Modernism · 1890–1960s

Modernism (arts)

모더니즘 (예술)

The collective name for the currents that, from the late nineteenth to the mid-twentieth century, broke with inherited modes of representation and form in the literature, art and music of Europe and America. Novels that follow a character's consciousness without a break, music that abandons tonality and art after Cubism that gives up single-point perspective are its typical forms. In Marxist aesthetics the word served as the counterpart of realism, and from the 1930s to the 1960s Marxists argued over whether modernism expressed the crisis and decadence of capitalism or criticised that crisis by exposing it. After the Second World War the centre moved to the United States, where the "high modernism" of abstract expressionist painting and International Style architecture became the canon of museums and universities, and in the 1960s and 1970s currents arose against it.

In depth

What did modernism change?

Suppose you want to write a novel about one person's day. A nineteenth-century novelist would have had an all-knowing narrator recount the character's circumstances and the events in order. James Joyce's Ulysses (1922) laid a single Dublin day over the episodes of Homer's Odyssey, changed its style from chapter to chapter and recorded the thoughts and sensations passing through the characters' minds in the technique called "stream of consciousness". T. S. Eliot's poem The Waste Land, from the same year, strung fragments together without a continuous story. Virginia Woolf's Mrs Dalloway (1925) and To the Lighthouse (1927), Marcel Proust's In Search of Lost Time, Robert Musil's The Man Without Qualities, Alfred Döblin's Berlin Alexanderplatz (1929) and Franz Kafka's novels and stories belong to the same current.

German literary history names as its marks the stream of consciousness, a fragmented view of the world, the relativising of viewpoints and shifts of perspective. Experience of reality moves towards the subjective and psychological, the narrator who mediates the story steps back, and the work reflects on itself. Changes in intellectual history such as Sigmund Freud's The Interpretation of Dreams (1900) and Albert Einstein's theory of relativity (1905) are counted among its background.

The same happened in art and music. Pablo Picasso's Les Demoiselles d'Avignon (1907) did not present its subjects from a single point of view, and the Cubism of Picasso, Georges Braque and others followed. Wassily Kandinsky founded the Blue Rider group in Munich in 1911 and in the same year painted the picture he later called the first abstract painting. Arnold Schoenberg abandoned the tonal centre at the end of his Second String Quartet in 1908, and in 1913 Igor Stravinsky's ballet The Rite of Spring, with its dissonance and primitive rhythm, caused an uproar. The individual movements of the period are treated under "Expressionism (art)", "Futurism (Italy)", "Dada", "Surrealism" and "Bauhaus", and the Soviet currents under "Russian avant-garde", "Russian Futurism", "Suprematism" and "Constructivism (art)".

What the name covers varies with the writer. In German the phrase "Klassische Moderne" (classical modernism) marks it as the style of a closed epoch, and the American critic Clement Greenberg went so far as to call the philosopher Immanuel Kant "the first real modernist". It usually means European literature, art and music from the 1890s to the 1930s; taken broadly it also includes the "high modernism" of the 1950s and 1960s, after the centre had moved to the United States. In Catholic theology the same word names the reform theology inside the Church that Pope Pius X condemned in the 1907 encyclical Pascendi, which is a different matter.

Are modernism and the avant-garde the same thing?

The two words are often used interchangeably. In "Avant-Garde and Kitsch" (1939) Greenberg called the modern art that rejected the artifice of mass culture and moved towards abstraction the "avant-garde", though what he meant is what is now usually called modernism. The German literary scholar Peter Bürger separated the two in Theory of the Avant-Garde (1974). On his account the avant-garde did not merely change the form of works: it rejected the "institution of art" itself, the standing of an art detached from life and enjoying autonomy, and challenged social and artistic values together, so that it was necessarily political. Modernism renews form within that autonomy.

On this distinction Joyce and Schoenberg are modernists, while Dada and Surrealism, which attacked the institution of art, are avant-garde. The Marxist debate did not always keep the two apart: as shown below, Lukács used "avant-gardism" to lump Kafka, Joyce and Beckett together.

Other accounts drew the relation differently. The Italian-born comparatist Renato Poggioli, in The Theory of the Avant-Garde (Teoria dell'arte d'avanguardia, 1962), treated the avant-garde as a state of mind bound up with the legacy of Romanticism, and the Romanian-born Matei Calinescu, in Faces of Modernity (1977; revised in 1987 as Five Faces of Modernity), set modernism and the avant-garde side by side as different faces of "modernity". Russian art history usually treats the two words as the same, so that "Russian avant-garde" covers the whole innovative art of the period.

How the word "avant-garde" passed from military usage through politics into art, Poggioli's and Calinescu's definitions, and its Russian and Soviet usage are under "Avant-garde"; Bürger's and Greenberg's essays are under "Theory of the Avant-Garde" and "Avant-Garde and Kitsch".

Why did the Soviets single out Joyce?

The Marxist dispute over modernism took the official stage in Moscow in 1934. The First Congress of Soviet Writers, held from 17 August to 1 September that year, proclaimed "Socialist Realism" the method of Soviet literature, and the "Union of Soviet Writers" was founded after it. Maxim Gorky gave the report on literature and Nikolai Bukharin the report on poetry, while Karl Radek reported on world literature in "Contemporary World Literature and the Tasks of Proletarian Art". One section of that report was titled "James Joyce or Socialist Realism?".

Radek said that in Proust's pages the old world, like a mangy dog no longer capable of any action, lies basking in the sun and endlessly licking its sores. Joyce's work he likened to a heap of dung crawling with worms, filmed by a cinema camera through a microscope: Joyce tries to reproduce a given character on a given day with complete exactitude, yet the picture he obtains does not fit even the trivial characters he depicts. Radek said Ulysses was set in Ireland in 1916; the novel in fact covers a single Dublin day, 16 June 1904.

There was dissent at the congress. Wieland Herzfelde, from Germany, praised Joyce as a great artist. In his concluding speech Radek called this "a very important and very dangerous speech": he did not discourage reading Joyce or learning from him, but Herzfelde's appraisal, he answered, cut right across the high road of Soviet literature, socialist realism. A few years later Radek himself was sent to the Gulag in the Great Purge and murdered there.

How did Marxists divide over modernism?

After Radek, the debate over modernism within Marxist aesthetics split in two broad directions. One side saw modernism as the decadence of capitalism in decline and upheld realism; the other read in modernism's fragmented forms fidelity to, or resistance against, a fragmented reality. Neither side was of one piece.

György Lukács led the first. In "Expressionism: Its Significance and Decline" (1934) and "Realism in the Balance" (1938) he held that writers from Naturalism to Surrealism merely transcribed reality in the fragmented form in which it appears and never reached the connections of the whole behind it. In the 1938 essay he set Thomas Mann's "bourgeois refinement" against the Surrealism of Joyce. Ernst Bloch countered that if reality is discontinuous, montage and interruption may be what is faithful to it. This exchange is treated under "Expressionism debate".

Bertolt Brecht defended realism but rejected Lukács's formal norms. In 1938 he wrote that he had never understood why the interior monologue should be rejected as formalistic: that Tolstoy would have done it differently was no reason to reject Joyce's method. The editors of Aesthetics and Politics remark that Lukács's aversion to Joyce and Brecht's to Mann show the divisions between the two.

At the end of the 1950s the debate flared up again. In "Against Misunderstood Realism" (1958) Lukács set the "decadent avant-gardism" running from Kafka to Beckett against the "critical realism" represented by Thomas Mann. Theodor W. Adorno replied with "Reconciliation under Duress (Adorno)". He held that in modern art formal elements have the objective function of determining aesthetic content, and that art is the negative knowledge of the actual world. The editors of Aesthetics and Politics judge Adorno's essays less a Marxist defence of modernism than the expression of a modernist Marxism. Adorno's writing on music is treated under "Philosophy of New Music" and his late theory of art under "Aesthetic Theory (Adorno)".

In the 1960s the rehabilitation of modernism became an issue inside the communist parties. In 1963 Roger Garaudy, theorist of the French Communist Party, published Realism Without Shores (D'un réalisme sans rivages) on Picasso, Saint-John Perse and Kafka, and the same year the "Liblice Kafka Conference" set out to re-evaluate Kafka from a Marxist standpoint. On the other side the Soviet aesthetician Mikhail Lifshitz wrote "Why Am I Not a Modernist?" in 1963, finding "the gospel of a new barbarism" even in the most sincere and innocent searches of the modernists. The course of that debate is treated under "1960s Soviet modernism debate" and "The Crisis of Ugliness".

What, in the end, did the debate ask?

The Marxist debate over modernism comes down to three questions. First, does fragmented form mirror a fragmented reality, or does it hide the connections of the whole? Second, should the anxiety and loneliness of characters be shown as the product of a particular society, or may they be shown as the human condition in general? Third, is art that resists immediate understanding politically powerless, or is the refusal of easy understanding itself a form of criticism?

Lukács broadly gave the first answers, Adorno the second. Brecht, who saw forms as means to be chosen according to circumstances, was at odds with both. The realist side is treated under "Realism (arts)" and "Typicality (literature)", and a map of the debates as a whole under "Western Marxist aesthetics debates".

What was post-war American "high modernism"?

Picture a studio in Springs, a village on Long Island, New York, around 1950. Jackson Pollock lays a large canvas on the floor instead of standing it on an easel, moves around it and pours and splashes thin household paint onto it. The result is a web-like surface with no top and no centre. This "drip technique" was also called "all-over painting", because it covers the whole surface evenly, and "action painting", because it shows the act of painting itself. Pollock had first worked with liquid paint in 1936, in an experimental workshop the Mexican muralist David Alfaro Siqueiros ran in New York.

From 1946 the pictures of the New York School, painters such as Pollock, Arshile Gorky, Willem de Kooning, Mark Rothko and Franz Kline, were called "abstract expressionism". With this current, which grew up after the Second World War and gained mainstream acceptance in the 1950s, the centre of Western art moved from Paris to New York. The critics Clement Greenberg and Harold Rosenberg prepared the way. Rosenberg saw the canvas as "an arena in which to act"; Greenberg, in "American-Type Painting" (1955), saw these painters moving towards greater emphasis on the "flatness" of the picture plane and treated that as the next stage of modernism. In his view the United States had become, after the war, the guardian of "advanced art". Pollock died in a car crash in August 1956, and four months later the Museum of Modern Art (MoMA) in New York gave him a memorial retrospective.

In 1960 Greenberg delivered "Modernist Painting" in the Voice of America's Forum Lectures, and the essay was printed the following year. There he defined modernism:

"The essence of Modernism lies, as I see it, in the use of characteristic methods of a discipline to criticize the discipline itself, not in order to subvert it but in order to entrench it more firmly in its area of competence."

The essence of Modernism lies, as I see it, in the use of characteristic methods of a discipline to criticize the discipline itself, not in order to subvert it but in order to entrench it more firmly in its area of competence.

Because Kant was the first to criticise the means of criticism itself, Greenberg called him "the first real Modernist". Applied to painting, each art must shed what it shares with other arts and return to what is its own. The enclosing shape of the picture it shares with the theatre, colour with the theatre and sculpture, but flatness alone belongs to painting. So Greenberg took Manet's pictures, which frankly declared the flat surfaces on which they were painted, as the first Modernist paintings, and explained painting's turn to abstraction less as a wish to drop representation than as an effort to shed the illusion of three dimensions it shared with sculpture. He also insisted that modernism had never meant a break with the past and continued tradition without a gap.

This theory, in which each art withdraws into the purity of its own medium and tests itself, became orthodoxy in American museums and universities in the 1950s and 1960s, and later critics call the stage Greenberg spoke for "high modernism". The word sounds the same as the "high modernism" the political scientist James C. Scott used for the state's scientific design of society, but the meaning differs; that one is treated under "Modernity".

How this art was entangled with the Cold War is also disputed. What the documents establish is this. Anti-communist intellectuals founded the Congress for Cultural Freedom in West Berlin in 1950, and reports in The New York Times in 1966 and in Ramparts and other magazines in 1967 revealed that the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) had been involved in its founding and funding. Greenberg himself joined the government-funded American Committee for Cultural Freedom in December 1950. From the mid-1970s it was argued that the CIA, seeing abstract expressionism as a symbol of free thought and free markets, helped promote it abroad through the Congress, a case Frances Stonor Saunders set out in detail in The Cultural Cold War. Against this, Michael Kimmelman, art critic of The New York Times, argued that the revisionist reading distorted the facts or stripped them of context. The details are under "Avant-Garde and Kitsch".

How did modernist architecture become the "International Style"?

In architecture modernism is remembered as unornamented white boxes and glass walls. In Toward an Architecture (1923) the Swiss-born French architect Le Corbusier scolded architects for leaning on the tired doctrine of the École des Beaux-Arts while engineers used scientific methods to "fabricate the tools of their time", and called the house a "machine for living in" (machine à habiter). One of the book's working titles was Architecture or Revolution. In 1925 he presented the Plan Voisin, a scheme to bulldoze a large area north of the Seine and replace its narrow streets, monuments and houses with sixty-storey cruciform towers on an orthogonal street grid set in park-like green space, and was met with scorn. In 1928 he co-founded the International Congresses of Modern Architecture (CIAM), whose Athens Charter, drafted on a cruise ship between Marseille and Athens after a planned Moscow meeting was cancelled and published in 1943, became a guide for city planners in the 1950s and 1960s. During the Second World War he stayed for a time in Vichy, offering his plans to the collaborationist government.

In Germany Ludwig Mies van der Rohe built the November Revolution Monument to Karl Liebknecht and Rosa Luxemburg in the Friedrichsfelde cemetery in Berlin in 1926, and from 1930 was the last director of the Bauhaus. The Nazis forced the school out of Dessau in 1932, the Gestapo raided it in Berlin in April 1933, and in July the faculty "voted" to close it. Mies emigrated to the United States in 1937 or 1938, settled in Chicago and completed the Seagram Building in New York in 1958. "Less is more" was one of his favourite sayings.

It was an American museum that named this architecture. The Museum of Modern Art in New York, founded in 1929 by Abby Aldrich Rockefeller and others with Alfred H. Barr Jr. as its first director, called the work of European architects of the 1920s the "International Style" in a 1932 exhibition by the historian Henry-Russell Hitchcock and the architect Philip Johnson. Its principles were architecture as volume enclosed by thin planes rather than mass, regularity instead of symmetry, and no applied ornament. In 1936 Barr drew a family tree of abstract art from the 1890s to the 1930s for the catalogue of the exhibition Cubism and Abstract Art. Modernism, which began in Europe as revolt, thus became the canon of museums and universities. The United Nations headquarters, Lever House and the Seagram Building are counted among the landmarks of the post-war International Style.

The Marxist Marshall Berman argued in his book of 1982 that Le Corbusier sowed the seed of a modernism that sought to erase the bustle of the street with the efficiency of the highway, opening the path of city planning that Jane Jacobs later fought. That critique is treated under "Modernity".

How did modernism come to be called "over"?

By the early 1960s the reign of abstract expressionism in the United States had already weakened, and Pop art and Minimalism arose in rejecting its individualism. Greenberg granted that Pop art tended towards "openness and clarity" against the turgidities of second-generation abstract expressionism, but held that it did not really challenge taste on more than a superficial level. In architecture Robert Venturi turned Mies's "less is more" in 1966 into "less is a bore".

The symbolic scene came from St Louis, Missouri. Pruitt–Igoe, a public housing complex of 33 eleven-storey blocks designed by Minoru Yamasaki and first occupied in 1954, began to be demolished in 1972 with a televised implosion. The critic Charles Jencks called its demolition "the day Modern architecture died". Later appraisals, however, put more weight on St Louis's precipitously declining population and the fiscal problems of the housing authority than on the architecture.

On the Marxist side the end of modernism was seen not as a matter of form but of historical conditions. In "Modernity and Revolution" (1984) Perry Anderson argued that the conditions which had produced the modernism of about 1890 to 1920 (academicism and the aristocratic old order, newly emerging technologies, the felt closeness of social revolution) had vanished after the Second World War. What to call what came after, and which stage of capitalism it matched, became the debate of the 1980s. That debate is treated under "Postmodernism" and "Postmodernism, or, the Cultural Logic of Late Capitalism", and the social experience to which modernism responded under "Modernity".

Related people

Sources

  1. Wikipedia (EN)
  2. de.wikipedia.org
  3. Wikipedia (EN)
  4. Wikipedia (EN)
  5. de.wikipedia.org
  6. Wikipedia (EN)
  7. Wikipedia (EN)
  8. de.wikipedia.org
  9. Wikipedia (EN)
  10. Marxists Internet Archive
  11. monoskop.org
  12. library.fes.de
  13. cep.museepicassoparis.fr
  14. gutov.ru
  15. Wikipedia (EN)
  16. Wikipedia (EN)
  17. Wikipedia (EN)
  18. web.archive.org
  19. Wikipedia (EN)
  20. Wikipedia (EN)
  21. Wikipedia (EN)
  22. fr.wikipedia.org
  23. Wikipedia (EN)
  24. Wikipedia (EN)
  25. Wikipedia (EN)
  26. Wikipedia (EN)
  27. Wikipedia (EN)
  28. Wikipedia (EN)
  29. Wikipedia (EN)
  30. Wikipedia (EN)
  31. marxistarkiv.se
  32. newleftreview.org
  33. aladin.co.kr
  34. Wikipedia (EN)
  35. it.wikipedia.org
  36. aladin.co.kr
  37. cca.qc.ca
  38. Wikipedia (RU)