Aesthetics
미학
The branch of philosophy that asks about qualities such as beauty, ugliness and the sublime, about the taste that perceives and judges them, and about what art is and what it does. The questions go back to ancient Greece, but the field became a distinct branch of philosophy when the German philosopher Alexander Baumgarten named it aesthetica, "the science of sensible knowledge", in 1735; the Korean word mihak comes from a Japanese translation of that term. Marxism tried to explain beauty and art through social labour and class relations, and disagreements over how to do so produced distinct Soviet and Western Marxist aesthetics.
In depth
What does "beautiful" refer to?
Suppose two people hear the same song: one calls it beautiful, the other finds it dull. Can we ask which of them is right? With food we do not bother. People who love coriander and people who hate it will never settle the matter by arguing. Yet over a song or a painting people argue readily, because each thinks the other has "missed" what is good in the work. Is beauty only a feeling of mine, or is there something in the work that grounds it? Aesthetics begins with questions like these.
There are more. A sunset seen in a dream can be beautiful. The joy of passing an exam vanishes once you learn it was a dream, but the beauty of the dreamed sunset remains whether or not it was real. How, then, does the mind that enjoys beauty differ from the mind that wants to possess something? And when a urinal is placed in a gallery and called a work, what makes it art? Today aesthetics is often summed up in three large questions: what is art, can aesthetic judgments be objective, and how is aesthetic value related to other values such as truth, morality and usefulness?
The name came later than one might expect. The German philosopher Alexander Gottlieb Baumgarten coined aesthetica in his 1735 thesis on poetry, from the Greek aisthesis (sensation, perception), and called the new discipline "the science of sensible knowledge". If logic dealt with knowing through concepts, aesthetics would deal with knowing through the senses. The Korean word mihak, "the study of beauty", comes from a Japanese translation of this term, so its characters stress beauty where the original stressed sensation.
What answers did the ancients and the moderns give?
The Pythagoreans of ancient Greece held that beauty arises from proportion and harmony between elements, as a pleasing chord sounds when string lengths stand in simple whole-number ratios. Plato went further: beyond the visible beautiful things there is an unchanging form, beauty itself, independent of matter. Art for him was a craft of imitation, and so stood far from the truth. His pupil Aristotle agreed that art imitates but thought that good imitation gives pleasure and can reveal universal truths. The dispute is treated in this dictionary's entry on mimesis.
In modern times the centre of the question moved from the object to the person. In Britain David Hume developed a subjective theory in which beauty is not a property of the object but a pleasure in the mind of the beholder. In 1757 the Anglo-Irish politician Edmund Burke separated the beautiful from the sublime. In the Critique of Judgment (1790) Immanuel Kant tried to resolve the paradox that an aesthetic judgment rests on a subjective pleasure yet demands everyone's agreement, and found the key in a "disinterested" satisfaction free of desire (see Kantian aesthetics). After Kant, Friedrich Schiller saw art as "play" that unites the different human drives, and Hegel described artistic beauty as the way truth appears to the senses (see Hegel's aesthetics).
In the nineteenth century this consensus cracked. Arthur Schopenhauer took over Kant's disinterestedness and saw aesthetic experience as a brief release from endless willing, while Friedrich Nietzsche rejected both the disinterestedness of aesthetic experience and the autonomy of art from the rest of life (see The Birth of Tragedy). Around the same time, in his 1855 dissertation, the Russian Nikolai Chernyshevsky declared that beauty is not an idea but life itself, taking on German idealist aesthetics head-on (see The Aesthetic Relations of Art to Reality).
What did Marx and Engels add?
Marx and Engels wrote no book on aesthetics, yet a handful of scattered sentences became the starting point of Marxist aesthetics as a whole. In the Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844 Marx wrote that an animal produces only according to the need of its species, while man can produce according to the standard of every species and knows how to apply to each object its inherent measure; "man therefore also forms things according to the laws of beauty." Beauty is sought not in a heavenly idea but in the labour by which people work on the world.
der Mensch formiert daher auch nach den Gesetzen der Schönheit.
In the introduction to the Critique of Political Economy, written in 1857 and left unpublished, he posed a harder question to himself. Is Achilles possible alongside powder and lead, or the Iliad alongside the printing press? It is easy to see that Greek epic was bound to a particular stage of social development. "The difficulty," Marx went on, "is that they still give us aesthetic pleasure and in a certain respect count as a norm and an unattainable model." Explaining art through the base and superstructure of its time, he admits, does not explain why the art outlives that time.
Die Schwierigkeit ist, daß sie für uns noch Kunstgenuß gewähren und in gewisser Beziehung als Norm und unerreichbare Muster gelten.
In letters of his later years Engels argued that a writer's political opinions and the reality the work shows can part ways. He wrote that he had learned more from the novels of the royalist Balzac than from the historians and economists of the day (see triumph of realism), and that a character in a novel should be a type representing a group and at the same time a living individual (see typicality). The letters Marx and Engels exchanged in 1859 over Lassalle's play, contrasting Shakespearean vividness with Schiller's speech-making, survive as a literary debate (see Sickingen debate).
How did Marxist aesthetics divide?
Aestheticians after Marx asked how art reflects, and also shapes, a society's ideologies and power relations; Leon Trotsky and György Lukács are prominent examples. Their answers went in very different directions. At one end was the practice of treating a work as a code for its author's class interests, to be deciphered. Fashionable in the Soviet Union of the 1920s, it was later condemned as "vulgar sociology". At the other end stood those who, like the Soviet aesthetician Mikhail Lifshitz, held that beauty and artistic truth have an objective ground beyond class (see Marxist aesthetics (Lifshitz)). Both sides shared reflection theory, the view that art and cognition mirror reality, yet fought over what the mirror shows and how.
In 1934 the Soviet Union made socialist realism the official creative method for its writers. Under that doctrine aesthetics became the party's yardstick for judging art, leading to campaigns against artists such as the anti-formalism campaigns of 1936 and 1948 and the Zhdanovshchina from 1946. The many disputes inside Soviet aesthetics, over narodnost, Russian formalism, the avant-garde and the modernism debate of the 1960s (see The Crisis of Ugliness), took place on that ground.
In Western Europe another road opened. Walter Benjamin asked how technical reproduction such as photography and film transforms art, and Theodor Adorno criticised the commodification of art while holding that art can express alienation and challenge social norms (see culture industry and critical theory). The debate in which Lukács, Bloch and Brecht argued over realism and expressionism is another major fork in this current. These aesthetics started from the same Marx yet often clashed head-on with official Soviet aesthetics.
How did the question "what is art?" change in the twentieth century?
Dadaism in the early twentieth century and later conceptual art shook the traditional definitions that made art a matter of some quality inside the work. Before a urinal in a gallery, or a sculpture copying a supermarket carton, it became hard to define art by beauty or skill. The American philosophers Arthur Danto and George Dickie answered with institutional theories: whether a thing is a work of art is settled not by its properties but by the social conventions of the "art world" of museums, critics and collectors. Danto also presented this as a new reading of Hegel's "end of art".
From a Marxist point of view the institutional theory is half familiar, in that social relations draw the boundaries of art. Whose interests those relations serve, though, and whether such a definition answers the question Marx put to Greek art, why some works still move us across the ages, remain open.
A further change is the recognition that aesthetics is not a purely European discipline. Traditional Indian aesthetics analyses art through rasas, the basic emotions of life such as delight, humour, sorrow and anger, while Chinese aesthetics centres on the "three perfections" of poetry, painting and calligraphy and ties art to self-cultivation and social harmony. Comparative aesthetics, which sets these traditions side by side, has become a field of its own.
Where to start in this dictionary
This entry serves as a map of the aesthetics entries. The line of classical aesthetics runs through mimesis (Plato and Aristotle), Kantian aesthetics (the judgment of taste and the sublime) and Hegel's aesthetics (the end of art). Marx and Engels's writing on art appears under the Sickingen debate, the triumph of realism and typicality; the nineteenth-century realist movement itself under realism (arts); and the starting point of Russian materialist aesthetics under The Aesthetic Relations of Art to Reality.
For Soviet aesthetics, read in turn Marxist aesthetics (Lifshitz), vulgar sociology, socialist realism, the anti-formalism campaign, the Zhdanovshchina and The Crisis of Ugliness. Western Marxist aesthetics can be approached through the culture industry, Dialectic of Enlightenment and critical theory. Among the documents, translations of Lifshitz's "Why I Am Not a Modernist" and The Crisis of Ugliness are in this dictionary.