Author of the 1919 Karakhan Manifesto that renounced Tsarist unequal treaties with China
Karakhan became doyen of the Beijing diplomatic corps in 1925. The Bolshevik who scorned bourgeois manners nonetheless rode in a gilded six-horse coach, clad in evening clothes and white kid gloves, to present his credentials. Time magazine called him: "A Bolshevik who can wear white gloves gracefully."
Born into an Armenian lawyer's family in Tbilisi, he joined the RSDLP at 15 in 1904, initially as a Menshevik. Siding with the Bolsheviks in 1917, he served as secretary of the Soviet delegation at Brest-Litovsk and became Deputy People's Commissar for Foreign Affairs. In 1919 he drafted and issued the 'Karakhan Manifesto' renouncing all Tsarist unequal treaties and privileges in China, a foundational document of Soviet Asia policy. As ambassador to China he concluded the 1924 Sino-Soviet agreement, and later served as ambassador to Turkey. Arrested in the Great Purge of 1937 on charges of a 'pro-fascist conspiracy,' he was shot and posthumously rehabilitated in 1956.
Also known as: Levon Karakhanyan
Activities and affiliations
-
1917–
Soviet Communist Party and Bolsheviks
Diplomacy and international organization -
1918–1921
Soviet Union state institutionsForeign affairsMain
Diplomacy and international organization -
1923–1926
Soviet Union state institutionsSoviet plenipotentiary and ambassador to China
Diplomacy and international organization
Career Timeline
- 1904Joins RSDLP at 15, initially a Menshevik
- 1913Joins the Mezhraiontsy
- 1917–1918Secretary, Soviet delegation at Brest-Litovsk peace talks
- 1917.08VI Congress: Mezhraiontsy merge into the Bolshevik Party
- 1918–1921Deputy People's Commissar for Foreign Affairs (RSFSR)
- 1921–1922Plenipotentiary Representative of the RSFSR to Poland
- 1922–1923Head of the Eastern Department, NKID
- 1923–1926Plenipotentiary Representative, later Ambassador, to China
- 1925Doyen of the Beijing diplomatic corps
- 1926–1934Deputy People's Commissar for Foreign Affairs (USSR)
- 1934–1937Plenipotentiary Representative of the USSR to Turkey
Related historical events
- 1915–1921May Fourth and the founding of the Chinese Communist PartyThe Karakhan declaration (1919)Renounced tsarist privileges in China, shaping how Chinese intellectuals saw Soviet Russia.
- 1917.11–1921.10Revolution and war in the CaucasusRussian signatory of the Treaty of MoscowSigned the 7 May 1920 Treaty of Moscow recognizing Georgian independence on Russia's behalf.
- 1917.11–1924.10Revolution and war in Central AsiaDeputy People's Commissar for Foreign AffairsSigned the Russo-Persian Treaty of Friendship with Chicherin on 26 February 1921.
- 1917.12–1918.11Brest-Litovsk and Germany’s eastern occupationSecretary of the Soviet delegationHe served as secretary of the Soviet delegation at the Brest-Litovsk peace talks in 1917–1918.
- 1918–1922The Civil War and Foreign InterventionSecretary of the Brest-Litovsk peace delegation
- 1921–1924Mongolian revolution and establishment of the republicSoviet envoy who recognised Outer Mongolia as part of ChinaArriving in Beijing in 1923, he declared Mongolia part of China; the Sino-Soviet agreement followed on 31 May 1924.
- 1924–1927The first united front, the Northern Expedition and the catastrophe of 1927Soviet envoy to the Beiyang governmentAppointed alongside Borodin in 1923 to conduct formal diplomacy in the north.
- 1937–1938The Great Purgearrested and executed in 1937Diplomat behind the Karakhan Manifesto, he was executed in 1937 for a “pro-fascist conspiracy”.
How did a Tbilisi lawyer's son enter the revolutionary movement and end up in Siberian exile?
Lev Karakhan was born in Tbilisi on 20 January 1889; his Armenian name was Levon Mikayeli Karakhanyan. His father Mikhail was an Armenian lawyer from Kutais Governorate and his mother was Vera; there were two sons, Lev and Iosif, born in 1891. After the Tbilisi Realschule he worked as a tutor and newspaper reporter, and the family later moved to Harbin in Manchuria. Harbin was the hub of the Russian-built Chinese Eastern Railway, a city full of Russian officials, railwaymen and merchants. There, in 1904, at the age of fifteen, he joined the Russian Social Democratic Labour Party and worked with the Mensheviks, carrying on party work in Harbin and St Petersburg. This start in an international railway town on the empire's fringe was also the beginning of his later connection with China. In Vladivostok in 1908 he met Klavdia Manayeva, whom he married the next year; they had a son, Mikhail.
In 1910 he entered the law faculty of St Petersburg University but did not graduate. From 1912 he was active in the trade unions, and in 1913 he joined the Mezhraiontsy, the Petersburg organisation of "united social democrats" that belonged to neither Bolsheviks nor Mensheviks and called for unity, doing propaganda and organisational work. When the First World War broke out in 1914 he took the internationalist line that demanded a break with the "defencists" who supported the war. He helped produce the textile workers' journal Tekstilshchik, Rabochie Vedomosti and the illegal paper Vpered, and set up an illegal printing press in Chubarov Lane.
In autumn 1915 he was arrested as he was leaving the press. He is said to have chewed and swallowed the list of party members he was carrying so that his comrades would not be exposed. He was exiled to Tomsk in Siberia, where he kept up illegal work for the Irkutsk party organisation and wrote for the Transbaikal social democratic press. During his exile he enrolled at Tomsk University but was expelled in May 1917 for not paying his fees; the Russian-language account, by contrast, says he passed the Tomsk University examinations externally in 1916.
Karakhan's early years trace a path typical of Caucasian revolutionaries of his generation: an Armenian middle-class family, a Russian-language education, activism that began in a railway town on the empire's fringe, law studies and underground publishing in the capital, and Siberian exile. Through the Mezhraiontsy, the group Trotsky came to lead, he joined the Bolsheviks in 1917 and, with Adolph Joffe, who had followed a similar route, became part of the first generation of revolutionary diplomats.
What did he do as a diplomat of the revolutionary government at Brest and in eastern policy?
Freed by the February Revolution, Karakhan returned to Petrograd in summer 1917 and became a member of a district duma and of the Petrograd Soviet. He was admitted to the Bolshevik party in May 1917 as a member of the Mezhraiontsy (the English-language account dates his joining to the Sixth Congress in August), and from August he sat on the presidium of the Petrograd Soviet. During the October rising he was a member of the Military Revolutionary Committee.
From November 1917 to March 1918 he served as secretary to each of the three successive Soviet delegations at the Brest-Litovsk peace talks, headed by Joffe, Trotsky and Sokolnikov. In March 1918 he signed the peace treaty along with Sokolnikov and others, and the same month became Deputy People's Commissar for Foreign Affairs of the Russian republic in charge of the Eastern Department. Under Foreign Commissar Chicherin he thus became the working head of Soviet diplomacy towards Asia and the Middle East; the Karakhan Manifesto to China of July 1919 came from this post.
In 1918 he was sent on a mission to establish relations with Switzerland, which failed, and he was expelled in November. His first wife and son stayed abroad for the son's health, and the marriage ended there. The same year he married the Komissarzhevskaya Theatre actress Vera Dzheneyeva and adopted her daughter. The British diplomat Robert Bruce Lockhart, who met him in Moscow in 1918, remembered him as "the adonis of the Bolshevik Party", with "dark, waving hair and a well-trimmed beard", "perfect manners" and "an excellent judge of a cigar", and wrote that even while his colleagues were denouncing Lockhart as a spy and assassin he never heard an unpleasant word from Karakhan's lips.
Being Armenian was at times an obstacle in eastern diplomacy. In August 1919 Stalin, then People's Commissar for Nationalities, objected that because Muslims, and Turks in particular, deeply distrusted Armenians, Karakhan's presence in the post was causing problems for establishing Soviet rule in Azerbaijan and for relations with Turkey, and would cause worse ones as the Red Army advanced through Turkestan. The memory of the Ottoman genocide of Armenians during the First World War was still raw. Karakhan nonetheless kept his post, and in May 1920 he represented Russia at the Treaty of Moscow with the independent Democratic Republic of Georgia. Under that treaty Soviet Russia recognised Georgian independence, but the Red Army invaded and Sovietised Georgia the following February.
In these years he embodied the two faces of revolutionary diplomacy. On the one hand he sought the goodwill of Asian peoples by renouncing imperialist unequal treaties; on the other he had to defend state interests in borders, railways and spheres of influence. That tension showed most clearly in relations with China.
The Karakhan Manifesto (1919): Renouncing Tsarist Unequal Treaties
On 25 July 1919, as Deputy People's Commissar for Foreign Affairs, Karakhan issued an 'Appeal of the Council of People's Commissars to the Chinese People and the Governments of Southern and Northern China', the document that came to be known as the Karakhan Manifesto. In it, Soviet Russia unilaterally renounced all unequal treaties imposed by Tsarist Russia on China, offering to return Manchurian territories, surrender extraterritoriality, relinquish economic concessions, and give up Russia's share of the Boxer indemnity. This was the first diplomatic document from a European power to treat China as an equal sovereign nation, and it made a profound impression on Chinese intellectuals and nationalists including Sun Yat-sen. The favourable climate it created was one of the intellectual preconditions for the founding of the Chinese Communist Party in 1921.
Yet a wide gap separated the text of the manifesto from its implementation. Within a month, the Soviet newspaper Izvestiia published a revised version that removed the promise to return the Chinese Eastern Railway, and by 1923 Moscow had begun denying that the original declaration ever existed. The Sino-Soviet agreement of 31 May 1924 reaffirmed the renunciation of extraterritoriality but provided for joint Sino-Soviet administration of the Chinese Eastern Railway and effectively preserved Soviet influence in Outer Mongolia. The Karakhan Manifesto thus stands as a historical document that sharply reveals the tension between anti-imperialist principle and the demands of realpolitik.
What did he achieve as Soviet envoy in Warsaw and Beijing?
On 30 May 1921, a month after the ratification of the Peace of Riga that ended the Polish-Soviet War, Karakhan arrived in Warsaw as the first plenipotentiary representative of the Russian republic to Poland. He was recalled on 9 October 1922 and headed the Eastern Department of the Foreign Commissariat in Moscow in 1922-1923.
In August 1923 he was appointed head of the Soviet delegation to China and reached Beijing in September. His task was to establish diplomatic relations with the Beiyang government in Beijing, the internationally recognised central government that rival warlords took turns controlling. Joffe had failed in his talks with Beijing in 1922-1923 and had gone on to issue his declaration with Sun Yat-sen in the south. Karakhan went into the negotiations backed by the goodwill that the 1919 manifesto bearing his name had built among Chinese intellectuals.
The core issues were the Chinese Eastern Railway and Outer Mongolia. After long haggling the "Agreement on General Principles for the Settlement of Questions between the USSR and the Republic of China" was signed on 31 May 1924. The Soviet Union renounced the tsarist unequal treaties, extraterritoriality and its share of the Boxer indemnity, but the railway was to be jointly managed by the two countries and Soviet influence in Outer Mongolia was in effect preserved. On 13 June Karakhan proposed in a note that both missions be raised to embassies, and he became the first Soviet ambassador to China. In a Beijing where the Western powers kept only legations, this symbolised that the Soviet Union treated China as an equal.
On 20 January 1925 in Beijing, after long and exhausting talks with the Japanese minister Yoshizawa Kenkichi, he signed the Soviet-Japanese Basic Convention that opened diplomatic relations with Japan. In April 1925 he was elected doyen of the Beijing diplomatic corps, since the Soviet Union was the only country with an embassy there. His youngest daughter Irina was born in Beijing during these years.
While he was in Beijing the Soviet Union was also sending advisers such as Mikhail Borodin to the Kuomintang government in Guangzhou in the south to support the united front. In this double policy, official diplomacy with the warlord government in the north and aid to the revolutionary forces in the south, Karakhan was the face of official diplomacy. A music lover, he kept a player piano and rolls recorded by Prokofiev himself in his Beijing residence and listened to them in the evenings; Prokofiev, after meeting him in 1927, wrote in his diary that it was "awfully touching: Karakhan, while implanting revolutionary ideas in China, finds refreshment and renewed strength in the sound of my music." He was recalled to Moscow in September 1926. The collapse of the united front the following year and the armed clash over the Chinese Eastern Railway in 1929 badly shook the relationship he had built.
Why was the former deputy foreign commissar and envoy to Turkey shot in the Great Purge?
Back in Moscow in September 1926, Karakhan served as Deputy People's Commissar for Foreign Affairs of the USSR from 1926 to 1934. Through the 1920s the Foreign Commissariat was riven by a near decade-long feud between Commissar Chicherin and his deputy Litvinov; Chicherin regarded Karakhan as his ally and felt weakened while he was posted abroad. In November 1929, when Chicherin was in Berlin for medical treatment and Moscow feared he might defect, Karakhan was sent to persuade him to come home. Chicherin returned but resigned, and Litvinov succeeded him.
He was famous among colleagues as a dandy. Radek maliciously called him "the ass of classical beauty", and the junior diplomat Alexander Barmine wrote that the young staff "gave him unstinted admiration, amazed that humanity could produce such perfection. He had a purity of profile such as is seen, as a rule, only on ancient coins." From about 1930 he lived with the Bolshoi ballerina Marina Semyonova. In January-February 1934 he attended the Seventeenth Party Congress as a delegate with a consultative vote.
In June 1934 he went to Ankara as Soviet plenipotentiary in Turkey. He is credited with proposing an international conference to regulate passage through the Dardanelles so as to keep the straits out of Nazi Germany's hands; the result was the Montreux Convention of July 1936, though it was Litvinov who signed for the USSR.
On 3 May 1937 he was summoned to Moscow on the pretext of an appointment as ambassador to the United States and arrested. He was reportedly severely tortured. On 2 June he "confessed" that he had been part of a conspiracy with Marshal Tukhachevsky and other Red Army commanders, who were supposedly plotting with Nazi Germany a war the Soviet Union would lose; the officers he named were shot nine days later. On 20 September the Military Collegium of the Supreme Court sentenced him to death for taking part in a "fascist conspiracy", and he was shot the same day. Yet on 20 December Pravda announced that he had been tried on 16 December with a group of "spies, bourgeois nationalists and terrorists" headed by Avel Yenukidze, had confessed and been executed. When the archives opened after the Soviet collapse, the date turned out to be false.
At the last Moscow trial in March 1938 the prosecution repeatedly named him as a German spy linking the Nazis with anti-Soviet conspirators, but the main defendants, Bukharin and Rykov, denied knowing that he was a spy. That entire trial was officially annulled in 1988. Karakhan was posthumously rehabilitated in December 1956. His daughter Irina, born in Beijing, became an ivory carver, and his son Yuri volunteered for the front and was killed in 1942. The revolutionary diplomat who had proclaimed the end of unequal treaties ended as a victim of trials staged by his own government.