1945.05.05–12

The Prague Uprising and the Prague Offensive

Why did the fighting in Prague go on after Germany's surrender had been signed, and whose hands liberated the city?

On 5 May 1945 the people of Prague and the Czech resistance rose against the German occupiers. The 1st Division of Vlasov's Russian Liberation Army fought on the insurgents' side for two days, while the Americans in the west halted on the line agreed with the Soviets. On 8 May the Czech National Council signed a protocol letting the Germans withdraw, and at dawn on 9 May the tanks of Konev's 1st Ukrainian Front entered the city. The Soviet Prague offensive encircled Army Group Centre and became the last large operation of the war in Europe.

What was the situation in Bohemia and Moravia at the start of May 1945?

Germany occupied the Czech lands in March 1939 and set up the Protectorate of Bohemia and Moravia. In six years of occupation more than 20,000 Czechs were executed, thousands died in concentration camps and some 400,000 were taken to Germany for forced labour. When the Protectorate's deputy governor Reinhard Heydrich was assassinated in 1942, the occupiers took revenge by wiping out the villages of Lidice and Ležáky. Because Germany counted the Czechs as a people that could be Germanised, its rule there was less harsh than in other occupied lands of Eastern Europe, but anti-German feeling ran deep. In the spring of 1945 about 120 partisan groups, some 7,500 people in all, were attacking railways and bridges in Bohemia and Moravia. 1 2 3

German forces treated this territory as a last bastion. The Protectorate held Field Marshal Ferdinand Schörner's Army Group Centre and part of Army Group Ostmark (the new name of Army Group South), pushed up from Austria. Czech Wikipedia puts the German forces in the Protectorate at about 900,000 at the beginning of May, while Schörner himself told interrogators on 30 May that his army group had about 500,000 men. The Prague garrison numbered about 30,000, with another 60,000 men with heavy weapons at training grounds near the city. Schörner, a commander Hitler favoured, was known for hanging deserters on the spot, and meant to hold out against the Red Army until at least 20 May. At the same time, on 5 May, he drew up the "Blumen" plan for a stage-by-stage withdrawal westward so that his units could surrender to the Americans. 4 5 6 7

The German leadership was divided. In his memoir "Year of Victory" (1945), the Soviet commander Ivan Konev wrote that on 2 May Dönitz's government reckoned Schörner's forces could hold Czechoslovakia for at least three weeks; Dönitz wanted an immediate withdrawal to the south-west, where surrender to the Americans would be easier, while Keitel and Jodl objected that the army group would collapse as soon as it began to fall back. Schörner's chief of staff, General Natzmer, also argued against leaving positions resting on the Sudeten mountains and the old Czechoslovak fortifications, and even a move of the government to Prague was discussed. Sergei Shtemenko, then head of the Operations Directorate of the Soviet General Staff, also wrote that Jodl had ordered buildings to be readied in Prague for the High Command and the government. 8 9

The Czech side was preparing too. Karl Hermann Frank, the Protectorate's state minister and chief of the German police, threatened on the radio on 30 April and 1 May to drown any uprising in "a sea of blood". Former officers of the Czechoslovak army formed the Bartoš command under General Karel Kutlvašr for fighting inside the city and the Alex command under General František Slunečko for the suburbs. Representatives of several parties formed the Czech National Council to take over political leadership once the occupation regime fell. Its chairman was Albert Pražák, a professor at Charles University, and the Communist Josef Smrkovský was a deputy chairman. Frank and the Protectorate prime minister Richard Bienert, meanwhile, were holding their own talks about a peaceful hand-over of power. Because the Germans had overwhelming forces, the resistance leaders wanted to put off a rising and wait for the Allied armies to come closer. 1 3 4 9

What passed between the Allies over Prague?

Among the Western Allies, the only leader who pressed hard for an American liberation of Prague was the British prime minister, Winston Churchill. He cabled the Supreme Allied Commander, Dwight Eisenhower, that the liberation of Prague by US troops might make the whole difference to the post-war situation of Czechoslovakia and its neighbours. President Edvard Beneš, on his way back from London, also hoped that an American liberation would weaken the Communists. The American command, however, gave greater military weight to operations in northern Germany and Austria, and did not want casualties in a war that was nearly over or friction with a Soviet Union whose help it needed against Japan. Czech Wikipedia records that Stalin announced on 24 April that the Red Army would liberate the Vltava basin, and that President Truman replied on 1 May that American troops would not take Prague. 1 4

The line between the American and Soviet armies was fixed by messages between the military commands, not by a treaty of the summit conferences. Czech Wikipedia stresses that no agreement at Yalta fixed it, and English Wikipedia writes that the first line had run along the border before a new one was drawn inside south-western Bohemia. Eisenhower proposed the line on 30 April, and the Soviet side agreed that the Americans could come forward to the line Karlovy Vary–Plzeň–České Budějovice. According to Konev's memoir, Eisenhower wrote to the Soviet chief of the General Staff, Aleksei Antonov, on 4 May that he was ready, if the situation required, to advance to the Vltava and the Elbe to clear their west banks, and Antonov replied on 5 May asking him, to avoid the mixing of troops, not to move east of the line first agreed. German Wikipedia likewise records Antonov's demand of 5 May that the Americans halt on the line Karlsbad (Karlovy Vary)–Plzeň–Budweis. Shtemenko gave the same line as the Mulde–Chemnitz–Karlsbad–Plzeň–Klatovy. American troops had crossed into the western tip of Bohemia on 18 April and taken Cheb on the 25th; with Eisenhower's permission George Patton's US Third Army advanced into the interior on 5 May, and on 6 May the 16th Armored Division took Plzeň. 4 6 5 8 3 9

On 5 May Konev received Omar Bradley, commander of the US 12th Army Group, at his command post north-east of Torgau near the Elbe. Shtemenko wrote that the Americans offered to help destroy the German forces in Czechoslovakia and that Konev declined, citing the demarcation line. Konev himself wrote that Bradley asked how the Soviets meant to take Prague and whether the Americans should help, and that when he answered that no help was needed and that crossing the line would only cause confusion, Bradley said his troops would keep to it. Konev noted himself that Bradley described these meetings differently in his memoir "A Soldier's Story". Meanwhile Patton, hearing the news from Prague, asked for permission to advance to the Vltava, and Eisenhower refused. 8 9 1 6

Soviet preparations began just before Berlin fell. Shtemenko wrote that about a day after the meeting with the Americans on the Elbe, Stalin telephoned Konev himself and asked without preamble: "Who is going to take Prague?" On the night of 1 May the Stavka ordered the 1st Ukrainian Front's troops in Berlin to be relieved by the 1st Belorussian Front and turned towards Prague, and directed the 2nd Ukrainian Front (commanded by Rodion Malinovsky) to turn its main forces towards Jihlava and Prague, reach the Jihlava area by 12–14 May and then take Prague. Shtemenko wrote that the General Staff expected the operation to last at least two weeks. In his directive issued at 01:10 on 4 May, Konev ordered his two tank armies to take Prague on the sixth day of the operation. The 1st Ukrainian Front in the north was to be the main force and cut the escape routes to the west, while the 2nd Ukrainian Front from the south-east and the 4th Ukrainian Front (commanded by Andrei Yeryomenko) from the direction of Olomouc in the east would close round Army Group Centre; the attack was set for 7 May. The Polish Second Army and two Romanian armies fought within these fronts. 9 10 6 4

How did the uprising begin, and why did the Russian Liberation Army join it?

The spark was the Czech language. When word spread on 4 May that the Protectorate government had lifted the rules on bilingual signs and the ban on Czechoslovak flags, German signs began to come down across the city. At 6 o'clock on the morning of 5 May the Czech Radio announcer Zdeněk Mančal gave the time check "it is exactly six o'clock" as a Czech sentence with only the number in German (Je právě sechs hodin), and from then on broadcast only in Czech. When the German director called in soldiers, shooting broke out inside the building, and at 12:33 the radio cried: "Calling the Czech police to the radio! There is shooting here!" Policemen, men of the Protectorate's Government Army, armed citizens and unarmed young men rushed to the building and had taken it by evening. The Czech National Council declared that it was taking power as the body authorised by the government in Košice, the prime minister Bienert was arrested, and the leading Czech collaborator Emanuel Moravec killed himself. 4 3 1

By the end of 5 May the insurgents held most of the city east of the Vltava, the radio, the telephone exchange, most of the main stations and ten of the twelve bridges, and had freed 3,000 prisoners from Pankrác prison. With the telephone exchange in their hands, communication between German units and commanders in the city was cut. The Germans held most of the west bank, the Ruzyně airfield to the north-west and surrounded strongpoints across the city. When the radio appealed that evening for barricades to stop German tanks, tens of thousands worked through the night in bad weather and built about 1,600 by morning; by the end of the uprising there were 2,049. The insurgents' weapons were mostly rifles, light machine guns, grenades and anti-tank weapons taken from the Germans. Schörner ordered the uprising put down and pulled Waffen-SS units from the front towards Prague, and on 7 May the Wallenstein battle group, formed from units at the SS training ground at Benešov, joined the attack with tanks. On 6 May the Luftwaffe bombed barricades and housing and hit the radio building, but broadcasting continued from a makeshift studio in Vinohrady. 1 4 3

At this point an unexpected army joined the insurgents. The 1st Division of Andrey Vlasov's Russian Liberation Army was made up of Soviet soldiers captured by the Germans; in mid-April it had left the Oder front without orders and was now near Beroun, south-west of Prague. Its commander, Sergei Bunyachenko, faced punishment as a traitor if handed to the Soviets. The Bartoš command negotiated with him from 3–4 May, and according to Russian Wikipedia Vlasov himself spoke against joining the uprising at a meeting of officers. The sources give several reasons for Bunyachenko's decision: the German commander's threat to disarm the division, the hope of asylum in a Czechoslovakia the Americans were expected to enter, and the calculation that fighting for the Czechs would lift the stigma of collaboration. Agreement was reached on the morning of 5 May, and the soldiers, still in German uniform, wore white-blue-red armbands to tell them apart. 10 11 12 1

The division began fighting the SS near Zbraslav, south of the city, on the morning of 6 May and then moved into the southern and western districts. On 7 May it seized the Ruzyně airfield, from which German bombers had been flying, crossed the Vltava and fought its way into the centre. Russian Wikipedia puts the division at 18,000 men, Czech Wikipedia the number who actually fought at 12,000–14,000. Czech Wikipedia judges that this division, with artillery and armour the insurgents lacked, kept the Germans from crushing the uprising on 6–7 May. The Czech National Council, however, could not ally itself with a force the Soviet Union regarded as traitors. Smrkovský told the division's representatives that they were traitors to their country and no less an enemy than the Germans, and Kutlvašr protested. An envoy of Beneš also warned the council against dealing with them. On the evening of 7 May the council announced on the radio that the anti-German action of Vlasov's units was their own affair and that no political agreement had been made with them. Having learned from an American patrol that the US Army would not come to Prague, Bunyachenko ordered a withdrawal at 23:00 on 7 May, and the division left westward towards the Americans by 8 May. German Wikipedia says the division lost about 300 men in the Prague fighting; Czech Wikipedia gives its losses up to 7 May as 308, apparently including most of the wounded. 10 4 3 1 11

The Soviet memoirs say almost nothing about this fighting. Shtemenko wrote only that some of Vlasov's men came twice to the Czech National Council offering to help defend the city and were turned away, and that some groups exchanged fire with the Germans on their own initiative. Konev does not mention their fighting in his account of the uprising. Czech Wikipedia notes that the historiography of the Communist period suppressed the Russian Liberation Army's part in the uprising for ideological reasons, and that after 1989 simplified accounts appeared that inflated it instead. 9 8 4

The insurgents appealed for outside help. From the night of 5 May the radio called in English and Russian for air strikes against German tanks and for weapons, and early on 6 May it broadcast: "The city of Prague asks all Allied armies for help. Send aircraft, tanks and weapons." Shtemenko wrote that the General Staff first learned of the uprising at 4 a.m. on 6 May, from a telephone call by General Heliodor Píka, head of the Czechoslovak military mission in Moscow. According to Czech Wikipedia, the defence minister Ludvík Svoboda, in Košice, asked through Píka whether the Soviets could fly about 600 soldiers to Prague. Stalin gave no answer to the request; instead he asked Antonov whether Konev could attack at once rather than on 7 May, and when Antonov replied that the strike group would be ready on the 6th, the attack was brought forward by a day. An airlift of weapons promised by the Czechoslovak military command in London was called off because of the weather and Soviet objections: the Soviets allowed no foreign aircraft into their zone of operations, and they also kept Czechoslovak airmen who had fought in the RAF from flying home. 9 4 1

The Communists in the Košice government were dismayed by the news. Klement Gottwald, Communist chairman and deputy prime minister, complained: "Our best people will lose their lives needlessly at the end of the war. Besides, there is a danger that the Americans and British will get to Prague before Malinovsky and Konev." Gottwald and the prime minister Zdeněk Fierlinger, a Social Democrat, asked Stalin through the Soviet ambassador Valerian Zorin to make sure the American army did not reach Prague before the Soviet one. Fierlinger later admitted that he had turned down, through Zorin, Eisenhower's offer to liberate Prague without discussing it in the government. 4

What happened in Prague on 7–8 May, after Germany's surrender had been signed?

At 02:41 on 7 May, at Allied headquarters in Reims, Jodl signed Germany's unconditional surrender, to take effect at 23:01 Central European time on 8 May. The German command meant to use the interval to move as many troops as possible westward to surrender to the Americans. Shtemenko wrote that at the Reims talks on 6 May Jodl had said that the forces of Schörner, Löhr and Rendulic would not obey a surrender order as long as they could still reach areas occupied by the Americans. Konev quoted Schörner's order of 7 May: "Enemy propaganda is spreading false rumours of Germany's surrender to the Allies. I warn the troops that the war against the Soviet Union will continue." 9 1 8

During these two days the German forces in Prague made their strongest attack of the uprising to secure the city's routes. SS tanks and artillery broke through the barricades one after another, reached the Old Town Square and shelled the Old Town Hall, whose neo-Gothic east wing burned and had to be pulled down in 1947. The SS drove Czech civilians in front of their tanks as human shields. At the Masaryk railway station, after taking it, the Germans shot surrendered insurgents, railwaymen and passengers who happened to be there; the sources differ on the number, English Wikipedia giving about 50 (on 8 May), German Wikipedia 53 (on 7 May) and Czech Wikipedia 47. The SS commander in the Protectorate, Carl Friedrich von Pückler-Burghauss, demanded incendiary bombing of Na Příkopě and Wenceslas Square, the centre of the uprising, saying "the whole nest must burn". By the evening of 7 May the Germans had retaken most of the insurgent territory east of the river, and the insurgents held only a salient around Vinohrady and Strašnice. When the Bartoš command heard of the Reims surrender it ordered an immediate ceasefire, which caused confusion among the defenders. 1 4 3 6

Americans also passed through Prague. On the evening of 7 May an American delegation came to the Bartoš command to announce the German surrender and to say that the US Army had to stay at Rokycany. That night the "Velichovky mission", a column of armoured cars and jeeps from a reconnaissance squadron of the US 16th Armored Division, left Plzeň carrying Colonel Wilhelm Meyer-Detring, a liaison officer of the German High Command, and drove through Prague. It met the Bartoš command and the German commander, General Rudolf Toussaint, demanding an end to the fighting in the city, and on the morning of 8 May reached the spa of Velichovky, where Schörner had his headquarters. Czech Wikipedia says it is unclear whether the mission actually met Schörner; according to English Wikipedia, Meyer-Detring told Schörner that with the surrender signed, a withdrawal of the army group westward as a body was out of the question; Schörner ordered his command to observe the surrender but said he could not guarantee he would be obeyed everywhere. On the night into 9 May officers of the American Office of Strategic Services (OSS) reached Prague; according to Czech Wikipedia, Smrkovský, who met them, discouraged an American advance because he wanted the role of liberator to go to the Red Army. 4 13 6

With no weapons, no relief and the city being wrecked, the Czech National Council decided to negotiate with Toussaint, a career officer who had been Wehrmacht commander in the Protectorate in 1941–1943 and again from July 1944 and was the last German commander of Prague. Czech Wikipedia records that Schörner ordered Toussaint to destroy Prague, that Toussaint refused and came to the council instead. At 16:00 on 8 May Toussaint, the council and the Bartoš command signed a "Protocol on the Form of Carrying Out the Capitulation of the German Armed Forces". Czech Wikipedia gives 18:00 the same day as the time it took effect, while English Wikipedia writes that after several hours of negotiation a ceasefire was agreed around midnight. The Germans were to stop fighting and release prisoners and internees, leave heavy weapons and aircraft on the outskirts and at the airfields, and hand over their remaining arms at the American demarcation line; in exchange they could withdraw freely westward through Prague. At 19:15 the International Red Cross broadcast the ceasefire order on Prague radio in Czech and German. Toussaint, however, had no authority over the SS. Some SS units accepted the truce and left westward, but Pückler-Burghauss's SS units fought on. 4 14 1 9

The agreement later became a political issue. Shtemenko saw it as a compromise by the "bourgeois majority" that let the Germans slip away towards the Americans with their rifles. He quoted the council chairman Pražák as saying later: "The aim of the uprising was to save the city from the destruction that was expected, since the Germans did not mean to leave it without a fight. We were waiting from hour to hour for the Allied armies to arrive." Czech accounts see the decision as a choice to protect the city and its people without weapons or relief. The Soviet reaction was swift. On 11 May the Soviets told the Czechoslovak government that they regarded the council's members as traitors and demanded their punishment, and on 31 May Ambassador Zorin, in a formal note, accused the council of trying to save a German army and demanded that Kutlvašr and other commanders be punished too. The government did not protest, but Beneš promoted the commanders and kept them in the army. After the Communists took power in 1948, Kutlvašr was sentenced to life imprisonment in a staged trial in 1949, and Jaromír Nechanský, who had headed the council's military commission, was executed. 9 4 3

How did the Soviet army enter Prague, and when did the fighting end?

The 1st Ukrainian Front's offensive began on 6 May. According to Shtemenko, the forward detachments of several armies moved off at 12:00 and the main forces at 14:00. The main thrust was made by Nikolai Pukhov's 13th Army, Vasily Gordov's 3rd Guards Army, Dmitry Lelyushenko's 4th Guards Tank Army and Pavel Rybalko's 3rd Guards Tank Army, while Aleksei Zhadov's 5th Guards Army attacked towards Dresden in the evening. The same day the 40,000 German troops besieged for two months in Breslau (Wrocław) surrendered. On 7 May the 2nd and 4th Ukrainian Fronts joined the attack. On 8 May the 1st Ukrainian Front crossed the Ore Mountains (Krušné hory) and took Dresden, and the 4th Ukrainian Front took Olomouc. 9 6 10

At dawn on 8 May the 5th Guards Mechanised Corps of Lelyushenko's army ran into a large German staff column heading west between Jaroměř and Žatec and smashed it without stopping. Konev wrote that only later did they learn it had been the headquarters of Army Group Centre, and he quoted Schörner's later testimony: "From that moment I lost control of the withdrawing troops." Schörner deserted his command, made his way in civilian clothes to Podbořany and flew to Bavaria the next day; he gave himself up to the Americans on 18 May and was passed to the Soviets a few weeks later. Without an army group headquarters, its armies were left to fend for themselves. At 20:00 on 8 May, on the Stavka's instructions, Konev called by radio on the German forces in western Czechoslovakia to lay down their arms by 23:00; there was no reply. 8 6 7

Rybalko's and Lelyushenko's tank armies covered 80 kilometres on the night of 8–9 May and reached Prague. Konev wrote that the tanks burst into the city at 3 a.m.; English, Russian and Czech Wikipedia mostly give about 4 a.m. According to Konev, the 10th Guards Ural Volunteer Tank Corps of Lelyushenko's army came in first from the north-west, followed almost at once by the 9th Mechanised Corps of Rybalko's army from the north. Russian Wikipedia records that three tanks of the 63rd Guards Chelyabinsk Tank Brigade were in the lead, and that one of them, No. 1-24, was hit while fighting German tank destroyers at Klárov by the Mánes Bridge, its commander, Lieutenant Ivan Goncharenko, being killed. Most of the Germans had already left the city. Soviet tanks fought SS groups that had not got away, and at Dejvice they also shot up German columns that were leaving already disarmed. Konev wrote that Prague was fully taken by 10 a.m.; Czech Wikipedia says he reported its liberation at 9. Crowds came out and greeted the tanks with lilac. 8 6 10 4 3

At 13:00 on 9 May the lead units of Andrei Kravchenko's 6th Guards Tank Army of the 2nd Ukrainian Front met Lelyushenko's army 35 kilometres south-east of Prague, and at 18:00 the mobile group of the 4th Ukrainian Front also reached the city. The tank brigade of the 1st Czechoslovak Army Corps entered Prague on 10 May. The ring closed round the main body of Army Group Centre east of Prague; Konev wrote that more than half a million men were inside it. On the morning of the same day Soviet aircraft bombed Mladá Boleslav to stop German troops from retreating towards the Americans. According to Russian Wikipedia, SS units held out in parts of the city until 16:00. 8 10 5 6

On 10 May the Stavka ordered the 2nd Ukrainian Front and the forward detachments of the 1st Ukrainian Front westward to occupy the line of contact with the Americans, and the main forces to keep the encircled Germans from breaking out to the west. Soviet and American troops met near České Budějovice and Chemnitz on 10 May, and by the end of 11 May the line of contact ran for some 250 kilometres along Chemnitz–Karlovy Vary–Plzeň–České Budějovice. After 8 May the Americans returned German soldiers who came to surrender to the Soviet side. Blocked short of the American line, Pückler-Burghauss's SS units, with German refugees, 6,000–7,000 people in all, dug in on the hill at Slivice near Příbram, and on 11 May they were attacked by the Red Army and Czech partisans. At about 3 a.m. on 12 May Pückler-Burghauss signed a capitulation in the presence of American and Soviet representatives and then killed himself. The Battle of Slivice is counted as the last large battle of the war in Europe. 10 6 15 3

The same day, about 40 kilometres south-east of Plzeň, a column of the Russian Liberation Army's 1st Division heading for the Americans was caught by the reconnaissance of the Soviet 25th Tank Corps. According to Shtemenko and Konev, Captain Yakushev of the 162nd Tank Brigade, helped by the Russian Liberation Army battalion commander Kuchinsky and by Vlasov's driver, pulled Vlasov out of a car, and the division surrendered without resistance. Bunyachenko surrendered to the Americans but was handed over to the Soviets a few days later. Soviet and Russian histories date the end of the Prague operation to 11 May, and Russian veterans' law extends the Great Patriotic War to 11 May for those who took part in it. Fighting between scattered German units, pursuing Soviet troops and partisans went on in places until about 20 May. 9 8 10 4

What did it cost, and why do the figures differ between sources?

Czech losses have never been counted exactly. Czech Wikipedia gives, from counts made since 2016, at least 2,898 Czechs killed in the uprising and its aftermath: 1,694 civilians identified just after the war and about 1,200 who fell on the barricades or died of wounds. Shtemenko quotes the council chairman Pražák as speaking of 3,000 killed and 10,000 wounded. The Czech journalist Karel Pacner argued that losses could have been much lower had the council asked the Americans for help or not turned away the Russian Liberation Army. 4 9

The number of Soviet soldiers killed in Prague itself is where the sources differ most. English Wikipedia says the Red Army lost only ten men in Prague, its "easiest victory" of the war; the figure comes from a 2016 study by a researcher of the Russian Academy of Sciences in St Petersburg, which counts ten killed in the city centre and about twenty more who died of wounds, illness and accidents before the army left in September. Czech historians put Soviet dead in inner Prague at about 30 and in all the fighting on the approaches to Prague at close to 700 (662 or 692). Russian Wikipedia says more than a thousand died around Prague and, by Czech figures, 54 in the city on 9 May. The Russian researcher Vladimir Pomortsev found that of the 492 Soviet soldiers buried at Olšany cemetery, 75 died in the fighting of 8–15 May, while many of the rest died of methanol poisoning, tuberculosis, typhoid, traffic accidents and the like. English Wikipedia notes that the Communist regime inflated the number of Red Army soldiers killed in Prague. 1 6 4 10

For the operation as a whole the numbers are much larger. According to English and Russian Wikipedia, which follow Russian loss statistics, the losses of the Soviet forces and the Polish, Romanian and Czechoslovak units fighting with them from 6 to 11 May were 11,997 irrecoverable and 40,501 wounded and sick, 52,498 in all; of these the Soviet irrecoverable losses alone were 11,265. Shtemenko's statement that more than 140,000 Soviet soldiers gave their lives for the liberation of Czechoslovakia refers to the whole campaign from the Carpathian battles of autumn 1944 to this operation. On the German side, about 860,000 men were taken prisoner by the Soviet count; Czech Wikipedia gives about 800,000. Germans killed in Prague itself are estimated at about a thousand, a figure that seems to include civilians. For the Russian Liberation Army, Czech Wikipedia estimates about 150 killed in action in Prague, about 250 killed by the NKVD and others after the Soviet army arrived, and about 200 more murdered near the city. 6 10 9 5 4

The meaning of the operation is also disputed. Shtemenko rebutted the view, voiced almost a quarter of a century after the war, that the battle for Czechoslovakia had been unnecessary, writing that the armies of Schörner and Rendulic, more than a million men who would not lay down their arms after the surrender, were a real threat. Konev likewise insisted that the Prague operation was not symbolic, as some in the West claimed, but a serious fight against a large German force. The German official history, by contrast, in its volume 10/1 of 2008, points out that the Prague operation's casualty rate was far lower than that of the Berlin operation and stresses Stalin's political aim of keeping Army Group Centre from surrendering to the Americans. The Soviet official history says nothing of Stalin's political aims. 9 8 6

What happened to the Germans and to the Russian Liberation Army soldiers after the uprising?

During the uprising German forces committed many crimes against Czech civilians: summary executions, threats to shoot hostages and the shelling of surrounding houses whenever tanks were stopped by barricades, with several massacres of more than twenty people at a time, most of them on 7 and 8 May. On 8 May 21 prisoners and civilians were killed, their bodies bearing marks of torture, on the ramp above the Stag Moat (Jelení příkop) by Prague Castle, and at the Pražačka school in Žižkov Luftwaffe men, SA men and Sudeten German Hitler Youth members tortured and killed captives. Most of these crimes went unpunished: many of the SS men who led the massacres escaped to the Americans, and West Germany would not hand suspects to Czechoslovakia. Toussaint was sentenced to life imprisonment by a Czechoslovak court in 1948 for the killing of civilians in the uprising and was released in 1961 in an exchange of agents. Frank, captured by the Americans near Rokycany on 9 May, was hanged for crimes including the destruction of Lidice in the courtyard of Pankrác prison on 22 May 1946, before 5,000 onlookers. 1 4 14 2

Czech retaliation also began during the uprising. The government-in-exile had planned to expel the German minority, and its London broadcasts had urged violence against German civilians and suspected collaborators throughout the occupation. Before his return, Beneš said on the radio that "everyone who deserves death should be totally liquidated in the popular storm", and the justice minister Prokop Drtina asked resistance leaders to make liberation "bloody" for the Germans. In Prague, surrendered German soldiers and civilians were killed both before and after the Red Army arrived. Some captured soldiers were hung upside down from lampposts and burned alive, and German civilians were beaten, raped and robbed. On 10 May forty German civilians were murdered at Bořislavka. Czech Wikipedia puts the number of Germans killed in Prague at about 300. Many were harmed on mere suspicion, or to settle private scores. On 8 May the collaborator Felix de la Cámara, a founder of Czech fascist organisations, was lynched by a mob, and on 10 May a Soviet soldier shot the film director Jan Sviták while a crowd was trying to lynch him. Thousands of German civilians and surrendered soldiers were interned in makeshift camps with poor food and hygiene. The historian Mark Levene called the events in the city a "tidal wave of anti-German mob justice" and compared them with the anti-Jewish pogroms in eastern Poland and Lithuania in 1941 before the German army arrived. 1 4

The NKVD and the military counter-intelligence SMERSH came into Prague with the Soviet army. They began arresting "White" Russians who had emigrated after the revolution, and carried off several hundred Czechoslovak citizens, among them the Czechoslovak army general Sergej Vojcechovský, to Soviet camps; only some came back. The Russian Liberation Army's soldiers were hunted down too. Bunyachenko took his lightly wounded with him, but the badly wounded left in Prague hospitals were dragged from their beds by SMERSH and NKVD men, killed and thrown into an unmarked pit at Olšany cemetery, and at Jinonice a group that had not got away was shot. Visiting the insurgent headquarters on the evening of 9 May, Rybalko is said to have threatened to have the people there shot; when the council chairman Pražák asked for humane treatment of Vlasov's soldiers because they had spared the blood of Prague's people, he first refused and then, it is reported, answered: "Very well, I promise I will not have them all shot." Emil Hácha, the president of the Protectorate, was arrested at Lány Castle on 13 May and moved to the hospital wing of Pankrác prison, where he died on 27 June. English Wikipedia says he was badly beaten by NKVD agents; Czech Wikipedia says he was arrested on the order of the interior minister, Nosek. Vlasov and Bunyachenko were sentenced to death for treason in a closed trial before the Military Collegium of the Soviet Supreme Court from 30 July to 1 August 1946 and were hanged on 1 August. Schörner was sentenced to 25 years in the Soviet Union in 1952; the sentence was reduced, he was handed to East Germany and released in 1955, and after returning to West Germany he was sentenced again for having soldiers of his own executed for desertion. 4 11 6 12 7

How were the uprising and the liberation remembered?

The uprising became a national myth of the new Czechoslovakia: in the words of the journalist Jindřich Marek, "the greatest military action of the Czechs for freedom and national independence fought on their own territory". At the same time, the Western Allies' failure to liberate Prague was taken as a second proof of the indifference to Czechoslovakia first shown at Munich in 1938. Since few Czechs knew of the demarcation agreement, the Communists could accuse the Americans of having remained "a cowardly or cynical onlooker while Prague was struggling for life", in the words of the historian Stephen Kertesz. The memory that Stalin had opposed the Munich Agreement, together with the Red Army's entry into Prague, turned opinion towards Communism. The British diplomat Orme Sargent saw the Prague uprising as the moment when "Czechoslovakia was now definitely lost to the West". According to Czech Wikipedia, Beneš himself later told the British diplomat Bruce Lockhart that halting Patton had been a grave mistake that "stood at the beginning of all the further misfortunes". 1 4

The Communist regime rewrote the memory of the uprising. According to English Wikipedia it purged or arrested former resistance leaders to discredit a home resistance that threatened its legitimacy, and exaggerated the role of the working class and the number of Red Army soldiers killed in Prague; the Russian Liberation Army's part was erased. The Soviet memoirs follow the same frame. Konev praised the "heroic essence" of the uprising but wrote that the "complicated knot" of negotiations and conflicts had been "cut" by Soviet tank crews. He wrote that whenever he visited Olšany cemetery in Prague he read with sorrow the date "9 May" on the gravestones of Soviet soldiers. 1 8

Monuments too changed fortunes with the times. On 29 July 1945 a memorial to the Soviet tank crews was unveiled in Konev's presence, with a different tank on the plinth instead of No. 1-24, said to have been the first into Prague. In April 1991 the artist David Černý painted this "Tank No. 23" pink, and it became known as the Pink Tank before being removed. Konev was made an honorary citizen of Prague, and the Soviet Union created a medal "For the Liberation of Prague". A plaque to Konev and the 1st Ukrainian Front, put up on the Old Town Hall in 1946, was taken down during renovation in 2018, setting off an argument over who deserved how much credit for the liberation. In 2019 the Russian embassy protested when the Prague district of Řeporyje put up a memorial to the Russian Liberation Army. 4 3 10

Consequences

Army Group Centre collapsed and most of it went into Soviet captivity, and Czechoslovakia entered the post-war years as a country whose capital the Red Army had liberated. The belief that the West had not saved Prague, and the Red Army's entry, strengthened the Communists. Retaliation against German inhabitants and Soviet punishment of Russian Liberation Army soldiers followed at once.

Timeline & Map

Prague Dresden Velichovky Plzeň Slivice Olomouc Košice 2 North-east of Torgau 7 Dresden 1 Prague 4 Prague 5 Prague 6 Prague 8 Prague 9 Prague 11 Prague 3 Plzeň 10 Slivice
  1. 1945.04.30United StatesSoviet Union
    Demarcation line agreed

    Eisenhower proposed a demarcation line, and the Soviets agreed that US troops could advance to the Karlovy Vary–Plzeň–České Budějovice line.

  2. 1945.05.01Soviet Union
    Stavka orders the turn on Prague

    The Stavka ordered the 1st Ukrainian Front's troops in Berlin to be relieved and turned towards Prague.

  3. 1945.05.04Soviet Union
    Konev's operational directive

    In a directive issued at 01:10, Konev ordered his two tank armies to take Prague on the sixth day of the operation.

  4. 11945.05.05CzechoslovakiaGermany
    The Prague uprising begins

    Czech Radio called the police to its aid, and citizens and police seized the radio building and key points of the city. About 1,600 barricades went up overnight.

  5. 21945.05.05Soviet UnionUnited States
    Konev meets Bradley

    Konev received Bradley at his command post north-east of Torgau, and the Americans undertook not to cross the demarcation line.

  6. 31945.05.06Soviet UnionUnited States
    Soviet offensive opens; Plzeň taken

    The 1st Ukrainian Front attacked a day ahead of schedule, and the US 16th Armored Division took Plzeň.

  7. 41945.05.06CzechoslovakiaGermany
    Russian Liberation Army 1st Division joins in

    Bunyachenko's division entered south-western Prague and began fighting the Germans.

  8. 51945.05.07GermanyCzechoslovakia
    Surrender signed at Reims; SS assault

    Jodl signed the surrender at Reims, while in Prague the SS made their strongest attack, breaking through the barricades. The Russian Liberation Army division began to withdraw that night.

  9. 61945.05.08CzechoslovakiaGermany
    Toussaint's protocol with the Czech National Council

    At 16:00 Toussaint and the Czech National Council signed a protocol on the Germans' withdrawal from Prague and the hand-over of their weapons.

  10. 71945.05.08Soviet UnionGermany
    Army Group Centre HQ overrun; Dresden taken

    The 5th Guards Mechanised Corps overran Army Group Centre's headquarters column, and Soviet troops took Dresden.

  11. 81945.05.09Soviet UnionCzechoslovakia
    Soviet tank armies enter Prague

    Rybalko's and Lelyushenko's tank armies entered Prague at dawn and cleared the remaining Germans from the city during the morning.

  12. 91945.05.10Czechoslovakia
    Government arrives in Prague

    Fierlinger's government flew in from Košice and held its first meeting with the Czech National Council.

  13. 1945.05.11Soviet UnionUnited States
    Soviet–American contact line set

    The line of contact between Soviet and American troops was set along Chemnitz–Karlovy Vary–Plzeň–České Budějovice.

  14. 101945.05.12Soviet UnionGermanyUnited States
    Surrender at Slivice; Vlasov captured

    Pückler-Burghauss's SS force surrendered at Slivice, and Vlasov was captured by Soviet troops south-east of Plzeň.

  15. 111945.05.16Czechoslovakia
    Beneš returns

    President Beneš returned to Prague and resumed office.

Related people 30

Soviet forces13

Sources: reference 1reference 2reference 3reference 4reference 5reference 6reference 7reference 8reference 9reference 10reference 11reference 12reference 13reference 14reference 15