Communist League Marxism Germany Germany 1818.5.5.–1883.3.14. ○ Natural causes

Author of Capital and leader of the First International

"From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs!" — Critique of the Gotha Programme (1875)

Born into a lawyer's family in Trier, he began as editor of the Rheinische Zeitung. He renounced his Prussian citizenship in 1845 and remained stateless for the rest of his life, living in London exile from 1849. Over forty years with Engels he wrote the Communist Manifesto and Capital and led the First International. The late Critique of the Gotha Programme (1875) takes apart, line by line, the Lassallean thinking lodged in the German workers' party's unity programme, his last answer to the idea of the state as the instrument of socialism.

Activities and affiliations

Career Timeline

Related historical events

How did a Trier lawyer's son become a Young Hegelian philosopher?

Karl Marx was born on 5 May 1818 in Trier, a small town in Prussia's Rhine Province, the third of nine children. His father, Heinrich Marx, was a lawyer descended on both sides from prominent rabbinical families. When Trier passed from Napoleonic France to Prussia, Jews could no longer practise as lawyers, and Heinrich converted to Protestantism; Karl and his siblings were baptised in 1824. The household respected the Enlightenment and constitutional liberalism, and a neighbour, the aristocratic official Ludwig von Westphalen, introduced the boy to literature and ideas. In 1836 Marx became engaged to his daughter, Jenny von Westphalen.

He was especially attached to his headmaster, the Enlightenment-minded Johann Hugo Wyttenbach, and passed his final examinations at the Trier Gymnasium in 1835, at seventeen. At his father's wish he began law at the University of Bonn, but after an unsettled year of poetry circles and a university penalty for nighttime rowdiness and drunkenness, he moved to the University of Berlin in 1836. He attended law lectures there too, but his interest soon turned to philosophy and history. Berlin was still dominated by the philosophy of Hegel, who had died in 1831. Hegel saw history as reason realising itself, and his followers split. The right treated the Prussian state as its fulfilment; the left, known as the Young Hegelians, used the same logic to criticise religion and the existing state. Marx joined the Young Hegelian "Doctors' Club" around Bruno Bauer and became its sharpest young polemicist.

He continued his studies after his father's death in 1838. His doctoral dissertation compared the natural philosophies of the two ancient Greek atomists, Democritus and Epicurus. It looked like a classical thesis, but by stressing Epicurus's emphasis on chance and freedom it pushed forward the Young Hegelian philosophy of self-consciousness. To avoid the conservative climate of the Prussian universities he submitted it to the University of Jena, which awarded him a doctorate in philosophy in absentia on 15 April 1841.

He hoped to teach alongside Bauer, who had a post at Bonn. But the government of Frederick William IV, who came to the throne in 1840, began driving the Young Hegelians out of the universities; when Bauer lost his licence to teach in 1842, Marx's academic plans collapsed with it. As Engels later put it, the man who in 1842 was about to become a lecturer in philosophy was diverted by the political movement into another channel. Barred from scholarship, the young philosopher turned to journalism, and that meant the Rheinische Zeitung.

Why did the editor of the Rheinische Zeitung leave for Paris, and what did he find there?

The Rheinische Zeitung was founded in January 1842 by liberal businessmen in Cologne as a paper shared by the opposition in all its shades, from constitutional monarchists to radical democrats. Marx began as a contributor and took over the editorship on 15 October 1842. He wrote on the Rhenish Diet's debates about press freedom, on the wood-theft law that turned poor villagers gathering fallen branches into thieves, and on the distress of the Moselle wine growers. In the preface to A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy (1859) he recalled that this was when he first found himself in the embarrassing position of having to discuss so-called material interests, and that it gave him his first reason to study economic questions.

Prussian censorship treated the paper with particular severity. A special censor was sent from Berlin, and when that was not enough every issue had to pass the district governor in Cologne as well. Engels recalled how the editors fed the censor harmless items to strike out so that the articles that mattered got through. In the end the government banned the paper from 1 April 1843. When the shareholders tried to save it by softening its line, Marx resigned as editor on 17 March.

In June 1843 he married Jenny von Westphalen in Kreuznach, and that summer he wrote a manuscript criticising Hegel's theory of the state, moving towards the conclusion that to understand the state one had to examine civil society beneath it, that is, people's economic relations. In October the couple moved to Paris, where censorship was lighter than in Germany and workers' associations and socialist ideas were alive. Marx founded the Deutsch-Französische Jahrbücher with Arnold Ruge, but only one double issue appeared, in February 1844. The money ran out, much of the print run was seized at the border, and above all the two editors parted ways: Ruge remained a bourgeois democrat while Marx was moving towards communism.

In Paris he met the associations of exiled German artisans, French socialists and the poet Heinrich Heine, and began to read classical political economy in earnest. The first result was the Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844, unpublished in his lifetime. Engels's "Outlines of a Critique of Political Economy" in the same Jahrbücher caught his attention, and when Engels stopped in Paris for ten days at the end of August 1844 their lifelong partnership began. Marx also worked on the Paris German-language weekly Vorwärts!, which attacked the Prussian monarchy. Under Prussian pressure the Guizot ministry expelled him, and in early February 1845 he left for Brussels.

How did three years of exile in Brussels lead to the Communist Manifesto?

On arriving in Brussels Marx had to promise the Belgian government that he would not engage in politics. When he learned that Prussia meant to demand his expulsion from Belgium, he renounced his Prussian citizenship in December 1845. His later attempts to recover it, in 1848 and 1861, were refused, and he lived the rest of his life as a citizen of no state. Engels moved to Brussels in April 1845, and that summer the two travelled together to England, where they made contact with the radical wing of Chartism, the workers' political movement.

Their task in these years was to settle accounts with their Young Hegelian past. In spring 1845 Marx jotted down eleven short notes, later published by Engels as the "Theses on Feuerbach", whose last line reads: "The philosophers have only interpreted the world in various ways; the point is to change it." The two then wrote the manuscript of The German Ideology in 1845 and 1846. It was the first extended statement of the materialist conception of history, which treats history not as the unfolding of spirit but as the history of people's productive activity and social relations, but it found no publisher and appeared in full only in 1932.

Ideas also needed organisation. In early 1846 the two set up a Communist Correspondence Committee in Brussels to link socialists in different countries by letter, and argued in turn with Wilhelm Weitling, the voice of German artisan communism, and with the Frenchman Pierre-Joseph Proudhon. The Poverty of Philosophy, published in French in 1847, is Marx's critique of Proudhon's economics. Marx also founded a German Workers' Association in Brussels and lectured to workers there; those lectures later became "Wage Labour and Capital". He wrote for the Deutsche-Brüsseler-Zeitung, attacking Prussia's police regime, and the Prussian government again tried to have him expelled, this time without success. The poet Ferdinand Freiligrath and Joseph Weydemeyer, who later took Marxism to America, were among those who gathered around the two in Brussels.

In early 1847 the two joined the League of the Just, a secret society of exiled German workers with its headquarters in London. In June the League renamed itself the Communist League and replaced the motto "All men are brothers" with "Working men of all countries, unite!" In Engels's account, a body that had been largely conspiratorial was turned into an organisation for communist propaganda. Its second congress in London in November and December 1847 commissioned the two to write a programme, and the Manifesto of the Communist Party, which Marx finished in Brussels, was printed in German in London in February 1848. That same month the February Revolution broke out in Paris; when its wave reached Brussels, the Belgian government arrested Marx and deported him. The Manifesto's contents are treated in a separate entry.

What did the Neue Rheinische Zeitung try to do in the Revolution of 1848?

Driven out of Brussels, Marx entered Paris in March 1848 at the invitation of Flocon, a member of the French Provisional Government. German exiles in Paris were then caught up in a plan to form an armed legion and march into Germany to proclaim a republic. Marx opposed it: Germany had to make its own revolution, and any legion raised abroad would be betrayed and destroyed. Instead he and Engels wrote the "Demands of the Communist Party in Germany", calling for immediate goals such as a unified democratic republic, universal suffrage and the abolition of feudal burdens without compensation. When revolution broke out in Berlin and Vienna in March, the two went in April to Cologne in Prussia's Rhine Province.

In Cologne Marx founded the daily Neue Rheinische Zeitung, with himself as editor-in-chief and Engels as his deputy. Its first issue appeared on 1 June 1848 under the subtitle "Organ of Democracy". Marx held that Germany, still a patchwork of feudal monarchies and dozens of states, first needed a thoroughgoing democratic revolution to create a unified republic, within which the workers had to build up their own independent strength. The paper therefore attacked the indecision of the Frankfurt National Assembly and the liberal bourgeoisie's readiness to compromise with the princes, and even called for war against tsarist Russia as the mainstay of European reaction.

The paper's position showed most sharply during the Paris workers' rising of June 1848. While other democratic papers fell silent or welcomed the restoration of order, the Neue Rheinische Zeitung defended the insurgents without reservation, and lost almost all its shareholders as a result. When martial law was declared in Cologne in September, the paper was suspended for a time. When the Prussian king dissolved the parliament by force in November, the paper printed at the head of every issue an appeal to refuse taxes and to meet force with force. In February 1849 Marx stood trial before a jury twice, over this appeal and over another article; he conducted his own defence and was acquitted both times. The paper also serialised "Wage Labour and Capital", based on his lectures.

In May 1849, after the risings in Dresden and the Rhine Province had been crushed and Prussian troops were massing against the revolutionary army in Baden and the Palatinate, the government served the stateless Marx with an expulsion order. The last issue of the Neue Rheinische Zeitung, on 19 May 1849, was printed in red ink. Marx went back to Paris, but when the French government ordered him to the marshes of Brittany he refused and in August 1849 crossed to London, where he would spend the rest of his life. In 1850 he revived the Neue Rheinische Zeitung in Hamburg as a monthly review, printing his analysis of the French revolution of 1848, but as reaction intensified it had to close after a few issues. Making sense of the revolution's defeat was now work for exile in London.

How did the London exile restart his economic studies in poverty?

In London the Marx family lived in great poverty in rooms on Dean Street in Soho. Four of their seven children died young; among them were three lost in the first years of exile, Guido (1850), Franziska (1852) and Edgar (1855). From the autumn of 1850 Engels went back to the family firm in Manchester and sent money steadily, which kept the household afloat. An inheritance from Jenny's mother in 1856 let the family move near Maitland Park in north London and breathe a little more easily.

In the first years of exile Marx expected a new revolution soon and tried to rebuild the Communist League. But in September 1850 the League split with the Willich–Schapper faction, which demanded an immediate rising, and after the Cologne Communist Trial of 1852 destroyed its German organisation it dissolved. In this period he wrote "The Class Struggles in France", an analysis of the French revolution of 1848, and The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte (1852) on Louis Bonaparte's coup of 1851. After that, as Engels put it, Marx withdrew from political agitation for ten years and devoted himself to research and journalism.

What kept him alive was the New-York Daily Tribune. From 1852 to 1862 he was its European correspondent, sending articles on European and Asian affairs. Of the roughly 487 pieces published under his name, about 125 are thought to have been written by Engels. They covered the Crimean War, the Indian rebellion against British rule, the Opium Wars in China and British diplomacy, and many ran as leading articles. When the American Civil War broke out the paper let its foreign correspondents go, and in March 1862 this income stopped.

Meanwhile Marx restarted his study of economics from scratch in the reading room of the British Museum. In the 1859 preface he explained that London was the best vantage point for observing bourgeois society and that the Museum held an enormous accumulation of material on the history of political economy. When the world crisis of 1857 broke out he thought a revolutionary opportunity was near and wrote through the nights. These manuscripts of 1857 and 1858, over 800 pages, were published only in 1939 as the Grundrisse. He polished part of them into the first instalment of A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy, published in Berlin in 1859, but it attracted little notice. In 1860 he spent a year writing Herr Vogt to answer the slanders of Karl Vogt. After these detours he revised his plan and began again from the beginning under a new title, Capital.

Through which drafts did Capital pass, and why did it remain unfinished?

From 1861 Marx set out to write the sequel to A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy and found the manuscript growing out of control. The manuscript of 1861–1863 filled 23 notebooks, and at its centre was a long examination of earlier economists' theories of surplus value, from Adam Smith to David Ricardo. Engels meant to publish this part as the fourth volume of Capital; Karl Kautsky later issued it as Theories of Surplus Value. Then, in 1863–1865, Marx reorganised the whole plan and drafted three books: the process of production, the process of circulation and the process as a whole. The only draft of the third volume in Marx's own hand dates from this time.

His health kept breaking down as he wrote. From 1862 to 1874 he suffered from boils and skin disease, often unable even to sit, and poverty and the work of the International ate into his time. In the end he dropped the idea of publishing the three volumes together and decided to finish the first one alone. In April 1867 he took the finished manuscript to the publisher Otto Meissner in Hamburg himself, then stayed as a guest of the Hanover physician Ludwig Kugelmann while he waited for the proofs. Volume I of Capital appeared that September in an edition of 1,000 copies. Its subtitle was "A Critique of Political Economy": not a supplement to the economics of Smith and Ricardo, but an inquiry into the social relations that produced the categories that science took for granted. For Engels, who had paid the family's way for years, the book was also the fruit of that sacrifice. Engels wrote anonymous reviews for a range of papers so that the German press could not simply ignore it.

Marx kept revising Volume I. He brought out a second German edition in 1872, and the same year the first translation, into Russian, appeared in St Petersburg. Between 1872 and 1875 he reworked the French edition, issued in instalments, rewriting substantial parts, and in its afterword said it had a scientific value independent of the original. Meanwhile he worked on the manuscripts for Volume II until 1881 and for Volume III until 1882, but brought neither to a publishable form.

Volumes II (1885) and III (1894) were therefore put together after his death by Engels, who joined and edited several manuscripts. How far Engels's editing went has long been debated. The question could be examined directly only once the second section of the Marx-Engels Gesamtausgabe (MEGA), "Capital and preparatory writings", printed all of Marx's economic manuscripts in their original form, from the manuscripts of 1857–1858 to Engels's editorial manuscripts, and was completed in 2012. The contents of Capital are treated in a separate entry.

What part did Marx play in the First International?

The meeting held at St Martin's Hall in London on 28 September 1864 had been organised by British trade-union leaders and French workers' delegates in support of the Polish rising that Russia had crushed. Some 2,000 people attended; the meeting resolved to found an international workers' organisation and elected a provisional General Council to sit in London. Marx, invited as a representative of the German workers, sat silently on the platform, but he soon became the most influential member of the Council.

The difficulty of the International Working Men's Association, the First International, was that its members were so different: British trade-union leaders just turning to politics, French Proudhonists who distrusted both the state and strikes, Italian followers of Mazzini and German communists. When drafts by others failed to satisfy, Marx wrote a new Inaugural Address and provisional rules. Rather than leading with revolutionary phrases, he started from the experience of British workers, the Ten Hours Act and cooperatives, and moved to the principle that the emancipation of the working class must be won by the working class itself. According to Engels, Marx was the soul of every General Council from then until the Hague Congress and drafted almost every document it issued, from the Inaugural Address of 1864 to The Civil War in France of 1871.

Disputes within the International never stopped. Through the congresses of Geneva (1866), Lausanne (1867) and Brussels (1868), the Proudhonists, who rejected collective ownership of the means of production, lost ground. In 1865 Marx gave talks to the General Council refuting the claim that struggles for higher wages were futile; they were later published as Value, Price and Profit. From 1868 the conflict with the Russian revolutionary Mikhail Bakunin grew. Bakunin wanted to keep his own organisation, the International Alliance of Socialist Democracy, inside the International, and rejected political action aimed at state power altogether; Marx held that workers' parties had to contend for political power.

The Franco-Prussian War of 1870 and the Paris Commune of 1871 made the International a name that frightened Europe's governments, but they also made its work harder everywhere. At the Hague Congress in September 1872 the Marxists won a majority, expelled Bakunin and James Guillaume, and voted to move the seat of the General Council to New York. Engels explained this as a decision to stop the International's name being used for futile putsches, but the move effectively ended the organisation, which formally dissolved in 1876. At a meeting in Amsterdam just after the congress, Marx said that there were countries, such as America and England, where workers might reach their goal by peaceful means. His work during the Commune is covered in the section on the Paris Commune and The Civil War in France below.

The Paris Commune and The Civil War in France

When Napoleon III surrendered at Sedan in September 1870, a republic was proclaimed in Paris. In the General Council's second address on the war, Marx warned French workers that any attempt to overthrow the new government with the Prussians at the gates of Paris would be desperate folly. But on 18 March 1871, when Thiers's government tried to seize the cannon of the Paris National Guard, the workers rose, and Paris was in the hands of the Commune for 72 days. About a third of the Commune's council were members of the International, among them Eugène Varlin and Leó Frankel.

Marx followed events from London, gathering newspaper reports and corresponding with Commune leaders. In a letter to his friend Kugelmann he called the Communards people who had "stormed heaven", while counting their failure to march at once on the government troops who had fled to Versailles as a fatal mistake. After several drafts in April and May he wrote The Civil War in France as an address of the General Council. The pamphlet appeared in June 1871, about two weeks after the Commune was crushed in the "Bloody Week", and the General Council set up a committee to help the Commune refugees who poured into London. Written in English, the address was soon translated into German, French and other languages and ran through several editions within months, becoming the labour movement's standard interpretation of the Commune.

Marx called the Commune "the political form at last discovered". It proved that "the working class cannot simply lay hold of the ready-made state machinery and wield it for its own purposes." A standing army abolished and replaced by the armed people; councillors elected by universal suffrage, responsible and revocable at short terms, forming a working body that was executive and legislative at the same time; public servants paid no more than workmen's wages. This was the outline of a proletarian state that Marx drew from the Commune.

This reading became the backbone of the Marxist theory of the state. In his 1891 introduction Engels named the Commune an example of the "dictatorship of the proletariat", and Lenin, writing in The State and Revolution (1917) that Marx had learned from the Commune, put this very passage at the centre of his theory of the state. After the Commune, Europe's press and governments named the International and Marx as the hidden hand behind the rising. In Engels's words, the International was suddenly raised to the position of "the seventh Great Power" in Europe, yet at that very moment it was cut off from any possibility of action in most countries. In this way the Commune's defeat and the repression that followed made the International a body to be hunted as dangerous, which led to the decisions of the Hague Congress the following year.

What occupied Marx in his last years after the Hague Congress?

After the Hague Congress Marx withdrew from organisational work and returned to research. But his last ten years were also a struggle with illness. In 1874 he applied for British naturalisation so that he could travel safely on the Continent; the Home Office refused, calling him a notorious agitator and the head of the International. In 1874–1876 he took cures at Karlsbad, the spa in Bohemia, and in 1877 at Neuenahr in Germany. Throughout he kept up a constant correspondence with labour leaders in Europe and America, and many came to see him in London.

His most important political text of these years was the Critique of the Gotha Programme of 1875. Judging that the programme on which Germany's two workers' parties were about to unite leaned towards Lassalleanism, he sent critical notes to the leadership; the text stayed buried until Engels published it in 1891. In 1877 he wrote a chapter on the history of economics for Engels's Anti-Dühring. Both works are treated in their own entries.

What Marx took up anew in his last years was Russia and the societies outside western Europe. He learned Russian to read material on the Russian village commune and land tenure, and filled notebooks with excerpts from ethnological works such as the American anthropologist Lewis Henry Morgan's Ancient Society. In 1881 the Russian revolutionary Vera Zasulich asked him whether the Russian peasant commune, the mir, could become a starting point for socialism without passing through capitalism. After several drafts he answered that, if the influences assailing it from all sides were first removed, it could become the fulcrum of Russia's social regeneration. In the 1882 preface to the Russian edition of the Communist Manifesto, written with Engels, he added that if a Russian revolution became the signal for a workers' revolution in the West so that the two complemented each other, the commune could serve as the starting point of communist development.

Personal losses followed one another. His wife Jenny died of cancer on 2 December 1881. Suffering from pleurisy and bronchitis, he spent February to May 1882 in Algiers and then rested in Nice, Monte Carlo and Cannes, without recovering. In January 1883, on the Isle of Wight, he learned that his eldest daughter, Jenny Longuet, had died. On the afternoon of 14 March 1883 he died sitting in his armchair at home in Maitland Park, London. Only a dozen or so people attended the burial at Highgate Cemetery on 17 March. In his graveside speech Engels said that just as Darwin had discovered the law of development of organic nature, Marx had discovered the law of development of human history and the law of motion of the capitalist mode of production, adding that he was before all else a revolutionist.