1941.07.10–09.10

Battle of Smolensk (1941)

What happened for two months at Smolensk, on the road to Moscow, and how did it slow the German plan for a lightning war?

The fighting around Smolensk from 10 July to 10 September 1941 between German Army Group Centre and the Soviet Western and Reserve Fronts. Guderian's and Hoth's panzer groups encircled three Soviet armies at the end of July and took hundreds of thousands of prisoners, but repeated Soviet counter-attacks and the struggle for the Yelnya salient stopped the German advance on Moscow for nearly two months, during which Hitler turned the armour towards Kiev.

What was being prepared before Smolensk in early July?

In the German invasion of the Soviet Union that began with Operation Barbarossa on 22 June 1941, the German Army Group Centre (commanded by Fedor von Bock) encircled and destroyed the main body of the Soviet Western Front around Białystok and Minsk within two weeks. The Western Dvina and the Dnieper then lay across its path, and the narrow strip of land between the two rivers, linking Vitebsk, Orsha and Smolensk, was the most direct road to Moscow. Smolensk, an old fortress city about 400 kilometres west of Moscow, guarded that road. 1 2

On 2 July the Soviet side put People's Commissar of Defence Marshal Semyon Timoshenko in charge of the shattered Western Front and gave him the 19th, 20th, 21st and 22nd Armies, held until then in the reserve of the Stavka (the Soviet high command), together with the newly arriving 16th Army. By the count summarised in German Wikipedia some 42 divisions stood on this new line. Ivan Konev's 19th Army and F. A. Yershakov's 22nd Army held the north, Pavel Kurochkin's 20th Army the centre, and Mikhail Lukin's 16th Army Smolensk itself. Many units were still on the railways, and the Germans knew little of this build-up until they met it on the battlefield. 1 2

This line before Smolensk was hastily rebuilt on the wreck of the Western Front. After the front lost its main body in the Białystok–Minsk pocket in the first week of the war, its commander Dmitry Pavlov was relieved at the end of June (on the 29th or 30th, depending on the source), and on 22 July he was tried and shot together with several of his staff on charges of "cowardice" and "criminal incompetence". Andrei Yeryomenko held the front for a short time in between. In early July the Stavka gave the Western Front six mechanized corps not yet committed, more than 2,000 tanks on paper, and hurried the mobilisation of further reserves. 1 3

The German plan had made the "Smolensk gate", the land bridge from Minsk through Orsha to Smolensk, the main axis to Moscow ever since Erich Marcks drafted the first operational study in the summer of 1940. Under Bock's orders Heinz Guderian's 2nd Panzer Group was to cross the Dnieper in the south and drive up to Smolensk, while Hermann Hoth's 3rd Panzer Group swung round through Vitebsk in the north; the two were to meet at Yartsevo, 50 kilometres north-east of Smolensk, and trap the Soviet forces inside. The Red Army struck first, on 6 July near Lepel, with the 5th and 7th Mechanized Corps, but many of their more than 1,500 tanks on paper broke down before reaching the field and the two corps were virtually destroyed. 1 4 2

The German command itself argued over whether to hurry or wait. Guderian wrote in his memoirs that on the morning of 9 July Günther von Kluge, commander of the 4th Army, which then had both panzer groups under it, came to his command post and demanded that the Dnieper crossing be halted until the infantry arrived; Guderian says he answered that preparations had gone too far to stop and that waiting would expose his troops to Soviet aircraft, and in the end obtained consent. Having failed to seize the bridges at Mogilev and Rogachev by surprise, the 2nd Panzer Group crossed the Dnieper on 10–11 July in the poorly connected country around Kopys. 5 1

How did the July encirclement unfold, and how many soldiers were trapped?

Crossing the Dnieper on 10 July, Guderian's troops broke through the weak Soviet 13th Army and bypassed Mogilev on the 13th. Mogilev held out until 26 July in positions that Fyodor Bakunin's 61st Rifle Corps had dug together with the townspeople, and the Germans took some 35,000 prisoners in that city alone. On 15 July the German 29th Motorized Infantry Division entered Smolensk from the south and, after house-to-house fighting against Lukin's 16th Army, held the districts north of the Dnieper a few days later. Around the same time the Red Army used the Katyusha rocket launcher for the first time, at Rudnya west of Smolensk. 2 1

The defence of Mogilev was one model of Soviet resistance at this time. From 3 July the garrison and mobilised townspeople dug positions, and when the German VII Army Corps attacked with two divisions on 20 July the fight for the Dnieper bridges went on for six days. The garrison commander Bakunin ordered a breakout to the east on the night of 26 July, but only the 20th Mechanized Corps got through, and the German 15th Infantry Division fought the remaining soldiers until the evening of the 27th. F. N. Remezov, commander of the 13th Army, was replaced on 26 July for the loss of Mogilev. 1

In the north Hoth's 7th Panzer Division reached Yartsevo on 15 July and nearly cut off the retreat of three Soviet armies. On 17 July the Stavka gave the defence of Yartsevo to Major General Konstantin Rokossovsky, who had just come up from Ukraine. Rokossovsky wrote in his memoirs that Timoshenko told him reinforcements would bring two or three divisions, "but for now take under you any units and formations" to stop the enemy on the Yartsevo line, and that on the road from Moscow he gathered scattered infantrymen, gunners, signallers and medics into what became "Rokossovsky's group". Alongside this improvised force, Alexander Lizyukov's 1st Moscow Motorized Rifle Division, which had held the Dnieper sector between Solovyovo and Ratchino, fought until early August to keep an escape route open for the encircled armies. 2 1 6

Sources differ on when the ring closed. German Wikipedia has the 17th Panzer Division and the SS Division "Das Reich" break through towards Dorogobuzh and close it on 24 July; English Wikipedia gives 27 July. Inside were most of Lukin's 16th, Konev's 19th and Kurochkin's 20th Armies. A breakout led by the 20th Army staff and attacks from outside let part of them escape, but on 5 August Bock reported 309,000 prisoners taken in the whole battle of Smolensk, a figure later raised to 350,000 including the fighting at Mogilev and Rogachev. About 50,000 men of the encircled 16th and 20th Armies are counted as having got out by 7 August. 2 1

Outside the ring the Red Army counter-attacked without pause. On 20 July Stalin ordered Timoshenko to strike at Smolensk simultaneously from south of Bely, from Yartsevo and from Roslavl, and from 21 July operational groups named after Ivan Maslennikov, Vasily Khomenko, Stepan Kalinin, Rokossovsky and Vladimir Kachalov attacked in turn. Most were newly formed, short of training, artillery and signals, and poorly coordinated, so they won back little ground. Yet they tied the German panzer divisions to the long perimeter of the pocket, and in the south Kachalov's group was itself encircled by Guderian at Roslavl in early August and destroyed (38,561 prisoners by the German count). 1 2 7

Why did the Yelnya salient become the focus, and who took it back?

Guderian put a further advance towards Moscow ahead of closing the pocket. The 10th Panzer Division of his XLVI Motorized Corps took Yelnya, about 80 kilometres south-east of Smolensk, and the heights around it on 19–20 July, establishing a bridgehead over the Desna. Guderian saw it as a springboard for a later advance on Vyazma and Moscow, but the protruding salient soon came under Soviet counter-attack from three sides. He wrote in his memoirs that the commander of the 10th Panzer Division reported destroying 50 Soviet tanks in a single day while losing at least a third of his own, and that "ammunition had to be brought from depots 450 kilometres from the division". 8 2 5

Holding the salient was hard from the start. Guderian wrote in his memoirs that on 23 July Heinrich von Vietinghoff, commander of the XLVI Motorized Corps, reported Soviet counter-attacks on Yelnya from the south, east and north with very strong artillery support, which the corps could barely meet because of the ammunition shortage it had suffered since the war began. On 26 July he asked for the 268th Infantry Division to be sent to Yelnya so that the panzer troops could rest and repair their equipment. German Wikipedia likewise notes that until the following infantry of the IX Army Corps arrived, the position of the armour at Yelnya was critical, and that the 268th Infantry Division reinforced it. 5 1

On the Soviet side the man who drove the Yelnya counter-offensive was Georgy Zhukov. Zhukov wrote in his memoirs that on 29 July he told Stalin the Southwestern Front must be pulled back behind the Dnieper and the Yelnya salient eliminated, and that he was removed as Chief of the General Staff and sent to command the Reserve Front. He recalled saying that "the Hitlerites can later use the Yelnya bridgehead for an offensive on Moscow" (the Kiev part of that conversation belongs to the Battle of Kiev (1941)). The 24th Army (Konstantin Rakutin) and 43rd Army of the Reserve Front, formed on 1 August, were given Yelnya, but their first attack in early August was called off after two days and further attacks up to 20 August achieved little. 9 8

For Zhukov, Yelnya was the first offensive he planned and led on his own. He wrote in his memoirs that the Yelnya operation was "my first independent operation, the first test of my own operational and strategic abilities in the great war with Hitler's Germany", and that he prepared it with particular care. The Stavka directive printed in the memoirs told the Reserve Front to keep fortifying its main line from Ostashkov to Kirov while attacking on 30 August with the 24th and 43rd Armies on its left wing. When Stalin summoned him to Moscow on 1 September, at the height of the offensive, Zhukov says he asked to go instead to the Roslavl sector, where the 211th Division had fallen back, and Stalin agreed. 9

On 30 August the 24th Army opened a new attack on both shoulders of the salient at once. The Germans had meanwhile replaced the panzer divisions with infantry divisions of the XX Army Corps; as the danger of encirclement grew they began withdrawing on 3 September, and Hitler accepted Bock's request to evacuate. On 6 September the Red Army re-entered Yelnya. Soviet propaganda claimed the Germans had been annihilated, but most got away. By the figures cited in English Wikipedia the German XX Corps suffered 23,000 casualties between 8 August and 8 September, while Soviet casualties for 30 August to 8 September alone were 31,853; the historian David Glantz judges that the 24th Army lost nearly 40 per cent of its operational strength. 8 10 7

Still, Yelnya was the first place where the German army had fallen back and the Red Army had regained ground since the war began, and both sides' propaganda made much of it. People's Commissar of Defence Order No. 308 of 18 September 1941 renamed the 100th, 127th, 153rd and 161st Rifle Divisions, which had distinguished themselves at Yelnya and Smolensk, the 1st to 4th Guards Rifle Divisions. The Red Army's Guards formations began here. 7 8

Why did the German command quarrel in August over Moscow or Kiev?

While the pocket was being cleared, Guderian fought a separate battle on the southern flank. His troops attacked Roslavl from 1 August and took it on the 3rd, and Guderian wrote in his memoirs that he then ordered the highway to Moscow held at all costs. From 12 August the German 2nd Army and his XXIV Motorized Corps struck the Soviet Central Front around Gomel and Krichev, taking 78,000 prisoners by the German count and capturing Zhlobin, Rogachev and Gomel. The XXIV Motorized Corps pushed on in mid-August through Mglin and Unecha to Starodub, which it took on the 22nd; this southward reach later became the starting point for turning the whole panzer group towards Kiev. 1 5 11

As the Smolensk pocket was being cleared, the German command split over the next objective. The army commander-in-chief Walther von Brauchitsch, the Chief of the Army General Staff Franz Halder, Bock, Hoth and Guderian wanted to concentrate the armour and go straight for Moscow. From mid-July Hitler, through Directive No. 33 and its supplement, ordered part of Army Group Centre's armour turned south and north, putting Ukraine's grain, the coal and industry of the Donbas and the road to the Caucasus first. At an Army Group Centre conference at Novy Borisov on 27 July the generals had to listen, without a chance to reply, to a memorandum telling them to follow the directive; Guderian noted that night that Hitler preferred to bleed the enemy through small encirclements and that every officer present thought this wrong. English Wikipedia summarises that Guderian, Hoth and Bock tried to delay carrying out the directive. 2 12 13

In August the army high command submitted a memorandum arguing for an attack on Moscow, but on 20 August Hitler rejected it sharply and on the 21st signed an order that part of Army Group Centre turn south and, with Army Group South, encircle and destroy the Soviet Southwestern Front. On 23 August Halder came to Army Group Centre headquarters to announce the decision. According to Guderian's account, Halder was deeply shaken that his Moscow plan had collapsed, and those present agreed that an attack on Kiev would bring on the winter campaign they had wanted to avoid. Bock proposed that Guderian, as a "front-line general", fly with Halder to the Führer's headquarters and put the case to Hitler in person. 12 13 5

Guderian's memoirs tell the evening this way. When he landed at Lötzen in East Prussia, Brauchitsch told him, "I forbid you to raise the question of the attack on Moscow before the Führer." He then reported to Hitler with neither Halder nor Brauchitsch present, surrounded by Wilhelm Keitel, Alfred Jodl, Rudolf Schmundt and others; when Hitler asked whether the troops could make another great effort, he answered that they could if they were given a goal every soldier understood. When Hitler said, "You mean Moscow, of course," he set out at length why Moscow, as a centre of communications, politics and industry, mattered. Hitler heard him out and replied that Ukraine's raw materials and food were vital for continuing the war and that the Crimea was "the Soviet Union's aircraft carrier against Romanian oil". Guderian wrote that it was then that he first heard the phrase "My generals know nothing about the war economy". 5

Accounts of how the meeting ended disagree. Guderian wrote that once Keitel and Jodl both sided with Hitler he gave up the argument for that day, and that since the decision had been confirmed his only task was to carry it out well, so he asked that his panzer group not be split but sent south as a whole. He blamed Halder, saying the army high command had already issued that day a southward order naming him and that "I knew nothing of this order on the day I reported to Hitler". Accounts following Halder's and Bock's records, on the other hand, say that Guderian, sent to argue for Moscow, came out of his talk with Hitler offering of his own accord to use the whole panzer group in the south, which angered both men. English Wikipedia writes that this "abrupt change of heart" made Guderian something of a pariah among the army leadership. The memoirs, published in West Germany in 1951, are heavily self-justifying and Halder's diary has its own stance, so what was said in the room cannot be settled from either side. What is clear is that Guderian flew back with orders to set out for Ukraine on 25 August, that the 2nd Panzer Group resumed its advance south that day, and that, contrary to the promise, the XLVI Motorized Corps was not returned to him. 5 14 12 3 11

How did the fighting at Smolensk end after August, and what did each side lose?

Even after the pocket was cleared the Soviet command did not consider the battle over. Two large counter-offensives followed, on 6–24 August and from 29 August to 12 September; in the north, at Dukhovshchina, the 19th Army (Konev) and 30th Army struck the German 9th Army and produced a crisis from 17 August. On 28 August, with the reserve armies assembled, Timoshenko ordered a general offensive to retake Smolensk from 1 September. The attacks towards Dukhovshchina and Roslavl broke on the German defences at heavy cost; only Yelnya remained as ground regained. These offensives too petered out in the first half of September, and Soviet histories date the end of the battle of Smolensk to 10 September. 2 1

Losses vary greatly with whose count is used. The official Soviet figures of Grigori Krivosheev's team, published only in 1993, give the four fronts and the Pinsk flotilla in the area 486,171 irrecoverable losses (killed, missing and captured) and 273,803 wounded between 10 July and 10 September, 759,947 in all. The prisoners reported by the Germans for the separate battles of those weeks add up to more than 500,000, and Nigel Askey, re-examining Soviet documents, puts the real loss at a million including 565,000 prisoners. For German Army Group Centre a document in the Russian archives gives 101,000 men, while Glantz, working from German records, estimates about 115,500 killed and wounded. 2 1

For the Germans Smolensk was another great encirclement victory, but a costly one. Bock wrote in his diary that he had been "forced to commit all of my combat-capable divisions from the army group's reserve", and that despite huge losses the enemy attacked daily in several sectors so that he could neither regroup nor bring up reserves. The German panzer divisions were driven on to the next battle without time for repair, and supply lines were stretched to their limit. The Red Army held the German advance on the Moscow axis for nearly two months, and in that time prepared new defensive lines and reserves before Moscow. The historian Andreas Hillgruber argued that this stubborn resistance weighed heavily in deterring the Japanese army, which had expected a quick German victory, from attacking the Soviet Union. 2 1 7

The fighting at Smolensk also sharpened the quarrel within the German leadership. Halder and Brauchitsch and commanders such as Bock, Hoth and Guderian urged that the armour not be dispersed but concentrated on Moscow, while Hitler, playing down Moscow and strategic encirclements, repeatedly ordered a concentration on economic targets such as Ukraine, the Donbas and the Caucasus and on smaller tactical encirclements to wear the Soviets down. The German offensive became more fragmented, leading to the battles of Uman and Kiev in the south. English Wikipedia judges that both were German victories but cost dearly in time, men and equipment on the way to Moscow, and gave the Soviets time to prepare the capital's defences. 2

The two sides also divided and named the fighting differently. Soviet histories group 10 July to 10 September into one great "battle of Smolensk" (srazheniye), divided into a defensive operation and several counter-offensives, and present it as the fighting that bought time to defend Moscow. The German army high command recorded the Smolensk encirclement of 8 July to 5 August and the later fighting at Yelnya, Roslavl, Gomel and Velikiye Luki as separate battles. Glantz titled his two-volume study of 2010–2012 Barbarossa Derailed, expressing the view that these two months knocked the German plan off its track. English Wikipedia sums up that after the encirclement much of Army Group Centre was tied down in positional warfare all through the late summer, suffering heavy losses in defensive battles, and that this attrition fed into the defeat before Moscow in December. 2 1

What happened to the civilians of the occupied land and to the captured soldiers?

Having taken Smolensk, the Germans soon rounded up all the Jewish inhabitants of the city and region and confined them to ghettos; they were later murdered. The city stayed under martial law until the Red Army retook it in September 1943. The Germans also seized almost the entire archive of the Smolensk regional committee of the Communist Party and of the NKVD, covering 1917 to the late 1930s, and shipped it to Germany. Used for propaganda, it fell into American hands in 1945 and went to the United States, where, as the "Smolensk Archive", it became the first unfiltered primary source on Soviet provincial life. 2 1

The civilians around Yelnya were in the middle of the fighting. The British war correspondent Alexander Werth visited the area just after its recapture and wrote that the town of 15,000 had been completely destroyed, that nearly all able-bodied men and women had been formed into forced-labour battalions and driven to the German rear, and that only a few hundred old people and children remained. Witnesses told him that on the night before the Germans left they had been locked in the church while soldiers looted the houses and set them on fire one by one. Werth described the whole salient as land where "every village and every town" had been destroyed and "the few surviving civilians" lived in cellars and dugouts. 8

Every encirclement turned hundreds of thousands of Red Army soldiers into prisoners. By mid-December 1941, 79 per cent of the Soviet prisoners taken so far, more than two million people, had been captured in thirteen great encirclements, Smolensk among them. They were marched hundreds of kilometres with little or no food or water, and those who were wounded or could not keep up were shot. At Dulag 131 in Bobruisk alone 30,000 to 40,000 died, and about two million of the deaths of Soviet prisoners in German hands occurred before January 1942. The Commissar Order was also carried out on this battlefield. Guderian wrote in his memoirs that it never reached his panzer group and was not applied there, but the surviving records show his corps commander Joachim Lemelsen saying that the order to take aside and shoot prisoners identified as commissars came from Guderian, and Guderian himself reporting to the armed forces high command that his panzer group had "shunted off" 170 commissars by the beginning of August. 15 14 5

The criminal orders prepared in advance by the military leadership also targeted civilians. The Barbarossa Jurisdiction Decree of 13 May 1941 exempted crimes against the occupied population from court-martial and allowed "collective measures of force" against villages on a battalion commander's order. English Wikipedia writes that for all divisions of Guderian's panzer group whose files are preserved there is evidence of illegal reprisals against the civilian population. The Germans also went to war counting on feeding their army from the occupied land, and the reckoning of the Hunger Plan, that doing so would leave tens of millions to starve, had already been set out at a meeting of state secretaries on 2 May 1941. 16 14 17

Consequences

The Germans took Smolensk and won a great encirclement battle, but after losses of about 760,000 by the Soviet count and some 100,000–115,000 on the German side the advance on Moscow halted. At Yelnya the Red Army regained ground for the first time, and the bulk of the German armour turned south into the Kiev encirclement.

Timeline & Map

Smolensk Yartsevo Yelnya Roslavl Mogilev 14 Moscow 5 Yartsevo 13 Yartsevo 2 Lepel 1 Smolensk 4 Smolensk 9 Smolensk 6 Yelnya 11 Yelnya 12 Yelnya 3 Kopys 8 Borisov 10 Wolfsschanze 7 Mogilev
  1. 11941.07.02Soviet Union
    Timoshenko takes the Western Front

    Marshal Semyon Timoshenko became commander of the Western Front, and five armies of the Stavka reserve were placed under him.

  2. 21941.07.06GermanySoviet Union
    Lepel counter-attack fails

    The Soviet 5th and 7th Mechanized Corps counter-attacked near Lepel and were all but wiped out against the anti-tank defences of the German 7th Panzer Division.

  3. 31941.07.10GermanySoviet Union
    Germans cross the Dnieper

    Guderian's 2nd Panzer Group began crossing the Dnieper south of Orsha, while in the north Hoth's 3rd Panzer Group pushed east past Vitebsk.

  4. 41941.07.15GermanySoviet Union
    Germans enter Smolensk

    The German 29th Motorized Infantry Division entered Smolensk from the south; the same day the 7th Panzer Division reached Yartsevo to the east.

  5. 51941.07.17Soviet Union
    Rokossovsky's group formed

    The Stavka gave Major General Rokossovsky the defence of Yartsevo, and he formed an improvised group from scattered men and units.

  6. 61941.07.20GermanySoviet Union
    Germans take Yelnya

    Guderian's 10th Panzer Division held Yelnya and a bridgehead over the Desna, creating a salient pointing towards Moscow.

  7. 71941.07.26GermanySoviet Union
    Mogilev falls

    The Soviet garrison of Mogilev, fighting encircled since mid-July, attempted a breakout and resistance collapsed.

  8. 81941.07.27Germany
    Novy Borisov conference

    At an Army Group Centre conference attended by Brauchitsch, the generals were read a memorandum ordering strict compliance with Directive No. 33.

  9. 91941.08.05Germany
    Bock reports 309,000 prisoners

    With the Smolensk pocket cleared, Bock reported 309,000 prisoners taken.

  10. 101941.08.23Germany
    Guderian reports to Hitler

    Flying to the Führer's headquarters with Halder, Guderian argued for Moscow, but Hitler confirmed the order to turn south towards Kiev.

  11. 111941.08.30GermanySoviet Union
    Yelnya offensive opens

    The Reserve Front's 24th Army attacked both shoulders of the Yelnya salient at once.

  12. 121941.09.06GermanySoviet Union
    Red Army retakes Yelnya

    After the Germans withdrew from the salient, the Red Army re-entered Yelnya.

  13. 131941.09.10Soviet Union
    End of the battle of Smolensk

    The date Soviet histories give for the end of the battle of Smolensk; the Western Front's counter-offensive to retake the city had stalled without major gains.

  14. 141941.09.18Soviet Union
    First Guards divisions

    People's Commissar of Defence Order No. 308 made four rifle divisions that had fought at Yelnya and Smolensk the 1st to 4th Guards Rifle Divisions.

Related people 14

Related terms

Sources: reference 1reference 2reference 3reference 4reference 5reference 6reference 7reference 8reference 9reference 10reference 11reference 12reference 13reference 14reference 15reference 16reference 17