, he insisted that no communist party had yet won the majority of the working class, and defended as a model political step the “Open Letter” of January 1921 in which the United Communist Party had proposed joint struggle to the other workers’ organisations. 24 39 41 40
As the revolutionary wave in Europe subsided, Lenin concluded that proletarian revolution was no longer on the immediate agenda. The slogan of the Third Congress was “To the masses!”, and on 18 December the Executive issued theses on the “united workers’ front” — joint defensive struggles with socialist rank-and-file against the capitalist offensive. Amid world economic crisis and unemployment, the theses found an “irrepressible” urge to unity among workers, and defined the united front as the unity of all workers willing to fight capitalism, including those who still followed the anarchists and syndicalists. Temporary agreements with reformist leaders were allowed, but the weight lay on unity “from below”. The Red International of Labour Unions (Profintern), to co-ordinate communist work in the unions, was founded on 3 July 1921. 1 24 41 25 26
Moscow’s authority and its price
The statutes made the world congress the supreme body and the Executive the leading body between congresses, but point 8 laid down that the Executive’s work fell mainly to the party of the host country, the Russian Communist Party, which had five voting representatives to one for each other major party. The Third and Fourth Congresses created a Presidium, Secretariat, Organisational Bureau and International Control Commission modelled on the Russian party’s organs, and the Comintern began sending “agents” and “emissaries” to intervene in national parties. From 1921 the International Liaison Department funded foreign parties and clandestine work from the Soviet treasury, making the parties economically dependent on Moscow as well. 1 6
The interests of the revolutionary organisation and of the Soviet state also began to diverge. The united front was bound up with the New Economic Policy and the search for trade with capitalist countries, and the Treaty of Rapallo between Germany and Soviet Russia in April 1922 exposed the tension between the Comintern’s revolutionary aims and the interests of the state. The left wings of the French and Italian parties found it hard to accept a united front with the “social chauvinists”. 1
Even so, the Comintern of Lenin’s time left room for debate that later vanished. Leaders such as Levi and Bordiga were not docile, and national parties resisted or reinterpreted Moscow’s directives. As Carr put it, the Communist International that was to make the world revolution was created in the image of the party that had made the Russian revolution. The founding of the Comintern institutionalised the split of the international labour movement between communism and social democracy, a split that lasted through the twentieth century. 1 31
Consequences
Communist parties were founded as Comintern sections, institutionalising the split of the international labour movement between communism and social democracy. The colonial theses and the Baku congress became a starting point for communism in Asia. The Russian party’s dominance and Moscow’s funding steadily narrowed the national parties’ autonomy.
Timeline & Map
- 1919.01.24Letter of invitation
Trotsky’s invitation to the founding congress of a new International went out from Moscow by wireless.
- 11919.02.03–
09 Bern socialist conferenceReformist socialists met in Bern to revive the Second International.
- 21919.03.02Founding congress opens
The founding congress opened in the Kremlin.
- 1919.03.04Third International founded
The congress voted to found the Third International and set up an Executive under Zinoviev.
- 31919.03.21Hungarian Soviet Republic
Béla Kun’s council government took power in Budapest.
- 1920.04“Left-Wing” Communism
Lenin published his critique of the Western left communists.
- 41920.07.19–
08.07 Second Congress opensThe Second Congress opened in Petrograd and moved to Moscow from 23 July.
- 1920.07.28Theses on the national and colonial questions
The congress adopted Lenin’s theses and Roy’s supplementary theses.
- 1920.08.06Twenty-one Conditions adopted
The congress adopted the conditions of admission with three votes against and one abstention; Serrati voted against.
- 51920.09.01–
08 Baku Congress of the Peoples of the EastSome 1,891 delegates from across the East met in Baku, and Zinoviev called for a “holy war” against British imperialism.
- 61920.10Halle congress
The German Independent Social Democrats (USPD) voted 236 to 156 to join the Comintern and split.
- 71920.12.25–
30 Tours congressA majority of the SFIO voted 3,208 to 1,022 to join, creating the French Communist Party; Blum stayed with the minority.
- 81921.01.21Communist Party of Italy founded
When the Italian Socialist majority refused to expel the reformists, the left under Bordiga and Gramsci founded the Communist Party of Italy.
- 91921.02.27Vienna Union founded
Ten parties including the rump USPD and the SFIO founded the International Working Union of Socialist Parties in Vienna.
- 101921.03.19–
04.01 March ActionThe United Communist Party called for a rising, which was crushed by 1 April.
- 1921.04.15Levi expelled
Paul Levi, who had publicly attacked the March Action, was expelled from the United Communist Party.
- 111921.06.22–
07.12 Third CongressThe Third Congress met in Moscow under the slogan “To the masses!”.
- 1921.07.03Profintern founded
The Red International of Labour Unions (Profintern) was founded in Moscow.
- 1921.12.18United front theses
The Executive adopted the tactic of the united workers’ front.
Related people 46
Leadership5
Called for the Third International and guided the Twenty-one Conditions and the colonial theses.
First president of the Executive CommitteeGrigory Zinoviev1883–1936Drafted the Twenty-one Conditions and gave the keynote at Baku.
Author of the founding manifestoLeon Trotsky1879–1940Wrote the Manifesto to the Proletariat of the Entire World.
Organizer who presided over the Comintern's foundingYakov Sverdlov1885–1919He presided over the founding of the Comintern.
Leader of the USPD left’s Comintern affiliationErnst Friedrich Däumig1866–1922In 1920, he led the USPD left into the Communist International.
Participants30
Took part in the founding and early congresses for the Bolsheviks.
Secretary of the ExecutiveKarl Radek1885–1939Was in a German prison during the founding congress and after his release served as secretary of the Executive in 1920.
First secretary of the ExecutiveAngelica Balabanova1878–1965Served as the Executive’s first secretary after the founding and left in 1921.
Balkan Revolutionary Federation delegateChristian Rakovsky1873–1941Attended the founding congress for the Balkan communists.
German Communist Party delegateHugo Eberlein1887–1941Conveyed Luxemburg’s misgivings and abstained on the founding vote.
Swiss communist, founding presidiumFritz Platten1883–1942Sat on the founding congress presidium.
Leader of the Hungarian Soviet RepublicBéla Kun1886–1938Founded the Hungarian Soviet Republic just after the founding.
Supplementary colonial thesesManabendra Nath Roy1887–1954Debated the colonial question with Lenin at the Second Congress.
American communistJohn Reed1887–1920Attended the Second Congress, went to Baku and died in Moscow in 1920.
KPD chairmanPaul Levi1883–1930Publicly criticised the March Action and was expelled.
KPD leadershipClara Zetkin1857–1933Shared Levi’s criticism of the March Action but stayed in the party.
Leader of the pro-Comintern majority at ToursMarcel Cachin1869–1958Led the SFIO majority into founding the French Communist Party.
SFIO general secretary, first PCF secretaryLudovic-Oscar Frossard1889–1946Led the Tours majority but left the party in 1923.
Pro-Comintern leader at ToursBoris Souvarine1895–1984Led the pro-Comintern faction and later sat on the Executive.
Italian Socialist leaderGiacinto Menotti Serrati1872–1926Refused to expel the reformists, causing the Livorno split.
Profintern leaderSolomon Lozovsky1878–1952Led the Red International of Labour Unions founded in 1921.
Founder of the Communist Party of ItalyAmadeo Bordiga1889–1970Led the left out at Livorno and founded the Communist Party.
L’Ordine Nuovo, co-founder of the PCd’IAntonio Gramsci1891–1937Led the Turin factory councils and co-founded the Communist Party.
Committee for Adhesion activistAlfred Rosmer1877–1964In May 1919 he transformed the committee into the Committee for Adhesion to the Third International, laying the foundation for the French Communist Party.
Delegate to the First Comintern CongressSerafima Gopner1880–1966She attended the 1919 First Comintern Congress as a delegate of the Ukrainian Communist Party.
Delegate to the Second Comintern CongressHenk Sneevliet1883–1942In 1920, he attended the Second Comintern Congress as the PKI delegate and was elected to the Executive Committee.
Comintern executive committee memberKullervo Manner1880–1939He was elected to the Comintern Executive Committee in 1920.
Comintern Latvian section leaderPēteris Stučka1865–1932After the Comintern’s Second Congress, he was elected chair of the secretariat of its Latvian section.
USPD delegate to the Comintern's Second CongressArthur Crispien1875–1946In 1920, he attended the Comintern's Second Congress as a USPD delegate.
Opened the Baku congress, Azerbaijani Communist PartyNariman Narimanov1870–1925Helped organise the Baku congress and called it to order.
USPD delegate to the Second CongressWilhelm Dittmann1874–1954Defended the USPD with Crispien in the debate on the conditions.
British left communist at the Second CongressSylvia Pankhurst1882–1960Opposed the advice that British communists affiliate to the Labour Party.
Pro-Comintern leader at ToursFernand Loriot1870–1932Led the SFIO majority that voted to join the Comintern.
Delegate at the Tours congressHo Chi Minh1890–1969As Nguyen Ai Quoc he denounced colonial exploitation and backed joining.
United Communist Party chairman during the March ActionHeinrich Brandler1881–1967Led the party after Levi; the Third Congress resolution noted his rebuttal of the offensive theory.
Opposition & resistance3
Rejected the Conditions and stayed in the SFIO to keep “the old house”.
Leader of the Vienna UnionJulius Martov1873–1923Was a leading figure of the Vienna Union, the “Two-and-a-Half International”.
Leader of the Vienna UnionOtto Bauer1881–1938Led the Austrian Social Democrats into the Vienna Union.
Targets & victims4
The Second Congress named him among the reformists to be expelled.
Reformist named in the Twenty-one ConditionsGiuseppe Emanuele Modigliani1872–1947Zinoviev cited his remark that joining took only a postcard to justify stricter conditions.
Bern conference; centrist named by the ConditionsJean Longuet1876–1938At Bern he urged withholding judgment on the Bolsheviks; the Conditions named him for a break.
USPD right-winger named by the ConditionsRudolf Hilferding1877–1941Zinoviev named him as a USPD right-wing leader to be broken with.
Witnesses & chroniclers2
Historians & interpreters2
Related terms
Sources: reference 1reference 2reference 3reference 4reference 5reference 6reference 7reference 8reference 9reference 10reference 11reference 12reference 13reference 14reference 15reference 16reference 17reference 18reference 19reference 20reference 21reference 22reference 23reference 24reference 25reference 26reference 27reference 28reference 29reference 30reference 31reference 32reference 33reference 34reference 35reference 36reference 37reference 38reference 39reference 40reference 41reference 42